Food is awesome and the portions are HUGE!! We've been there 3 times now, and have zero complaints.read more

There were five waitstaff serving four occupied tables, in a good size room; that was my first clue…read morethat this may not be a great dining experience. Our waitress was cheerful as she extolled the history and reputation of this "authentic" Italian eatery. Menu was standard Italian fare, moderately priced, with lunch specials. After ordering, I waited for bread or breadsticks to appear; they never did. Lunch arrived, but no one offered fresh, or even old, Parmesan cheese. Again no bread. Servings were huge, the only positive thing I could say about the meal. Alfredo sauce on the pasta was totally tasteless, like wallpaper paste. Stromboli shell was not crispy, as it should be, and there was no sauce inside (not unusual), but there was excessive moisture from the vegetable filling, which made the crust soggy. Other than the staff, there was nothing appealing or memorable about this restaurant, and based upon my extensive experience and knowledge of Italian cuisine, there is little authentic about it.

It is a large, very beautiful restaurant. We were visiting Warsaw and we love Italian food so we…read morechose Papa Vino's for an early Saturday's dinner. Dinner started with a loaf of warm bread served with a small plate of.olive oil seasoned with small bits of crunchy garlic, oregano and black pepper. Top notch. One thing I noticed is that every dish that the servers brought out to the diners was smoking hot. Every single dish. No way was anyone's food sitting under a heat lamp. As an appetizer, I ordered the crab stuffed mushrooms. Three very large mushrooms. I didn't taste much crabmeat. I would order a different appetizer next time. Our entrees were the Chicken Bacon Ranch flatbread and the Eggplant Parmesan with a side of spaghetti The spaghetti sauce was very bright and fresh tasting. Based on the little bit I tasted of my husband's dinner, next.time I will order Spaghetti and Meatballs. We had enough leftovers to bring home another night's dinner.

This is the second time I have visited this restaurant and it is amazing. The service is top-notch…read moreand the food tastes really good. Frank Sinatra is singing in the background and other Jazz music is playing. I actually ordered the exact same thing that I ordered a year ago when coming through this area I love the Tuscan salad with Papa dressing. My husband ordered the baked penne. We ordered a piece of the chocolate cake to go. I also bought a bottle of their house dressing. I definitely recommend this restaurant when in Indiana.

This place provided great service for a rowdy bunch of baseball players! Grab some pizza in between…read morebaseball games at a local tournament. The staff was great and willing to serve us with a smile.

I have been to this place about 3 times. It is very good. I just had the best minestrone soup I…read morehave ever had. Their Marinara sauce is first rate. It's homemade, flavorful, the best marinara sauce I have ever had. Obviously, I have not had everything on the menu. This place is not fancy or expensive. It is a very nice place.

It was a little chilly in the room, so I ate with my coat on. The chairs were nicely padded and…read morecomfortable. The broccoli cheddar soup was as hot and tasty. The wild salmon was a big portion. I had it with risotto, but spaghetti marinara was a choice, too. I didn't want red sauce with salmon. The salmon was a bit dry. Risotto was flavorful and soft. We both had an interesting assortment of roasted vegetables. Hubby enjoyed his lasagna. We also got a basket of crispy Italian bread and a plate of olive oil with a sprinkle of basil in it. Too full for dessert!

Hands down in our top two restaurants in Lafayette/West Lafayette! We love this place. It is all…read moreabout the food! The food is quality and consistently delicious. The owner has a farm and uses a lot of the produce she grows herself for the freshest ingredients. The variety on the menu is fabulous as well. They always have exceptional daily specials. It's always so hard to decide what to order! The negative is that it is only open for dinners on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays. They used to be open more than than as well as for lunch (they had a fantastic lunch menu!) so that's a disappointment. The place is also clean, but I would like to see them replace their tables and chairs. The chairs are old and you sink down so low. The tables don't have a smooth surface and crumb debris gets caught. This is the only authentic, quality Italian place in town so I hope it sticks around for a long time! With her decreasing the hours from what she had before, I worry she'll eventually close. It would be a huge loss to the community if it did.

