We heard great reviews about this local restaurant! Since we were in the area for an Airbnb…read moreweekend, we decided to order ahead. The menu is extensive, think Paisanos with options of salads, subs, pizza, sides, and pastas to choose from. We ordered the chicken parm and asked for angel hair instead of spaghetti. It's rare I find a place that doesn't skimp on the portions or cheese! I loved it and for one of my favorite dishes it was executed very well. Only comment I could make is that the sauce is a little on the sweet side. The Greek salad was filled to the top of feta! Cucumbers, onions, tomatoes, olives, and crunchy iceberg lettuce were all in the mix. The house dressing was yummy with this salad! The caprese salad was plentiful too! My husband loved the pizza, very cheesy and full of Philly steak. He described it as very flavorful! Prices seem fair and we got a lot of bang for our buck. Highly suggest this restaurant. Our food was ready on time and ready to go! Packed well and in an easy box to take out our large order for the weekend.

I found the experience to be just average. I ordered the margherita pizza, but the mozzarella…read moredidn't taste fresh; there was hardly any cheese, and it didn't melt while I ate it. My wife noted that the crust was worse than Costco's, which I think is an accurate description. The environment wasn't terrible, but it was quite loud and had poor lighting, giving off more of a fast-food vibe than that of a restaurant. If you are particular about your pizza, I wouldn't recommend this place. However, the staff was friendly.

We finally tried Angelos Brick Oven. This is a brick oven…read morestyle that you can taste in the crust! Even cheese melt, blended nicely with sauce and crust. Not a lot of pull though. Sauce was a little bland and slighlty higher ratio than I prefer, but not too much. I did pick up. They do have several tables with a very Casual atmosphere. Staff was very friendly. Order was ready at specified time. Note: I love Pizza! All kinds of Pizza! And I am a self proclaimed pizza snob. I truly believe you can taste the ingredient quality. That said, I have a new Pizza specific scale below evaluating the cheese quality, sauce balance, crust flavor/structure, style execution, and overall value. 4.0 Solid pizza; something slightly off, though I still recommend and will order again. Pizza-specific scale: .5 Cheese Quality & Performance: Flavor (milky, rich, balanced--not bland or rubbery). Melt quality. Stretch without greasiness. Stays put (doesn't slide off in one dramatic bite) .5 Sauce Flavor, Texture & Ratio : Flavor depth (brightness, seasoning, balance) Texture (not watery, not paste) Ratio to cheese (supporting role, not the main character) 1. Crust Flavor, Texture & Structure 1. Style Execution & Balance: Does it nail its intended style? Ingredient harmony 1. Overall Satisfaction & Value: Would I order it again?

Door dashed their caprese pizza with their chef's salad, a cannoli, and 2 brownies. Everything was…read moregood but the pizza was cold when I got it.

Any business that stands behind what it makes is a business I want to patronize. I ordered myself…read moredinner while at the brewery and to my surprise when I went up there were TWO pizza boxes. I looked confused and the guy behind the pickup window said the first one had a hole it it so they remade my order and the original was on the house. When I opened both boxes they looked identical save for one slice have a tear which to me is neither here nor there. What stands out to me is I didn't get my pizza, notice the flaw, and then say something. They spotted the error and corrected it before I even got the text my food was ready. The pizza itself was delicious. They accommodated my special request for stracciatella cheese too. Delicious crust, quality toppings, and the sauce was where it needed to be. I highly recommend them for dine in or take out.

Stopped here on a Saturday night to knock off one of the list of places I've wanted to try. Located…read morehooked onto a brewery type place that shared space to sit with a large room and a bar, Although they didn't have some of the pizzas I've seen in advertisements on hand, we were able to find a few to try. 12" pies so obv 3 for 2 people to do some taste testing makes the most sense. We also scooped an order of cheesy bread as well and a couple of waters. MARGHERITA: thin on the sauce (which is a heavy tomato paste consistency) so it looks overcooked. Flavor was good but the sauce was nearly dried on - maybe thinning the sauce so it keeps its liquidity more? Don't know. Again - a solid pie (7.2/10) RICKERONI: Cupping pepperoni, ricotta mounds, and some jalapeños . More of a traditional feel here - loved the pepperoni and the sauce. The ricotta looked cool but wasn't my favorite addition. Peppers really had a pop to them. Liked this way more (8.1/10) BIG MAC: Meat, garlic sauce, MAC sauce and pickles - I liked this a lot but I wish I would had ordered more MAC sauce on top - like these style specialty pies (7.8/10) The cheesy bread was good, the pesto very thick on top. Nice large space to sit and eat. Staff was nice and friendly at the pickup window.

Great food, wonderful customer service and the owners are not too bad themselves... Suggestion When…read moreyou eat the lasagna "And I hope You do" please eat it there the cheese demands attention not a ride home. :) Feels like your dining room at home if you give it a chance.

