Got a chance to check out the new place in town, and I hope they're here to stay. Tried the chicken…read moresalad sandwich which was tasty. Great menu, great service, great ambiance, and how refreshing it is to have one more option in town for breakfast and lunch. Parking is not an issue and they have a few tables inside so you can enjoy dining in. Looking forward to trying more of their menu in the coming weeks.

Ive enjoyed everything ive ordered there, friendly staff and owner, good prices, will definitely…read morecome again.

My girlfriend brought sandwiches from Mario's this past Friday. I had the Honey's Honey and it…read moreabsolutely delicious. The other 3 girls had the Italian Sub which they said were very good..The sandwiches had a lot of meat on them.. These 3 girls and myself meet up every 2 months for lunch at one of the girls house. At our next meet up I will ask my friend to please pick up the Honey's Honey for me.. I

Extremely Disappointing Experience - Ignored and Forgotten…read moreMy son and I visited Mario's Deli today, May 17, 2025, around 12:45 PM, and it was hands down the worst deli experience I've ever had. We walked in and were completely ignored by the staff for a full 15 minutes. It wasn't until another customer came in and looked ready to order that I had to speak up and point out that we hadn't been served. I placed a simple order for two sandwiches: one plain turkey sandwich and one half pastrami with American cheese and mustard. After another 15 minutes passed, during which at least four other customers who came in after us received their orders, our sandwiches were still nowhere in sight. When I inquired, the staff claimed they "might've fell somewhere" and they couldn't find our order ticket. By this point, my son had been waiting patiently for 45 minutes just to get a simple sandwich. I had to specifically ask them to please, quickly make my son's sandwich as he was very hungry. I always try to be understanding and avoid confrontation, but this level of disregard and inefficiency is unacceptable. Waiting 45 minutes for two basic sandwiches, being ignored, and then told our order was lost is beyond frustrating. This experience has unfortunately pushed me to share this negative review. We will not be returning to Mario's Deli.

Hungry after apple picking, we passed this place lot filled with contractors' trucks. Figure they…read moreknow where to eat we pulled in. I had 3 pcs fried chicken ( 2 thighs & wing). Crispy crust seasoned just right, very moist not greasy at all. Great quality quantity for great price. My companion ordered a grilled chicken on a roll. Full dressed (LTO) she said chicken was tasty and moist, LT was crisp and fresh. Definitely a place to grab a bite in the Greenwood Lake area. The

Great services speak very nice respectful very clean food. The best deli in West Milford'sread more

Solid wrap 10/10 recommend!! Friendly staff , will definitely return when in the area . Great findread more

Friendly local vibes at this deli. Stopped in after a hike nearby and had a great chicken cutlet…read moresandwich. There were a few people waiting for their orders, but the food was coming out pretty quickly. Waited about 10 minutes for 1 cold and 1 hot sandwich.

Stopped here for a sandwich for lunch during the week. I called it in and they said 5-10 min which…read morewas great. There is parking in front and my sandwich was waiting for me when I got there. I ordered the full Route 23 which came with a side of coleslaw (they also have macaroni salad & potato salad but they were out). Sandwich was pretty good but the bread was ok. Coleslaw wasn't too seasoned but also okay. I need to try more things on the menu!

I will always choose this deli if I am in the area. Food is always fresh, portioned very well &…read morenever disappoints! Everyone is always super friendly & service is always fast.

Sooooooo good! This is the spot to get great subs!!!!…read more This picture says it all!!!!

Amazing place to get a breakfast sandwich and if you want a deli sandwich for lunch or dinner its…read morealso amazing can't say enough great things about this place and plus the pricing is just right. Definitely will suggest this to my friends and family and I will continuing coming here!!

Well, 2 1/2 years since the last review. It was a bad one. Had been going for 30 years at the time…read moreand there was a definite and sudden decline in quality. I asked the girls what was up and they said there was a new boss in the kitchen and he _____s. They have recovered and both the bar and deli products are well worth the trip. The specials are daily and change up. The Rib eye specials are great. Breakfast,(which is near impossible to ruin), is much better and the deli service is great.

Yes. I can now confirm that the bar side of Jessie's is officially a dive bar. That's OK. I really…read morelike dive bars. Darkish, check. Slightly grimy, check. Cheap drinks and food, check. The only thing wrong was that the bartender was actually very friendly and attentive. Good spot to have a cold one if you are in the vicinity of Greenwood Lake. The deli side was pretty cool as well. Featuring a very nice selection of sandwiches. Everything from breakfast bagels to cheese steaks to classic deli and more. I had the roast beef panini which was much better than I expected. Well prepared and delicious. I will definitely put Jessie's on my go to list.

I ordered through DoorDash and they didn't even accept or confirm the order until my dasher was…read morealready there and waiting - almost 30 minutes later. After the food got delivered I noticed the matzo balls were only two per cup and kind of small but otherwise "decent" at best. The problem I had was when I was almost halfway done eating half of a breakfast wrap - I bit in and found a used bandaid that must have fallen off of whoever was making the sandwich when they were wrapping. I called to complain about it and the person who answered the phone was surprised and said they'd issue a credit but I had to reach out to DoorDash hours later to get it resolved by myself. Under no circumstances should anyone bite into their food and find a used bandaid - this place is disgusting.

Great bagel place. Ordered a simple ham and cheese with mayo and they did not hesitate to do a…read moregreat job.

My opinion the number 1 catering place and food store in Bergen county and I am loyal customer for…read more30 and counting! Food is always outstanding and worth the price you pay. The service is outstanding and delivery is well done. Store is clean and quaint and well organized. Looking to get catering it is well done.!

To the people in hot prepared foods:…read more I wanted to take a moment to congratulate your prepared foods department on accomplishing something I didn't think was possible: making chicken completely inedible. This afternoon my wife purchased two portions of your "Harvest Chicken" from the hot foods counter. When she brought it home, we sat down expecting dinner. Instead, we were treated to what can only be described as a culinary experiment in dehydration. I didn't realize chicken could actually reach the texture of corrugated cardboard, but your staff has apparently mastered that technique. Large sections were so hard that even a fork had trouble getting through them, which is an impressive achievement if the goal was to create building materials rather than food. It's honestly a shame, because an animal had to give its life for that meal, only for it to be cooked into something no human should reasonably be expected to eat. I have seen more care put into kindergarten cooking projects. In the end, most of it went straight into the garbage, which seemed to be the most appropriate place for it. For comparison, a stop at Burger King would have been a noticeable upgrade in quality. You may want to take a look at what's happening behind that counter, because if this is the standard being served to customers, something has gone very wrong.

I love to support privately owned small businesses in my community and this one is no exception…read more I stopped to get a sandwich yesterday on my way home. Black forest ham, Swiss cheese on rye with German mustard. 2 slices of ham, 1 slice of Swiss and no mustard. I go to a deli with the expectation that I will get what I am paying for. Not so here. Most disappointed. Don't think I will return even though they carry foods direct from Germany. Oh and on that note, while there, I priced the stolen - $18.00 and it was a commonplace mass produced stolen. Much too expensive and too little in return for my taste buds.

This spot delivers an experience worth perfect ratings. They've designed the space with evident…read morecare. Trust what I'm saying, the staff is exceptional, unusually friendly, knowledgeable and instantly make you feel like family. There was plenty to divide between people. This restaurant won my approval.