Had a good friend buy dinner for me and my wife due to me having surgery earlier in the week. We are grateful for him and his beautiful wife!! Wonderful friends!! He had called them set it all up for pizza to be here by 5 pm. He texted me I said no he called them and basically they lied to him,it ended up about 545 pm to get here. We tipped the driver not his fault at all!! He gotten us an all meat lager pizza it was delicious to a point. If you are going to put a teaspoon of sauce on there you might want to add a cup for dipping we ended up opening a jar of pizza sauce to eat it very disappointed! To me sents the new ownership came in they have gone downhill! The corners they cut isn't right. It's going to be a min before I have them again!! Thank you to my friends though love you guys !! You get 6 stars read more

Friday night late dinner 4 delivery! My food came within 1 hour as stated. It was well worth the wait! Price was reasonable. Overall, a 5 Star experience.... !! Large Philly Steak & cheese sandwich w/banana peppers, mushrooms & onions.... Comes w/ fresh tomato & lettuce... def satisfied my palate. However, I preferred ranch dressing instead of mayo. The large philly steak sandwich was grt!!! Not dry.....Hot just the way I like it! Only wished they had a variety of choices of the sides. I had plain chips & a side salad.....Thx PPizza for a grt food experience! Until next time!! No pic this time! read more

Friday night and they were busy, which to me is a good sign! The staff is kind and the delivery driver engaged with conversation. The Italian sub is HUGE and received good reviews from both kiddos, it was enough for all four of us. Pepperoni and cheese pizza delicious and we will order again! Four stars only because of delivery time, which if the food is good (it is) we will wait! read more

This place has the best pizza around and the Italian subs are the best I've ever had anywhere!

Sadly NO STARS, 2nd time was the charm for us! Waiting almost 2 hours for 2 simple pizzas to feed KIDS. I had to call and remind them AGAIN! $50 wasted and never will return! read more

This place has the best pizza and subs. My family loves ordering from paynes. All the employees are so kind! Best pizza place in Marion!!!! read more

In town visiting and had the hall Italian sub and it was absolutely delicious. Toasted bread and plenty of fillings was alerted about the generous size and definitely not disappointed. Going back tomorrow and try the pizza read more

Pizza was great! We moved from out of state and I was nervous to eat pizza from OH. My newneighbor said. i had to give Payne's a try and i was not disappointed! The crust was soft (foldable) but thin. The sauce was tasty and I even did some changes to my pizza to see if there were any errors and they NAILED IT! So I wanted to give them full stars for that! read more

Would give zero stars if I could. Ordered at 6:45, told delivery at 7:45. Understandable for a Friday night. Called at 8:15, a woman answered "Marion" (poor customer service) and was told on its way. Called at 8:45 to question and a man advised it would be there any minute. Tried to explain that we were told this already and asked if it's been in a car for over an hour and was hung up on. I know they won't care about this review but it's the only voice available, a sad state of affairs. Called at 9pm and it was determined that they delivered to the wrong address and they took it!!!!! However, had Paynes looked into this at 8:15, it wouldn't be this bad! Update: we got a cheese pizza and not the pizza/sub we ordered. Worst experience ever! read more

Very good pizza for a very good price.. I'm a big fan of the Big Daddy, they really pile on the toppings. Also, their subs are pretty good too but overall the entire restaurant is worth going to because of the variety of quality food they have for really good prices. Plus if you're on a lunch break from work or just on the go they are very, very fast here, like Wendy's type fast nearly... Highly recommend any and all of their soups as well...and the taco salad is huge. Their "half sub" special too is particularly a great value because it's about the size of a full sub you'd get at Subway. Check out Payne's pizza, it's very good food and I heartily recommend! read more

See all

Food is usually great, occasionally you can tell it was rushed but no major complaints on the food. Timing on the other hand is a completely different story. Ever since they switched ownership, the pickup times have been way off, on every occasion since. They've had plenty of time to get things under control since ownership change, that's why I'm now posting this review. Most of the time when you show up to pick up your order now, you get the same "it's not quite don't yet, but shouldn't be to long" ...as they're printing the order ticket to just then start prepping and cooking. So be prepared to wait in a range of 20-45 minutes past your original pickup time, with many others also waiting throughout the restaurant. read more

