Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Randy's Pizza

    3.4 (5 reviews)
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Randy's Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Randy's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    7 years ago

    Very busy when we went. Did their best in a bad situation due to a whole city losing power so yeah

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Michael's Pizzeria - I dug in so fast that i had a lot gone by the time i thought to take a pic

    Michael's Pizzeria

    4.2(17 reviews)
    15.8 km
    $$

    I Love there pizza all works, it taste unique, all the meat and vegetables together in one. Yummy !read more

    TERRIBLE Dining Experience at Michael's Pizzeria August 12, 2023 (Michael's Customer for over 30…read moreYears) Dropped in to Michael's Pizzeria this evening for some munchies and finger food. When we walked in around 9 pm we were surprised to learn the large dining area was closed (in the past this was open until midnight) and this is a night night when Jerry Seinfeld was in town and had filled the CUP. I saw a large number of people coming in to grab some munchies shortly after the completion of the Jerry Seinfeld Show and were told that the dining room was closed. We were thankful to be able to sit in the smaller dining, containing four tables, just prior to the Seinfeld show's completion. We decided to order some items that we have ordered repeatedly in the past as we really enjoyed them (we felt that the Nachos were some of the best we have had anywhere over the last 20 years). My partner ordered nachos and I ordered the Wings and Things (6 wings, 4 mozzarella sticks, celery, and carrot sticks). While we waited, we heard the waitress be asked several times by customers coming in to grab a bite where they could sit. Her less than welcoming response was, "you can take some chairs down" (as she pointed towards the large dining area where the chairs were up on the tables). Our food came. After I had a couple of wings, I noticed there was no celery or carrot sticks with the Wings and Things. I asked the waitress about them and she indicated they don't serve celery or carrot sticks (items listed on the menu that are included with the Wings and Things) after 9 pm. That information was lacking at the time of our order. My partner was having a few Nachos, and I really mean a few, when I had finished my four mozzarella sticks and 6 wings. I reached over to have some nachos. The problem was ... I could not find any nacho chips in the Nachos. There was lots of cheese (a staple of the past amazing Nachos from Michael's) but no visible Nacho chips. I moved some of the cheese around on my side of the Nacho order and I was able to find a couple of nacho chips under the cheese. The problem with the two chips I did find was, they were completely soggy. Unable to find anymore on my side of the basket, I asked my partner how she was getting along with the Nachos and she indicated she had a few chips located on the outside edge of the basket but, also could not find not find any nacho chips. Being completely dissatisfied with the Nachos my partner brought them to the waitress, who was standing behind the counter, and expressed that the Nachos were not very good (why they were not good) and requested to have them remade with more nacho chips. The waitress asked Ryan from the kitchen area to address the issue with the Nachos ( there was no apology or how can we help or fix the issue, etc.). Ryan stepped behind the counter and picked our order of Nachos while listened to my partner indicate there were no nacho chips in the Nacho order. Ryan said "well, that is how we do it here. We put down two rows of chips and that is it". My partner indicted that maybe the case but, where are the Nachos in the order (while he was looking at our order he was holding)? While listening to my partner, Ryan noticed that some Cheese was actually gone from the order (approximately 10% from what was given) and he said "well I can't replace it, you have eaten some out of the order". I spoke up and said "Ryan, there are no Nacho chips in the order". Ryan turned his back and while walking away he replied "well at most, I might be able to make half an order". My partner came and sat back down. We had a quick discussion, decided that UNFORTUNATELY BEING VERY DISSATISFIED AND DISAPPOINTED, THIS WAS THE LAST TIME WE WOULD BE DINING AT MICHAEL'S PIZZERIA! We paid for our $43 bill, that did not contain the munchies and finger food that we have come to love over the years, experienced far less that adequate customer service and a left with a terrible taste in my mouth! I am sorry to say that a PAST STAPLE in the Summerside area for great Munchie food, no longer exists at Michael's!

    Photos
    Michael's Pizzeria
    Michael's Pizzeria - Pizza, bacon pepperoni ham and extra cheese

    Pizza, bacon pepperoni ham and extra cheese

    Michael's Pizzeria

    See all

    Famous Peppers - The Cardigan pizza

    Famous Peppers

    4.4(34 reviews)
    69.6 km
    $$

    There was a guy from PEI they use to call potato…read more... And apparently he went on to make some banging pizza that feature potatos.... To the person who put carbs on our favourite carb, I salute you! Famous peppers is the most well known pizza joint in Charlottetown with a few locations including their newest spot in Founders Food Hall serving up some fantastic wood fired Za, sammys, and some boujee tacos. I can't speak too much on the location or service bc my BF was the delivery boy for this but WOW the Spud Islander could put me in my grave. The maple cream sauce, with chunks of sliced potato, caramelized onion, and smoked bacon were the party flavour town didn't know it needed! The dough is pretty good, not quite thin crust or Neapolitan but a solid tasty fortress holding in all those toppings. This was a white pizza with lots of cheese and salty sweet deliciousness that will have you reaching for more (and probably some water... or beer bc they offer that for takeout too) We also got the tropic thunder (where you at my pineapple pizza lovers?!) which is a red sauce pizza with cheese, jalapeños, red onion, pineapple (like real pineapple, not those weird canned chunks) and pepperoni. So good and nice spice! Definitely will order again, highly recommend anything with the maple cream sauce or potato's on it! Cheers to carbs on carbs and good pizza!

    I forgot how good this pizza is! We visited the restaurant in Charlottetown for the first time in a…read morewhile, and it was sooo good. Restaurant is ok inside, lots of seating. Staff were friendly and pizza was delicious. We had a one vegetarian and one gluten free in our group so it was great that both were accommodated on the menu.

    Photos
    Famous Peppers - Dining area

    Dining area

    Famous Peppers - Beef brisket single

    Beef brisket single

    Famous Peppers - The restaurant

    See all

    The restaurant

    Randy's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...