We stayed on the east side of Evansville this weekend for our son's hockey tournament and always eat at local joints when out of town. This place did not disappoint! Curb appeal for the place isn't the best but the food is great. I got the sweet heat smash burger and it was AMAZING. Our son got the slider app as his meal (plain and cheese on the side because he doesn't like melted cheese) well done patties and they came out exactly like we wanted. Spouse got the Cesar blackened chicken salad and loved it. I sampled the dressing and it was killer! The pretzel bread stick that come with salads was also really good. Prices are great. Beer and spirits options were amazing. And let's talk about the service. If the people who run this place are reading this, Brandon gets a 6/5 star review. Friendly, attentive, gave us suggestions, and an overall great guy. Fantastic employee! Thank you Brandon! read more

The patty's were so hard and was hard as a rock. We used door dash and when we called prime time, they tried to blame them. Do better read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - 3 beef slider appetizers. - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Staying in town on my way to work, I decided to see what was available. This was a great surprise! While it looks like a strip mall esque chain, it's local and is very inviting once you arrive. Couple that with being ULTRA clean and you have a great first impression. The staff were very pleasant, helpful, and quick. I sat at the bar and the service was extraordinary. As for the prime rib; ABSOLUTELY amazing. Perfectly cooked to my specifications, complimented by a baked potato with basic accoutrements at my request, this was the perfect meal! Highly recommend going past the chains and get here as quick as you can. read more

Finally tried Prime Time recently and had a wonderful experience with family. We all enjoyed our meals. I ordered the mushroom snd Swiss burger and tots for the side. Everything was great including service and the ambiance was relaxed. I'd return and recommend to others. read more

Bar food un-elevated. Sorry to say over done chicken tenders, dense dry mashed potatoes, no ketchup or honey mustard to choke any of it down. We ordered the line for a pick up, and it was ready when it was supposed to be. Lace looked like every other manufactured pub and grill. Emotional damage read more

Well the credit card surcharge is back under the cover of 'cash discount'. Same thing as a surcharge but sounds good though. One thing is that they list cash discounts on the menu instead of the actual price before the discount. Not sure this is even legal but doesn't matter. Looking for good places to eat without gimmicks. read more

We were looking for a nice place to have dinner and drinks before a football game and Prime Time did not disappoint. My husband was able to watch the Hoosiers on multiple TV's... as well as other sports networks. Of course I was excited that they had Michelob Ultra on tap and it was perfectly chilled. My husband ordered the old fashion and was pleased with the taste. We were especially excited that they served us pub chips while we waited. Our food was served quickly and our first bite was the French onion soup. It was good, but the taste was a little different. It had a smoky flavor that my husband liked... but it probably wasn't a highlight for me. The prime rib with au jus and horseradish was delicious... perfectly cooked! Our service was definitely worth 5 stars! Derek, Devin and Ben were fantastic and quick to deliver and clean up! * we came back after the game and we were greeted by name! WOW!! Thank you for such amazing service! read more

See all

Timely seating, immediately and attentively greeted. Excellent food; Fresh, hot flavorful chicken quesadillas. Beer cheese is a must try with the pretzel sticks. Nice atmosphere. Will visit in the future! read more

We rented out the room next door to the restaurant for a work event, which Prime Time catered. The room was brightly lit, and we played corn hole. The server was quick and attentive, and the food was tasty. read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - Corn hole and catering - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Great service and food. Everyone was very gracious on giving great suggestions. Great place to stop by for drinks or a .eal. read more

First time dining here. Food was delicious and the server was friendly and patient as we decided what to order from the wide variety of options. House made chips were great! We also got a pork tenderloin, chicken wrap, and chicken tenders. Price was a little high for some items but we will return. read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - Plain Pork Tenderloin - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Prime dip sandwich is our favorite. Not super expensive and good portions. Tater tots are a great side

Great restaurant. Good Meat! I had a great burger. The staff are friendly. Food is delicious. I wish it was quieter. The previous establishment was noisy as well. That's why only 4 stars. I'd give them 4 Bellies on my scale. read more

Mondays are half price burgers. And they are big and juicy. They start you off with homemade chips which are crispy and tasty. They have drink specials also. Live entertainment on their patio is a plus for an evening. Always had friendly and prompt service whether in the dining room, bar or on the patio. I recommend this place for food, service and ambiance. read more

When we arrived we were seated immediately. It was 1pm on Saturday. A bowl of complimentary homemade chips were served. They were cold and overcooked. Some were almost burned. We ordered onion straws as an appetizer. They were limp and left a greasy taste in our mouths. Served with a smoky Ranch dip that did not work for me. My wife and i ordered the Prime Dip sandwich. I added peppers and onions to mine. My wife did not. The large bun was split in half with thin sliced beef piled over the bun with melted cheese and onion straws heaped on top. It was so much there was no way to fold it to dip it in the au jus. After she started eating her sandwich, she found hers had been made with peppers and onions too. She just pulled them out because she didn't want to wait for a new sandwich to be made. Service was okay but only around four or five tables had customers. When our server came to ask if our food was okay, my wife hadn't found the onions and peppers yet and our server never returned to see if we needed anything. The restaurant was nice. The food just left a lot to be desired. Plus the check before tip was $51.05 for sandwiches for lunch on a Saturday! read more