I ordered for delivery on a Monday evening while there was a pretty good snow storm going on. I was told it could take up to an hour and a half for my delivery. But I was so pleasantly surprised when it only to about 45-50 min for my food to arrive! The pizza was amazing fresh toppings and very generous amount too. The chicken sub was delicious as well! If you haven't tried this pizza shop I highly recommend it!! If I'm ever in the area again I'll definitely have Paynes Pizza!! read more

The best lasagna ever!!!! Delivery service is quick and efficient. I recommend the sandwiches...the bread is fresh and tasty. I cannot wait to try the pizza. We heard they are fantastic. read more

This used to be our favorite pizza place for dine in and delivery but the service, delivery, and quality has gone down Hill quickly. The last 3 delivery orders were either wrong, missing something, cold, bread hard, etc. They give no time approximation for delivery and when they screw up they act like it's an inconvenience for them to correct it. Tonight , January 4, 2019 my order arrived with a lukewarm pizza, very hard sub bun and it was more bun than meat or toppings, wrong chips and missing drinks. When I called they told me it would be awhile for it to be remedied. First, the management may want to hire a business consultant to help them understand that if they delivered good and hot food and orders are sent out correctly they would get better reviews. Management obviously does not care . I do not recommend this place unless you are open for getting whatever they decide to send out and not necessarily what you order. read more

This is my go-to pizza place when I'm in town. The pizza is always good. I've tried their soup and their salads... stick to the pizza. Yikes! I usually carry out, and will probably continue to. The couple times I've eaten in we're not the most pleasant. The dining room experience leaves a lot to be desired. read more

Good was great and delivered hot. We had a pizza which was loaded with toppings a sub and some wings. I would order again if I'm ever in Marion for supper read more

Meal (****): I ordered the hot wings and was pleased with the flavor. For some reason they tasted buttery, though. They were not greasy nor messy, but came out piping hot from the oven. Ambiance (***): The atmosphere is communal and family oriented. It is a great place to wind down and have a few good laughs! The noise level can vary depending on the day and time. Service (*****): Service is usually impeccable, though unconventional: your name is shouted across the room and you are served by the staff that assemble the food. Everyone is very helpful and remember you if you are a regular. read more

Paynes Pizza & More - Mmm - Pizza Near Me - Marion, Ohio

We ordered for delivery and again our order was delivered barely warm. I called to check on the order to make sure they had written it down correctly and they had. We ordered double pepperoni on our pizza and for the 3rd time we were charged for double pepperoni but barely got the any at all. To add insult to injury the man that answered the phone started to argue with me that he "loaded" it with pepperoni. He also did not want to see the photos that I have taken of the last 3 orders. They will not get anymore of my money!! read more

Just got into town and decided to give this pizza place a shot. Outside didn't look very appealing, but looks can be deceiving. One large cheese pizza later, I was unpleasantly disappointed. The cheese tastes rubbery and stiff, and leaves a bad aftertaste- very cheap. The dough was undercooked, and what little sauce I could taste wasn't very flavorful. I can safely say that the crust was the only good part. Overall, disappointing. Not recommending to my friends. read more

This is a classic home-town pizza shop. You order at the counter, grab a drink, have a seat and they run your food to you. We stopped for a pizza lunch and by the time we left, it was hopping. The service was good, and we ordered a large Payne's Supreme pizza - a cracker crust with plenty of toppings and the right amount of cheese. Not super-greasy, which kept the thin crust crispy. The large was the right size for two hungry people and came out quickly. Although I like my crust a bit thicker, Payne's is pretty good pizza. We got timely and friendly service as well, although coming for lunch means a more seasoned staff. Would return to try again. read more

Pizza isn't the only thing great about Paynes Pizza. Their salads, their sandwiches, and their spaghetti is the best out of any of the major pizza chains. I would recommend trying this pizza place over the big franchises. Support local businesses! read more