Upon entry to the establishment we were surprised to see the nice setup they have for dine in…read moreguests considering they are next door to a gas station. It was very clean and tastefully decorated. We had seen a review on them and had been wanting to come pay them a visit but their hours are a little wonky as they open for a few hours and close down for a few and open back up for dinner time. This is unfortunate for us because we commute 50 minutes one way to work and when we come home they are always closed by 2:00 and don't open until 4:00 sadly. Nevertheless, we had a chance to pop in today due to the holidays. We ordered the Al's Steak Special and the Italian sub. We thoroughly enjoyed both of them with having a few things we commented on and noticed to one another. My husband loves trying Italian subs all over and so he had to try it here. The flavor was nice and the bread was great.. the middle was a little light as you can see the meat thinly layered in the sub roll and then filler of the lettuce and tomatoes and red onion. So, if you typically like an Italian thick/heavy with the meat, this may not be your preferred selection here. However, it did taste good ! I love finding a good cheesesteak and the review we saw was for just that, so I had to try it! Again, the bread was noticeably delish and not soggy at all! I had mine with everything but tomatoes. I think for my own preference I would ask them to cook my green peppers longer. Again, to each their own! Flavor was good.. added a little salt/pepper but it was full and very good. I would get it again.. and their menu options look really good so we will have to come back if we can fit into their open hours.. I am sure they are overlooked often being next to a gas station but I have to share that you shouldn't skip out on them.. they are work a try !

Top shelf pizza and wonderfully friendly proprietor and staff. Fantastic authentic pizza, perfectly…read moreseasoned and inventive varieties. Best pizza in Gettysburg to be sure, and a competitor that would hold its own anywhere.

Food was delicious- we ordered "to go" and the staff were very personable and friendly!! We ordered…read moremozzarella sticks, white pizza, and cheese pizza. Ingredients super fresh on the white pizza. Loved the crust. Can't wait to go back and try more items!!! A Must Stop when you are in Gettysburg!

Don't waste you money here!! This place goes up and down,…read moremostly down, not consistent. Hardly any place is close enough for delivery so we settle for this place, until now. Last night I got a roast beef sub. You know that micro thin sliced meat, I had 2 layers of meat. This was the whole long sub, like $16 and 2 thin slices of meat, can't begin to taste that! I also ordered avocado, $4. No avocado. My wife got a philly steak and cheese. She had about a tablespoon of meat in one chunk, she spread it around best she could. Lots of cheap veges except avocado. Theres another sub place, kings will get our business.

We recently ordered some food to carry out. The Philly cheesesteak with grilled onions and…read moremushrooms, was overly salty, and light on steak. It was more onions and mushrooms. I love a good Philly cheesesteak, and this was overly disappointing. The deep-fried mushrooms were tasty.

Love this place!!! Cheesesteak the Works is my favorite. The Italian is pretty good too!read more

Great service great location great tasting food very affordable prices!! Very friendly people!!read more

Visiting from out of town and hubby wanted wings and I didn't feel like cooking so we found…read moreMythical Pizza here on Yelp. From the second we walked in, it felt very welcoming and friendly. I've never seen so many wonderful pizza options on one menu. I wanted all of them! He had the Alfredo Parmesan wings and he said they were delicious. I chose a pepperoni roll (I hear it's a West Virginia thing) and it was very tasty with a boat load of cheese. I personally like a spicer marinara for dipping but it was still very good. The staff was super friendly and helpful finding me the right souvenir t shirt with the Mothman on it. Oh and we tried the tiramisu and boy howdy! It was Dee-LISH!!! Def worth a try.

Even before you step into Mythical Pizza, you will catch the vibe. Royal Purple exterior with…read moreillustrated cryptids beckoning from the windows and doors. The enticing aroma of smoke from real pizza ovens in the air as you park your car. Then you enter and, honestly they had me at 5-stars on aesthetics alone. My husband said, "I hope the pizza is even a tenth as good as their branding!" And it WAS!!! Actually it was 100% as good. Absolutely delicious vegan pizza done right! And the veggie man vegan roll... Yum Yum Yum! Surprisingly affordable too. YEZ: vegan friendly YEZ: family friendly

Awesome brewery close to home! Lots of outdoor seating and…read moreamazing food as well. Beer I'd give a B+ We frequent this place

How to order was a little confusing for our first time. But once we figured it out, the staff is…read moresuper friendly and helpful with picking out beers. You sit where and order at the bar. The food came out quickly along with the beers. My only complaint was there was no chicken wings.

We were doing some yard work and decided to get a Pizza. Well we all loved Rocky's Pizza in…read moreHagerstown at both the Halway/Old Orchard location as well as the downtown location in the Hagerstown Square. Well low and behold upon entering the restaurant I not only see an old friend Raymond who was the owner of the Old Orchard Rocky's but also Vinnie who was the owner of the Downtown Rocky's. I knew immediately that the Pizza we had ordered would be awesome. Guess what! Yeah it was! So if you are looking and craving for a delicious pizza definitely stop in and enjoy the pie. Great Place, Excellent service and absolutely Awesome food. I see that another customer that reviewed this Rocky's had the same experience as we did, so I second his opinion.

I'm pretty particular when it comes to pizza, especially New York-style, and unfortunately, this…read morejust didn't hit the mark for me. The garlic butter crust was the best part, and while the cheese was okay, the sauce really missed the mark. Honestly, I've had cafeteria pizza that tasted similar, if not slightly better. My wife ordered a salad, which was a bit subpar. It included canned mushrooms, which isn't what we expected in a fresh salad, and it was made with iceberg lettuce instead of romaine, which gave it a lower-quality feel. While the experience wasn't what we had hoped for, I appreciate the effort and the friendly service.