Cathy Heese took care of us. She has such a warm and funny personality. Very kind and shared in our excitement for our upcoming wedding! Walter repaired my ring...which I professionally demolished in the closet door. All that remained was a crumpled mess with a couple gems missing. I had to bend it to pry it off my finger. After Walter got to it...It looks BETTER than NEW. Just an incredible job. Extremely timely and professional. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! The man knows what he's doing! read more

Great service and value very happy with my purchase Eric is very good as well ! That has to be enough !! read more

Robert Haack Diamond - Gold and diamond chain - Jewelry Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

The staff are friendly store is nice and I have bought jewelry here but to me there is not a big selection of kids jewelry

Everything starts and ends with Cathy at the Greenfield store. She is so fun and easy to work with. This is our 3rd time at Haack's. We bought our wedding rings there, we sold old jewelry there, and our latest visit was for a resize of a ring and a replacement watch battery. Not a big sale by any means but that did not impact the service we received or the friendly experience we have come to expect. Even though the store was busy, we were not rushed or pushed. I highly recommend Robert Haack's and if you're lucky, Cathy will be there to help you with whatever you need ! read more

"Marva" at the Brookfield location (on Greenfield Ave) was wonderful. I had some old gold and silver to sell... and she was friendly, funny and took the stress out of the whole situation. I had gone to two other local jewelers and got quoted a price for the gold... but Robert Haack Jewelers beat both of the other "offers" by a huge amount which surprised me. Marva has years of experience in the jewelry business... and was a sweetheart. At first, I was a bit concerned, as the entrance to the shop is on the back of the building... so when you drive by... it looks like no one is there... but just drive around back and you will find cars... and people ready to help. read more

The experiences I have are so inconsistent and back and forth. The first time I went thinking I could get the $20 promise if I could find a better offer somewhere else, which didn't happen. Instead they made up some excuse. Then a cpl times I went in to sell and was satisfied with the offers... And of course a few times I was very unsatisfied bordering on feeling like I'm just being ripped off. The only thing that's consistent is that they were always extremely friendly. I actually started feeling like I made some friends there. Just gab friends, not close friends that offer you special treatment, but still nice ladies. And honestly once when the price they'd be able to offer was extremely ridiculous and 'unfair' Leslie whom I've come to like and have a decent respect for kinda shook her head warning me away, letting me know it really wouldn't be worth it, and telling me honestly she wouldn't do it. I really like the staff, it's just the last time I went in for an appraisal and one of the ladies gave me an offer of about under 250 from just the MELT value of the gold and not even taking into account the 2c sapphires and 2c diamonds I've decided I most likely won't sell here again regardless how much I like them read more

I went to this store after I got married and paid 150 dollars to get my ring solder my engagement ring with my wedding bands. The women working the counter took down all of my information and assured me that my rings were in good hands and that I would be receiving a call in about two weeks once my ring was returned. My rings were returned to me three and a half weeks later reversed, completely attached the wrong way. I was absolutely devastated as I had waited nearly a month to get my rings back. The representative then began to patronize me referring to me as honey and sweetie, all of which was completely unprofessional. I then asked her to refer to me by my name and she proceeded to walk away from me and help an incoming customer. The jeweler then took an additional week taking my rings apart, so by then a month later I had received back my ring the way I had given it to them. I met with the jeweler and store manager and they both had nothing but excuses. If you care about your sentimental items I do not recommend Robert Haack. read more

Robert Haack Diamond - Jewelry Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

After 17 years of marriage, my wife wanted to "upgrade" her ring. We stopped in with the intention to just look around and dealt with the manager, Leslie. She was very patient and spent a lot of time showing my wife various options and took the time to explain the different setting and quality of diamonds. My wife wound up finding a ring she loved and bought it! Leslie offered a very fair trade value for her previous wedding set and applied it to the new ring. We were very impressed with the amount of time Leslie spent with us and we never felt pressure to buy that day, nor did she try to upsell either. We would definitely recommend Robert Haack Diamonds and Leslie in particular! read more

Robert Haack Diamond - Jewelry Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

Sold, gold and silver a couple times. Always a good experience. Nice collection of jewelry as well!

