Ream Jewelers

What a job Finch Jewelers has done! My fiancé (she said yes ) had a look of shock, horror, joy, and…read moreeverything in between when she saw me down there with this ring. I can happily say that she was surprised! While working with Julia, she knew I wanted to capture something stunning, with a little twist but not too much, and with a beautiful complement of side diamonds but not too many, and to have the ring with plenty of time before the proposal, but not too much! I knew I wanted the ring without knowing exactly when I'd propose, but Julia worked with me every step of the way! Offering expert insight, her suggestions at each phase, and being willing to teach me about each detail with the ring and the diamond, especially the mounting! I am grateful for the time Julia spent helping me navigate a million different choices for the perfect ring to give the love of my life. Thank you to all of the special people at Finch Jewelers who take care of everyone else's special person!

Wonderful customer service. I took my dad here to have some links removed from his watch. They were…read morehappy to help and were quick and efficient. They didn't ignore us just because we weren't there to spend big bucks like some jewelers. While we waited, we wandered around and looked at all the shiny treasures. They have beautiful pieces there and it's easy to see why their reviews are so good. When I'm in the market for a unique piece of jewelry, they will get my return business.

Brent Miller Jewelers & Goldsmiths

4.4

(48 reviews)

•$$$

Great service and very knowledgeable staff. I let them know right away that I was just window…read moreshopping and a sales rep walked me through the entire store, discussing watches and letting me try on any piece that I wanted. No pressure and very open / honest about the wait list for high demand pieces. Highly recommended - also very good YouTube / instagram content

I have been on the "Wait List" for over a year after requesting several Rolex models, )nothing…read moreunobtainable like a Daytona or even a Submariner) Nothing has been offered, and continue to get the BS run around!

Vincent & Company Fine Jewelers

(7 reviews)

This jewelry store is conveniently located and the people were so nice. They helped me with a pin…read morethat I inherited that the clasp didn't seem to work. But it was my error and not the clasp design. That was embarrassing. But the staff was so understanding and made me feel great. They offer some beautiful pieces.

I recently gave just an Average rating to Vincent and Company because I had lost the diamond they…read morehad replaced in a ring for me. After my review I was contacted by them and asked to bring my ring back in so that they could correct the situation. It turned out that though the ring had been repaired over a year ago, they replaced the diamond and polished the ring so that it looked sparkling new and charged me nothing for this. This company truly believes in standing behind its reputation and providing the best service to customers. They are as good as it gets!

j. a. sharp Custom Jeweler

4.8

I just picked up a wedding band last week, and I'm very pleased with the quality. Jude did a…read moreterrific job not only on the outside finish, but also on the inside. One of the most comfortable rings I own. My only mild criticism is 5e time frame. They are custom made and that takes time- up to four to six weeks, or more. If you want it by a specific date you may be disappointed. That being said, I would by from Sharp again.

Wonderful selection of traditional and contemporary jewelry. We had our wedding rings custom made…read moreby Jude. She did an amazing job and we get lots of compliments. The shop has many other beautiful collections of jewelry. Sylvia, Andrea and Jude are friendly and offer great customer service.

Veleska Jewelry

4.1

(12 reviews)

Every Single experience here is a great one. Thank You Mrs…read more Veleska For Continuing to Bless Me With Amazing Prices.

Kathryn brought tears to my eyes when I picked up a ring she brought back to life for me. My ring…read moreholds a special place in my heart and Kathryn worked her magic to enhance its beauty and make it everlasting for me. Don't think twice to visit this jewelry store. Talk with its beautiful owner. Believe me you will not leave empty handed.

Oletowne Jewelers

4.6

(10 reviews)

Went in for a repair/restoration. Was given excellent options. Work performed was much better…read morethan expected... outstanding. Price was excellent (and better than two other local jewelers I tried). Completed before it was promised. I could not be more satisfied.

I brought my watch in to get the band replaced and John was super helpful. I even learned a few…read morethings about watches while I was there. Good customer service will have me going back for any other jewelry related issues.

Classic Estate Jewelry

Great selection and beautiful jewelry at affordable prices. Staff very patient and helpful. My…read morego-to store for fine jewelry.

Nice, clean, helpful staff. Big selection of jewelry and keep stakes. Value was good. They…read moreappraised rings I had with me.

Vanscoy Maurer & Bash Diamond Jewelers

4.0

(18 reviews)

•$$$

Had an appointment. The staff was so helpful. I got the ring of my dreams and special ordered a…read morepair of earrings. I had a limited time line and things could not have gone more perfectly!!! Highly recommend this jeweler !!!!

