Just got a beard trim here for the first time, and it was great! Abby did a great job cleaning my…read morebeard and mustache up despite my probably unclear instructions. She also made me super comfortable with hot towels, precise trimming, and the whole nine. Will definitely be going here again the next time I'm in Sarasota. Highly recommend.

I made an appointment for a head shave which went very well. Fifteen minutes for a perfect head…read moreshave. I couldn't have been more satisfied. Next is the part where they failed me. It clearly states on their website that a head shave is $25.00. When it came time to pay, I asked how much. The barber who serviced me said $38.00. Rather than create a stink, I just paid. So 5 stars for the actual service and 0 stars for shaving my wallet as well. Honesty is Always the best policy.

Had my first haircut at Pompetti Master Barber and it was an excellent experience. Karen did a…read morefantastic job. She took her time, paid close attention to how my hair naturally lays, and shaped everything with precision rather than relying on clippers alone. The result looks clean, natural, and easy to manage. She also listened to what I wanted, made thoughtful suggestions, and clearly takes pride in her craft. If you want a barber who really knows how to cut with scissors and give you a polished, tailored look, I highly recommend booking with Karen at Pompetti Master Barber.

Got my haircut today by Angelo and I'm extremely grateful to have come across this gentleman. By…read morefar the best haircut iv had in my life. If you want to look stylish , presentable , and professional , this is where you come.

I've been going to Dave's on Main for a while now and it's one of the best barbershops around. The…read moreshop has a great vibe, everyone is friendly, and it never feels rushed. Kyle is my barber and he does an excellent job every time. He pays attention to detail and makes sure the cut comes out exactly how you want it. I always leave happy and get compliments on my hair. If you're looking for a solid, reliable barber, definitely check them out and ask for Kyle.

My cut was 'meh'. I had no sense that there was any attempt being made to make me look good--there…read morewasn't any evident pride in the work being done.

Great haircut at fair prices. No faked high-style "salon". Just a good old-fashioned place to get…read morethe cut you want just right. Shop is hidden in a corner. Worth the effort.

Normally I get a great haircut, but since Sally and Scarlet have gone it's hit or miss. Oscar did a…read moregood job both times he recently cut my hair (he's no longer there), but the last two were not so great. One of them (I don't recall his name) didn't listen to what I wanted and faded in the sides ... I had asked for a number 3 on the sides and a 6 on the top. Today I had Joey as my barber. I think my haircut took him about two or three minutes and he was extremely rough. I won't be asking Joey to cut it again. Other than that, this is an economical and speedy place for a cut.

A true old-school barbershop vibe! Dawn gave me a perfect #3 taper fade with a scissors-cut…read moretop--she's skilled & chatty while Erik keeps it cool. They know their locals, spoil kids with candy, and make you feel at home. Small-town charm in the city. I'll be back!

I've never been here but god I love this place! Came for a Beard trim and got some of the best…read morelaughs ever . These folks seem genuinely nice and have the best humor ever. The lady even joked about her Breast Cancer battle 10 years ago. Good for her to be able to talk about it and laugh about it. I will definitely come back and wish anyone reading this gives them the business. It's hard to find nice business owners like this. Oh, and their beard trim was $5! Amazing price. I pay $12 in Texas. I wish these folks the best.

Updated 12/21/2018- We have been to many barber shops in Sarasota and I have to say this is by far…read morethe favorite. All of the barbers do such a good job! We will continue to come here. Still coming here, these barbers do a fantastic job. My older high-school son is all about fades and "looking fresh". Smiley is EXCELLENT! They are haircut artists here.

My Husband had a Cut / Shave & he loved it! They took their time & the attention to detail was most…read moreappreciated. Looks like a New man ! Call ahead to reserve your time

Francisco is the man! Not just the owner but he cleaned my head up for the upcoming holiday. Love…read morethe vibe his shop emits and how I can book on line. Quality and professional; never disappointed

This is a great barber shop in downtown Sarasota on central avenue. It has a traditional barber…read moreshop feel to it. It's recommended that you book before going in, but if they're not too busy they also have walk in appointments available. I've alway been very happy with my haircut from Dylan. Prices run at around $40 which is on par for downtown Sarasota. They're closed Sundays and Mondays.

Amazing experience! I was long overdue for a haircut and my beard was an overgrown mess because I…read morewas trying to grow it out to get reshaped after the last place butchered it. I've never been to American Shave before and I scouted them on Yelp before going. They had great reviews except for a couple negative comments about a guy named Maverick, but I was impressed with the owners commitment to follow up and make things right so I took a chance and went in as a walk in. I ended up getting a Signature Cut and Shave. The staff was friendly from the second I opened the door. The drink menu was a nice touch. I was greeted by my barber and when I sat he introduced himself; wouldn't you know...it was Maverick. At first I was a little concerned but that trepidation quickly went away. Maverick was awesome. He was professional. Did a stellar job. Carried on a great conversation over multiple topics. It wasn't long before we were laughing with each other like we were college buddies. His suggestions and attention to detailed were on point. Everyone else in the other chairs seemed to be having a pleasant experience too. The hair cut and beard trim was easily the best I ever received. If you're looking for a place to get a cut and shave from a clean, friendly place with competent barbers who know what they're doing then look no further than American Shave. And if you really want a great experience, ask for Maverick. Don't know why he had negative comments - I guess everyone is entitled to have one of those days. But based on my experience, he got hosed by someone looking for a freebie.

Felix is awesome and extremely skilled at what he does. I'm always impressed by both the quality of…read moremy haircut and how quickly he gets it done.

Ricc knows how to cut hair…read more One of the best haircuts I've had in a very long time and his restaurant recommendations are spot on.

Everytime I get a few hairs cut, fewer everyday...this spot knows just the right way. Always a good…read moreconversation and food not far make it an easy Saturday AM venture. Later in the day, you might find me next door for live music and hoppy flavor! Save your cash, stick with a local tried and true cut. Njoy!

Great quality haircut by Stepan, the vibe is immaculate. Best barbershop in the Sarasota district,…read moreso glad I found a real barber locally.

I flew in for an improv festival and just walked in off the street to get my undercut trimmed…read more Stephan told me he had an opening later that same day. When I returned, he was ready and it was worth waiting! He took time to ask what I was trying to go for, explained what he thought the right plan was, and then executed it perfectly. He was friendly, but not over-talkative and I left his chair very happy with the cut! I wish I lived in Sarasota, Stephan would be my new go-to every time!