Been in town for a few years now and decided to change it up and try this place. Good prices the way things used to be years ago but also not impressed with the menu. Cheap ingredients that someone is trying to cover up with lots of mozzarella cheese on everything. I believe it used to be great but someone lost their way over the years. read more

First timer here! I ordered delivery because I literally just moved into my house yesterday so I had no food and am not exactly sure where my dishes ans silverware are lol. Needless to say I ordered from Red's based purely off the pics from Google and it didn't disappoint! Delivery was fast and my order was made correctly and piping hot. But omg can we talk about the cheese?! The cheesy goodness of a pie was layered with the standard pepperoni and mushrooms and then a giant fistful of cheese. If you're a cheese lover like me there is no such thing as too much cheese! My only suggestion is to add some flavoring ro the crust. Itvwas bland and mot super crunchy. Just that added tweak would've made this pie from cheesy goodness to over the top amazing! read more

Horrible customer service and the food is dry burnt or salads that have slimy lettuce

I don't know what Mike and Kelly was talking about the food was GREAT lettuce was not slimy even though there was no one there it was so good and customer service was amazing I have a family member who has a severe gluten allergy and they were so understanding so yeah COME HERE read more

Had an assignment in Fostoria last week and my co-workers were craving pizza and we like to patronize local places so ate here. Big mistake. They advertise a buffet and that was the reason we decided on Red's and we were told they weren't providing it that day because they were short on help. Even though we were the only ones dining in the order took a long time. My coworkers ordered a pizza and the toppings were sparse and even thoug we waited a long time for the pizza, it was undercooked. I have an allergy to mushrooms and ordered the steak sub with no mushrooms. It came out with mushrooms and when I asked for the sub to be remade and the pizza to go back in the oven for a few minutes, the employee had a real nasty attitude. She insisted the pizza was cooked and that I didn't order the sub with no mushrooms even though my co-workers remember hearing me order it that way since they know of my allergy. She thought I should just take them off the sandwich and eat them. She must not know how food allergies work. I asked for a manager and the owner talked to me and her attitude was een worse than the employee's was. I would avoid this place. Overpriced, lousy food and an owner that needs a class in customer relations. read more

Ordered and had it delivered. It came on time and hot. The sauce was off. The crust was ok. I finally ended up picking the toppings off.

USED to be super good. Dont get me wrong i still purchase their subs...BUT the bread is always burnt and hard as a brick. the wait can take forever and i dont have time to waste on getting rocks to eat. Shaking my head you can do better. Get better reds read more

Way to expensive, food was extremely greasy! The customer service was aweful! I will never eat there again. 40 plus tip for a large special pizza an 2 drinks, pepsi and a diet pepsi! read more

Red's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fostoria, Ohio

See all

Hands down the best pizza! The pizza is out of this world, they don't skimp on the toppings. Worth the drive.

Places an order for an 18 in ham and cheese fold over picked it up got down the road and they mad the wrong thing. Went back and they did not do anything but say sorry! Ugh...... how do you take the order wrong......I don't live around go-town to was it for a new one! Ugh bad customer service! read more

The Reds bread was fantastic! Great food during our stay. If we ever go to Fostoria, OH, we will be eating here.

The place itself is nothing special but I love to order a couple of Italian subs with mayo and extra Italian dressing on them and take them home. One sub is plenty for two to share. My husband loves the mega meat sub. Never really ate in the place. Not sure about how the dine-in service is but the carry out service is great and friendly. read more

Ordered there last night and it took them 2hours to deliver it and when it got here everything was cold and we didn't get to eat our money was wasted . I didn't call back to complain because I wasn't about to wait another 2hours for them to deliver again!!! I am very disappointed and don't think I'll order from there again!!!!! read more

Red's bread is a must with any order. Great subs, creamy Italian dressing and cheese loaded on most subs, taco pizza and fold overs are great. Always enjoy the pizza and occasionally a crispy chicken salad that is big enough for 2-3 people. Also have a lunch buffet on weekdays!!! read more

If you find yourself in Fostoria, you have to check out Red's. It's truly a community treasure! For a relatively low price, you get a large amount of food. Food that could be best described as "your hometown's favorite pizza place - but a little better." If you pick up a foldover, you will not be disappointed. It's a charming, satisfying & humble joint that you won't forget to stop back into. read more

The pizza here is pretty good. I recommend the Reds bread. It is really amazing. We also had the Taco Salad which everyone wished we had more of. They are really affordable and give you your moneys worth. read more

Speaking as someone who has not always lived in Ohio, reds is one of the many pizza laces that does not cut the pizza right, like a pie. I don't like that, also most pizza places in Ohio have no idea what great pizza tastes like. It's hard to find good pizza in Ohio. Reds is no exception. And there are way too many pizza joints in this tiny town. In my opinion as a transplanted citizen, their sandwiches are not very good either. Of course, I've had the chance to experience better food from all around the country, which most Ohioans have not so they don't know the difference. read more

Great little sub place, I bought four subs and it feed a family of six and we had subs for lunch the next day. We got Italian Subs and they had plenty of meat and cheese on them, they really was good. I Love the low prices and love the ease of the location. If I'm back in Fostoria again I'm going back, keep up the good work. read more

Get a BLT foldover and a grilled chicken salad here with homemade ranch. Amazing food. Just try to ignore the hole in the wall decor....my husband and I drive an hour just to get reds. This place is no joke. read more