This place came highly recommended, so maybe that's why I ended up a little disappointed. I had…read moreheard so many great things that I think my expectations were just set too high. We ordered pizza and wings. Personally, I still prefer wings from a good Chinese restaurant--they're usually crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and they never disappoint me. These, unfortunately, were a bit dry. As for the pizza, it was okay. Nothing bad about it, but nothing that really stood out or made me want to come back just for it. Overall, it wasn't a bad experience--it just didn't live up to the hype for me.

Placed order over the phone, service was nice and quick. Order was completed about 20 min after…read more Deal was great! I was able to customize my 1 topping pizza since I ordered over the phone. Pizzas were huge! Delicious cheese, big slices of pepperoni, crust was well cooked. Wings were delicious, crispy and meaty. We had a bunch of leftovers!! Very happy will definitely be back!

Staff were friendly and the interior is just what you'd expect from a local pizza place on a main…read morestreet in a small town. On top of the pizza box was a copy of a local flyer that was a nice bit of local reading. The wings were fresh and tasted great prepared medium buffalo-style. However, they definitely weren't medium spice which was a bit disappointing. It might be the water in Okeechobee, but the pizza crust was dense. I suspect the cheese and pepperoni were of low quality, and the fresh garlic likely came from a jar. Overall, the pizza wasn't special and definitely wasn't worth the price. If you want to try just a slice or two, make sure to arrive before 4pm, because they only sell whole pizzas after that time.

When you walk into Joey's Supreme Pizza in Okeechobee, it feels like stepping into a local favorite…read morewhere pizza, wings, and good vibes rule the table. The space is casual and welcoming, perfect for a family meal, a game-day hangout, or just when you're craving a serious slice. We ordered a little bit of everything--because why not? The mozzarella sticks were golden, crispy, and came with that classic marinara dunk. The jalapeño poppers had the perfect crunch with just the right kick of heat. Then came the wings--juicy, saucy, and downright addictive (BBQ and teriyaki both hit the spot). But the real star? The pizza and stromboli. The pizza came out loaded with toppings, gooey cheese stretching with every bite, and a crust that held up like a champ. The stromboli was stuffed with melty cheese, peppers, mushrooms, sausage, and pepperoni--every bite a flavor-packed punch that makes you close your eyes and go yes. Joey's feels like one of those places that doesn't need to be fancy--it's just good food, good portions, and fair prices. Exactly what a neighborhood pizza spot should be. If you find yourself in Okeechobee, don't skip this place.

First impression walking in, I felt like the ambience is missing something. There's a couple of…read morecute things on the wall, but I feel like they can step it up more. We made our way to the bar where we decided to sit and was greeted by the bartender who seemed extremely stressed out. The restaurant is not busy, but the phone did seem to ring pretty frequently. I was in the mood for a beer, but the selection was very small and then they ran out of IPA. That was a bit of a disappointment and they should invest in a better beer selection. Having beer on tap is way better than bottles. So the beer was a failure so we ended up getting a bottle of Pinot Grigio which made sense since we both decided on wine. It was a good bottle for the one option. The menu has a pretty good selection and decided on the famous bruschetta and San Pierre pizza. Bruschetta- it was pretty good. I like how the bread had a nice crisp and the flavor of the tomatoes. 8/10 San Pierre- pizza was delicious. Loved all the protein and ricotta cheese combination. Next time I will request extra ricotta cheese because I love an overload. 9/10 It's definitely nice finding different locations throughout Port St. Lucie since this county is pretty large and going into small areas with these hidden gemstones was definitely a good find.

We ordered 14 inch pepperoni pizza and Parmesan wings. Everything was good and my guy who loves…read morepizza said he will go back. The price is a little pricey however it was the same price for one of the best brick over pizzas in Oklahoma so for us it was worth it. He does also like that they change out their beers and offer IPA options. Bartender service was great even though busy.

Great food, authentic pizza place, reminds me of new York, waitress is very friendly and attentive…read more The chef came over to ensure the food was what we expected.

Oh my they have the best service. They love baseball. There is stuff hanging everywhere. Simple…read moretable real silver

A Hidden Gem! I…read moreabsolutely loved the customer service here! Everyone was friendly and welcoming, and the pizza sauce is a game changer--seriously, it makes the pizza stand out! I also really enjoyed the pictures on the walls. They're great conversation starters and give the place a fun, personal feel. And let's not overlook the clean bathroom--that's always a major plus for me! I've already recommended Mozzarella's Pizzeria to family, and we've been back three times. That should tell you everything! Great food, great service, clean atmosphere, and a place that makes you want to come back. Definitely recommend!

The best pizza in PSL. I order it with light sauce. And truly, of all the places we've ordered here…read morein PSL this is by far the best one. Ordered one Tuesday by chance and they offered the 2 medium pizza special. Great buy. A MUST try. Been ordering from them since.

Great pizza with friendly and fast service! We will be back for the specials! With a few tables…read moreoutside it was nice to watch the rain.

Been coming here for years. My dad took me here as a child and I've been coming as an adult. Won't…read moreget a better Sicilian anywhere else.

Estella's Pizzeria has undergone an impressive transformation under its new owner, Allen. His…read morecommitment to quality is evident in every aspect of the dining experience--from the upgraded ingredients to the consistently excellent service. The pizzas are perfectly balanced, with crisp crusts, vibrant toppings, and flavors that feel thoughtfully curated. Allen's presence in the restaurant adds a welcoming, personal touch; he engages with guests, oversees the kitchen, and ensures that every plate reflects his high standards. Estella's is now not only a reliable local favorite but a standout destination for anyone seeking exceptional pizza and genuine hospitality.

This place has the absolute worst customer service period. This is the second time this place has…read morepushed my buttons. I've worked in pizzeria's before, I understand it can be busy and hectic at times, but to be placed on hold for over 7 minutes, hang up and call back just to be placed on hold again before even getting a word in is absolutely ridiculous. The first time we went inside the place to eat they were apparently "too busy" to let us dine in (there was a whopping 4 ppl already eating inside) and they told us we can only get food to go. Who, TF, does that when there's only 4 ppl dining in?! Ridiculous customer service. Literally garbage. So we ended up calling Labbys pizza off gatlin and guess what, they answered right away and took our order. And the pizza and wings are better! Bottom line, don't go here. I'd give zero stars if I could.

Nice ambiance and that's about it. Peel and eat shrimp unpeelable . Weak pours, overpriced and slow…read moreservice. Ate half the meal without a second drink. 3rd time there . Won't be back.

Really great wings! This is the takeout/pickup location across the parking lot from the…read morerestaurant. Service is usually quick. Not much ambiance but, again, it's just the building for takeout. The wing sauce is very good, all I'm sayin'