The restaurant was pretty empty. Many folks were picking up orders. Seating was comfortable in chairs. There was only one booth type seating available The pizza was good, the crust got a little soggy after it was served, but I think that was due to the good amount of toppings, so no issue there. . Prices are a bit steep, but we are in Kauai in a tourist area so it's to be expected. read more

See all

This pizza parlor is pretty good! Local ingredients means fresh and delicious. Although it's thin crust, there's still chewiness and airiness of a pan pizza without the grease. It gets pretty busy with dining-in and takeout customers around 6 pm, so take that into account if you're pressed for time. It's by no means a fancy place--casual parlor that caters to mostly tourists is what you get here. Neverthess, service is quick and friendly, food is delicious, and it's a solid option for food on the South Shore. read more

Poipu Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Koloa, Hawaii

See all

If you love pizza as much as I do, you may agree that this is the best pizza on island!

Expensive but good and fresh. Great and friendly service. Awesome and easy spot for family last minute

Excellent service topped with Excellent food is one place you can't pass up. The atmosphere is inviting, service is personable and friendly and the pizza was delicious. We had a cesar salad to start was fresh and delicious, then a Margherita pizza which was hot and the tomatoes were so sweet enough cheese and sauce to make this one you can't miss on your visit to Poipu. read more

Poipu Pizza - Entrance to the pizza part of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Koloa, Hawaii

See all

Poipu pizza is delicious baked pizza with thick crust and the perfect amount of sauce. It's nicely sized for a family of 3-4. The staff was friendly and quick with their service. It's located in the back of the shopping area so lots to see when you're all finished! read more

Poipu Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Koloa, Hawaii

See all

This place and the restaurant it is attached to replaced Volcano Pizza. Service was fine but the pizza we had was bland and tasteless. We ordered the margarita pizza. Place has zero atmosphere too. Perhaps some of the other pizzas are better given all the good ratings but it did not do it for us. read more

Pizza was not what we expected very ordinary no where near the way it was described Toppings were very bland We did carry out read more

Ordered take out. The Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza Pros- good overall flavor, the dough & cheese Cons- skimpy with the pepperonis, there was like no marinara on here whatsoever. I'm not sure if there wasn't supposed to be any or not with the hot honey pizza but it tasted like it was missing. read more

Poipu Pizza - Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Koloa, Hawaii

Good pizza, I disagree with some of the not so good reviews. The pizza crust was delicious and they gave good quantities of toppings. We had the all meat pizza and it was a generous size for $35... not bad at all. We added a side Cesar salad and it was plenty for two. So if you're ever in the area you gotta try Poipu pizza! read more

The pizza oven is shared between this restaurant and the one next to it, so our single pizza took about an hour to come out. The pizza itself I would give a 3/10 and I feel like the price is way too overpriced for the size and quality of the pizza itself. The place is very small and cramped, but the service was great and our server was very nice. I am looking forward to trying this place again soon hopefully with some improvements read more

See all

Great pizza, good atmosphere, great place to take the family. Kids menu was good. The quattro carne is my favorite. Take out or dine in, this was an all around easy spot in the poipu shopping center read more

Well ordered pizza to go. Took hour. And they said they would call or text when ready. Hmmm. NOT poor service very poor. Pizza Sticking to box. Not hot barely warm. Wow Waste of time read more

The food was really good, especially for someone who is gluten free. The service however was really bad. Our waitress was rude and neglectful. Just overall not polite. It was also really hot in the restaurant. read more

Very good pizza. More than enough for the two of us. Reasonably fast service given how busy they are. However, $34 for a pizza is pricey.

If you are ok with maybe not getting your order, ever - go here! The heroic solo staff cannot be blamed. She is working so hard. Just know - pre order does not matter. Be flexible. Be patient. It may not work out so have options. read more

Pizzas were good. The gluten free version was the best we have had. The crust was tasty and the outer crust was crisp. The Caesar salad was also very good. read more

We got a caesar salad and margarita pizza. Both were tasty! Thin crust and nice crunchy bottom! Very kind and attentive staff. There was only one server for the whole place but he didn't let that hinder our service he was amazing. read more

Good pizza ! Good service ! Clean and would recommend the place. The side salad was very fresh and was a good portion.

