I ordered through DoorDash and they didn't even accept or confirm the order until my dasher was…read morealready there and waiting - almost 30 minutes later. After the food got delivered I noticed the matzo balls were only two per cup and kind of small but otherwise "decent" at best. The problem I had was when I was almost halfway done eating half of a breakfast wrap - I bit in and found a used bandaid that must have fallen off of whoever was making the sandwich when they were wrapping. I called to complain about it and the person who answered the phone was surprised and said they'd issue a credit but I had to reach out to DoorDash hours later to get it resolved by myself. Under no circumstances should anyone bite into their food and find a used bandaid - this place is disgusting.

Great bagel place. Ordered a simple ham and cheese with mayo and they did not hesitate to do a…read moregreat job.

My girlfriend brought sandwiches from Mario's this past Friday. I had the Honey's Honey and it…read moreabsolutely delicious. The other 3 girls had the Italian Sub which they said were very good..The sandwiches had a lot of meat on them.. These 3 girls and myself meet up every 2 months for lunch at one of the girls house. At our next meet up I will ask my friend to please pick up the Honey's Honey for me.. I

Extremely Disappointing Experience - Ignored and Forgotten…read moreMy son and I visited Mario's Deli today, May 17, 2025, around 12:45 PM, and it was hands down the worst deli experience I've ever had. We walked in and were completely ignored by the staff for a full 15 minutes. It wasn't until another customer came in and looked ready to order that I had to speak up and point out that we hadn't been served. I placed a simple order for two sandwiches: one plain turkey sandwich and one half pastrami with American cheese and mustard. After another 15 minutes passed, during which at least four other customers who came in after us received their orders, our sandwiches were still nowhere in sight. When I inquired, the staff claimed they "might've fell somewhere" and they couldn't find our order ticket. By this point, my son had been waiting patiently for 45 minutes just to get a simple sandwich. I had to specifically ask them to please, quickly make my son's sandwich as he was very hungry. I always try to be understanding and avoid confrontation, but this level of disregard and inefficiency is unacceptable. Waiting 45 minutes for two basic sandwiches, being ignored, and then told our order was lost is beyond frustrating. This experience has unfortunately pushed me to share this negative review. We will not be returning to Mario's Deli.

Excellent cooking and definitely wholesome fresh food. I try to get there at least two visits per…read moreweek due to my travel schedule. The best sandwich is hard to select due to overflow of freshly prepared food. Honestly I continue to coat my sandwich's with delicious "hot" sauce but you have to ask. Ready made dinners are another wonderful treat. The adjoining pub is small but if you want a drink and meet some of the local people I promise you a decently made special drink and experience new liquors presented with taste.

OK, all the comments about employees attitudes was right on the mark today. Rather terse and abrupt…read morebut the order (Chef Salad ) was perfect and meat, cheese, vegetables were fresh and had excellent taste. Next time I'll get a sub/hero sandwich which is the core of their spring and summer business. New owners or not, these people should find a job they enjoy doing and spread that new happiness around to the vast and varied array of customers. After waiting and commenting, I did get a smile which was appreciated. About five people were waiting but in all honestly they tried very hard to keep pace and get the orders on the counter.

Best bagels in Sussex County! They always get my order right and the staff is friendly.read more

Just stopped in today to get a cinnamon raisin bagel and I gotta tell you the experience is just…read moreamazing. They are quick to take your order quick to complete it yet. The quality of food is always excellent and it is Service with a smile. They treat you like you're the only customer in the store. I will tell you they are always busy so if you're planning on stopping in, make sure you have a few extra minutes. It is worth the weight.

Always good, always quick, always tasty. Bottom line - one of the better bagel stores in the area…read moreplus parking is ample

Small little bagel shop that has delicious bagels! We hit up this place on our way to go hiking in…read moreNorvin Green State Forest. We got a breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel with Taylor ham, bacon and cheese and it was loaded with meat. Also got an everything bagel with bacon scallion cream cheese which was delicious. Prices here are also great and service was quick and friendly!

The best BEC there is! After many trials of surrounding bagel joints this is our fave! The staff…read moreand service is great/always accommodating any requests or revisions. SO good!

Everything we have had from Bagel Train is so delicious! Bagel breakfast sandwiches are so good and…read moreare so substantial. Also try their chicken cutlet sandwiches, the chicken is so crispy and tasty. Also it's a big portion!

Poor attitudes from the staff, no logical method of taking and filling orders. And the quality of…read morethe product is low.

Daughter recommended it a few years ago. They have good coffee. I drink it black so it has to be…read morequality. Bagels are great. They get the orders done very quickly. The outside has the right crunch to the inside which is soft. I like Taylor Ham and egg with nothing on it. They know what a TH sandwich is supposed to be, thick sliced Taylor Ham. All the other bagel stores in the area are slicing the TH very thin, that's no good, and since TH and any combo of cheese and eggs is only a north Jersey thing for 50 years it's sliced thick. I recommend driving the extra 3.1 miles from Skyline Drive.

First time walking in and this place slapped me in the face with options. You know how most bagel…read moreshops give you the classics? Nope. Here it's like: "Oh you want a simple bagel? Cute. But have you considered 47 cream cheeses, 19 sandwiches, and a few items that made me stop and ask... wait, why is this here?" Not complaining though, it's actually impressive. There are choices that make perfect sense for a bagel shop, and then there are choices that feel like someone said, "Let's keep them guessing." Honestly? Respect. Variety for every type of mood and personality. If you're decisive, you'll walk out with something amazing. If you get overwhelmed easily... you might just stand there staring at the menu like it's a final exam. (Good problem to have.) Staff was super nice, friendly, and efficient. I was in and out ridiculously fast. No chaos, no attitude, just smooth operation. Place itself is small and clean, but comfortable and well kept.

Context: Mo - owner…read more Fantastic selection. He offered to increase my drink at most cost - which when you compare with the great food means I willl always visit here whenever around the area. Got the bagel sandwich warm with eggs, bacon, avocado as well as a coffee. Food was great!

Not a bad bagel place, but not great either. It was a convenient location for me for quite a while…read moreso I've been there during many different times of the year. They're cash only with an atm on premises, which is slightly annoying. I'd bring cash to avoid any fees. They have a decent selection of bagels and breakfast sandwiches. Lately, however, the breakfast sandwiches have been lackluster with their Taylor Ham feeling just slightly warmed. The bagels themselves are decent but nothing amazing, and their cream cheese options are very limited. If you're looking for a bagel place close to Mountain Creek, they're probably your best bet.

miss the old owner!! if he was out of our fave everything bagels that was it for the day. today…read more5/13/26 we got bagels around 11am and im pretty sure the were yesterdays bagels. they were stale. ripped up the roofs of our mouths. the inside looks great but we won't be getting bagels there again. very disappointing. don't mind paying the higher prices for them but only if they're fresh which these were the furthest from.

This place is pretty good, with well-priced items. I haven't had the breakfast sandwiches yet, but…read morethe croissant and elephant ear were good.

I've been coming to this bagel shop for well over 30 years and it never disappoints. They make the…read moremeanest bacon egg and cheese. The bagels hard on the outside and are chewy and delicious on the inside. This staff is incredibly friendly as well. These bagels are so good that through the years when I've been away from home I've stocked up and froze the bagels to have long term. To me no other bagel compares to this place. I will forever love and come to this bagel shop. They have the best bagels in NJ in my book.