Dave Racer showed up very shortly after my phone call with Erica. He is very personable,…read morerespectful, and thorough. He addressed my roof problem quickly and efficiently.

UPDATE AUGUST 2026 - STILL NO ROOF!! So they came in Aug 2025, tore off all the metal, 3 layers of…read moreunderlayment, instead of tearing up and replacing the entire sheathing at that time because they installed 15/32" in Jan 2025 not 5/8" which is code ... they pulled up the plywood sheets to fix the spacing issues but when they did that they cracked multiple trusses and uprights. I now have @ $100K in damages they have left me with. I hired an engineer Nov 2025, presented Norman Dopfer Jr, the owner with that report. Instead of him correcting the issues and taking responsibility, he hired an Atty! To this date Aug 7, 2026 he has refused to sign a damage contract, hire his own engineer to look at the damages his crews caused or make any attempt to fix the leaks in my roof. I have only had underlayment on my roof since Aug 19, 2025 ... technically since Jan 29, 2025 when the tear off began. My roof has been leaking nonstop since they started my job. At one point I was told by the owner "We normally never do entire tear off and rebuilds, we only do repair work" ... THAT is obvious!! They should have NEVER taken on my job! It sits with Attys and due to his negligence my house continues to deteriorate.

Kayla was very helpful in a referral for a gutter company as they only did gutters with a roof job…read moreat this location. Thanks Kayla. D.W.

Looking for only budgetary information and so it's difficult to get most roofing companies to…read morerespond. Shawn went well beyond and made sure I had my proposal in a timely manor.

Good communication. Decent/competitive pricing (I cannot say, "inexpensive", since everyone is high…read morelately). However, was willing to work with me to give me a decent price, all-in-one, to do the roof, plywood, soffit & facia so I knew what my total cost would be, rather than a cheaper price and getting hit with $xxx extra for plywood, $xxx extra for soffit/facia, etc. Time frame was relatively quick as well. Despite being out of Marco Island, the quote was actually the 2nd lowest (the first being a company that wouldn't include the "extras"). Theoretically, Mighty Fine Roofing is the lowest, but I cannot really compare exactly. The highest quote was about 75% more. Rusty was a pleasure to work with.

I gotta give this company a 5 star rating. I hired them for work on my roof and they did a…read morefantastic job. Their price is very fair and beat the other bids I had. Their son, Joseph, was the only company that inspected the attic to see if everything was in good repair. I strongly recommend to give this company a chance to work with you.

JGF is honest, reliable, easy to communicate with, and prices are reasonable. John replaced our…read moreroof, soffit, rain gutters, repaired garage ceiling and painted house. He and his team leave worksite clean and are trustworthy. We were so happy with his work in 2023, we have hired him to build an attached lanai this year. No need to shop around, JGF is the best we have found. Thank you for your honest, quality service.

I needed a new roof after Hurricane Ian. John actually answered his phone when most weren't! He…read moregave me a timely quote which was reasonable compared to others. He did the work when he said he would. He also answered my questions as they came up. I happened to be home when the final inspection was done. The city inspector said some of the materials were higher quality than normal!

I tried several SWFL roofers to replace app 1/3 of my roof. They either didn't call back, were way…read moretoo expensive, or in one case I signed the contract only to have the outfit call me a week later to say that they couldn't do the job as the contract stated but could if I paid 5k more. Williamson kept it simple. They came out, gave me an estimate then a date then did the job. Where they found an unexpected problem they were fair in the job change and made the repair. All my concerns were addressed and they always called back. Top of my list for future roof needs.

In searching Home Advisor for a roofing repair I found…read moreNastar Roofing of Ft Myers, FL WHAT A FIND. They were great, reasonably priced, prompt, and extremely competent. I can't say enough good things about them. I only wish all contractors I dealt with were half as good. Thanks Tony and Tony Jr. Charlie S Naples, FL Sent from my iPhone

This review is long overdue. Their customer service was horrible. After hurricane damage, we were…read morecautious and agreed on a set price in the contract--but the final bill was a few hundred dollars more. When we questioned it, the associate said, "It's Friday, I don't have time for this." Completely unprofessional and dismissive. Their mistake, yet we were treated like an inconvenience. Never again.