1. Pymatuning Valley Resort

0

Andover, OH

Cancel

Open app

Search

Pymatuning Valley Resort

4.0 (1 review)

Pymatuning Valley Resort Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pymatuning Valley Resort

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

18 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Wester Farm Bed & Breakfast - Country setting among Amish farms near Jamestown. Very comfortable, great breakfasts, welcoming family.

Wester Farm Bed & Breakfast

(4 reviews)

Two Artists and a Farm! So happy to have found this place…read more We needed something in the Pymatuning, Conneaut Lake area, and found this place with an internet search of "farm accommodations". I called their number and got to speak with both of them and their warmth, and hospitality, was obvious. We stayed in one of the cabins and it had everything a hotel room would have. Actually more, as we had a small couch, and dining table to sit at besides normal hotel features. Top that off with a delicious breakfast that included, meat-cheese-veggie omelet, whole wheat toast, homemade YOGURT from a cow next door, with homemade jam. Homemade oat bread, and something else I can't remember. D-E-L-I-C-I-O-U-S! I want to mention that we were asked for any dietary restrictions during our reservation phone call. I encourage you to spend a few minutes chatting with Betty and Al. These humble, unassuming, wonderful people have led very interesting lives. Having been college educated Artists, they chose the farm life and have been farming, painting, sketching, and doing pottery, their entire adult lives. Truly amazing people worthy of a Netflix documentary. For entertainment we went to Mortal Key Brewing, and Gatehouse winery just down the road who had 2 live music stages going simultaneously.

Correct name is Wester Farm B&B. Country setting among Amish…read morefarms near Jamestown. Very comfortable, great breakfasts, welcoming family.

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Ashtabula-Geneva - My dad also has some good friends. A friend drove up from Bardstown Kentucky to get my dad because AAA sucks.!!!

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Ashtabula-Geneva

(19 reviews)

$$

I've very torn here between a 3 and 4 so I've erred on the side of 4 since overall I was pretty…read morehappy with our stay, however there were some clear pros and cons. Pros: - Location was convenient to the freeway, surrounding areas, and was safe - Hotel and room were very clean and updated - Breakfast had a wide variety of items and everything was hot and well-prepared - Staff was incredibly nice and went out of their way to help Cons: - The property needs some maintenance and upkeep. Surfaces like tables are worn and chipped. The huge lightshade in our room was broken and falling apart. Caulk and grout were cracked and looking poor, etc. - Humidity was really high indoors even though it wasn't horribly high outside. Our door would not close properly because of the humidity level and all my papers felt damp. - The public spaces (hallways, lobby, pool, etc) were very poorly lit with only these tiny wall sconces and no other lights. Overall, I would stay again, but definitely has some things needing improvement.

Missy needs a raise! I started with her pleasant voice on the phone!! My fathers transmission went…read moreout on his truck while he was traveling home to Louisville, Kentucky from Maine. Apparently there was a concert going on in the area and there were no available hotels Airbnb's or bed-and-breakfast so my father had to sleep in the Denny's parking lot across the way from this hotel the next morning, the 17th Sunday I had booked and room for him here and although check-in time was until 3 PM when I spoke to Missy she understood the circumstances that my father was going through and let him check in early and get a shower and some sleep. my dad is 78. He was traveling alone by himself and it was horrible knowing that he had to sleep at a rest area. I just want to take the time out to thank Missy for her hospitality and her compassion that she conveyed to my dad. I wish there were more people in the world like Missy cause heaven knows we're lacking them right now. Thank you Missy.!!

Green Acres Motel - Room with 2 Double Beds.

Green Acres Motel

(2 reviews)

I read the review about the 'Bate's Motel' award. There is a bed and breakfast not too far from…read morethat motel if you are interested in luxury. When we moved 100 miles to this area and couldn't move in right away we tried both. After one night in the B&B we left before breakfast. I work nights and had pets, children, and a babysitter that had to come with us. The B&B owner knew all of this prior to our staying. By 530am the owner of the B&B told me that Ma'am you need to change your lifestyle... we were gone gone before breakfast. The next night we stayed in two rooms at the Green Acres Motel (one for me and my husband, and one for the kids and sitter). Ok, the rooms weren't the most up to date... blah blah blah.... BUT the staff was incredible! They were unbelievably accommodating and friendly! The linens were clean and fresh, I felt very safe leaving my kids and sitter in a separate room. I live here and have summertime relatives who look for a place to stay for a few nights to visit in the winter, I have told them of both the B&B and Green Acres. But I would truly recommend Green Acres. If Anthony Melchiorri were to come and help them renovate they would be the best Motel around!!

After bicycling 2500 miles staying in 48 motels along the route we have finally found the motel…read morethat is the hands down leader for THE BATES MOTEL award. Grody tile in the bathroom, hole under bathroom sink, dirty bathtub caulking and fixtures from the 1960s. I'm a little scared! It's the only motel in Kinsman and touring bicyclists have few options as we can't easily drive to the next town. I keep repeating the mantra, " It's only one night. It's only one night!"

Buhl Mansion Guesthouse & Spa - Artist Loft

Buhl Mansion Guesthouse & Spa

(24 reviews)

My husband and I spent one night for our anniversary and everything was absolutely perfect. Check…read morein was done with careful covid precautions in place, which we appreciated. Once we got up from signing in, everything we touched was disinfected immediately and set for the next person. There was an optional short tour which we accepted and enjoyed, as well as champagne when we arrived. We stayed in the Grand Turret and it was a beautiful, clean and well appointed room. The welcome tray and bottle of champagne was a treat. There were robes and slippers in the room and a gorgeous, huge jetted tub with lots of fun bubbles and bath herbs to toss in. The bed was really comfortable. Breakfast the next morning was great. There was a menu of 3 or 4 options to choose from which were delivered to our room at the time we chose. The grounds and common rooms here are stunning. We didn't have much time to really sit and enjoy all of it but we did enjoy walking through and looking at all of the details around the property. The restoration done here is really something. Buhl's name is sprinkled on buildings and roads around the area and you can tell how appreciated he was in this town. We will definitely return for another visit (soon, we hope!) and maybe book an extra night so we can really take it in everything this Inn has to offer.

