Absolutely love every experience at Pastaru Pastificio--especially with their recent menu change. Every dish felt intentional, fresh, and packed with flavor. You can really tell they take pride in their pasta here, it's perfectly cooked and tastes like it's made in-house (because it is!!) The new menu brings such a fun, elevated twist while still keeping that authentic, comforting Italian feel. Everything we tried was a hit--rich sauces, high-quality ingredients, and beautiful presentation across the board. The atmosphere is cozy but still has that trendy, date-night energy, and the service was just as good as the food--friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu. Simone and his team are the BEST!!! This is one of those spots that you leave already planning your next visit. If you haven't been since the menu change, RUN back--you're seriously missing out. read more

See all

Been here twice so far and I must say, it's my new favorite pasta spot on Long Island. I love how you can make your own plate and mix n match. The food: I've only tried the bolognese with two different pastas, both fireee. I really enjoy the addition of carrots in the bolognese. The carbonara was delicious along with the lasagna. The veal and the celery in the lasagna make it unique. I highly recommend! The service is really friendly, they remember your faces and are quick! The ambiance is chill, never too packed and loud. It's perfect for a date or with anyone really. The bathrooms are also clean thankfully. Overall, super tasty authentic food with excellent service 5/5 read more

See all

Good portions, fresh pasta, great service and very clean ambiance. Keeps my family coming back for more

New pasta bar in Mineola. Home made pasta, all different shapes, you pick the pasta then the sauces. The portions were good, but needed more protein besides chicken. The desserts were excellent tiramisu, torte and the cannoli all fresh and decent size. They give you bread with no butter and not enough sauce to dip it into. Ugh. Overall decent experience. read more

See all

Nice place in Mineola to get fresh homemade pasta dishes. My first item I ordered was the Rigitoni Pesto. Delicious and I ordered during the lunch special which meant my lunch was just $12 One negative thing is a very small glass bottle of soda was $3.00. Other places you get a normal size bottle or glass with refills. Othen thank that I'll definitely be back there again. read more

Pastaru Pastificio - Delicious Rigitoni Pesto lunch special. Amazing - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

The staff members are very friendly but I wasn't blown away by the food. The parmigiana di melanzane was ok and very small in portion for the price. The server brought us bread to dip into the sauce which was nice. Although I liked the texture of the rigatoni and the sauce was tasty but overall a little salty. The spaghetti was fine and the sauce was fine; could have more flavor. Nothing was bad, just not good enough for me to visit again as there are so many Italian restaurants to try. read more

See all

Honestly really had higher expectations and was very disappointed. I wanted to like the place because the concept reminded me of the pasta place in Brooklyn. We came in on a Sunday afternoon and we were one the first customers. It was our first time and we were unsure how to order/where to sit. Customer service was fine - they explained we order at the counter first before sitting but were nice to let us sit and look over the menu prior to ordering. We ordered the fusilli with pesto, rigatoni with funghi e tartufu, polpette (meatballs) and their special spaghettoni with spicy cherry tomatoes sauce and stracciatella $22. The cheese was great. The meat was not memorable and the pastas ... ALL three were extremely salty. We thought it was just the first bite and it would mellow out but it was the whole dish and thus the disappointment. The table next to us left around the same time we did and they also said it was very salty. Hope it was just a fluke that day and not a consistent thing ... read more

See all

Such a cute new spot in Mineola! The food was so good, and the portions felt just right--people say it's small, but honestly, I think it's cozy. The fried artichokes were tasty (a pinch more salt wouldn't hurt), and my friend's carbonara with fettuccine had a great sauce. I went for the truffle mushroom fettuccine and loved it--the mushrooms were perfectly thin and bite-sized. The burrata salad was simple but fresh and yummy, and the rice ball was massive and super tasty. For dessert, we shared cannolis and cappuccino. The cannolis were delicious but tiny--two minis for $8 feels a little steep, but the flavor made up for it. Service was quick and friendly--food came out fast. You order right at the counter when you walk in, so I recommend grabbing a table first. The vibe reminded me of an IKEA cafeteria, but in the best, chill way possible. I'd totally go back and definitely recommend it! read more

See all

Love this place! Great fresh house made food, fast, reasonably priced, and everyone who works there has always been so kind. We keep coming back, and are working our way through all of the different sauce options. My favorite so far is the alla vodka - absolutely delicious! read more

Food: Excellent Service: Superb Ambiance: Chick/Casual. Everything was so good! The Staff was super nice and the Resturant was very clean and inviting. The only thing missing.........Gelato! read more

