Fantastic spot for ice cream! Friendly people that are happy to describe the flavors, even…read moresuggesting tastings. Cute set up too with benches to enjoy your baseball-size scoops of delight.

Cute lil spot next to the golf course. We love coming here and sitting on the tailgate in the…read moreparking lot. Ice cream is great!!

Good ice cream Numerous options…read moreGood service Why does Yelp need reviews to be wordy?Just promoting padding reviews!

Not homemade ice cream. Good outdoor seating but the ice cream was not very good. I may be an ice…read morecream snob lol but it was a little icy. It's a cute setup, nice outdoor area and parking but ice cream is just ok

Honeycone is a wonderful little ice cream shop that I stumbled upon while checking out some shops…read morein Cheshire. They offer a variety of seasonal flavors, and they've just swapped to their winter ones! I got a cup with gingerbread ice cream and chocolate orange ice cream. There were a bunch of other flavors though, like a peppermint one and eggnog! Since there's a good number of seasonal flavors, it was hard to figure out which one to try! While they unfortunately don't offer samples, they do offer an ice cream flight with 6 small scoops for $13.50. Tempting, but I unfortunately didn't need 6 scoops so I went with just the two! A cute option nonetheless. They do let you mix and match flavors of the scoops you get, so I got to try two. The flavors were phenomenal, I was so happy to get try them. What a pleasant little surprise in the middle of a cute shopping area!! I certainly recommend it here.

Delicious little ice cream shop. I had the seasonal peppermint stick and it was perfect.read more

Huge amount of ice cream for the price. It was yummy. We all liked it. Nice outdoor space to eat…read moreit but it was chilly so we ate inside.

Such a good vibe. Outside seating only but lots of tables and a gazebo and space to stand. The…read morescoops they give are HUGE! Like such big scoops. Lots of flavors and seasonal flavors too (I loved mudslide seasonal flavor)! Line can get long but moves fast!

I'm not sure I have the story right, but it seems like Fenwick Ice Cream moved across the street…read morefrom it's old location. I'm guessing from some limited information that the at least some of the owners are the same, but I don't really know. In any event, the new space is bigger inside. Meaning you can actually walk inside now. There is still significant outside seating. They also seem to serve some limited non-dessert food. Like the day I was there, they had lobster rolls and hot dogs. There isn't any reason why I would change my prior review score. Service was friendly. They have 33ish flavors of hard ice cream. I had a hard time picking a flavor because I was looking for something different, but the flavors seemed fairly standard. I ultimately ordered a sugar cone with a scoop of key lime pie ice cream. They asked if I wanted any toppings, and I asked for a single Blue Raspberry Sour Patch Kid on top because I thought it would look cool. The ice cream flavor was good. It had like a pie crust swirl which added some contrasting flavor and texture.

First time at Fenwicks on Rt 1 right in the heart of Old Saybrook and I was satisfied. The ice…read morecream was great, I tried their famous Toasted Almond. The kid working there had his hands full with a long line, working solo but didn't skip a beat. The thing this place gets right where most ice cream shops get wrong, is the bright digital menu signs mounted up high. You can actually stand in line and see what they have. Other shops you don't know what they have until you get up to the register, thus causing delays and indecisiveness. I dislike the ice cream sample tasting though. This should be banned. It's only ice cream, take a chance. When there are 15 people in line, the rest of us don't have the patience for you to sample a flavor and think about it before committing to buying a 1-scoop cup. Ok my rant is done, but Fenwick's is a great place with great ice cream.

Oh how I love twisters! It's finally back open for the 2026 season! Perfect outdoor seating (only),…read moreyou go up and order at the window and they'll call out your number. Right on the water, so you have perfect views. They serve hard and soft serve with lots of toppings. It's always high school/college kids working but they've always been nice and respectful! Takes Apple Pay too :)

Rating: 4.5…read more Delicious and reasonably priced ice cream! $5 for a single scoop. The ice cream was thick and creamy and tasted fresh. The oreo had a fair amount of oreo pieces in it; the cookie dough didn't have much cookie dough in it (hence the .5 star). There's plenty of picnic table seating and it's by the water which is nice. Service was fast-- by the time my boyfriend was ordering after me, my scoop was ready. Totally recommend and it was pretty close to the Mystic Seaport Museum.

Stopped in to try their milkshakes. Attached to the store on the right side. So plenty of…read moreparking, was able to park right in front of the window. Menu was very easy to read and understand. Lit of choices. Was surprised that they had more ice cream options, and noticed they had what they called New Orleans styled sno-balls, which looked like an icee but with larger ice and added flavors. Prices were reasonable. Milk shakes were thick and creamy.

Ordered two sundaes here tonight -- had them made with "Moosetracks" but it was a fake variety and…read morenot very good. We assumed there would be hot fudge topping but everything was served cold. Not much taste really.

It's always a special treat to be close enough to stop at the Salem Valley Farms Ice Cream stand…read more I sampled the nondairy (almond milk) apple pie & Pumpkin cheesecake ice creams and decided on the pumpkin with chocolate sprinkles and it was delicious! Love the bits of Graham cracker crust in it. My parents ordered the cherry vanilla, and strawberry ice cream. I have written about the location in the past and nothing has changed. It's a very charming place.

Ice cream, you scream we all scream for ice cream! Fantastic homemade ice cream here. My seasonal…read moreice cream request of Banana Fudge Swirl was creamy decadence with fudge ribbon throughout- so yummy! The young lady taking the order was very friendly. You'll order at the window, and there's no inside seating. Plenty of picnic tables outside.

What a great list of home made flavors! My sister had the mint chip, and it wasn't neon green,…read morewhich is a good indicator of a solid ice cream in our books. I got the Vermont maple nut and it tasted just like maple nut goodies! (RIP) Definitely a great place for ice cream, and it's open late which is a plus!

A Sweet, Iconic Stop: Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream…read more Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream is one of those rare places where the nostalgia hits just as hard as the flavor. It's the kind of shop that feels woven into the fabric of Mystic itself--warm, welcoming, and perched right over the water with a view that makes every scoop taste a little sweeter. Ice Cream That Actually Lives Up to the Hype The ice cream here is rich, creamy, and clearly made with care. Flavors are bold without being artificial, and classics like chocolate, vanilla, and mint chip are elevated by how fresh and balanced they taste. Their specialty flavors--especially anything with fudge, cookie chunks, or local ingredients--are the real standouts. Every scoop feels indulgent in the best way. A Location That Makes the Experience There's something magical about enjoying your cone while watching the drawbridge rise and fall. Whether you're inside by the windows or outside taking in the breeze, the setting adds a charm you just can't replicate. It's a perfect stop during a Mystic stroll, and it's hard not to linger a little longer than planned. Friendly, Patient Service Even when the line stretches out the door (and it often does), the staff stays upbeat and helpful. They're quick with samples, happy to make recommendations, and keep things moving without making anyone feel rushed. It's the kind of service that makes the whole experience feel personal. A Must‑Visit in Mystic Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream earns every bit of its reputation. Great flavors, generous portions, a beautiful waterfront setting, and genuinely kind staff make it a five‑star stop every time. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this is one of those Mystic staples you don't skip. Andddd they are opened year round!!! Cheers

Love Scottie's Custard better than ANY other area ice cream shop!…read moreService is great! Flavors of the day or week vary for added variety. Definitely recommend Scottie's!

Food was excellent! The staff was super nice and fast. My only thing was that i wish i knew that…read morethe various toppings for the burgers cost extra, either it's not posted on the menu board or i missed it. Custard is delicious too. We would definitely go back there again.