Best fresh fish on the bone for miles! Great service and food. Salads and other Greek delicacies…read moreare also remarkable. The grilled calamari is delicious. Better to me than the deep fried alternative,

We stopped in for a late lunch and had a great experience. Our server, Ruth, was outstanding --…read moresmart, personable, and attentive while still giving us space. The menu pulls from a wide range of recipes from the Dodecanese and other Greek islands, and it shows in the flavors. We started with olives and beets served with warm pita bread. For mains, we had the Gyro (beef & lamb) with hand‑cut fries, tzatziki, salad, and more pita. Everything was fresh and well‑seasoned. The spanakopitakia -- handmade phyllo with spinach, leeks, and feta -- was another standout. We finished with their Baklava Cheesecake, which layers freshly baked phyllo, nuts, cinnamon, and honey syrup over homemade cheesecake. Rich, sweet, and worth saving room for. Great service, excellent food, and a menu that feels genuinely rooted in the islands. We'll be back.

Love this restaurant. It's our family's favorite. The food…read moreis fresh, tasty and authentic Greek cuisine and ingredients. The service is the best and it's our go to restaurant any time of the week.

Great little Family style Greek Restaurant in Kenilworth. We grabbed a late lunch and shared a…read moresalad, an order of Spanakopita and the grilled Shrimp, Octopus and Calamari plate with lemon potatoes. The food portions were perfect for sharing. Also our server was great. We asked for extra red onions and dressing for the salad and she brought them quickly. In addition she gave us some extra tzatziki when she packed our leftover spanakopita. We enjoyed our grilled seafood platter so much that I missed taking a picture. Will have to do it next time. Definitely recommend place.

I don't come here often, but when I do with a small group of friends and/or family it's a great…read moreexperience! This place is Byob, so we typically bring a bottle of wine with company. The appetizers are delicious and pretty large (without jeoparding quality). My favorite are the horiatiki salad (a refreshing salad with feta) and the midia axnista (steamed mussels with broth). If you're a pita bread kinda person, you can't go wrong with their pita and dips! For entrees, you cant go wrong with their grilled fishes (I liked the lavraki branzino the most). Their hirini brizola (grilled pork chop) was delicious too! The service is good here and the wait staff is friendly. One time, we were running late for our reservation, but the staff was very accommodating and still sat us down.

Wonderful meal here. Did the Horiatiki salad added gyro. A delish dish!! Complimentary pita and…read morehummus were served when we sat down. And the owner was outside sitting with a few people he knew, just a good sign when the owner is present at their own restaurant!! The staff was sweet and tentative and I overall really enjoyed the meal.

Came here for a late lunch with a friend after watching The Odyssey in the AMC nearby…read more The restaurant was spacious and nicely decorated with Greek colored table setting. We ordered an appetizer and two entrees to share. The eggplant dip was refreshing and pairs well with the pita bread (which itself was so delicious and nicely baked). The lamb shank is a must try! The portion size is massive. The lamb was tender and not gamy and tomato sauce was flavorful and the orzo was cooked well. The chicken dish was less impressive in comparison but well grilled. The service was fast and friendly. It's such a good find in New Brunswick and would highly recommend esp for group gatherings!

We used to frequent this place when we lived in NJ. We currently live in MD and haven't been here…read morein about 10 years. I was so excited to come back. Unfortunately, I was highly disappointed. I know things changed since the previous owner (older Greek man) no longer owned it. He used to stop by the tables and chat with customers and we noticed that the portions had become smaller. This time we came for lunch on a Sunday. Place was kind of empty, with the exception of 2 large tables. We ordered Saganaki and were informed by waitress that they no longer flambéd it table side. We still ordered and it was good although not melted like we remembered. Husband only ordered the lemon soup, which he said was good. My daughter and I both ordered beef and lamb gyros, I ordered it with Greek fries (with the Greek cheese over them) and my daughter ordered hers with lemon potatoes. Both gyros came dry, in hard shaved pieces and I barely ate my fries as they were worse than fast food fries and not the traditional Greek cheese over them. The tzatziki was good, however, my daughter's had a hair in it. The worse part was that when we brought it to the waitresses attention, she was not apologetic or surprised. She just said she would bring a new one. This was unacceptable. To make matters worse, I went to their store next door to get the cheese I could fry at home and their custard dessert; they had neither. What a disappointment to the entire experience. Won't be returning if ever in the area.

Ordered ahead of time through their website to pick up but when I went inside I wish I was eating…read morethere. It's a very nice restaurant with plenty of seating and well decorated. The employees were so friendly when I arrived and the food is delicious!! I got the handheld gyro (chicken yeero) with tomatoes, red onion, fries and tzatziki and it was perfectly balanced. I also got a Greek salad and was so happily surprised with how refreshing it is! The tomatoes are so good. I only wish there was a smaller size to get as a side dish. Overall 10/10!

