Obsessedddddddddddd with Pugnuts! From the vibe on the outside to the delicious ice cream, you cannot go wrong with stopping in here. On my wife and I's Maine Ice Cream trek, this was our second stop. It took so long to figure out which flavor to get because they have such good combos. They, of course, have the traditional flavors but they were very inventive with others which I always love. The flavor I ended up getting was something along the lines of coffee and brownies? I can't exactly remember the name because they change their specialty flavors daily but mannnnnnnnn it was so good! My wife got strawberry; deliciously simple. Service was kind and efficient and it was a lot larger inside than we expected so plenty of room to sit and enjoy your tasty treats. I would fly back to Maine just for Pugnuts. This was my favorite of all the ice cream places we tried. read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Coffee Ice Cream with Brownies and Strawberry Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

See all

We LOVE Pugnuts! We've been customers since the opened...and we lived in Texas! Now that we've moved to Surry, we go at least once a week. My hubby always tries something new each visit! We love the cute shop and exploring all the interesting candies and snacks, too. Everyone who works there is super knowledgeable and friendly! If you like gelato and/or ice cream, you should visit. read more

Went to Pugnuts on the recommendation of a fried, so I was stoked to go. My excitement was short lived. Very disappointed with the ice cream and the service. I went in all excited and told the girl behind the counter it was my first time. No response. I ordered the coffee ice cream with chocolate chunks. How disappointing. The ice cream barely tasted of coffee, it was more like muddy vanilla. The chocolate chunks were cookie bits, not chunks. Luckily I only got a single scoop. My companion got Fluffernutter which tasted like a random chunk of peanut butter on vanilla, not anything close to marshmallow. It was ok, but not worth any hype. The single scoop cost 6 bucks. Not worth it. read more

We stop here often when returning home from Ellsworth. There are loads of flavors and every single one I have tried is excellent. As a bonus, the place is super cute and charming. read more

See all

This little ice cream shop is so cute! The girl waiting on us was very helpful and kind. We got Chocolate ice cream in a chocolate dipped cone and a cup of salted caramel, both were lovely! We will definitely be back during our vacation for a little sweet treat! read more

Ridiculous. How many people knew we were heading to Maine and told us Oh! Go to such and such forest ... oh! You've got to see this one pond: It's The Best! Thanks for nothin, people. From now and forever I will tell anyone and everyone- PugNuts. Maine = PugNuts read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Especially the Gelato. And the ice cream pipe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

One of my favorite shops on the peninsula. So many options for a cool treat on a hot day. The staff is always friendly, and the shop is clean and well maintained. read more

We very much enjoyed our special outing here during our recent vacation. Everyone was super sweet and very excited to see us even though we got over to the shop right before closing. It was a bit expensive but a fun treat for vacation. read more

Great ice cream and gelato. Wonderful waffle cones. Kind and helpful service/staff. Multiple tables to sit and eat your cone at. Merchandise and fun facts also. read more

Excellent ice cream in a wide variety of fun flavors! Service was friendly and portions were generous.

What a delightful space with amazing tastes! My favorite is Lavendar Honey and wow...the flavors are AMAZING! GREAT service with smiles and patience as you try to decide which flavor to choose. Always the perfect choice. read more

Yummy ice cream, gelato and sorbet. Wish they would give multiple flavors for small sizes as there are 2 scoops and that they used a different sugar cone that does not leave paper residue when peeled off. read more

Stopped here on the fourth. Crowded but the kids working were great and not the least bit flustered. Ice cream was excellent! Definitely a must stop if you're in the area!! read more

If you're looking for ice cream in Surry, go to Pugnuts. If you're looking for ice cream in Ellsworth, go to Pugnuts. If you're looking for ice cream anywhere in Downeast Maine, go to Pugnuts. Seriously, their ice cream is amazing--creamy, rich, and smooth, with a great selection of flavors, friendly service, and reasonable prices. I always try to stop at least once (or twice, or thrice...) at Pugnuts while I'm in Maine, and after three years of doing so, I can say with absolute certainty that it's some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Period. As far as flavors go, I'd personally recommend either the peanut butter or coffee, but you quite literally cannot go wrong here. I simply can't recommend this place enough. Just go to Pugnuts. You'll be glad you did. read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Peanut Butter Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

Friendly service, great selection of ice cream and gelato flavors made on premises. Prices were reasonable and the store itself was charming. read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - a man standing outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

Very good homemade gelato, great customer service, and excellent Pug decor :-) We go to Maine every year for our family vacation and ever since Pugnuts opened it has become our go-to post hike spot for a summer treat! The gelato is very smooth and rich. For an added price you can get your gelato scooped in a fish cone- very cute but, personally, not worth the extra fee. The lobster claw shaped ice cream cones/sticks are a very unique item- I haven't come across them elsewhere in Maine. My partner always gets mint chocolate chip with rainbow sprinkles. I tried several fruit flavors before settling on c Restaurant is very clean and the customer service is great. They are willing to let you try as many flavors as you want, which is good for the more exotic choices. Our family friend lives in a nearby town and says the Annual Pug Jamboree and Pug Parade is not to miss. She and her Pug dress up in costume and join the other Maine pugs for some fun and games. Update- we have come back here during the COVID-19 pandemic and were very pleased with how PugNuts is implementing safety measures. I felt very safe and the staff was at a safe distance from customers. Glad we can support this local business. read more