Pastaru Pastificio - 6 Pasta Dishes - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

We ordered take out and we were really expecting to be blown away because of all we had heard and unfortunately we were not. It was fine, pasta was yummy but the sauces were just ok. I got bolognese and friend got vodka sauce. Both were good, we liked it but nothing that would make me come back for. I'll probably it try once more to give it another shot. read more

Pastaru Pastificio - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

I had heard so much about this place living in the area. I really am the worst Mineola person btw lol. I need to eat in my hometown more often. Anyway we came here one night after a hockey game since it's sort of by the train station and it was absolutely amazing. I can't even believe how long it took us to actually come here. Food was amazing. Service was great and ambiance is nice. I hope this place stays a very long time and I love that our town has this. I had the carbonara btw which I think just won a best pasta dish, I swear I read that somewhere lol. Absolutely amazing. read more

Ordered out, the rigatoni carbonara was mid -but honestly worse than I could have imagined. It had a really bitter burnt aftertaste, i can't get the taste out. I had the tiramisu which was fluffy and absolute perfection. I am so disappointed in the pasta though, the rigatoni itself was great, but the carbonara sauce was horrific read more

Delicious homemade made pasta at the right price!! Nice bottle of wine and a hot latte at the end to top off 2 great meals. The bolognese and the Penne were both delicious. Very nice staff on this Saturday afternoon. read more

See all

The freshest pasta I've ever eaten! Came for the lunch special. You're able to choose the shape of pasta and sauce you'd like for $15 and it comes with bread too! I got the fusilli pasta with vodka sauce. You can tell it is homemade from the texture alone. The sauce was so fresh too. It has a nice ambiance, but what set this apart was the customer service. The employees were so friendly and kept checking in to see how we were doing. I will definitely be back soon! read more

Pastaru Pastificio - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

Went for the lunch special. The pasta is made fresh and you can even see an employee in the very front of the store making things fresh. The staff is very nice. You order at the counter and they bring it to your table, unless you want your order to go. It's a good portion of pasta, and the perfect amount of sauce. They also have salads and desserts. I definitely want to get back to try those! read more

Pastaru Pastificio - Daily special menu - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Let's start with the outstanding customer service. We were met by Amani. Once I shared that we were first time patrons, he shifted into gear. He hit all three C's; clear, concise and courteous. He was personable yet not over the top. The restaurant had a clean, modern and yet classic look to it. Very welcoming. Although we didn't dine in, we took a seat while waiting for our food and the seats are very comfortable. On to the food. I tried the rigatoni bolognese. As expected the fresh pasta was really good. Cooked just right. The bolognese sauce was good, not WOW good, but good. I enjoyed my meal. Tasty and filling. As a good pasta dish should be. Will definitely return to try other menu options. read more

Pastaru Pastificio, a pick-your-pasta that's cooked right in front of you joint (been in operation just under 4 months) is a warm, family-owned restaurant with friendly staff and attentive service. All the items were very tasteful and well-prepared, reflecting the care and authenticity you expect from a family-run outfit. Also items were priced appropriately priced for the quality and portion sizes. That said, was bit disappointed when they told the fresh pasta making stopped for the night (we went there at 7p) which was something I was looking forward to. Also disappointing was to learn they don't have any veggie option like primavera. Nevertheless, with few tweaks to add more veggie choices and extended fresh pasta making hours, this place could easily be a neighborhood favorite. Simone, must have been my fat finger that caused the error which I didn't even realize until you pointed out. My sincere apologies for that oversight. With respect to complimentary dessert and singing for birthday, I consider them as customary which I do not generally include in my review because i don't want customers to think my reviews are biased because of those special favors read more

See all

I'll start by saying the service is great and the workers are very friendly. This is a good spot to grab a quick pasta, but I don't think it's the best pasta I've ever had. I had high expectations given that this is fresh made pasta, but I just thought it was OK. In the picture, it looks like Chef Boyardee lol. I got the paccheri alla vodka - the vodka sauce was watery and didn't cling on to the noodles. I think it also could've used more sauce. The burrata I added on was more like a mozzarella. Overall, it was just very bland. I did like the complimentary bread! read more

