Fun place with a really unique vibe right in downtown Red Lodge. The setup with the mailboxes and ice cream shop makes it stand out and gives it a cool, local feel that you don't see everywhere. We stopped in for pizza and were happy with it overall. The crust was solid, ingredients tasted fresh, and everything fit the casual mountain-town atmosphere. It's the kind of place that works well for a relaxed stop while walking around town or grabbing something quick after a day out. The ice cream side is a nice bonus and adds to the experience, especially if you're with family or just want dessert after pizza. Overall, a fun spot with good pizza and a memorable setup that makes it more than just a standard pizza place. read more

We had left the Badlands of South Dakota that morning, and spent the entire day driving across Wyoming. We were spending the night in Red Lodge, before heading to Yellowstone in the morning. Red Lodge is a cute little town, which was very busy the night we arrived. We were tired and hungry, and this restaurant looked like it would just hit the spot! It is very clean, and the staff is super friendly. We thoroughly enjoyed our pizza. Would highly recommend! read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Exterior - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

See all

Food was delicious and fresh. Dessert was AMAZING! Service was quick and We had a great server too! read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Graham Slam cookie - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

I've had pizza in New York and this pizza spot might be better... We ordered the bbq chicken one and it was SO GOOD. The crust was unbelievable fluffy. I would fly back to Montana just for this pizza read more

This place is very satisfying! A great place to take children. The food is delightful. Not many healthy options, but you never leave hungry. The interior is very impressive, and the signature Crazy Cookie is out of this world, although not the most calorie aware food. But! That isn't always a bad thing. The service is very nice, and the waiters/waitresses are always kind. Very much recommend! read more

We love it here! Always busy, great for kids, pizza is good and the crazy cookie for dessert is legend.

So happy to have an option for pizza in Red Lodge with exciting toppings and pizza alternatives. Consistently good pizza, with gluten free crust options ($$$). Huckleberry drinks are a hit! Wish the large salads would be large enough for more than 1-2 people, but otherwise a great option if in Red Lodge. read more

I've been here a few times and pizza is always great. People are friendly and atmosphere is fun. Get a malt.

My two adult sons and I did an online order 8/30/25 to take to our campsite outside of Red Lodge. We got the Zip Code - chopped chicken, artichoke hearts, spinach, Swiss & mozzarella on ricotta sauce and a Rural Route - Canadian bacon, pepperoni, sausage, onion, black olives, mushrooms, mozzarella on tomato basil sauce. Both were yummy with perfect crust - the crust was thick at the edges, like bits of breadsticks. We made our order when we were approximately 25 minutes out of Red Lodge and as we were pulling up in a parking spot, I got a notification that our pizzas were ready read more

This is one of the best pizza places in Montana! I LOVE their mozzarella sticks and pepperoni rolls. The staff are very sweet and take their time with you while also working really fast. The restaurant itself looks like a vintage ice cream shop or bar, with nice leather booths and pretty ceilings. read more

I would not take children to this place for a pizza. Yes, they go out of their way to get my wife and I seated in the adjoining bar. When we declined (some questionable looking people in there) and said we would wait the estimated 10 minutes, the young guy at the reception insisted I give him my phone number. Of course I declined and was told that could cause a seating delay even though the reception area was a few feet away. To top it off, mediocre pizza, tourist pricing and rude staff. One block down and you will find a great pizza place with options besides pizza, and it was excellent. read more

Phenomenal pizza and great service! The menu has gluten free options as well. We drove the beartooth highway from Yellowstone and were THRILLED to have so many great menu items to choose from after a week of eating sandwiches out of our cooler. The pizza has great flavor, delicious crust. The garlic parmesan fries were some of the best I've had anywhere. I was in a huckleberry mood and the lemonade just hit the spot! Our waitress was the sweetest woman, very attentive and helpful. This would also be a great place to take kids. If we find ourselves in Red Lodge again someday, it will be to get pizza! read more

See all

The customer service and environment was great! No complaints... Coming thru the town again for work but stopped by for food this time around 8:30p, was served drinks and food with great customer service, highly recommend to travelers and locals! We got a SMALL pizza, fish and chips, house salad and salad, several house Moscow mules and more. Stop by for the food, remember it's not just pizza :) The small pizza is also surprisingly large! read more