Without fail, every time I call to place an order, I am welcomed by a bored, apathetic employee with the warmth of the North Pole. But it doesn't end there. When arriving to pick up my meal, I am ignored for at least a minute or more while standing at the counter. Two or three employees are looking right at me but seem too relaxed to acknowledge me or even give me a courtesy "I'll be right with you." And this isn't a one time occurrence. It happens EVERY TIME! Try it yourself and see. I don't blame the employees either. They are bored teenagers working for minimum wage at a job they hate. I get that. We've all done it. I blame the management. Pay attention to your employees and crack the whip when you see this happening! But they are probably miserable too. On a positive note, the sandwiches are excellent. read more

Frequented by numerous locals, Payne's is a nice sit down pizza joint with a good selection of Pizza's, Subs and Pasta dishes. The food has always been good here. Last night we had a veggie pizza which was very good and served quickly, and done just as we like. The Staff was pleasant and friendly. Worth a stop if your in the area. Delivery is available as well. read more

I was in Marion, OH for the annual Popcorn Festival a day early and was looking for some dinner when I discovered Payne's Pizza. Have to say this was some of the Best Pizza I have had in a long time. I ordered a 12' pie with pepperoni and mushrooms and that's all I needed. I recommend Payne's to anyone looking for some good pie in Marion, OH. read more

Paynes Pizza & More - Need I say more? - Pizza Near Me - Marion, Ohio

Payne's menu has something for everyone. Their pizza sauce is sort of a "love it or hate it" thing, but there is a lot of other options.

The pizza was average. The service was terrible! The price was average. Nothing impressive. Felt like the people working there didn't care or want customers. The sauce and cheese for the breadsticks were cold. read more

One of the most diverse selections in marion. Pizza, subs, lasagna!. Not to mention their subs are about as long as your arm. My personal favorite is the club. Yiu definitely get your moneys worth. read more

Best subs! I definitely recommend it. The Italian sub is the best, but you can't do wrong with ordering subs from here.

the absolute best subs around in marion and i include the sub shops in that. love the ease of ordering either pizza by whole or pizza by the slice read more

Sauce is half the battle. Theirs is just about right. Thank goodness it isn't sweet!!! I was in town for business and came in for lunch. I decided on baked spaghetti with meatballs by quickly looking at the menu. At the same time, G was having a sandwich delivered from Paynes. Both were satisfactory and the place looks very popular. If I could make changes, I'd say add a dollar to the price and get better meatballs, add more cheese, offer Parmesan at the table or as an addition from the kitchen, and offer a thinner pasta option. I am an angel hair girl and I bet a lot of others are too. I don't know if this is on the menu but Rigatoni would go well as an option for this dish. read more

I like it! Food is decent quality, good selection, and my kiddos will eat it up, which is really all that matters most nights. Dine in, carry out and delivery are fantastic. Actually, they are one of only 3 places that deliver to the area of Marion I live in, so it's very helpful on nights I don't want to cook or pack up the babies to drive into town. read more

It's a good lunch place if you want a quick meal, nothing fancy. Pizza was very good. I enjoy returning for lunch

There's a reason why it's called paynes. You'll figure it out later that evening our the next day.

Tasted like poop. The delivery drivers nearly ran us over and the pizza tasted out of the toilet. If I didn't know better I'd say they put about as much love in their pizza as they do their customers! read more

Do not waste your money or calories here. Worst pizza ever. More like a cracker with stuff on top. Having eaten pizzas all over the country, this should not be called a pizza. Maybe a flat crusty base with tasteless toppings. Luckily I only ordered a few slices. All the customers were EXTREMELY large people. They are definitely not there for the taste. More like a herd of cows. read more

Hhhhmmm second time ive had issues here just today 2 sandwiches were made wrong manager refuses to make it right! Sorry not trying to get free food out of the deal just the right food! Never again guys not worth it read more

I normally don't complain but I must!Marion Store is a Joke!The manager Amber needs some training!If you mess something up it's ok just fix it especially for customer that's been ordering atleast once a week...They def just helped a local pizza shop get more business! read more

my son loves this place but on Saturday October 20th we was very upset with our service. we order the same thing all of the time. when we got our food it wasnt right. my sub was gross. I asked for extra mayo and extra cheese and I got neither. I was pretty disappointed in it. we wasnt told when it would be delivered. it was here in less than 30 minutes which is good if the food was hot. my son wouldnt eat his pasta because it was cold. highly disappointed in the service. read more