Always a hit, my favorite restaurant in New Buffalo, Mi - awesome pizza and tikka masala surprise…read moreawaits you - outdoor tables with a relaxed vibe. Good service. Will be back again and again - my staple go to place Thanks

We stopped in for lunch and had a wonderful experience. The vibe inside is lovely--they have an…read moreoutdoor patio, but we opted to sit indoors by the bar. They even have an indoor atrium with fake windows, which was a pretty cool touch! I started with their tropical unsweetened iced tea, which was incredibly refreshing and delicious. As someone who eats gluten-free, I was thrilled to see how accommodating they are. They offer GF pizza and pasta, and other GF items are clearly marked on the menu. I asked our server about their cross-contamination protocols for the pizza, and she was super reassuring: they use a fresh pan and change their gloves, even though it goes into the same oven. I built my own pie with red sauce, cheese, and hot honey, and it was absolutely fantastic. My husband ordered a regular Detroit-style pizza and said it was delicious. They even have a few GF dessert options on the menu, but we were way too full to try them this time. We will definitely be back!

Excellent food Excellent staff…read moreHighly recommended Have tried almost everything on the menu

I used Scartozzi's for a catering pickup for a group of 15. I don't live in the area & ordered by…read morephone. No deposit required. Just have to pay when you pick it up. Everything was ready on time and packed perfectly for pick up. Plus the price was extremely reasonable and the food was pretty good too.

Casual vibe and friendly service. The waitress was very helpful, and gave good suggestions. We got…read morerolls to start, and the herb butter provided was straight from the refrigerator and hard to spread. We got bruschetta and mozzarella sticks as an appetizer. The bruschetta was delicious, and it is worth coming here for that alone. The mozzarella sticks were very average and nothing spectacular. The Penne All'Arrabbitta was good, but they were definitely very heavy handed on the red pepper flakes. Over time, it lacked any flavor besides spice. The Tortellini al Forno had lots of flavor and was very cheesy. We did ask for it with grilled chicken and didn't get any. The waitress explained that there's a language barrier with the kitchen and mistakes like that are common. She was very understanding of the situation, as were we. After leaving, my partner did start to feel sick on the drive home. I would love to come back to try their pizzas since we went the pasta route this time.

The food was okay - I would not recommend ordering the lasagna - it's more like a soup. The…read morewaitress said it was frozen and they microwaved it and it turns into slurp. Makes me wonder if ALL their food is frozen! Seems like a bar type place vs a real restaurant.

Welcome, friendliness, and service were outstanding! Restaurant had several tables of regulars and…read morethe host/owner knew them by name, showing a personal interest and dialogue in/with her customers. Food was very good. Shared homemade potato chips (yum!) and stuffed mushrooms with friends. Great starters! Salmon on my salad was delicious. Hubby's chicken carbonara was tasty, but sauce was rather thick and heavy. As has been mentioned, it was a bit distracting that all food is served in aluminum foil pans with plastic silverware. Don't quite understand this, except to say it likely saves on dish-washing!

This is the best fettuccine I've ever tasted and probably ever will!!!! The service was amazing and…read morethey make you feel at home!!! I hope I can come back very soon!!!!

The food is always delicious. We usually order dinner for 2 with spaghetti and meatballs. The…read moreservice is always good and the ambiance of the building makes this a great place to eat.

We came here for a family gathering and had an overall great experience!! There's plenty of parking…read moreout front (with a 2-hour limit), which was convenient. One thing to note; there's only one unisex bathroom on the first floor, which wasn't quite enough for the number of guests that day. There is another restroom upstairs, but it may not be ideal for those with mobility concerns. The wait staff were friendly, attentive, and happy to answer our questions since it was our first time dining here. The owner also made a point to visit every table, which added a warm, personal touch. The food truly stood out; comforting Italian dishes that reminded us of meals we enjoyed in Italy. Portions were just right, with a great balance of pasta and ingredients. The stuffed eggplant was a highlight; perfectly seasoned and absolutely delicious. The Pizza Bianco was another favorite, generously topped with artichoke hearts. A few minor notes: the calamari was slightly overcooked, and while the Shrimp Scampi with Capellini Aglio Olio was flavorful and well-seasoned, the pasta was a bit on the dry side for my preference. Some of the shrimp were slightly overcooked as well, but it didn't take away from the overall taste as it was still very enjoyable. Overall, we had a wonderful dining experience. We'd definitely recommend this spot and look forward to coming back the next time we're in the area.