I was so disappointed! We are visiting from out of town, absolutely so disappointed with how…read moreexpensive a tray of pizza was I wish the pizza came with cheese. It was all crust and sauce. Called to ask about getting more cheese, all they said is they do their pizza differently than the other locations in town. Wish I would have known that I would have gone to another location, than at least we would have gotten the good pizza we were use to.

I grew up on DiCarlo's Original Pizza located in Wellsburg, WV, so I am quite familiar with the…read moretaste and quality associated with DiCarlo's. From their website they provide the following information: For nearly 60 years, DiCarlo's very unique combination of hot crust - cold cheese has been successfully satisfying their devoted customers.Only DiCarlo's initially flash-bakes its crust and sauce in a special brick oven, and when the steaming crust emerges, it is adorned with cold creamy provolone cheese, making the taste indescribable! Orginal DiCarlo's Pizza uses NO frozen products. Fresh dough mixed daily in all of our stores. Our very own signature sauce made from superior-tasting, fresh tomatoes and combined with our unique spice mixture. We pride ourselves in using only the finest quality 100% provolone cheese, never pre-shredded. Only 100% meats - no fillers. We use products free of MSG. I can assure you that this pizza is quality and delicious. It is pizza served either by the slice at 90 cents per slice, or you can opt for a boxed square which usually will run you around 13.99 for a box of 16 slices. You can only order takeout at this location. Their pizza is good enough to take home and enjoy! If you get it "DiCarlo's style", it is with cold cheese on top. I prefer it this way, but to each their own. This is their signature style and it really adds to the flavor. They will happily melt the cheese for those of you that request it that way. I give it 2 thumbs way up! Great pizza!

the workers are nice and good pizza i like it so much food and good workers and have a ice cream…read moreset up now so its so ambiance for people

I purchased a mixed berry pie from this place. It was SO good! I was so happy with it I forgot to…read moretake a picture! The best part was the price. Extremely reasonable especially for how much fruit was in it! This seems to mainly be a pizza pie place, but don't leave without fruit pie!

Driving from PIT after a day traveling, called ahead for some slices. They were ready when we…read morearrived, piping hot with crunchy doughy crust. It's Ohio Valley style- cheese & pepperoni added at the end. If you like that style come here - this is one of the best I've had. Bonus if you're on a road trip- there's a nice space for eating and clean restrooms.

They have the worst customer service. They are rude, obnoxious argumentative, and wouldn't know the…read moretruth if they fell in it. The woman behind the counter waiting on customers should spend more time cleaning the restaurant instead of arguing with customers and chatting on the phone! I'm really not sure how this place stays open. The pizza is poor at best. If you like overcooked cardboard and uncooked cheese and toppings! My late wife for some reason liked their pizza for some reason and the only reason I went was to try and bring her a little joy in her last days. This has been over a year now and she passed in June of last year. I doubt if this place has changed. It makes me very sad every time I think about it.

We got pizza and a chicken salad. The pizza was really good and had a nice amount of cheese. The…read morechicken salad wasn't my favorite. They don't use freshly made grilled chicken, they use the frozen bagged stuff with the weird texture. We used the drive thru. The employees were nice and the place looked clean.

Super delicious pizza and fried mushrooms! They have a drive through and we're friendly and fast…read more The building is easy to get to and looks nice.

the pepperoni rolls are fire as well as the cheesy bread ,foods pretty good but they won't hire me…read moresooo . some of the employees are great ! it's a small place so you can't really eat inside but who's stopping you ?

New pizza shop in Claysville where Biggy's used to be. I've heard a lot of hype around town about…read moretheir dill pickle pizza! i tried to order last week when I was in the area and called twice with no answer. I was just down the street and knew they were opened so I stopped in to place my order and was told it would be a two hour wait (at 4 pm), so I passed. Today in my way home I stopped and got a small cheese pizza and a small "the big dill" to take home. The woman on the phone was very nice. The restaurant was clean. Like Biggy's was, it's mainly a takeout joint- there are only two small tables inside. It's right on Main St so there is plenty of street parking all around. Walking out, my pizza smelled amazing! Even though I ordered the small pizzas, I was surprised to see how small they actually were- they were definitely like personal pizzas. Each had four cuts, but the pizza was only about 8". The cheese pizza was alright. The crust is pretty thick and doughy, and there wasn't much of an outer edge on the crust on the cheese which was fine. The sauce was good, I just wasn't crazy about the cheese, but hey it's plain and that's what I ordered! The big dill was awesome! The crust was seasoned with some herbs and cheese. The pickles were great, and I liked the garlic sauce. Some fresh dill would take this to the next level, and maybe some different cheese, like a feta or something, too. I definitely recommend this pie though! The pizza was really greasy though and it was also a little too doughy/undercooked for my taste. I would probably ask for mine a little more well done next time. I would definitely get the big dill again. I would also like to try their salads and calzones. Prices are a bit high, especially for Claysville; medium specialty pizza is $17 and a whole hoagie is $16, but we all know what food costs are right now, especially for small businesses. I really hope they do well here!

