I've stayed in lodging in this area for about 35 years due to having family nearby, and coming to…read morevisit nearby Indiana Beach. Typically we would stay outside of town in Logansport or Lafayette due to there being no branded hotels in Monticello. We've also stayed at a cottage in Indiana Beach. We've stayed at a handful of Best Westerns before and had fairly good luck so decided to try this place since we noticed this branded property and we would prefer to stay right in town. It's a little sad to me that I think a lot of the mom and pop type motels have been torn down around the park, but I get it that sometimes people don't want to stay in places like that or they just aren't kept up well enough. I had no complaints with the Best Western stay. Our top floor room was quiet. There is a full gym attached to the hotel which seemed unusual but gave us the opportunity to get a full workout plus a sauna visit. I didn't use the pool and the hot tub was closed. I don't generally eat much from hotel free breakfasts anymore but at this one I found a yogurt with simple ingredients including cane sugar so I enjoyed that topped with some almonds. The hotel is also pet friendly, which is generally a must for us. The day we checked in they were having a roof redo, so there was a crew on the roof and discarded shingles and packaging all over, but other than that it didn't disturb our stay. We arrived around 2:15 and their check in time is 4. We were able to check in early with a fee of $35. It was worth it to us to be able to get to the amusement park earlier. There are restaurants and bars a short drive or longer walk down the road, and I'd definitely stay here again.

Clean, quiet, comfortable, and cost affordable, that's what you get here…read more Stayed for a quick one night stop for business, so a late check in and an early check out. Breakfast board shows the menu for the week, nice. Staff is friendly.

Sweetie and I stayed at the inn during a family camping trip. Neither of us was up for camping…read more(I've done it before but I'm getting old, and she has never been into it) so we searched for someplace decent nearby. This turned out to be an amazing B+B with, yes, a friendly old black dog, and a lot of history. The owners are very down to earth, and the building is very cozy, an old rambling house tucked away on a shady knoll right next to Indiana Beach. We didn't end up going to the park, but we could have walked. The bed was comfy (though a bit high for Sweetie) and the room in general was nice. There is a common area by the entryway, and a couple of small dining rooms for breakfast. Prices are amazing for something right in the heart of things during the busy season. Next time we are in the area we will definitely be back.

As I arrived at the Black Dog Inn, the Innkeepers Bo, Tom and Vickie greeted me at the door by…read morename. I asked to see the room and quickly felt comfortable. I'm extremely cautious traveling alone and overnight accommodations. Bo (Black Dog) was very friendly and I knew immediately this was the place for me. My room was extremely clean, quaint and comfortable. I enjoyed a delicious breakfast with Tom and Vickie. Everything was tastefully quaint and special. Thank you for a warm cozy night. I definitely recommend this inn and look forward to visiting again when I'm in the Monticello area.

We just stayed there for the 3rd time and it was yet another AMAZING stay. This is the ONLY place…read morein Monticello that my family and I will stay at. We just had our family reunion there this past Saturday and Keli was so accommodating. We even ordered our reunion shirts from her and she had them ready at check in! The best resort in the area! Keli the owner is absolutely amazing! We have seen every cottage and motel they have and each and everyone of them are updated and beautiful! We have been there twice and have 2 more stays booked this year and the whole resort booked next year for our family reunion! We love you Keli!

. I was just crashing for one night but I wish I could have stayed longer. This place had…read moreabsolutely everything I needed, down to grilling utensils and firewood . I'd recommend it!

The owners Terry and Jackie were such down to Earth people who are genuinely grateful to have you…read morestay with them. They offer different sized rentals to suit your needs. My family needed a place to stay at the last minute and Terry helped me find the perfect option for all 9 of us to stay. We were able to walk to Indiana Beach. You are within 200 yards of the park's entrance, which was so convenient. By being a guest at Bay Side Resort, you also received a generous discount into the park. The property had paddle boats and kayaks that were free to use. This was something the whole family participated in, and was an added perk that no other rental offered. There is a giant deck for all residents to enjoy without feeling cramped. They offered a multitude of grills (gas/charcoal) so we were able to enjoy grilling out as a family which also saved us money by being able to avoid an expensive restaurant. They are located on a quiet bay area that has minimal big boat traffic, so the family was able to swim in Lake Shafer, along with boating. If you don't want to swim in the lake, the property also had a large swimming pool and hot tub. There is a convenient marina located across the bay, so if you need to rent a boat or wave runner you had that option as well. There was also a huge fire pit that is free to use at your leisure. The inside of the house we rented was rustically beautiful. It had a full size refrigerator, stove, microwave, and sink. The bathroom had a walk in shower. The particular house we had included a queen, full, set of bunk, and futon beds. Overall the experience was wonderful. We highly recommend to anyone looking for an awesome place to stay. Terry and Jackie were amazing, give them a call!!

It's kinda hard to give it 5 stars. The carpet really needs to be replaced. Otherwise it's a nice…read moremotel. Big tv. Overall I'd say I was pleasantly surprised when I came in. The manager was very accommodating and helpful. Great location too. Everything is close by. Including a Walmart.

My husband went on a quick Turkey hunt and needed a place to stay. We found the Monticello Inn. He…read morewould definitely go back! The price was right and while the rooms were a little dated, it was comfortable and clean. Staff was friendly...check in was easy. Thank you!

This place is awesome, I'm going to start with the amazing views of the lake, and the short walking…read moredistance to the amusement park, Indiana Beach (excellent fun park). Rooms were clean, very comfortable, and the staff was amazing. They went over and beyond to help make our stay enjoyable. I highly recommend this hotel for anyone visiting here.

Very clean and cute resort located within walking distance to the amusement park. Loved the room…read morewith the bunk beds for the kids, and the beautiful deck overlooking the lake. Highly recommend

I will NEVER stay here again. My wife and I paid $190 to stay here from Friday to Monday. $980 was…read morepaid for 4 couples. and we got the upstairs room. Spider webs were so bad and they positioned the beds closed to them. The bed frame gave in on my my wife. They stapled straps to hold wood underneath the mattress together. The air conditioner looked like it was about to come out the wall and the recliners looks dirty as as shit. This should be a homeless shelter, not a resort.

I recently made the mistake of staying at this place during a family vacation. This is by far the…read moreworst hotel I have ever stayed in. We booked a 2 bedroom suite with access to a grill for cooking. Our grill was literally located in the gravel parking lot of the resort. The room was filthy and there was an infestation of yellow jackets under the porch light of our suite. The air conditioner broke on our second day. The maintenance man finally came at 10:30 at night to attempt to fix it. He cleaned the filter and told us to let them know if it is not cooler by morning. It was 88 degrees in the main room at 10:30 at night, and even worse in the other rooms. When we told him that was unacceptable, he got angry and yelled at us about going to buy a new air conditioner from walmart. I told him that he should go buy one becauase we cannot stay in rooms this hot. They wouldn't move us to an empty room because they said that their cleaner didn't finish cleaning any of the rooms that day, so there were no clean rooms available. THe maintenance man finally returned with a new air condidtioner, and installed it. This air conditioner worked. However, in the process of installing it in a rage, he cut himselft. THere was blood on the wall and on the door. While removing the old air conditioner, it leaked dirty water all over the floor and the futon. He replaced the futon and tried to wipe off the water on the floor with a bath towel. He left he blood for us to clean up though!. To top if off, the front desk said they would clean it up when we left. This place should be shut down. Disgusting, filthy, infested and incredibly rude staff. I am giving this place 1 star because it won't let me give zero stars.

Gross. Don't stay here…read more I grew up here and have attended events and stayed here many times on trips home; I thought I knew what I was getting with a small-town hotel like this. I was wrong. I've previously stayed in the main hotel (lodge) near the lobby without issue. Sure, it's outdated and a little musty, but it's a lakeside hotel that caters to summer crowds with kids fresh out of the lake and allows dogs. You can't expect it to be anything else. This trip, I was put at the very back of the property in a separate building surrounded by men (I'm a woman traveling alone and expressed concern about this). There wasn't another vehicle anywhere near the main building. My dogs are with me, as they've been on previous stays, and the front desk woman said these are the only dog-friendly rooms available. Fine. The room is disgusting. The floor is filthy (my disgusting socks prove it), the bathtub is cracked, the smoke detector is covered in plastic wrap, paint is chipped and peeling, the door doesn't seal properly, the towels are a gross beige from use - the list keeps going. I will not be returning for my second booked night and would have bailed immediately if it weren't late on a Sunday with no other options available.

Not a "resort". More like a truck stop, roadside motel…read more I'll start with the positives: Sheets were clean and no bed bugs. That's it. The rest of the room was awful Dated (looks like a hotel from my childhood and I'm 45!) Dirty! Dirty walls, mold in fridge, dirty cups, dirty walls, phone, etc Gap around door which leads directly outside When I opened the wrapped soap, it was wet inside Towels have holes Ice bucket was wet and dirty Room keys are recycled - they used white out to cover the old room number and write my room number This is a disgusting place for over $100 a night! We did not go to the pool or the breakfast.