I'm seeing many 3-4 star reviews from fellow Yelpers and I keep thinking that perhaps my experience…read morewas a singular one. The two stars I'm giving here is for the restaurant itself. This restaurant looks great. There is a nice counter area to order, a really nice seating area inside and even outdoor seating. Some of the decor makes you feel like you're in a household's kitchen. By the cashier there is a table you can wait at complete with local newspapers. It's very charming. This was my first visit and I ordered my food to go. I had two key dishes. The first was hummus with falafel, which is very standard for me whenever I go to any Mediterranean place. When I opened the take out box at home I was really surprised. Most places give you a good amount of hummus, but here it was basically a thin layer. Kind of like a layer of mayo on a sandwich (maybe a tad thicker). Then on top of the hummus was a huge layer of pickled vegetables and tiny pickles. This was a surprise. I've had hummus orders from a lot of restaurants before and I've *never* seen this on an order before. Then the falafel balls were on top and well...they were really dry and didn't have much flavor. Now, sometimes you can cover that up by just coating the falafel in hummus, but there wasn't enough hummus to do that. The dish was just disappointing all around. The other dish I tried were the Lemon Potatoes. They were good! The lemon flavor was strong and they were cooked well. Not the best example in the area, but they would do in a pinch. At some point I'll give this place another try. Maybe this was a fluke (at least I hope so).

Love the food and service at this establishment. Invited a…read morefriend to join me for lunch today. We shared saganaki with fig jam and a fish dorado which was cooked perfectly. Thank you Konstantine for your professionalism and Hektor for your excellent food.

I've been meaning to write a review for this spot ever since my folks took me out here for a…read morepre-birthday dinner in late January (2026). I don't know why we haven't frequented this spot sooner (at least during trips back home), but EVOO is legit. Also NOTE - its BYOB (but there are even some places nearish by you can grab a bottle or 3 if needed). Our server was very attentive, despite the restaurant being fairly busy. For apps, we decided on the: Hummus - how do you properly judge a Mediterranean restaurant without trying their hummus, and this was creamy, decadent and served with some fresh pita. Grilled Calamari (with roasted red pepper, lemon, evoo, capers, red onions) - very nicely cooked, not rubbery at all Grilled Octopus (with roasted red peppers, fava puree, capers, onions, red wine vinegar, arugula, evoo) - if octopus is on the menu, I'm gonna have it. For my entree, I got the pan-seared scallops with cauliflower puree, quinoa, spinach, heirloom tomato. Loved it. Cooked perfectly, loooved the silky puree...just a solid solid dish. All in all, EVOO definitely deserves to be on the Millburn/Essex shortlist when looking for nicer places to dine out. Can't wait to get back and try some more of their menu!

The atmosphere is intimate, the service is warm and friendly and the food is superb. Will…read moredefinitely visit again and again!

The entrance is located in a side alley, down the basement stairs, kind of weird. No wi-fi or phone…read moreconnection inside the restaurant, so you can't use your phone for anything---which can turn into an intentional exercise in disconnecting. I could not view reviews of dishes, so had to step outside to take a peak. Cannot justify paying such prices for dinning in a tiny, dark space in half-basement in the middle of NJ. Just can't. The portions are generous, which is good. But the prices are still outrageous for the location and vibe. It is BYOB for alcohol. We walked in on Sunday at 6pm without reservations and by 7pm, the small space filled up. The $12 hummus was bad. Store bought hummus of the cheapest brand tastes better. Seriously don't understand how a hummus can taste so bland and meh. No seasoning? The pita that came with it was low quality--it gave my friend an allergic reaction right away [he has sensitivity towards poor quality flour products]. $44 paidakia--lamb chops--had 4 chops that were tender and delicate. Pasnip pure was bland and totally a miss--did nothing to complement anything on the plate. Barely any demi lace sauce--definitely on the dry side. Asked for potatoes to be sutstituted for brocollini, but the kitchen did not follow through with that ask, even though our waitress confirmed it was possible. $39 lamb souvlaki was a solid dish. Filling and hearty. Good quality meat skewer. Smoked eggplant puree had a very strong smoke flavor. Lemony potatoes had bright, refreshing lemomy flavor that we appreciated. Service is attentive and quick. Complementary toothbrushes in the bathroom were a nice touch--a star for this little amenity.

We came with a group, and unfortunately our food was missed while everyone else was served. We had…read moreto wait about 40 minutes after ordering, which was frustrating. However, the staff did try to make it right afterward and gave us desserts, which we appreciated. Overall, not a great experience, but they did improve the situation.

An authentic Greek Mediterranean restaurant. We went there for Galentines Day with a group of 45…read morewomen. Had a private room along with a DJ. The appetizers were delicious. Best I ever had. Everything was so fresh and tasty. Pita bread along with the olive plate was excellent. So flavorful and colorful the way it was displayed. The calamari was cooked perfectly and was not overdone. I was in love with the spanakopita. For the main meal I had salmon with roasted asparagus and potatoes. They also had chicken souvlaki. The homemade baklava was done to perfection. The flavor just melted in your mouth. The service was on the spot. The servers were pleasant, very accommodating and had a great personality. The owner was on top of everything and made sure our Galentines dinner was set to perfection