I loved it here! It is so warmly decorated, and for Christmas the mansion really shines. I took the…read moreChristmas tour, which was very interesting and Taylor was so knowledgeable about the history. After having been partially destroyed by fire, vacated by a vagrant, and after sitting unloved and overgrown, the house has taken new life after being restored by the Winner family in the past 29 or so years. It really is magical inside and outside. I can see why people choose this as a wedding venue. I would love to come back and stay there and experience the spa. The guest rooms are pristine and the grounds are gorgeous.

Polly Harper Inn - Main kitchen

Polly Harper Inn

(12 reviews)

$$

My husband has stayed 5 times, myself with him 3 times. It's pure MAGIC here. The grounds are…read morebeautiful! We've spent many hours on the benches discussing our future together. We are always so inspired here! We very nearly named our daughter (expecting soon) Harper to honor this wonderful house and its history (we aren't, but maybe our next one). We look forward to the clean rooms, and of course the scrumptious breakfast! The owners/caretakers are fabulous hosts. Sitting in the tower overlooking the vineyards is an experience like no other. I have the fondest memories here and we plan to return again and again for special occasions.

We chose the Polly Harper Inn Bed & Breakfast in Geneva because the charming pink house immediately…read moreappealed to us and offered a central location for our plans. The owners were very welcoming and accommodated our early arrival, greeting us kindly and making sure we could get settled in right away. The property has a nostalgic, "grandmother's house" feel. We stayed in the Robert Harper Suite, one of three units, which featured a loft that we especially enjoyed. The separate kitchen area was thoughtfully stocked with essentials like a coffee pot and refrigerator, and storage space. The four-seat dining table was a nice touch. Each room includes a hot tub for two, which had plenty of hot water throughout our stay. Breakfast was plentiful and satisfying--an assortment of fruit, pastries, muffins, fresh-baked bread, homemade granola, an fresh omelet for each guest. Sue is a good cook. It was delivered by 7:30 a.m., and guests served themselves. The dining room fits three couples, but guest rooms feature space to eat privately. During our stay, two couples who traveled together ate together, while we enjoyed breakfast privately in our suite. Housekeeping was attentive as our room was refreshed with clean towels and trash removal daily, even without requesting it. Small details stood out, like many nightlights placed in hallways and stairwells--especially helpful when going up to the loft. Many Grandma's heritage antiques, flowers and crafts of a gone by era are spread throughout the property. Only one downside; temperature control. The house was set on air conditioning, and while the days were pleasant, the evenings turned chilly (dropping below 40°F), and then it rained, bringing even more cool. The in-room fireplace heater wouldn't turn on, and unlike a hotel, the thermostat can't be adjusted per room. While we made do by layering with sweaters and pants, and using all the blanket bedding, it was chilly. It's something to keep in mind when visiting in changing to cooler Fall weather. Overall, the Polly Harper Inn offered a cozy, accommodating stay with lots of thoughtful touches. We especially appreciated the charm of the property, the attentive hosts, and the comfort of our suite. It was also quiet as we didn't hear the other guests very often. We'd stay again and thank you for the nice visit. Recommend checking them out is they are very competitive with a regular hotel room and you get so much more for your money

Edinboro Lake Resort - Cabin view from lake

Edinboro Lake Resort

(25 reviews)

Too good not to share what a wonderful time we had at Edinboro Lake Resort - Sunset Grill! If you…read morelive in the Edinboro/Erie/surrounding area or are looking to visit this area, I highly recommend you book a stay here for your own retreat or trip instead of a night in another chain hotel! We were looking for a 'staycation' that felt like a getaway, and that's exactly what we got! For all we knew, it felt like we had traveled hundreds of miles to a vacation destination tucked away on our own exclusive resort! Their team was great and access to the room was totally contactless. They are pet-friendly and have a # of different style cabins with varying degrees of luxury & with our cabin rental, we received free kayak/canoe rentals and also received a discount to rent a pontoon boat, which we did and would do again! P.S. you do NOT need a license to drive the boat and all life jackets (except infant) are provided! You can bring food and alc/non-alc beverages on board for everyone to enjoy, except the driver, who can still enjoy a nice mocktail. The cabins were squeaky clean and have everything you need and more, most importantly: wi-fi, TV(s), heat, and A/C! Some cabins have their own deck, picnic table, and grill, but there are MULTIPLE community fire-pits and grills scattered elsewhere throughout. Even though we did not stay in a cabin right on the water, the second row was elevated high enough to still have a lake view! BIG BONUS POINTS if you have kids, as they have a HUGE lake-side sandbox like I've never seen before and an awesome playground! Hungry? Thirsty? No problem - take a few steps and you're at the connected Sunset Grill restaurant, which has a gorgeous view and observatory, live music on some nights, and my most-favorite feature, little dining cubbies for larger groups with your OWN, personal, controllable heat lamp and fan - absolutely brilliant. (No reservations unfortunately, but they were very accommodating as we tried to seat our larger group) We will definitely be going back! (*they have video walkthroughs & way better pictures on their site FYI )

Place was dirty, dog hair everywhere. The power and water went out and the owner wouldn't answer a…read morephone call. We left a day early because of the situation, they TEXTED a day later saying we were trying to get a refund.

Pymatuning Valley Resort - hotels - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...