My wife and I were cordially invited out for an honorary evening and while we were in the Newburgh area we decided that we would go out to eat afterwards. We decided upon this place after a little debate on trying something new and eating Indian food. As you can tell I lost the debate and we settled for a truly American style restaurant. I have never been here before and was thoroughly pleased with my wife's selection. We entered the restaurant and only stood there maybe two minutes before being seated. The booth was nice and the ambiance was great for an evening meal for two. The table was sticky though. From what I gathered it was the paint and would be willing to bet that every table was sticky. We were served water without asking for it and also some house made chips were brought in a moderately sized bowl. I was the first to try the chips and the water. I later gleaned my wife's take on them both. The water was absolutely tap water. No filter. The chlorine after taste was superb. The chips were certainly very crunchy but felt almost stale, albeit they did have a good flavor and I was hungry and ate most of the bowl assuming the texture was supposed to be as it was. We were also offered more water before our chlorinated pitcher was empty so I was obliged to say of course. Then our waiter came by and took our order. She didn't come back but to deliver the bill and receive payment. Our food was delivered accurately and seemingly promptly. The food was wonderful. I had the prime burger. I mainly chose this because the menu wishes you luck in the description? My wife ordered the prime dip with onions and peppers, for a little extra $$. It was served with a Au jus sauce and some horseradish sauce. The prime burger was great. When I ordered it I was asked "Red or no red" . I said no red. The burger had the patty, bacon, and bbq on it and it was really good. The fries were good too! Especially dipped in the horseradish sauce. I tried the prime dip as well. It was really good too. And it reheated well in the microwave as a leftover. The place was nice and I had a good time with my wife for a night on the town. Thanks Prime Time. read more

See all

My kids took me to prime time Newburgh June 14 for Father's day. Our took our orders and came around a second time to make sure he had everything right. 5 of the six of us ordered salads and asked they be served before our entree's. I ordered a 12 ounce ribeye medium rare and a baked potato. Our entree's came out followed by our salads. It isn't very often I say the salad was the better part of my meal. But it was. My baked potato could have passed for one fixed the day before. My steak was closer to well done than medium rare. I should have sent it back but didn't want to be there all night. I brought it home and tried to make a sandwich with it. A LOST CAUSE. Food is usually pretty good but not this time. read more

Not going to lie I felt a little out of place based off my skin complexion and not knowing exactly where I was at first. When I went in to eat, my waitress was super sweet and actually funny. I was treated great and friendly and was checked on by multiple people. The beyond burger with mushrooms and onions was "Bussin Bussin" I wanted to stop there again. 10/10 for me the homemade chips weren't bad at all. I'd given them an 8/10 and the tots were great too. My bro had the chicken wrap and fries and he said it was really good as well. The inside of the restaurant was nice and clean as well. I'd highly recommend you eat here!! read more

See all

Really impressed by Prime Time!! Both my husband and I got the Mac Daddy burger and it was GREAT! Good service and fries were decent too. Overall, we were very happy we chose Prime Time for our date night dinner. read more

Our 1st time here. Really liked it. Great service, cool place, good food ( we liked everything we ordered including kids meals except onion soup. I was not really impressed by onion soup), great beer selection and cocktails. read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

I drove two hours away to come here for dinner, and overall I'm let down and disappointed. Service was excellent. The waiter, Brandon, was very attentive, patient, and kind. The tots with pulled pork tasted good with extra bbq sauce ordered on the side. However, the ribeye was very bland, and overcooked, which thankfully I ordered rare, because it was medium rare, with only a slightly red center. My GF ordered the blackened salmon, with the bourbon glaze, which was hard and dry, blatantly overcooked. Not sure how that made it out of the kitchen. The mashed potatoes were... horrible. The cheese on them was cold, and they tasted like air. The drinks are okay I guess. Would not come back unless I was being paid to. read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - Ribeye (rare?), loaded mashed potatoes - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Quaint little restaurant in Newburgh, IN. The space is half restaurant, half bar. We sat in the restaurant side for dinner on a Saturday evening. Walked in at 5pm and were greeted and seated right away. Food: complimentary for each table is water and homemade pub chips. Not a bad way to start off while looking over them menu. But not an option for the low-carb, Keto people. Overall it's not good. In fact it's the reason I don't think this will be repeated again. We ordered the prime rib, broccoli and Caesar salad. Also the sea bass, seasonal veggies (zucchini, squash and onion) and Caesar salad. Our waitress took our order and returned to tell us they weren't serving salads and were out of lettuce. The other options for sides were all carbs or applesauce. (Seeing a trend yet with the menu?!) Our meals were brought out in 17 min!!! While most of the time you want fast service- how quick did they cook that meal? Or was it microwaved? And just as one would suspect the tasting went awful. Broccoli was cold in the center, refrigerator cold. The prime rib was order med well and was cold in the center. (That would not be med well!) Sea Bass was decent and warm. All veggies were Lukewarm as well. We overheard our waitress with another table and she brought them salads. Even tho we were told they didn't have any. A manager walked past every table asking how they were doing and surprisingly one never stopped by our table. Our waitress never bothered to ask how everything was either. Price - same price as anywhere else. $20-25 per person. Overall: not carb or keto friendly (if that's your thing!), not overly priced, service is quick and staff is friendly. But the food - thumbs down read more

