I was really excited to get started with this firm. Josh Ray was great on the phone and Brian Huber during an initial meeting was terrific. The first month was great and they fixed all sorts of issues in my books. I felt I had found a firm who could handle my three businesses and personal taxes. They get five stars for the first month they worked with me and one or two stars for all subsequent months. I am being generous in awarding them a three star review. I actually want to give them one star, but I do not like to harm small businesses.
Around the time Covid hit, things became challenging. Exchanged emails didn't seem to address the specific questions I was asking. Getting any help whatsoever for PPP loans was impossible. Brian would send me the same data sheets from the SBA as I had already seen and sent to him. I was later told that they don't get paid for helping, so they don't really want to do it. That would've been helpful to know at the beginning. Regardless, I have spent well over $10,000 with this company, and I think helping me get the books together for the PPP Applications would have been a great value add. Brian kept sending me emails telling me how to run reports and do it myself. None of my colleagues had to do the amount of work that I did for this application. In fact, as I received information from my bank and the federal government, I forwarded it to Brian. I suggested that they create a value add for their business clients by incorporating some of this information. I was more on top of it than the CPA firm was. I had no idea I would be charged for giving them information to help guide them.
I was still willing to excuse that. I had recommended that we put in the books the specific notes payable between the corporations. I wanted monthly invoices and payables to keep track of what each business was actually able to pay and where they were in arrears. I was told that this was not necessary and a total amount due was fine. Some of the payables were input, and some of them were not?
They also insisted that my company health insurance program not be itemized in payroll. This is because an owner cannot deduct their own health insurance. However, when it came time for PPP, this was a disaster and virtually impossible to figure out what was paid towards health insurance. Again, Brian sent me an email telling me how to run reports to figure out the total paid to Blue Cross Blue Shield. I just needed a number for the application. Not an assignment. It would've taken him less time to run the report and give me the number and just send me an email with detailed instructions on how I can run a report to get that same number. Isn't that why you have a CPA?
Still, I gave latitude and contacted Josh Ray, who referred me to someone else at the firm to help with the PPP loans.
They totally messed up my franchise tax returns. I had sent them the renditions from 2018 as a template and their 2019 renditions did not match up at all. That has taken me another five hours to resolve on my own. Additionally, when they sent me the renditions, they omitted page 1 and two. When I asked for a complete copy of the franchise tax form, Brian told me to look it up and find it in the 8820s. Those forms are about 80 pages. My job to sift through and find the report that should've been sent to me originally, imported into Acrobat, pull out the three pages and export so I have an actual franchise tax form report took me another two hours. The report should've simply been sent to me complete in the first place and when it was not, they should've just sent the file as I asked. Instead, three emails back-and-forth were exchanged explaining to me how and where to find that report on my own.
When I looked at income on the P&L for purposes of the property tax rendition, I saw $14,000 in voided checks. I have no voided checks, but again, I was charged for Brian to explain to me that they categorized something as a voided check that didn't match up from 2018. Regardless, it was not income, but now it creates an income line for tax purposes. This has still not been corrected. In fact, I have sent in two emails asking for this to be amended and nothing has happened.
I have three outstanding invoices that I have not paid yet because I'm still working my tail off trying to fix the errors. I wrote today in looking at one of them with 3.25 hours billed for Brian to research why he did not receive my QuickBooks files. I had shown proof that they were sent and he only opened one of them. He stated that he needed to go through all three companies and find out all the dates that accountants copies were sent, received, and returned. This seems like insane billing for an error that they made.
But most notably, today when I sent an email asking about those hours, Brian sent back an email saying he has some really important information to give me but he's waiting until the invoices are paid. read more