See all

Great options including gelato and ice cream. Can't go wrong with the Italian chocolate chip gelato in a waffle cone or waffle bowl read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Italian chocolate chip gelato in a waffle bowl (medium) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

I bring my visitors here almost every time someone is at camp. We went out of our way yesterday to drive there from Penobscot for our lunch dessert and where not disappointed. Blackberry on a sugar cone and a chocolate combination on a sugar cone were the orders. A healthy small serving allows the customer to flavor two ice creams in one cone which I thought was nice with the small serving. For a 2 o'clock on a Thursday there was a steady crowd of tourists and what appeared to be regulars. The crew on hand was most solicitous. If you want soft serve, find another spot, if you want an adventure, stop here! read more

The ice cream at this store is out of this world. I had the Oak Bourbon flavor and my husband and I agreed that we'd not eaten ice cream this good before. The kids had strawberry and cream and cotton candy. Usually we don't like cotton candy and even my husband thought it was good. They were super careful with our peanut allergy. read more

Absolutely delicious and a great array of flavors to choose from so you won't get bored. Conveniently enough they are selling their ice creams in other restaurants and convenient stores throughout the area. It's creamy, smooth, always available and inventive. One of the best treats I've had in relation to ice cream. I'm not a big sweets person so if you are like me and not really into ice cream give this place a try. They combine the taste and textures of Italian gelato and traditional ice cream brilliantly and it's an ice cream shop you wouldn't want to miss. 10/10 for sure. read more

Creamiest ice cream I've ever had! I got cheesecake strawberry. It lived up to its name. DELICIOUS! The chocolate was rich too and the gelato was yummy and could pass for ice cream. Waffle cone is dipped in dark chocolate which is a perfectly needed bitterness with the sweet creamy ice cream! read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Chocolate ice cream and coffee gelato in a dark chocolate waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

See all

Loved it. Loved the proprietors, the flavors, everything. Our group of five showed up 15 minutes before closing and we were all extremely pleased. It's three days later and it's still being fawned over. Our fan favorite flavors: -whisky -grape nuts -peanut butter ...but they're all delicious. We know because we tried them. :) Plus, pug faced ice cream!!! (Photo posted) 100% recommend! read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Cute, cute, cute! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

No trip to the down east coast of ME is complete without a visit to PugNuts! The gelato is top drawer and full of creamy goodness. We are never disappointed with the choice of flavors or the Pug decor! If you are a fan of Pugs or gelato, (or both) this is your pilgrimage. Enjoy. read more

An ice cream experience. If you been to a Maine ice cream stand, then you haven't been to this Maine ice cream shoppe that is nestled in quiet Surry, Maine. A unique ice cream experience. Most who venture off to Acadia will delight at Blueberry Hill for ice cream, but for those with a more discerning palate come to Pugnuts for an experience. Delightfully, hand-crafted masterpieces of ice cream. Seriously, the ice cream is other worldly. Delicious, subtle, and mesmerizing. I would love to hear what others think about it. I love it, but it is too decadent for me on the regular...but oh, what a treat! read more

This little ice cream shop was tops in my book. Good, quality flavors, just the right amount of items, nice and friendly.

My family went here after lunch, I got a simple double scoop of chocolate in a bowl. It tasted so good! My brother got the warm chocolate lava cake and some of the flour wasn't fully mixed in though. Come here while you can! read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - My order in front of the place - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

I live for Pug Nuts. Recently got a summer house in Surry and there was always a line out the door for this place, so we decided to give it a try. Absolutely incredible ice cream/gelato. Strawberry Cheesecake is definitely my favorite. Special shout out to Timmy and Kathleen, they the realest. I wish I lived up here all year cause I'd definitely be here every week. My new #1 ice cream spot in Maine. read more

I appreciate the inventive ice cream flavors at Pugnuts! We especially enjoyed the straciatella ice cream and vegan lemon sorbet! Just delicious!! Highly recommend visiting Pugnuts. We enjoyed talking to their staff too. read more

Amazing as always!!! We tried several new flavors and all were wonderful!!! The birch bark was exceptional!! We ended buying several pints to take back honme. read more

Driving home from Bar Harbor, I decided ice cream would be a nice treat! I ordered the Pannacotta Gelato... yumminess overload! So glad we stopped here. Worth the detour! read more

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop - Pannacotta Gelato... yumminess overload! So glad we stopped here. Worth the detour! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Surry, Maine

Yum! The ice cream was delicious! The shop was really cute and had lots of different flavors. I got the pineapple flavor in a waffle cone and it was delicious! All of the ice cream is homemade and so are the waffle cones. They also sell adorable ice cream bars and even ice cream for dogs! I would definitely recommend pugnuts ice cream! It's worth the drive! read more

