Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rosie O'grady's Pub & Eatery

    5.0 (1 review)

    Rosie O'grady's Pub & Eatery Photos

    Business Info

    More like Rosie O'grady's Pub & Eatery

    Recommended Reviews - Rosie O'grady's Pub & Eatery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Christian's Pub - Kiss the Cod!

    Christian's Pub

    4.0(35 reviews)
    8.5 km
    $

    Come from away, leave as an honorary Newfoundlander…read more.... Christian's Pub is where I was "screeched in". Gayle skipped being in the ceremony, but watched enthusiastically as we both had a great time. Plus enjoying a couple of wee pints of Guinness ahead of time was a great starter. After all, Christian's Pub is a cool bar and lounge in itself. As legend has it, an American serviceman stationed in Newfoundland during the Second World War downed some local rum one night and let out a 'blood-curdling howl'. Someone nearby asked what that awful yell was and a Newfoundlander sitting at the bar said, "The Screech? 'Tis the rum, me son." And that's how Screech earned its name. I now have the certificate as an Honorary Newfoundlander. But first the ceremony! That involved a shot of Screech rum, flambé bologna, kissing the codfish (a real frozen one), receiving a a personalized certificate, and taking a photo with Skipper Lukey. Joining me that Sunday evening were people from all over the world, all of us having a great time. It was a whole lot of fun and Skipper Lukey put on a show that was also thoughtful, folksy, and educational, all in just under 30 minutes. Other George Street bars do this, but Christian's was the only one that another businesses on the street recommended. And Hell Yes! I'd do it again.

    Every visitor "from away" must be Screeched in. It's the law. Being from Newfoundland myself, I had…read moreto use this opportunity to have my younger brother and partner Screeched in on our recent trip home. Christian's, being the oldest pub in St. John's on one of the oldest streets in North America seemed like the perfect place. Now, Christian's is no fancy joint, so let that be known right away. It's charming and a little edgy. Drinks are poured with love, and hope you're not hungry because you're lucky to get a bag of crisps. Or maybe a piece of flambéed bologna! But it's all served up with the typical Newfoundland charm. Fast forward to the Screeching in... Skipper Lukey is impressive! Memorizing everyone's name (all 40 or so guest) during our ceremony. Adding in his rough around the edges reminders on how the process works. You better be good at following instructions, because Lukey will remind you, not so gently, if you're out of line. All in good fun, I promise! Respect the ceremony and keep chatter to a minimum. It's a sacred duty to Screech in mainlanders after all. Overall a great experience and I highly recommend it to anyone and their group looking to become an honorary Newfoundlander!

    Photos
    Christian's Pub - Drink the Screech!

    Drink the Screech!

    Christian's Pub - Here fishy fishy

    Here fishy fishy

    Christian's Pub - Establish 1979. 1st bar on George St.

    See all

    Establish 1979. 1st bar on George St.

    The Stone Jug - Kids tacos

    The Stone Jug

    2.6(35 reviews)
    40.1 km
    $$$

    Road trip to Carbonear today!…read more The Stone Jug is perfectly situated on Water Street overlooking ... the beautiful water. The Stone Jug has so much history and character. Windows and doors wide open you feel the fresh air off the water. Couldn't ask for a more perfect way to spend the afternoon or evening with friends or family over a drink +/- food. Despite the pub fare focused menu I threw caution to the wind and ordered the vegetarian pizza and it didn't disappoint. Good size for 2 people, light, airy, yet chewy crust (?wood fire oven) and full of flavour. Paired with a Mill Street Organic Lager and you've got a great Saturday evening meal. Our waitress was fantastic! Super warm and friendly. Made us feel very welcomed and comfortable. I give The Stone Jug 4/5 stars only because they do not have many "vegetarian options" on their menu (fish & chips, salad, and veg pizza) AND the building is not easily accessible to folks with mobility challenges; there is no wheelchair ramp.

    Overall, this meal was pretty underwhelming, especially for the price. We ordered a smash burger,…read morepizza, and the kids' tacos. Unfortunately, everything was bland and below average. The kids' tacos were particularly disappointing--they were just pre-cooked chicken on a small tortilla with shredded raw cheese, with very little effort put into them. The smash burger and pizza also lacked flavor and weren't anything memorable. The one bright spot was the drink, which was well made. Service was also slow. It took nearly two hours from the time we sat down to receive our food and drinks, which made the experience even more frustrating. For a $120 meal, I expected much better quality and service. Sadly, I wouldn't return based on this experience.

    Photos
    The Stone Jug
    The Stone Jug
    The Stone Jug

    See all

    Rosie O'grady's Pub & Eatery - nightlife - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...