The kids love the preserved animals and displays…read more To me, the food is medium - nothing special. My mom likes it and, she's from Avella, so we always run into folks we know.

We stopped here out of necessity, because the place we wanted to go to, right down the road, was…read moreclosed because of a water break, and we were hungry. First of all, this is a no-smoking restaurant, but I could smell faint smoke as soon as I entered. Turns out, the bar next door allows smoking, and the smell emanates slightly into the restaurant part from the bar. The decor was quite interesting. Lots of taxidermy on display everywhere. The room itself is quite dated, and has a historic feel to it. Be sure to look at the lighting, and the wallpaper. The booths are quite unique (see my photos). The food was basic, and not too expensive. Service was very good, and the food arrived quickly. They have some arcade games in the back room, and mini golf outside. Overall, a decent place to eat if you are in the area ... Cheers!

Small business in Mars in the Brickyard Road strip mall. I was early for an appointment in the…read moreplaza so stopped in for dinner. I was promptly recognized and ordered. I sat at one of the tables to eat. In a short amount of time, my piping hot cheese steak arrived on a plate (a real plate v. paper plate). The roll was perfectly toasted. Nice ratio of meat to veggies and cheese. Would have liked to see fried mozzarella on the menu. With gyms and daycare as neighbors, I would think a lot of "local" foot traffic. Rewards program available. Looking forward to going back to try a deep dish pizza.

saw their food on Facebook, thought we would give them a try.Fresh cut fries like rubber probably…read morere-cooked from yesterday? Fried provolone not done and from a freezer .Pizza sauce was very bland not a spice in the house! Pizza burned on bottom and not done on top. The greasiest cheese I have ever had.

Best pepperoni rolls around! The owners are always friendly and do a great job preparing our pick…read moreup orders!

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and the taste was truly, absolutely horrific. I never in my life,…read morehave ever tasted a glycerol, oil like, chemical flavor on my pallet from a simple bite of pizza, like the pizza I had at this restaurant. He's putting some type of artificial fat, additive, or extremely low cost/ quality ingredient (cheese) into his pizza that makes the product almost inedible. It tasted like he put a stale synthetic vegetable oil based popcorn butter (that has no salty taste or popcorn flavor) with a tannic, and bitter flavor in the sauce or on the dough during cooking. To this day, I question, how he even managed to do that and it gives me chills just to think about it. Actually, I should rate this review higher. As a person that appreciates and enjoys good food you can make at home or get from a quality restaurant; I am truly impressed that this business produced a pizza that tasted like literal garbage. The pizza from this business is situated below the economic rock bottom for quality of Dominos and boarding on what a raccoon would question as a midnight snack. Mind you, this was the first time I ate two pieces of a pizza, and threw the entire remaining pie in the trash. I would rate this lower than a restaurant that served me 8 month old freezer burned ribs. I wish I had the vocabulary to describe that what I was served and ate, "didn't taste like food." Something that I also need to mention is that his business does not take any form of electronic payment, only cash or "personal checks." If you can't understand the owner's rambling at the end of the call when placing the order, he wants you, when you arrive to pick up your order, to walk or drive across the street to a gas station, to pay a fee and withdrawal money from an ATM machine and walk/ drive back over to pay for your "gruel." An expectation that 90% of his potential market is not expecting. Is this why they have such great reviews, are people just infatuated with a business that only takes cash? I'd rather eat boot leather boiled in a quality chicken broth, served by a bum in the street, over my experience with this restaurant and the food I was served. Something has to change here. NOTHING about this restaurant is sustainable or good. I would rate it lower, if I could. Advice to the owner: Make a quality product or turn the key and close down shop, Fucking disgusting.

Pizza and mushrooms were soooo good! The crunch on the crust was absolutely delicious and the…read moremushrooms were cooked to perfection!

Given this place so many chances because their pizza sauce is delicious but sadly they just can't…read morecook it. Multiple times I tried asking for the pizza well done and still get a chewy uncooked white bottom pizza smh. I finally quit trying. Today I tried getting salads ( can't mess up lettuce right ? ) they said - hold my beer. The chicken was pre cooked somewhere else and fresh out of the freezer. No joke, they litteraly forgot to heat it up and at least pretend they cooked it themselves. I made the mistake of asking for French fries on the salad lol, nope can't pull it off. I had to order a separate order of fries and put them on the salad myself no big deal.. but like most places in west Virginia they use the crinkle cut frozen trash fries from the local cheap store ridiculous. Oh, and don't forget that their drinks are not kept cold , paid $5 for 2 bottles of hot pop for a total of $23 .. Sorry it didn't work out between us , I gave you at least 30 chances because there's no other choices here.. which also explains how you stay in business. The standards are not just low, they're non existent. ... you owe me $23 by the way.

Food has gone downhill since they opened. It used to be really good. Now it's not near as good as…read moreit used to be.

Pizza was very good. We ordered pickup and it was hot when we arrived to pick it up. Everything was…read moregood only reason for 4 stars was due to the price 50 dollars and change for 2 large pepperoni pizzas and ranch.