See all

Wonderfully set up for the CV situation. Great intercom for ordering. Simple system and you get ice cream fast. Staff friendly and helpful. I had been waiting to try for months. Unfortunately, taste wasn't close to the reputation. No hot fudge and my gelato tasted like wood thanks to the wood spoon. I applaud caring for the environment, but if you want to spend some money for hopefully good tasting ic/gelato, better also bring your own spoon. Otherwise I suspect all flavors will taste the same - wood! Reminded me of Italian Ice from the ice cream truck as a kid. That always tasted like the wood spoon too! And if your go to order is a hot fudge sundae, well, you're rolling the dice. Good luck. read more

Excellent gelato and ice cream in Surry Maine. Flavors are creamy, fresh, local yet authentically Italian too. Definitely worth stopping in for ice cream and cappuccino on summer day Yum! read more

They are so friendly here. Anything you want to try, they're more than willing for you to have a taste. Any questions? Just ask! They'll happily answer it with a smile. My wife got the butter pecan and she said it was the best ice cream she's ever had. I got the blueberry ice cream and it was pretty good seeing as though I'd never had such a thing before. Their waffle cones were good as well. Only down side is it's super expensive. Two small white chocolate waffle cones cost us $17.79. read more

I'm severely disappointed in this place as much as I wanted to love it. As a person with a severe dairy allergy (NOT lactose intolerance - a lot of people don't seem to understand this distinction) I was excited to see that they advertised non dairy flavors. Upon walking in, I saw zero flavors of sorbet available. This has been true the two or three times I've been inside, even though they claim to offer sorbet on their website. There was a sign advertising three non dairy flavors of "ice cream" - banana almond, coconut, and another one I can't recall. Okay, not a huge selection, but I can live with it. I asked for banana almond in a cone. Something was mumbled to me about consistency and they'd have to serve it in a cup with a cone on top. Oookay, fine. This should have been my first warning sign. Then they had to go "in the back" to get it, and whatever was served to me was put in a blender. I'm pretty sure it was just frozen bananas and almond milk. The consistency was terrible - icy, and nothing like real ice cream. The flavor was lacking, too. I'm pretty sure I paid upward of $8 for the privilege of eating this flavorless concoction. With so many non dairy options out there (Ben and Jerry's, anyone?) I know this can be executed well, and my expectations aren't too high. Actually, there's a place in Bar Harbor, CJ's, that offers six or seven non dairy options daily - two or three sorbets, two or three soy ice creams (like chocolate graham cracker, cherry chocolate chip, vanilla peanut butter) in the display case, and an almond milk chocolate/vanilla swirl soft serve. I wish this place wouldn't even bother considering themselves non dairy friendly. Try harder, Pugnuts. Your regular ice creams look fantastic, but this non dairy thing is a sham. read more

A good selection of gelatos and sorbets and a great selection of both coated and plain waffle cones and bowls that should suit anyone's taste buds. Throw in plenty of parking friendly staff and a very convenient location and this shop makes a very nice stop for when it's time for a treat! read more

Pugnut's, where do I begin...? Let's start with the actual ice cream: Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop has very cool flavors like Blue Berry, Nutella, Chocolate Gelato, Lemon, and Cotton Candy. But they kind of lack for flavor. They do have different cakes and Lucy's Granola though. The staff there is very nice and super helpful, but can sometimes get annoyed. You can also taste test which is good. They have little gifts and snacks there for anyone who might want to grab a little gift or something. Pugnut's also has merch ( shirts, etc.) It is overpriced there, so this might just be a treat for some. This is why my rating is at four stars: because it cost more for less. It's one of the better places for ice cream though so I recommend it over others. Have fun! read more

This is a cute shop in the small coastal town of Surry, down the Blue Hill Peninsula. The signage really draws you in...I mean the shop is called Pugnuts. I've wanted to go in here for the longest time, just based on the name. The ice cream is good. I had caramel cashew and enjoyed it. There was the right amount of cashew and caramel throughout, a good blend of all flavors. I ordered a medium dish, and it was the right amount for me. Quantity is not quality. The shop is cute. It looks like an ice cream shop. Light and airy inside. It is cute. Digital screens behind the counter give prices and options. I really don't like this. I know, it is strange, but it is like McDonalds or Burger King with the digital screens. I was really put off. You have this quaint shop, with large TV screens on the wall scrolling through options. The juxtaposition of the cuteness of the shop, then contrasted by the technology seems contradictory. It becomes stock at that point. I wish there were a few more options for ice cream. The flavors are split between gelato and ice cream. And for two medium sized dishes it was $10, but any add ons jacks the price up. So, for dishes, its reasonable, but go past that, it becomes pricey and pretentious. read more

Best gelato evvahh!!! We Always try to take a detour to Surrey and visit pugnuts on the way to bar harbor. They really do have the most creative flavors and out of this world tasting gelato in Maine! Friendly owner and cool decor makes it a nice experience for every age. Can't wait to go back! read more

Delicious ice cream! Lots of yummy flavors! The employees are always friendly, and every time I've gone, they have not been shy with their scoops read more