This goodwill is a little unhinged, but that's what makes it interesting. I thrift a lot, and I…read moregenerally identify every thrift store, by their "strong areas" meaning "oh this place always has good bags," or "oh this place has a good book section," but this location doesn't particularly do any category exceptionally well but I always seem to find something. I do love that NJ Goodwills do $1.00 Sundays for certain colors though.

PROS: The staff here is very nice and the place is large with loads of inventory. Loads of parking,…read morepublic bathrooms, and a lot of the items are good quality CONS: Most items are overpriced with the average lowest price is $5 and that's for $10-$15 items retail. also, the shelves are all messed up. nobody is going around straightening out. looks like things were just thrown in OVERALL: If you're in the area, come in, but if you're a reseller you have to comb this place smoothly for the hidden deals

I love everything about how organized, this location is. I get Great patient,customer service at…read morethe jewelry counter, everytime I go. I don't complain about any pricing, because I check and know I'm truly getting a bargain anyhow. I truly support reduce, & reuse. It's a treasure hunt, I enjoy more than anything. Big discount on Tues. Staff is always lovely and helpful

Hello? Is this thing on? Not really sure why no one reviews thrifts stores, because they are NOT…read moreall created equal, haha. I like this 2nd Ave location for their extensive glass wears sections, but it really grinds my gears that they have started selling matching pieces only in full sets. I can totally understand selling in pairs, but 9/10 I don't need a full 6pc set or some random glass wear, and guess what? If I did, I would just buy the three pairs of two. It doesn't make sense to me. Also just as a general observation, 2nd Ave stores have been getting super expensive lately for a chain that operates solely on donations. You mean to tell me a secondhand piece of clothing is $25 when you got it for free? Kindof a rip off. Sure I can complain, but you bet your bottom I'm going to be here at least one Saturday or Sunday every weekend looking for stuff I don't need so LOL. Takeaways: selection is good but prices be whack these days.

Great stock, carefully organized, and amazing prices. 50% or 65% off certain colored tickets every…read moreday. Got brand new J crew dress with tags, in my size, a Kate Spade bag, and several cute tops fur the price of lunch! Men's women's and kid's clothes cane shoes. They even have kid's bikes!! Helpful and pleasant staff.

Great little store. My sister in law found an adorable knee length brown suede shoes with buckles…read morethat looked like it was used once or twice... for $30! They also have decent jewelry- a very expensive antique look for inexpensive prices. Not sure about clothing selection, but the shoes and jewelry areas were nice. The purses however were definitely for an older crowd (which to be fair is actually their predominant clientele).

As with any thrift store it's hit or miss with what you might find. The good thing here is there's…read morea large selection and everything is clean. The prices are in line for a thrift store, unlike some others. The staff is friendly and helpful. There is also plenty to offer help. I like to stop in when I'm in the area.