My boyfriend (now fiancé!) and I have come In a few times when shopping for potential engagement rings. While we were ignored at first, we didn't mind because we don't like to be bothered when shopping. However, we did get some vibes from the workers that they thought we were young kids with no money and didn't belong there. It's intimidating enough going to a jewelry store since you're often judged by the clothes you wear and your age... In the end, I had a great experience at Robert Haack (once they realized even though we were young, we were serious). They even took my moms old wedding ring from her first marriage (purchased from Robert Haack YEARS ago) for a trade in. They wanted to respect the old owners & offered us a decent amount of credit towards my engagement ring. We will be going back in soon to pick our wedding bands, so I will update this review after our visit! read more

Robert Haack Diamond - Jewelry Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

See all

I'll never be back. Just brought in a gold watch and matching gold ring for an insurance appraisal. The woman behind the counter was great however she went to get a price from the gemologist who came back out with her. He asked what I needed an appraisal for and again I said insurance. I told him I had an appraisal from 2006 and he cut me off and said "that should be good enough." Good enough? When gold was $600 an oz? He then said "if not I would charge you "like" $150. He walked away mid sentence. He didn't seem to care I was there or wanted the business. No wonder all these other reviews are negative. I'll never be back. Surprised the place is still open. Facade is rough, paint is peeling. Oh well. Other places will get my business. read more

this place has a great selection of new and vintage jewelry. The owner is always generous and helpful. They pay fairly when buying jewelry. Anytime I need something fixed it comes back quickly and correct. I have never had a bad experience over the years. Wish I posted something sooner! read more

My husband Spent over $5,000 for my ring. I spent nearly $2,000 for his. We were told our rings were new and rare to find. Boy oh boy we thought we had a great deal. We later found out that it's all estate jewelry. PREVIOUS WORN BY OTHERS...Sad, sad, sad the lies they told us in order to buy from them. Over time the rings looked dull so we took them to be cleaned. The shine never came back. On top of that, our rings were white gold. His turned back the gold color. We were told we have to have them rhodium or something like that to bring the silver look back. Mind you, we don't know anything about jewelry, so we got PLAYED. HERE'S How! We decided to take the rings to their other jewelry store and PRETEND that we wanted to sale. The GI guy happened to be in the building and he said ok u want to sale.... Not a problem, he looked at the rings and said oh you got these from Steins or Shaws or Zales....somewhere, this is their style of low budget rings. We we're stunned and jaws dropped. He offered $100 for the set of mines and $50 for his ring. The GI talked so bad about the rings, not knowing his company was the one that sold the bs to us. We are hurt and devastated. we eventually went back to the store we 1st purchase from just to find out that you can only exchange jewelry but NO REFUND! That was NOT what we were told in the beginning. We were told We could bring it back. The part we didn't hear was the part of EXCHANGE ONLY. NO CASH REFUNDS. I truly understand, they are in the business to make money. I also now understand why they have armed guards at the door.....Not because they got robbed or to prevent it, but because they have played people so much and people want their money back...PEOPLE HAVE PROBABLY MADE THREATS BECAUSE YOU RIPPED THEM OFF! I think they deserve some media coverage so they can stop PREYING ON PEOPLE ...I did record all conversations. Yes in the state of Wisconsin, you can secretly record someone as long as you are in the conversation. BUYER BEWARE read more

Entered the store looking to repair a few pieces of jewelry in addition to purchasing two nice pieces of jewelry for birthday gifts. After looking around and spotting what I wanted to purchase three employees walked past to me and never greeted me. Not a hi or someone will be right with you. Granted I was in a sweatshirt, however my money is money like anyone else's! I see there low ranking on Yelp.... I could have saved myself time and checked here first. read more