I have had the pleasure of purchasing from VMB for over 10 years now and I can say the experience…read moreonly gets better each time. Whether I am going into the store to pick up a specific piece, purchase for my wife, or just simply shop around; the staff and ownership is always helpful friendly and informative. I do feel you cannot put a price on excellent customer service. It's extremely refreshing in a market where it's not as common to find these days. On top of buying, my wife has had her rings serviced here as well. The service dept. is as good as the boutique. Her jewelry has come back in a timely manner and better than it was when we dropped it off. Service rates are extremely fair as well. So whether it is purchasing jewelry, presents, time pieces, or getting service work done, VMB has been an amazing pleasure to deal with. We will continue to shop there and thankful for such a great business that we can support as customers.

Sunshine Jewelry

4.8

(23 reviews)

I am thrilled with my service. I needed my engagement and wedding rings resized and have been…read moreputting it off for a while. I brought my rings in on a Saturday afternoon and they were ready about 24 hours later. They both look perfect. I almost cried putting them on my finger because I have missed them so much. I can't recommend them enough!

Laila and Tori took Great care of me. my wife's new diamond ring is beautiful! I'll be back for…read moremore jewelry for sure

C.Lefferts

(5 reviews)

Have you ever had a need to repair something that was very special and immediately felt at ease…read morewith a stranger who would do the work? That's how I felt when I met Curt Lefferts. As soon as I walked into his shop, I knew I was in the right place! His knowledge, his candor, his attention to detail all worked to make me feel comfortable. He identified the problem with our clock immediately, and lovingly adjusted and oiled it and sent me off with instructions on how to hang it. He then followed up the next day to see how the clock was ticking! I couldn't be happier with his service. On top of that, he's a darn nice guy. This man knows clocks. This man loves clocks. Let him love on yours! And wait 'till you see his shop! Five stars hands-down.

Smart guy. Recommend.He knows his stuff. Veteran. Willing to travel to you. Works on all kinds of…read moreclocks.

Mid-Atlantic Horological Cooperative

(1 review)

Mid-Atlantic did a PHENOMENAL job procuring and refurbishing a Russian watch for me. Their…read morecommunication during the process was top notch and their pricing was very fair. An excellent example of what customer service should be. Would recommend them to anyone.

From the owner: We specialize in antique and vintage watches and clocks. All our members are classically trained…read more Give us a call, text, or a message through our website!

Merritt's Antiques

4.0

(8 reviews)

•$

I've used Merrits on several occasions for clock parts and tools ordering. Their customer service…read moreis impeccable. They have never made a mistake on my orders, and the products are always of good quality. On the rare occasion where I do receive a damaged, item, they have always had a new one in the mail on the same day. Their monthly flyers are always good, and alert you to good deals they have going. I highly recommend this business.

may I first say when Merritt screwed up my order i used 1 word not at the person but at the…read moresituation that i should not have that being said. placed a order paid by credit card. was charged and was told it would be shipped shortly Friday get a call that my order is ready for pick up. excuse me? was to be shipped. was told I was not clear on order and next time I should be more clear. well Merritt. check your tapes if you keep them for training purposes. I know every customer is wrong. you're right. I'm sorry. well really sorry I called. since new owners let me say your just about hands down most expensive but you are convenient I was told timesavers might be a better fit. well ya. more stock, quicker shipping, and they get the order correct. I may not have been your best customer. having dealt there 30 plus years I was a long term customer sorry to say the new Merritt is not like the old Merritt. just telling you my last experience try them for yourself and see. your experience maybe better. I hope it is if I offended anyone in this review I'm sorry

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

G S.