I originally posted a review of this business on Google following my experience on August 4, 2026…read more I am sharing it here for people who use Yelp when deciding where to shop. This place used to feel like a genuine thrift store. Now it increasingly feels like an eBay reseller operating out of a brick-and-mortar location. Many prices are nowhere near what I consider reasonable thrift-store prices. I regularly see masking tape attached to items stating what they supposedly "sell for" online or what they cost new at stores such as Home Depot. An online asking price is not necessarily a completed sale. A new retail product may also include a warranty, return privileges, original packaging and assurance that it has not already been used or damaged. A used item donated to a thrift store should not be priced as though it provides the same value and protections as buying it new. If I wanted to pay eBay or near-retail prices, I would shop through those businesses instead of driving approximately 25-30 minutes to purchase used, donated merchandise. My largest complaint concerns Good Stuff's policy for merchandise its employees place on the sales floor without price tags. During my August 4 visit, I found two items I wanted to purchase, but neither had a price. This was the employees' mistake, yet I was told the items could not be priced while I was there. They had to be taken away and "processed," which could supposedly take up to 24 hours. This was not the first time this had happened to me. Why can't a manager assign a reasonable price while the customer is standing there? These were ordinary donated items already placed on the sales floor, not rare antiques requiring professional appraisal. Because I live approximately 25-30 minutes away, their policy means I either lose the item or make another nearly hour-long round trip, spend more money on gas and hope the eventual price makes the second trip worthwhile--all because an employee failed to price it properly. Even holding the item would not adequately resolve the problem. Something might be worth purchasing while I am already there, but it may not be worth making a separate trip solely for that item, particularly when I do not know what price they will eventually assign. Requiring an ordinary item to be "processed" for up to 24 hours also creates the impression that someone is researching online prices before returning it to the sales floor at the highest price they believe they can charge. To make this experience worse, another item I placed at the register was never scanned or put into my bag. Thankfully, I checked my receipt and confirmed that I was not charged, but I wanted the item and did not receive it. Between two unpriced items I could not purchase and another being overlooked at checkout, the store appeared seriously disorganized. Good Stuff responded to my Google review by saying: "Hi Rick, we are sorry to hear this was your experience shopping with us. We try to make sure we price our items at a fair value. We appreciate your feedback and make sure our team receives it. Thank you." That generic response avoided the actual complaint. It did not explain why customers are penalized when employees place unpriced merchandise on the sales floor, why a manager cannot assign a price while the customer is present, or why pricing an ordinary donated item can supposedly require up to 24 hours. Calling something "fair value" does not automatically make it fair or reasonable, especially when donated merchandise is priced according to online asking prices or what a comparable product costs brand-new at a conventional retailer. I understand that a nonprofit thrift store has employees, rent, utilities and other operating expenses. I am not suggesting everything should be practically given away. However, there is a significant difference between covering operating expenses and attempting to extract the maximum possible amount from every donated item. People donate this merchandise out of generosity because they believe they are supporting charitable causes and helping their community. They are not donating items so those items can be researched, marked up to near-eBay or new-retail prices and sold back to local shoppers for as much as possible. Customers should not lose merchandise because employees fail to price, scan or bag it correctly. Taking an unpriced item away for up to 24 hours does not correct the employee's mistake--it transfers the inconvenience and financial cost of that mistake to the customer. I submitted a formal complaint requesting review by Good Stuff Thrift's executive leadership. I will update this review if I receive a substantive response that actually addresses the unpriced-item policy, checkout failures and pricing practices.

My daughter and I planned a girls day for lunch and thrifting…read more We drove by 2nd avenue a few weeks ago and decided we'd like to check it out. An absolutely huge store that is very well organized and bright welcomed us. We visited every aisle. I got a beautiful Jones of New York purple pull up sweater for my sister, an 80's vibe black sweater dress for myself, and a great pair of suede blue ankle booties. My daughter was shut out, unfortunately. Really great prices! Id absolutely return for our same date - The Pub and here!

I love this thrift store. They have clothes, housewares, movies, books, toys and some furnitur.read more

Friendly service! They have a good system where they text you when your clothes are ready and…read moreprovide you a receipt. They are different from Plato's because they can provide you credit back in a higher value or cash in a lower value. Dropping a star because they went through three of my bags way too fast...at least fake taking the time to sort through it.

Went to this store to try to sell a lot of clothing that no longer fits. Name brand plus size…read moreitems. Also had some great shoe options for higher end shoes. They took not one thing. They had minimal plus size items on the floor so I was surprised they weren't interested. They said might items were previous seasons. I came home and listed all 38 items on eBay. 5 have sold in a few days so I have a new option. While waiting to have my stuff reviewed I browsed the store, Because you can't make an appointment you just go in and 4 other people were waiting to have their clothing reviewed for purchase. I had a lot of time to browse. They have everything displayed nicely. They have a men's and women's area and lots of accessories including high end brands. They have lots of fitting rooms and a rewards program when you earn points based on what you spend. Their clothing price points were lower than I expected. Most things i liked were under $15. If you are under size 12 women's or a man this place is great for shopping, rather than selling.

It's clean, and big, and organized BUT just too expensive. Prices are similar to Ross or…read moreBurlington.... And a lot of the brands are Shein or Promark etc. $14 for a used dress worn shoes. $10 for a scratched frying pan. Nope. Many employees do not speak English, which is odd to have them on the service floor / registers. Oh well- there aren't people working at the registers anymore - it's all self check out. Hella annoying.

I came here because my GPS brought me to this location, but I don't believe this is where I was…read moresupposed to be, but anyhow we still came in. They had some OK things. Some things were modernly price. Some things were overpriced. I did find some dishes in there That was like six for seven dollars or four for seven dollars. It was OK in there. I was happy with my purchases until I went to check out. Eddie was the worker who was standing at the self checkout. I had an issue so he came over and he was very short and rude with me. Things got a little heated but his coworker Charlie came and saved the day and all was well. They need more people like Charlie. It's not what you do, but how you do it. if I go back here, I don't want Eddie to help me, he's not customer focused.