I've shopped at Robert Haack on Layton several times over the years. Their staff has always been professional and helpful, always ready to answer any questions. I have also sold old gold jewelry back to them and have gotten a better price from them than from other places that buy back gold jewelry. read more

Had a wonderful time with Marva!! Great care and careful examination of all of our merchandise was greatly appreciated. We highly recommend Marva and Robert Haack. read more

My husband and I were looking for a ring for me to wear everyday that wouldn't over shine my wedding rings or engagement ring. We stopped here 4 times total. The 1st time we stopped in was to look at their selection and compare it to what we had seen in other stores we had stopped in. We found a couple I liked but we left and went to another store in the area to make sure we had seen all the stores near us. The guy we worked with was nice enough. He showed us the rings we wanted to see but didn't say anything. He was more interested in helping another customer in there who was looking at several hundred dollar rings.... The 2nd time we stopped in was to buy 1 of the rings we had seen earlier. We got the same guy as before. The purchase of the ring and figuring out what size I am was simple and easy. We were told it would be ready in about 1 week. The 3rd time we stopped in was about 1 week later to pick up the ring. As soon as I saw the ring, I knew there was something wrong with 1 of the diamonds - it was definitely not like it was when we purchased the ring and had it sent for sizing. I told the guy there was something wrong with the diamond. He tried to give some some bullsh*t run-around answer which I wasn't buying for a second. I told him I work with jewelry and I could clearly see something was wrong without even having to look closely at the ring. I told him I wanted that diamond replaced. I immediately got attitude from him AND the other guy working there. Sorry but I am not going to ignore something like that. Reluctantly, they agreed to replace the diamond and said it would be ready in 1 week. So now I have to wait 2 weeks for a ring that was supposed to take 1. The 4th time we stopped in here was to pick up my ring after the diamond was replaced. I asked to see the ring before we left and to use a monocular (for those to don't know - it is a , handheld tool in order to magnify gemstones and other jewelry) to look at it and the guy's annoyance was so apparent, it made me feel UNCOMFORTABLE. Then while I am trying to look at the diamonds in the ring, the guy kept talking and trying to distract me. Thankfully my husband was there with me and was able to get the guy to back off. I am pretty sure I will NOT be back here again. Yes we got a good deal on the ring but it was NOT worth the headache or the attitude we received from them read more

I am so pleased with the service, selections, pricing and friendly yet professional service I received at Robert Haack Diamonds on Layton Avenue. My sales person, Ms. Marva, was awesome to work with - kind, dedicated to helping me find an excellent piece, knowledgeable and went above expectations to making certain we were happy. Also, Ms. Leslie, the store manager took care of details so efficiently, effective and mirrored my style of let's make this transaction easy, enjoyable and efficient. We will certainly continue shopping with RHD! Ps. The follow up and thank you call to my fiancé was a nice touch too to thank him for his business and enduring him we got an excellent piece and value! read more

In 2021 I bought a diamond anniversary ring from the Robert Haack affiliated store in Southridge Mall. Recently a diamond fell out so my wife took it to a different jeweler that she deals with and they said the ring was in bad condition all around and that it wasn't even worth spending the $125 to replace the missing diamond. I took it back to the main Haack store on 76th St. and asked them to buy it back, not expecting them to do so. To their credit they refunded my money and apologized for the incident. Good customer service! read more