2 years ago

My husband and I purchased multiple engagement rings from Ream Jewelers. First one purchased on 2/2013. The diamond was priced at $13,995.00 On 8/23 my husband went back to upgrade the diamond ring and made the purchase. A trade in was made for $12,000 for our diamond. We purchased a 2.07 cushion cut diamond for $29,000. I since took the ring to two different appraisers who both told me it was not even closed to worth what I was charged which was highly disappointing to be taken advantage of for not knowing the correct cost of the value of the diamond. We did not even get the GIA original paperwork with the overpriced diamond. The diamond was delivered to our home in late October 2023. Around October 26th, which was well over the 30 days return timeframe, but you don't even get it back until after the return timeframe. On 10/30th my husband made our first call to the owner Alan to express our dissatisfaction with the ring and requested a return. He told my husband to "have me wear it for a week or so and see how she feels". I did not understand that the clock was still ticking. Nothing changed for me I was not happy with the quality for how much money we spent. In November, I was on the phone with him for over 16 minutes to request the return again. Alan did ask what I wanted from him, and I told him again to return the ring. Alan was willing to return the special-order band worth $3,900.00. He did go on to state it was a very business time for him in his store and he would like to visit his store after the busy season. We did not hear from him after the holiday season. We were respectful to not disturb him during his busy season and expected that he would reach out to us with a convenient time for us to come in or provide a pre-paid shipping label for the return. He never contacted us after his busy time. I followed up with multiple phone calls and each time he did not remember me nor the situation. After reminding him who I was and the prior conversations we had. He acted surprised that I was unhappy. During one specific call I tried to set up a date to have him meet me at his store for Friday. He stated that he had to drive his wife to the doctor's and did not want me coming on Friday. March 26th, I followed up again with him. He was very aggressive and said he is not going to return the ring, but he will try to sell it on a consignment basis and take a commission on the sale. Just to make more money on us than you already did... no thanks. He did hang up on me and I followed up with an email to him. He was very unprofessional and does not keep his word. In business your word should mean something. It does not mean anything with Alan. We never had a fair opportunity to make the return in a timely manner since he continued to blow us off. Don't not waste your hard-earned money buying anything from Ream. Ream does not care about you or will even remember you. read more

Kevin F.

8 years ago

One of the best jewelry experience's we have ever had! They treat you like family and have an amazing selection. I purchased my wife's wedding ring from the owner, Alan. He's a true gentlemen and really knows his stuff. He even gave my little one a bracelet for free, so sweet. I would recommend them to anyone. read more

Tom K.

15 years ago

I wish a few of my associates at the office would have considered asking me first before purchasing a ring anywhere other than Ream Jewelers.. best quality, best prices...friendly and sales people that truly wanted me to get the best for my budget...simply put... they are the best in Lancaster County. read more

Ryan S.

7 years ago

Excellent team there. And superb service! I even showed up a little late as they were closing shop. But they were more than happy to let me in and help me with my watch. I definitely recommend to anyone looking for a great time, service and learning about what you have. A+ Ryan read more

Courtney K.

8 years ago

The only Lancaster jewelry store worth going to! I absolutely LOVE my Lancaster County pendent. It's perfect for everyday outfits and shows my love for my hometown. They have beautiful engagement rings and wedding bands with so many different designs and diamonds. read more

Robin R.

2 years ago

Great service from Monica! Enjoyed window shopping the vintage and estate sale items.

Justin S.

9 years ago

Nice selection, very helpful and friendly.

Ream Jewelers - jewelry - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Ream Jewelers also viewed

Koser Jewelers

4.4

(21 reviews)

•$$$

This family owned business is located centrally on Main St in Mount Joy in a large, stand alone,…read moresomewhat elegant building with ample parking. Upon entry it is a skylit setting of a large number of jewelry display counters. Staff are amazingly attentive and knowledgeable. They offer something to drink and ask whatever they can do to make you feel comfortable enough to spend big bucks on beautiful jewels, watches and other elegant fittings. This is a beautiful store with beautiful expensive things. They are full service providing everything from jewelry cleaning, repair, replacement, sizing, whatever is needed to keep your jewels looking their finest. This is not free. These are high end professional jewelers who know what they are doing. Replacing a watch battery is $15. Making a ring a size bigger, about $125. Replacing a tiny stone and resizing, reinforcing prongs, about $225. If you love estate pieces as I do, there are 3 cases. A gold filigree type emerald ring surrounded by peridots was $1500. A large opal in a gold setting, $1600. A 1960s pink opal, $600. I have to say that skilled jewelers are harder to come by. To stock watch batteries when people don't even wear watches anymore, except us old folks, is no longer a Walmart counter service. If I was in the market for high end jewelry and wanted the lifelong service for my investment, I would be very secure doing business here. This is not a mall jewelry store with bright lights making every diamond seem to call your name. This is a first class, no kidding high end place where you get what you pay for. I took a few photos but was worried about appearing to be casing the joint, so no actual offerings photographed. You will just have to go and see for yourself!

I've bought a lot of jewelry here over the years. Most recently I purchased a stunning engagement…read morering. I've always had good experiences here with good service. The follow up service is also nice.

Vincent & Company Fine Jewelers

(7 reviews)

Oletowne Jewelers

4.6

(10 reviews)

Classic Estate Jewelry

Great selection and beautiful jewelry at affordable prices. Staff very patient and helpful. My…read morego-to store for fine jewelry.