See all

My friends and I were on a motorcycle trip coming up from Denver metro area. Dorpped into this place. Taylor, our server was awesome! She's a high school student working hard. Great personality, super friendly, and made excellent recommendations for food. We had an excellent conversation with her. Everything tasted delicious. The food was great. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

A very nice place on the downtown strip. Our waitress, Taylor, was very attentive and personable. We ordered the Rural Route pizza and it was excellent. The freshly made crust was thin yet had great taste and a soft chewy texture. The seasoning was just right with a hint of smokiness, most likely from the meats. A great stop for a family plus a good selection of craft beers. Additional food choices were also available with hard ice cream. We had a 15 minute wait but we sat outside on a bench and watched tourists which is always entertaining. read more

I love pizza. Seriously. If I had only a week to live, I'd eat pizza almost exclusively all that week. So, when visiting/vacationing, I wanna know where good pizza is in town. I looked on yelp (as always!), and found Red Lodge pizza. It had 4 star and so I went to see what the 1stars had to say. Honestly, I have no idea what their problem was. This place is soooooo good!! We ordered the pizza roll and garlic fries for appetizers. Both amazing. Then ordered three medium pizzas - rural route, a meat pizza (I forgot the name), and the Newman (a bison meatball pizza). All of them had excellent crust/bread. All of them had fresh ingredients, had perfectly placed and seasoned toppings, and we the perfect size for 8people. And all of them had incredible sauce (homemade) and cheese. We also had great service. Allie (not sure if that's how she spells it, lol) was very attentive, quick, helpful, and had a great smile. If I lived in Red Lodge, I'd be here at least once a week. Highly highly recommended! read more

See all

Stopped for lunch. Casual family pizza joint with terrific service! We shared a small thin crust pizza with bison meatballs. It was perfect for a light lunch. Might try the regular crust next time. The service though was truly exceptional! read more

Our first time in Red Lodge or Montana for that matter.Really good food. The service was even better- Love the look of an old soda shop. read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - First customers to order the new menu item."Honey chipolte wings" - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

Great tasting, served hot, lots of cheese just like pizza should be. Clean & great service. read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - This is the mail bag specialty pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

This is really a hot spot in Red Lodge, even on a summer Tuesday evening. It appeared, though, that there were no adults working and the youth, though really busting it, didn't always have their priorities straight. read more

Service: super attentive, friendly and efficient. Ambiance: clean, bright and open. Pizza: huge New York style slices. Not greasy at all. Perfectly cooked with a little crunch in the crust. Sandwiches: my wife had the grilled buffalo chicken and said it was great. Fries: fresh, hot and crispy. We ordered with Parmesan topping. Salads: I had a small salad with chicken, feta, and cranberries with balsamic dressing. The greens were crisp and cold. Obviously not just a bagged salad. Wings: my son had these and devoured them before I had a chance to taste. Later he told my dad over the phone that "it was maybe my favorite restaurant ever". He's 14. Dessert: you gotta try the deep dish chocolate cookie with ice cream. Shareable for four people and delicious. read more

Today we had held a Class for our Lender and Realtors. We were able to come in the day before and make sure everhting was working the way we needed it to be. We were able to come in early and setup and double check everything again, when we arrived the food was ready to and delicious as always and our Server Trya was waiting with a smile to help make sure our event went smoothly. She Made sure we felt important and allowed us to use the space as we wanted to!... She walked me through on where everything was from lighting to the projector and how she laid out all the food/ drinks for us! If you ever have an event, please make sure Trya is an amazing server and put ys at ease that we were going to have a successful event! The Gal's At Flying S Title and Escrow -Red Lodge read more

crappy service just a bunch of kids trying to flirt with local girls, and not even offering a menu or drink option. First time ever considering walking out on a bill after sitting for 30 minutes after they picked up our plates! Pizza was good however read more

I live in a foodie city. I'm also a pizza specialist on my Green Egg. This place was AMAZING!! I rate based on these standards: 1. Customer service 2. Quality of food 3. Overall experience 1. Customer service was great! Allie did a phenomenal job. She is an excellent server. She took care of us, made great recommendations, and explained the food. 2. We took her advice and had the pizza rolls and garlic fries as an appetizer. They were great! This place would excel in Vegas. Then we had 3 pizzas: all of them were excellent! The crust was excellent, with both a spongy quality and crispy. It was salted perfectly and no burnt spots. The cheese was well proportioned. The sauce is homemade, sweet and balanced well. The toppings were well done. The Newman was my favorite, but the two meat pizza's (rule route and other one (don't remember the name) we're well done too. We came back for ice cream and really enjoyed it too. The cookie was also awesome! 3. The overall experience was top notch. I'd eat here regularly if I lived here. Keep up the great work! read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - $$$$!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