Ugh. I was in this establishment to try and sell some gold I have. I said "try" because we waited in line for 45 minutes without even being acknowledged by the sales people running around. This isn't the first time this has happened, either. My husband and I came in here a few months earlier and the same thing happened. Not one acknowledgement to us, even though we spent more time waiting in line then we did selling our gold. To have customers waiting in line that long and to not acknowledge them standing there, even for a short wait, is very poor customer service in my opinion. Even "just a moment" or "we have several customers and are expecting a longer wait, could you wait a few minutes?" would have sufficed. One can only imagine what it would be like to buy a ring or a piece of jewelry from Robert Haack, if their customer service is this piss-poor. The rent-a-cop could use a few tips on how to handle customers as well. Regardless, we will never be back,as it was obviously a complete waste of time. If you still want to go, be advised their parking lot is absolute CRAP, and good luck finding a place to park. read more

This is NOT run by the Haack family but was SOLD a while ago. This used to be a reputable and honest diamond store but I cannot say the same now. read more

Robert Haack has been my jeweler for 40+ years. They have quality jewelry, fair pricing & great customer service. My suggestion, don't shop anywhere else. read more

Marva is MARVELOUS! professional, pleasant, friendly and highly qualified in her knowledge of all types of jewelry! It's always a pleasure to have her help me out with jewelry choices! Will definitely be returning in the near future! Thank You Marva and Robert Haack Diamonds! read more

We were way over charged for diamond earings! Told they would appraise for $1,275.00 given a great deal at $650.00 which turned out to be a bad deal. When appraised for insurance told only worth $275.00 and bad low quality diamonds. read more

I recently went here to sell some of my old jewelry but when I was only offered $50 for a 3 diamond gold pendant I was shocked at the low offer. I took the same item across the street to a different jeweler and was offered $200 for the same pendant! I will never again sell any of my old jewelry or gold pieces here and I urge you to go anywhere but here. They are thieves taking advantage of people when money may be tight. I cringe to think of what I could have gotten for some items I sold here in the past. Please take your business elsewhere!! read more

Great place. Rose was the best with helping me choose a gold chain and cross for my son. Prices and quality are the best. Steve and rest of team are top notch. This was my first purchase and I will be back. read more

Your response is just as irritating as my in-person interaction with you. What's at issue here is that we asked your employees if the jewelry was RETURNABLE and they said YES. I think if you ask any fair-minded person, they would agree that "return" and "exchange" mean two totally different things. I'm not taking issue with the quality of the jewelry or the fairness in price. I have no comment on those things. I'm not even taking issue with the exchange policy... had it been appropriately communicated. What I do take issue with is the fact that YOUR employees told us one thing verbally, and then you didn't stand behind it. For that reason alone I would never do business with you again, no matter how many manufacturers you work with. You can hide behind your "policy" but in my opinion you do not operate in good faith. The reason why I did not want to keep the rings is irrelevant. No, I didn't wear them on a weekend or for an occasion and you have absolutely no reason to think that I did. I thought I had the flexibility to look at them at home and decide what I wanted to do. And I thought that because - again - YOUR employees told us that was the case. I guess the lesson here is: do not trust what Robert Haack employees say. Great, reputable business you've got there. And by the way, the ring you wouldn't take back was off the floor for three days. I doubt you lost any big sales there. read more

I know the owner Bret! Real nice, professional, and friendly! You will get a good price on jewelry and buying it from them!

Highway robbery. I came in looking to sell a certified .53 carat diamond engagment ring which is appraised at around $1300. They were only going to give me around $300 for it. Are you kidding me? This place is ripping people off left and right. Not to mention waiting in line for over am hour to be robbed. read more

I was very impressed with the service I received here. Even though I was only out to spend about $100 dollars for my wife's valentine gift, they treated me like a customer with thousands. My wife was also able to get her wedding/engagement ring repronged, strengthened and appraised for only $70 after being told by overpriced mall stores that a new $1000 ring was required for her stones. read more

I took some gold in to get cash...and I left with more than I expected. It was super easy, quick and I even got rid of all my broken jewelry! The guy looked at each piece, showed me what it weight and gave me a price for each piece and total. It's a good way to clear out your jewelry box of un-paired gold earrings, broken necklaces / bracelets. It took about 15 minutes total and I left with cash in hand. read more