Ordered the chicken and spinach pizza to go, and it was perfect for leftovers. The order was ready promptly, and was easy to find in the shopping area. The crust was a bit tough, but the overall taste was great! read more

Well I hate hate hate writing poor reviews but here goes. Last night my wife and I decided to have pizza for dinner so we ordered take out from Poipu Pizza. The service was wonderful but the pizza was terrible. We ordered a margarita pizza because we love the combination of the cheese, fresh basil, olive oil, etc. Over the years of ordering margarita pizza we've never had one that we didn't love. Well, until now! The margarita pizza was absolutely flavorless. A regular cheese pizza would have been better than what we ordered! The sauce was flat, there were a couple of basil leaves scattered on top, the cheese was bland, and the pizza dough tasted like it was a premade frozen dough. My wife and I are celebrating our 50th anniversary on this beautiful island and the food we've eaten has been unique, tasty and memorable. Our pizza from Poipu was also memorable but memorable because it just didn't measure up, it was the worse pizza we've ever had. read more

Poipu Pizza - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Koloa, Hawaii

I have traveled all over Europe and the US, and I was shocked by how delicious this pizza was! Oh my gosh! We had a meat lovers or something with a ton of meat and it tasted so fresh! I can't wait to come here and can't wait until they start doing delivery!! Their pepperoni pizza also loooked like fire!! It's a must! It's not like the pizza back home, it's true wood fired pizza! The whole experience was perfect. It was so cute inside, especially the In Crust We Trust! read more

Great place great pizza and wings. Loved the people and vibes. Quick service to the resort and we went there and the environment was great.

Their pizza is good, so that's why they get 3 stars. Our experience was bad for a Saturday dinner: it was slow, only one person as hostess/waitress/busser/line server (she did an amazing job taking care of everything but the restaurant still needs more people). The room is too hot and poorly ventilated. Noisy too. From now on we will go to the pizza places in Koloa for a decent experience, only takeout from this place. read more

First time eating here and we thought the pizza was great! When you're on an island it's hard to nail ambience, pizza quality, service, and price. All things considered, they've done a great job. read more

Excellent pizza made from scratch with top quality ingredients. Also has a bar area, very laid back. read more

Tried Poipu Pizza with the family tonight. I'm not one to take my time to write reviews, but the poor service here constitutes my time to either warn others or warn this restaurant that they should get it together with more staff and better training so they don't end up having to close their doors. When we were seated we waited 20 minutes to put in our order of one pizza and two salads. We had a couple small questions before deciding on our order and the waitress was unable to answer any of them. She kept having to "go back and ask". It's okay to be new and not familiar, but basic training would help the customer and also help the staff not feel inadequate. The food was actually very tasty. We enjoyed it. However, here was the problem aside from what I've already mentioned. - We waited 45 minutes for one pizza of half cheese/half pepperoni. - My father asked for a refill of his drink and the waitress brought him half a glass with no ice. We asked if there was ice and she made an "oops" face along with a response of "oh, I forgot about that." - The manager kept coming in and helping out. We waited 20 minutes for two garden salads, and 45 minutes for the pizza. After waiting so long, we asked her about it when she made a pass by our table and of course told us she was going to check on it "right now" and then guess what? Miraculously she returned within one minute with our food. If you're hungry and hoping to "grab a pizza," I wouldn't recommend this place. At least not until they decide to get it together! read more

We just try because it's new to us in the island. So we tried. Cheese & Tuscan pizza. Staff needs more training, serving very poor, the Pizza do not waste here, I suggest go Brick oven, Dominos. What they said in their wall "The crust in trust" lol meaning the crust of pizza is goey hard to bite. Our daughter doesn't like it at all. No next time. Ambiance just okay. read more

To celebrate our anniversary we decided to try Poipu Pizza. Our server, Alan was friendly and greeted us as soon as we arrived at the Lounge. We ordered a sausage/mushroom pizza and it was delicious! The crust was light and crispy, the sauce was perfectly seasoned and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. The setting was cool and comfortable and we felt welcomed. Good folks, good service, and great pizza with plenty of Aloha. Mahalo from Omao, Rick and Marion read more

Best gluten free pizza we have ever had. Amazing pizza. It takes them a little while but it's because they are that busy. Be patient and you will be well rewarded!!!! read more

First and last time. Arrived 2 minutes before appointed time for pick up. Now told 15 minutes because kitchen is behind. No apology, didn't own it just said that's what I've been told, I just started here. No bueno. Can't rate food...yet, still waiting for order. Update after waiting the 15 minutes was told it would be 5 minutes to 8 minutes at the most. Another 15 minutes and my order was ready. read more

We ate dinner next door at Isola and wanted to order a Pizza. We decided to order takeout. Our Pizza was inedible! Tasted off. Something went bad. We did not want to get sick so we threw it away. Overall service and food was poor. Overpriced and a waste of money! We will not be returning. read more