Pizza Stop &amp; Subs

The food was fantastic! The pizza, sticks and and poppers were all full of flavor, pipping hot and…read morethe order was ready on time. The pizza was cooked perfectly, the crust wasn't too much, but just right. Met the owner, super friendly and very customer focused. The inside was small but can easily seat a number of families. Overall, great location and pizzeria!

Everything is great. Staff is friendly. Restaurant is clean. Highly recommend it. Service is great…read more Have daily lunch specials and throughout the week. Delivery is available.

Inside Dinning area

A beautiful Goodfellas pizza!!

See all

Outside of Goodfellas business and vehicles.

Bourbon Street Pizza

3.9(30 reviews)

9.1 mi

The food was very good. We did carry out but the counter service was good. We are looking forward…read moreto sit-in service in the near future

Excellent service and products. We frequently visit this location and Eric, and his team are always…read morefantastic. They offer great weekly specials, and the dining room is always clean.

If you eat at bourbon st pizza and get a drink, this is what you'll find in the ice 95% of the time. it's like a black gooey substance

See all

Rocksteady Pizza Parlour

4.8(10 reviews)

8.2 mi

Big fan of their food, especially their cheesebread, pizzas, and dipping sauce varieties. Love the…read morespicy ranch and cheese sauce. The vibe inside is fun as well, you can see the pizzas being slid into the oven and play pinball machines while waiting. Service has always been great, and carryout has been on time

Ordered a pizza for pickup. It was ready on time and I was greeted by a very friendly person at…read morethe door. The restaurant was very nice inside and appeared to be very clean. This was my first time here but I plan on returning. The pizza was excellent.

Interior decoration

Lil Peps and Sausage for the win.

See all

Front of establishment

Bailey’s Pizza Parlor

5.0(1 review)

23.0 mi

Homemade goodness prepared in front of customers! All made fresh. Pizzas are very generously…read moretopped! Subs are amazing. Don't miss the Garlic Goodness sauce. Staff are very pleasant.

Food prep: clean and fast.

Covered Bridge Cheese Bread. Generously cheesy and yummy!

See all

Daily menu board. Updated with specials.

Danny's Pizza & Sports Bar

3.7(35 reviews)

6.1 mi

Pretty cool place and great to watch a game in with friendly staff. Cold beer! Good pizzas.read more

We got 2 pizzas to go this weekend. One was a deep dish and the other thin crust. Both were burnt…read moreto a crisp and dry. The so-called deep dish was as flat as a pancake. Never again.

Deep dish pizza

See all

Chicago style pizza

Gambie's Pizza

4.1(18 reviews)

7.6 mi

They have a different pizza compared to every other pizza place around and we like to do there for…read morea change from the chain restaurants. They keep the restaurant clean and they are always happy and friendly when we come in for our pie.

Gambie's never disappoints! We go here every so often and…read moreare always left satisfied. Small staff, so make sure you aren't in a rush. They will take care of you. A Warsaw gem for sure!

Menu as of 4/28/24

See all

Supreme pizza without mushroom

Patellie's

4.7(89 reviews)

62.6 mi

Got the penne alla vodka and it was really tasty. The sauce had a creamy texture with a little…read morespice, which I liked a lot. Pasta wasn't mushy, which is always a plus. It came with a side salad that was pretty fresh too. Our waitress was kind and checked on us a couple of times without being pushy. The restaurant was clean and had a nice chill atmosphere. Solid meal overall.

Got a margherita pie and it was simple but really well done. The tomatoes tasted fresh and the…read morebasil actually added flavor, not just decoration. Crust was wood-fired and had that nice smoky edge. I do wish the center was a little crispier but the flavor was great overall. Loved that it wasn't too oily like some places. It's a small spot, cozy vibes and not too loud. Friendly counter service and clean tables made it a nice quick lunch stop.

See all

Sausage and mushroom with a lot of cheese

Salvatori's Authentic Italian Eatery - Warsaw

4.3(50 reviews)

5.4 mi

Food is awesome and the portions are HUGE!! We've been there 3 times now, and have zero complaints.read more

There were five waitstaff serving four occupied tables, in a good size room; that was my first clue…read morethat this may not be a great dining experience. Our waitress was cheerful as she extolled the history and reputation of this "authentic" Italian eatery. Menu was standard Italian fare, moderately priced, with lunch specials. After ordering, I waited for bread or breadsticks to appear; they never did. Lunch arrived, but no one offered fresh, or even old, Parmesan cheese. Again no bread. Servings were huge, the only positive thing I could say about the meal. Alfredo sauce on the pasta was totally tasteless, like wallpaper paste. Stromboli shell was not crispy, as it should be, and there was no sauce inside (not unusual), but there was excessive moisture from the vegetable filling, which made the crust soggy. Other than the staff, there was nothing appealing or memorable about this restaurant, and based upon my extensive experience and knowledge of Italian cuisine, there is little authentic about it.

Salvatori's Authentic Italian Eatery - Warsaw

Spaghetti supreme

See all

Plymouth Club Brick Oven Pizza

4.4(28 reviews)

44.2 mi

My wife and I stopped in while staying in Marion for the weekend. If we would have found this…read morerestraunt on Friday night, we probably would have dined here both nights. We had the onion rings which were the best we ever had. Hint, ask for the ranch dressing that is made in house.... WOW!! Then we went for a meat lovers pizza that was incredible and made in about 10 min. Due to their awsome brick oven. But, maybe the best part was the service. We had the manager Kim for a waitress and enjoyed a great conversation with her as we were there when it wasn't very busy. Kim... Enjoyed you very much. To sum up, great meal at a resonable price. We would definitely recomend and will be back if ever in the area again.