Everyone is so knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly. I always have a great experience every time I come! I always feel that I am treated with respect. If I don't understand or don't remember how to pick a perfect piece, they will help me understand or re-teach me. My jeweler for life!! read more

They Boast that they are the Best, Most Honest and highest paying gold and diamond buyers around. I wouldn't recommend taking anything there to sell as they are, in my opinion, flat out crooks! Took my ring in to sell them my diamond and the gentleman brought out his loupe to examine it and says to me, "well, it looks like it MIGHT be around ONE carat! RED FLAG!! It was a 2.01 SI2 Certified TWO carat diamond! Either he is Completely incompetent or was taking me for a ride. He then goes into the back to "figure out the offer" and comes back with 1200 written on an envelope. DONE, insulted by someone who said a 2 carat diamond was Maaayyybe a 1 carat then offers THAT. The appraisal stands at $8000.00 and 2 other diamond buyers offered me $5500.00 and $6000.00 so they weren't even in the same ball park. If they gloat that they are the Best and most honest wouldn't you be even a little bit closer to the other offers? It is their prerogative to offer what ever they want, just as it is my prerogative to NEVER enter into their establishment either to sell or purchase as I firmly believe they are crooks. read more

WOW! Robert Haack Diamonds is awesome. Great service, selection and pricing. I just noticed that when you go on Yelp it shows all these reviews that are FIVE stars that are not posted. I'm super confused. All I can say is stop in and give him a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Poor service. Never trust a word anyone in that Layton location says, especially fromthe female that works there. She's lousy to say the least. Bad communication skills, if none at all. read more

I sold some jewelry here. I got immediate service and out of four places that I got quotes from they were by far the highest. They buy for scrap so you're not getting resale value, but if you're looking to get rid of some unwanted jewelry I would definitely recommend this place! It also seemed like they had a great selection of jewelry and would return if looking to purchase any diamonds. read more

Very knowledgeable staff. Bret and his team do a wonderful job plus they are commited to the community.

Wonderful experience selling my (dis) engagement ring! They offered fair prices and very friendly service. Would highly recommend this jeweler for anyone looking to seek unwanted pieces. read more

This is the only place where my husband and I get our quality jewelry from. From my engagement ring to a gorgeous diamond ladened cross to our wedding bands, everything is Robert Haack. Brett and his staff made us feel comfortable with no sales pressure. Marva was fun to work with and treated us as though we come in all of the time! Our rings were ready before the scheduled pick up time and although there was a slight very tiny issue with my wedding band, the staff was able to correct it with no additional charge to us. We will continue to go to Robert Haack for every jewelry purchase. read more

Do not come to Robert Haack if you expect a positive and professional jewelry buying experience! They are only interested in buying scrap gold and even then people wait in line for long periods of time without ever being acknowledged by a staff member. I had a custom piece made there and waited in line too without even a glance or "good morning" from any staff member. This has been by far the most disappointing, frustrating and unprofessional experience I have had at a Jewelry store in Milwaukee. My custom piece was a nightmare and two of the four appraisals I had done there were inaccurate which I brought to the attention of the staff and they corrected. Really ???? Supposed to be experts !!!! It was not worth the time and money spent as my custom piece didn't turn out the way I specified which resulted in numerous trips to the store fro clarification throughout the process. What a waste of time especially since the piece didn't turn out as I wanted. I also inquired about selling a diamond that I had already had graded and their grading came way below the actual grading report resulting in their offering me a really low ball price. I didn't tell them I had the grading and wanted to see their "professional appraisal" Yikes, how horrible! Run,don't walk from this establishment. There are far more trustworthy establishments in Milwaukee. Let my lesson help you....I wasn't educated enough but am not (because I had learn ) during this horrible experience. What's really sad is that I can't even bring myself to wear my custom piece because of all the frustration it represents, Overpriced waste of my time and significant disappointment. read more