Nice, clean, helpful staff. Big selection of jewelry and keep stakes. Value was good. They…read moreappraised rings I had with me.

Warren Jewellers

4.4

(7 reviews)

Wonderful, welcoming & helpful staff. My parents bought their engagement & wedding rings here, and…read morewhen my fiancé proposed he bought my engagement ring here as well which made it even more special! Our jeweler worked closely with us to customize & design my dream ring. I would highly recommend this place to others looking for quality jewelry. I will certainly be visiting again for my seasonal ring cleanings and to eventually pick out our future wedding rings!

Hands down the most welcoming place to be! My husband had my engagement ring custom made and it's…read moreabsolutely perfect! Kimberly worked with my husband to craft the prettiest piece of jewelry I own. We also go our wedding bands there! They really work with you to stay within your budget and still help you get your dream ring. Any questions my husband and I had were answered with ease. Before we got married we stopped in many times to chat with Mike, Kimberly, and Julie and they were always happy to see us even if it was just for a ring cleaning. You can have your ring cleaned as many times as you want for free! They didn't push jewelry sales instead made sure we got exactly what we were looking for. If you're looking for a safe and welcoming place to browse or potentially buy engagement rings or any piece of jewelry, I highly recommend stopping in to Warrens!

Adams Jewelers

3.3

I searched all over for a ring I would fall in love with. Adam's online resource was perfect, the…read moreamount of Victorian style bands was far better than anything I had seen in person at the normal array of Jewelry stores on regular googling. I sent him an email with my selection asking if he had anything with the setting I could try on. We live in Baltimore so just stopping by in York wasnt really in the cards. His responses are so quick! He took care of us and I had my custom designed ring withing 2 weeks. He explained everything the entire time, was so lovely to work with and not the pushy-sales-fake type. Couldnt have asked for a better expierence for my wedding ring!!! I recommend them to everyone!!

I came in for a watch repair, broken clasp. The man behind the counter took the watch and worked…read morethe clasp for two seconds and then told me there was nothing wrong with it. I put it on a flexed my wrist and the clasp let go. He told me I was wearing the watch wrong and if I wanted the clasp repaired I would have to send it back to the manufacturer. They said they do repairs but I guess they couldn't make enough money off of me. Now I'm wearing the watch with the clasp taped shut until I can find a reputable dealer who wants my business. Worst service ever. Take your business elsewhere.

Futer Bros Jewelers

4.3

(6 reviews)

•$$$$

We needed to liquidate some of my relatives jewelry. The excellent and knowledgeable staff spent a…read morelot of time with us discussing our jewelry and educating us. We were quite impressed. I highly recommend them!

Staff was very kind and professionally trained. Goldsmith is very talented and will be bringing all…read moreof my jewelry repairs to them. Thank you for the help.

York Jewelry & Watch Service

4.6

(8 reviews)

Great service done right there in their store. They replace watch batteries and adjust metal watch…read morebands. They also have a nice selection of estate jewelry: Gold bracelets and necklaces and even diamond rings. Good prices and good people.

consistently honest with excellent technical skills. good advice and great service. Deal in…read moreconfidence!!

Franklin-Stevens Jewelers

4.0

Took a ring in that needed fixed, he soldered it together but cracked it more in other areas…read more Handed it to me and told me I wasn't happy and he didn't want to charge me. I honor work and pay for quality. Which I did pay but I wouldn't recommend this place to get gold fixed. He claimed to not want to charge so I wouldnt do this but I don't see how he would allow a piece of jewelry to walk out his shop like this I took it in for a fix and he said "I'm human not perfect" also said he's been in the business for many years but it doesn't show in the work he does or he just doesn't care about quality. Stones are loose and he couldn't fix it. A fine jeweler would recommend and find a way to get things done or send you to someone who can make it happen. Don't judge people by their appearance, you don't know what it's worth to them personally and how much they are willing to pay.

Lovely little store with great personalized service but limited hours. Have been using them for 2…read moregenerations. You meet the smiling man who actually does the work and that is important when you have a special piece and do not want to ship it somewhere to have it worked on. We also use them for battery replacements for watches and exercise bands since not everyone in this area has the tools. One Saturday the owner was away and shop closed so we wasted time going to 6 other jewelers in area for a battery. No luck elsewhere but 5 minutes when he reopened we were all fixed. Years ago I even had him engrave saying on an old wedding band. Really a one stop shop for all our jewelry needs, just call before you go!

Heisey's Jewelry Store