Lacking interpersonal skills. Customer service is essential to a good experience. Pizza was ok…read more Good flavor. Crust a bit thin. Scant cheese. Toppings fine.

The seating area - perfect for large gatherings/parties.

Pizza

See all

Menu

Fire -N- the Hole

3.7(9 reviews)

10.4 mi

•$$$

Had their pizza at the Quarter Horse Congress because everyone talked how great it was in previous…read moreyears. I was terribly disappointed. First I was a little taken aback when I was charged extra for a to-go box, which I feel like the majority of people would get it to go as they are walking around and heading back to arenas. Second, this was definitely store bought crust and prepackaged store bought ham. As someone who has worked on our local wood fired pizza truck, I can see a clear difference. It tasted like bland crust with spaghetti sauce and some toppings. Not worth the $20+ I paid.

Recommended to go to this small food truck-like pizza stone fire pizza. Amazing pizza and also…read moretheir dessert pizza. So worth the drive and the line. I wish I took a phot of my pizza but I ate it too quick before I remembered.

The crust of the pizza

Hawaiian pizza

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Roger B.

0

2

0

10 years ago

Have ordered pizza from Pizza Stop for years. Best pizza in the county and at a good price. Owner very generous with toppings and 2 pieces will fill you up. read more

Renee M.

24

3

10 years ago

I give the food a 5 star review but the owner only 1 star because she is so rude.

Pizza Stop & Subs - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Pizza Stop & Subs also viewed

Goodfellas Pizza - North Manchester

5.0

(2 reviews)

Everything was made to perfection: two pizzas and cheese curds…read more Great taste and flavor. I will have to return next time I am in town.

If you live in North Manchester, and don't really want to drive to Wabash for supreme pizza and…read moreexperience then hop on over to this Goodfellas Pizza closer to you! It has bigger dining room, the staff is just as nice as Wabash, and all the food is the same... TASTY! Want some real pizza? Then head here!

Panthers Pizza

3.2

(11 reviews)

The pizza was very good. I ordered online so I asked for a specific time which was Super Bowl…read moreSunday the only complaint was my Pizza stuff to the bottom of the cardboard.

Their pizzas are good size, but very pricey. This is my…read moresecond pizza I got from Panther Pizza, and the crust on both pizzas wasn't done. I ordered a large pepperoni with 4 different toppings. There was only 3 pepperoni on the pizza. They put way to much sauce on it, couldn't even taste the cheese. I'm a pizza lover, and couldn't tolerate this pizza!! I believe their oven isn't working properly. I wouldn't recommend this pizza place, unless you like undone crust and way to much sauce on your pizza.

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee

4.0

(31 reviews)

Food was amazing but our delivery driver deserves some recognition, David was extremely respectful…read moreand incredibly fast, you guys have some great employees and this is my favorite pizza in town:)

Ordered to go. I was actually surprised in a good way with the pizzas we ordered. The hand tossed…read morecrust is the way to go. Quality sauce and plenty of toppings. Friend my staff on pick up.

Pizza King

3.1

(29 reviews)

Pizza has very few toppings and little taste. I used to love Thor pizza. This place has changed…read moresince last I had been there. Probably won't be ordering from there again.

Food was great no issues ontime as always I use this location often…read more Highly recommended

Albion Pizza Depot

4.2

(15 reviews)

Really good pizza. Homemade crust and sauce. Great toppings. And the place was spotless. Very…read morefriendly employees. I watched the gal make salads to go and they looked delicious too. And we got offered free cookies as we were leaving. And they were great. It was a little bit of a drive from Muncie. But worth it, especially with a couple other stops added in. When my friend heard we were driving up she texted me her order to go. Prices were very reasonable. Two pizzas, one small and one large and 2 drinks for $30.

I've been here twice now - March 2025 and June 2025. Definitely one of the top 5 best pizzas I've…read moreever had. Neither trip did I slow down long enough to get any photos... but I order whatever their version of the meat lover's is & you can bet I'll get it next time too. The service has been just fine both times and the order comes out quickly (as quick as it takes to make and bake a pizza)!

Jim's Pizza

3.7

(33 reviews)

•$$$

I called at 4:05pm on a Saturday 5 minutes after they opened. Busy. My buddy told me they're good…read more We both called on separate phones for around 20 call attempts before I got through. We ordered a 12" pepperoni, mushroom and cheese pizza. Advised cash only. Told pick-up at 5pm. Sounds good. We arrived a few minutes early and the parking lot was packed! This is a pick-up only restaurant. My buddy went inside to pay and came back out stating it would be a few more minutes. He waited inside. Around 5pm he came out with our pizza. The pizza wasn't in a box. It was on a cardboard circle put in a paper type bag with another paper type bag over that bag. As for the taste? Up there with one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Price: $17.50.

Jim's is a great place to get your fresh made pizza. Made the same way for over 40 years. A take…read moreout pizza only. Call early the phone lines start early and they book up fast.

Bourbon Street Pizza

4.6

(7 reviews)

Online order, ordered pizza and a chocolate chip cookie and received a brownie, pizza is ok. C'mon,…read morenot a complicated order. Won' t order again.

Came into bourbon street pizza on a whim for lunch and it paid off. We had the pepperoni pizza and…read morethe taco pizza and they were both amazing! The staff were great and very friendly as well! Thanks for some great pizza!!

Gambie's Pizza

4.1

(18 reviews)

They have a different pizza compared to every other pizza place around and we like to do there for…read morea change from the chain restaurants. They keep the restaurant clean and they are always happy and friendly when we come in for our pie.

Gambie's never disappoints! We go here every so often and…read moreare always left satisfied. Small staff, so make sure you aren't in a rush. They will take care of you. A Warsaw gem for sure!

Bourbon Street Pizza

3.9

(30 reviews)