My husband said this was the best pizza he has ever had and that Dave Portnoy should definitely try it one day. There are gluten free crust options which I appreciate. Overall always a nice experience when we eat here. read more

The pizza was so so, but the ice cream was good. The food and ice cream is spendy but I would skip it if you are looking for pizza as there are better options read more

Our waiter was awesome and very patient. The pizza was really good and the environment was nice. Loved having lunch here while passing through town. read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

See all

Have brought the kids to this place for years. Before COVID it had The best salad bar ever! After Covid in a remodel... No more good salad bar. Their pizza still pretty great though. They also have really good Montana made ice cream. A bonus is to go next-door and look at all the dollar bills tacked to the ceiling. the place is popular so get in before noon if you want a seat! read more

Very good pizza, spouse had international. I had the Mailbag pizza. Both were very good, lots of toppings, house made sauce was good, and Montana wheat crust was yummy. Would definitely come back if we're in the area! read more

Took 45 minutes to get a personal pizza and sandwich, no water or napkins food was cold then she blamed kitchen food was good just not real hot read more

Excellent crust on very good pizza, great service and cute, young efficient servers. Ice cream counter to top off pizza. Good business model. read more

We were really excited to see a pizza place, pulling into town! Great location, and plenty of streetside parking. Heading in, we noticed the post-office theme right off the bat. The dining area was close to capacity, but the event room in back was available for seating, so we headed back there. The place has really been restored nicely, with the fireplace and all the decorations. Looking through the menu, there wasn't anything we weren't wanting to try. We settled on the Cliff Clavin pizza (wait, what? Oh, yeah...). Delicious, and perfectly done! The service here was great; friendly, helpful staff - no complaints at all. My associate's kid went off to play games in the arcade, which she thoroughly enjoyed. To top it off, they have an excellent selection of ice cream flavors, from a Montana creamery. We each loved our selection. Definitely stopping in here again on our next visit. read more

My family have eaten here hundreds of times, and the staff are always kind and courteous.

Got seated at a booth very quickly, even on a busy summer weekend day. Our waitress was extremely friendly and efficient. The pizza was perfection, and the crazy cookie is an absolute must-do. Will definitely be back next year! read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

Great tasting pizza in downtown Red Lodge. Decor is off to the good start but definitely looks like the average pizza parlor when you walk in. Don't let the decor fool you, the pizza is really tasty and the beer is icy cold. Definitely a good stop post ski or hike in the Beartooths. read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Bison Meatball & The All Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

One of the best pizzas I've ever had! Love the environment. Worth making the trip to Red Lodge for the pizza alone.

We stopped in for lunch while here for a few days visiting. Service was great and friendly. Pizza was delicious--the crust was just crispy enough and still fluffy. We got several by-the-slice pieces but you can also buy by the pizza. They also have gluten free crust which is nice. They have beer available from the place next door on tap. Highly recommend! read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

See all

We were looking for a great meal in Red Lodge, and we found it! The wait was a bit long and they did get our second pizza order incorrect, but we got that one for free. Food quality is outstanding. We had the pepperoni rolls and mozzarella sticks as appetizers, the huckleberry lemonade was great. The "mail stop" meat pizza was really amazing. We ended up taking some home and enjoyed it for lunch today. Outstanding pizza quality, great restaurant. Definitely try this if you are in Red Lodge. read more

Red Lodge Pizza Co - Our leftover pizza - Pizza Near Me - Red Lodge, Montana

Open during COVID with limited seating. There was a wait time, but we got seated quicker than we were told. Staff was incredibly friendly. Food was mediocre. We probably won't eat here again due to the food just being ok. No real complaints other than every glass at our table was empty by the time we finished and no one offered a refill. read more

Cool vibe great food and great service! The staff is always upbeat and the dinning room looks fresh and new. A must when in Red Lodge!