The food was so delicious and we left stuffed. They also have an amazing assortment of bourbon and drinks on tap. Had the blueberry cider. Yummy read more

My all time favorite restaurant in Newburgh and maybe even Evansville. The prime rib sandwich with the onion straws on it is to die for. The manager is super nice, the owner is awesome too. They both will check on you to make sure you're happy with everything. The last time I went with a friend, her chicken in her wrap wasn't cooked and they made things right. I hope that cook was let go though. Who knows. But I'd still go back, regardless. It's that good. Trust me. read more

Our first time here. From arrival to checking out, we had a wonderful experience! We sat on the pet-friendly patio in perfect weather, after being promptly shown to our seats by an endearing hostess. The hostess ensured our fur babies and both of us got water quickly, as well as house-made chips (yummy, salty goodness!) The bartender, Trey, made a perfect old fashioned for me & sported awesome old fashioned socks and gave our fur babies some love! My husband and I each ordered an 8 ounce filet with side salad, his with fries, mine with broccoli. The steaks were seasoned perfectly! Yum! Both were more rare than medium rare, as ordered, but better under than over cooked for me. My broccoli was fabulous as were his fries! I'm excited to go back and try more items on the menu!! read more

See all

Great food, service and atmosphere! Lunch pick two is good and so is dinner menu. Steaks are always cooked to perfection.

Service is always on point, food is fresh, hot, and fantastic. Always a good variety and drink specials daily. read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - Meat the Meat prime rib, broccoli, & mashed potatoes. - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

A bit overpriced and underwhelming, with no atmosphere to speak of, really. A few fake plants are scattered about, and someone stenciled the name of the pub on the wall here and there, but otherwise it was pretty spartan and gave off a bare bones vibe (e.g., this is one of those restaurants where the condiments and seasonings are so precious, they have to be hidden in the back out of reach, lest a customer get too carried away). Although the service was prompt and the fries were seasoned really well, we left feeling we had paid an arm and a leg for slightly-better-than-standard American bar food. A high price feels justifiable when enjoying the ambience is half the fun, but I have no real desire to go back. A burger is a burger. read more

After slow start due to a miscommunication with hostess and waitress, everything came out tasting great. We all wanted burgers and this is the place to come for that. House made potato chips while you wait and the fried pickle spears were crispy and perfectly seasoned. Our friends were here for lunch and raves so we came for dinner. Definitely recommend. read more

Lindsey was absolutely delightful! Her service was top notch. The food was awesome. The recommendations Lindsey made were spot on and my family enjoyed them very much! We will be back very soon and request Lindsey to be our server. Thank you Lindsey for making our experience here a good one! read more

Good food, good menu. High prices, too attentive waiter. Tip "recommendations" started too high. Tired of applications telling what I should tip. read more

Local pub with great food. My husband and I go there mainly for the consistently good service. The owner must be awesome to work for because he has the same faces working for him after a few years. Salads, burgers, flatbreads, breadsticks, and chili 110 on a 100 scale. Keep it local. read more

I went there tonight with a group of friends (10 of us total). It was my first time there and WOW! This place has it going on! Management is walking around making sure everything is good, but, honestly they didn't need to. McKinley was our waitress and she was awesome! Went above and beyond. They have lighter/healthier options. I got shrimp on a bed of romaine with a side of broccoli. It was amazing. The Mac and cheese looked truly amazing but I didn't order it. I just heard about how good it was! Amazing Service, food, and drinks...yes, we will absolutely be back! read more

My husband and I dropped in for lunch. The waitress was so sweet, and lunch was very good!

We went before it got busy, so service was on top of things and we had a great server. We both liked the food, I got a club sandwich and Mac and cheese which was very good. We got wings as appetizers but they didn't come till after the food because they were frying chicken for a catering gig. They should have a better set up for that, if it was any busier, that would have been a huge issue, especially since they were driving the carts through the dinging area and out the front door to get to their other location. Overall, the food we had was great and we most likely will be back. read more

Enjoyed the food and the friendly staff. The prices were fair. I'll definitely be back.

Restaurant was unexpected find. The food was really good. We had burger and the chicken sandwich. Prices were not horrible either. The restaurant is very comfortable but a bit small. We got in right away but went before 5pm. We just had one tea and the bill was $50. That's a bit higher than normal. But the burger was ground prime rib so very tasty. read more

Fantastic food. Burgers are a must here. Love the Mac and cheese! The cheesecake is splendid as well.

Food was GREAT!! Server Justin was amazing! And lets talk about that smokin house ranch yeah im in love

I'm giving it a 3 for the ambiance and staff. The steak isn't anything to be proud of for sure. read more

Prime Time Pub and Grill - The amount of fat that I had to cut off my steak. At least 5 ounces of fat which for a 12 ounce steak isn't a good thing. - Pubs Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana