J&A installed a metal roof on our house with the previous owner. Not only did they use the wrong…read morescrews that actually punctured the metal at the peak and caused leaks along the entire length of the roof. They also installed the transition from metal roof to shingles in a way that it caused a leak that can't be fixed without re-doing the entire roof. You get what you pay for - the lower cost comes at a price of workmanship. Stay away if you want to protect your house!

J&A roofing reshingled my roof in April of 2024. They worked fast and did a good job, but there…read morewere a few problems, one being that they failed to shingle all parts of the roof that were included in the contract, which reads "Remove existing roofing down to wood decking from entire house sloped roof areas only". The two areas not done do not have steep slopes, yet they are certainly sloped. Since I do not go on the roof, I did not see this failure for awhile. I didn't think anything of it when there were 10-15 packs of shingles left over, until later when I saw that these areas had not been done. In addition, the ceiling in a room upstairs goes up to the roof and many, many roof in jails came through it. Eventually I hired someone else to cut all of the nails off. I called and sent pictures twice. The woman that I spoke with said hat she would forward everythIng to Fred and he would get in toush with me. It has been months and I have had no response. My husband passed away in November of 2023 and I am dealing with many things that are new to me. I feel somewhat taken advantage of.

Steep prices. Came on time and were good about informing beforehand. Overall good serviceread more

Erik is awesome! Responded to my phone call right away and gave me a quick estimate for the work…read morethat I needed done on my property! His crew of Josh and Brandon worked tirelessly on the project and were easy to communicate with while on the job site. Highly recommend Castaldo Property Services-it's not easy getting someone out to do quality work these days! Thanks Erik !!!

We are totally satisfied with the job that Xterior Pro Roofing & Siding did for us in replacing our…read moreroof and sidings. David was very helpful, professional, and always returned our calls on time. He always explained every step in detail about our projects. His crew was amazing, very hard working, knowledgeable and did a fantastic job. I had another issue recently; David and his crew immediately came over and looked at the problem and fixed the issue. We are very happy we chose and continue to choose, Xterior Pro Roofing & Siding for our home. I highly recommend them. Thank you, David and the Team yet again!

Tagun took over 2 weeks to get back to me with a price. Four other roofing companies, gave me a…read moreprice on the spot ,and a written proposal within 24 hours. By the time he got back to me the job had been completed, and that included the 2 week hold up waiting for a permit from the town. I talked to him on 9/23/25. The job was completed on 10/14/25. He's still sending me texts, and emails at the end of December, asking if I want to go forward with the job. What a jerk.

We had Sheeley re-do our roof this February. They were fantastic. The roof was previously…read moreshingled with 3 layers of shingles (not my doing) and had some water damage underneath. Therefore, they had to remove the 3 layers, replace some of the plywood, and then replace the gutter-covers. They did a great job. They were very professional, finished faster than they said they would, and ended up charging us less than they initially said they would. One thing that really impressed me was that when something fell on a railing on our porch and cracked it, as soon as I pointed that out Sheeley agreed to replace it without hesitation, they went out purchased the replacement, and installed it without me having to lift a finger. When a company lives up to their mistakes like that it really shows their true value. These guys were not the cheapest option out there, but they were very well worth the extra cost.

Highest praises all around for Sheeley Roofing! We were about 30yrs in on a drab brown 3-tab…read moreshingle that had lived its full life. After dealing with several contractors who took weeks to confirm a site visit for an estimate and then NEVER getting back with a price, we called Sheeley upon seeing their ad in the Bluestone Press. Kelly got back right away to schedule an appointment with General Manager Steve, who came out and walked us through the process, giving a clear breakdown of pricing and answering any questions that arose along the way. Day of install, the crew was incredible - fast and precise with safety a top priority (ropes/harnesses etc.). Front and back of the house was draped with debris nets, protecting flower beds and siding during demo. Garrett, project manager and liaison between crew and homeowner, was very affable and kept us informed on the progress. By mid-morning the roof was off and ice and water shield was going on. By 5:30 the shingles were on and the yard was swept, even utilizing a wheeled magnet to syphon any rogue nails that may have landed in the grass. The charcoal architectural shingle with black drip edge looked sharp with clean edges, giving our home a more modern look while not breaking the bank. Sheeley offers an incredible decades-long warranty on their roofs, which is even transferable to future owners should you decide to sell. It's amazing to watch a crew firing on all cylinders and complete a project in one day - only wish we had set up a time-lapse! Hands down a great experience and we can't recommend them enough. Look around on your next drive and see all the Sheeley signs at the end of driveways - there's a reason for that!

Dave and staff were professional and excellent to do business with in everyway. I would recommend…read morethem to anyone.

Dave and Gary came the same day I called (weekend) to clear ice from the roof. Professional, prompt…read moreand efficient - and pleasant, too. Would highly recommend.

If it was possible to give more stars I would. I have never…read more dealth with such an awesome bunch. They are unbelievable. Besides doing an outstanding job they cleaned up so well you would never have know that they had just replaced my roof. Outstanding. Besides doing an awesome job the men were friendly and went out of their way to be helpful. I wish there could be more companies like Fishkill Roofing and Siding! Thanks guys!!!!!! Angela Panza

In the past 6 months, we replace an old Roof and Siding by Fishkill Roofing & Siding. They are very…read moreProfessional and take Pride in their workmanship.

Impeccable craftsmanship. Rudy is dedicated to providing the…read morehighest quality work. Very professional and hard working. They will leave you've home in the best shape it has ever been in. They compete all projects in a timely fashion and even help suggest design. They are great to work with. I had to renovate my kitchen. It looks better than I could have ever imagined. They take pride in doing the highest quality work at reasonable prices. I highly recommend Rudy and his company.

I wish I could give Rudy and Raphael 6 stars! When they start a job, their crew shows up on time…read moreand works consistently until the job is complete. Their work is beautiful and the cost is reasonable. They have done my roof on two homes, a gorgeous back patio, 2 bathrooms and more and I wouldn't use anyone else.

Jefferson and Xavier were fantastic, very nice and professional too! Their pricing was better than…read moreother roofing companies and best of all they came to fix our roof and side trim within 2 days. We also added a few extra jobs (ie, replace window shutter blown off in recent storm) and they were happy to do so. Highly recommend!!