Pastaru Pastificio - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

Not sold. I might give it another opportunity, I might not. The food I got to go was not the best when I got home. I love Italian but ordering from the app and not knowing the sauces are not the best option for first time customers. I got add on's. Which was chicken cutlet(1) meatballs (2) and shrimp(4) not a lot and the sauce was not a lot for the one that I did get with sauce, bread was hard. the location looks nice but would I try it again is the question. And to be honest I'm not sure. I threw the chicken cutlet and fettuccini in the garbage. It was horrible even if I added sauce the chicken was terrible read more

Pastaru Pastificio - Dry chicken thin cutlet. Yuck - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

Found this place on Facebook and knew that my husband would LOVE it! When we arrived, we parked on the street, around the corner and paid a quarter for 30 minutes. In the window to Pastaru, there was a man, portioning freshly made pasta. The space is clean, bright and inviting with 2 rooftop windows, letting in the natural light. The display had different pasta shapes and each one had suggestions for the various sauces they make. We were greeted by the owner, who was gracious and came over to chat with us. The girl behind the counter was very sweet. She explained to us the menu and took our order. I decided on fusilli with vodka sauce. Hubby ordered linguini pomodoro. We sat and waited no more than 5 minutes and our food arrived. A baby bread basket was served with grated cheese on the side. She also offered fresh pepper and red pepper flakes. DELICIOUS!! Cannot wait to return to try another shape with a different sauce! read more

See all

The pasta's texture was ridiculously awesome. Super speedy and friendly service, perfect for a lunchtime pit stop. I'd kill for a teensy bit more seasoning in that sauce, though. Hopefully, the chef will taste it more often now that they're still in the honeymoon phase. Definitely coming back for seconds ASAP. Love seeing new businesses pop up in the area, fingers crossed they'll knock it out of the park. Can't wait to upgrade them to 5 Stars pronto. read more

See all

The pasta is amazing and so are the sauces offered. This restaurant is like being in Italy. The menu is simple and thoughtful. The service is gracious and attentive. Even when it's busy! We went twice, once on Valentine's Day and another time with friends. It's quiet enough that you can talk to each other too! I love this place! read more

Pastaru Pastificio - A special pappardelle with oxtail sauce - Italian Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Great home made pasta! Everything was delicious and it's a real carbonara!!! Staff is so friendly! Can't wait to come back and try the rest!!! read more

We visited Pastaru Pastifico on a Thursday evening around 5:30-6 PM and were happy to find plenty of seating, even though the place already had a nice buzz of activity. Ordering can be a little confusing at first--there's wait staff, but the setup makes it feel like you should order at the counter. We went up to the counter, where the owner, Simone, greeted us warmly and explained their "pasta your way" concept. You choose your pasta, your sauce, and optional protein. Everything is made fresh using homemade pasta made with imported 00 semolina flour from Italy--so if you're gluten-sensitive, this might be worth a try! Starters: We ordered all the sides--yes, all of them--and they were fantastic. Highlights: * Carciofini Fritti - perfectly crispy * Eggplant Parm - simple, fresh, and full of flavor * Meatballs - super tender with a savory sauce * Arancini - golden, crisp, and comforting Pasta Dishes: * Spaghetti alla Carbonara - One of the BEST we've ever had (and no cream, just like in Rome!) * Paccheri with Amatriciana - So flavorful and well-balanced * Gnocchi with Vodka Sauce - Soft, pillowy, and absolutely delicious The sauces are clean, fresh, and made from top-tier ingredients. You can tell everything is made with care. Dessert: We were too full to try dessert at the restaurant, but we took home the Tiramisu and Torta della Nonna--both were outstanding. Light, flavorful, and not overly sweet. Vibe: This is a perfect spot for a cozy lunch or casual date night. The food is comforting and elevated without being fussy. I'm already dreaming of coming back for a light plate of pasta and a cappuccino. Huge thanks to Simone and the team for the hospitality--we're rooting for your continued success! Don't miss this place if you love fresh pasta and warm service. Total gem. read more

See all

This place is perfect for dinner with kids. You order in front, snag a table and food is delivered very soon after. All homemade pastas, and lots of fun sauces to sample. I had their bolognese on rigatoni, we also ordered Cacio e Pepe and ravioli in red sauce. Their ravioli was prob my favorite- simple. Will def be back to sample more. read more

First time this afternoon and can' t wait to return. Food was great along with the pleasant staff. A home-run.

I've been a loyal customer of Simone since his soft opening. I love the assortment of pastas and side dishes. They also have very nice wines by the glass. Everyone there is very happy to be a part of this great restaurant. read more

Great food,service Fresh pasta sauce,cheese Great location. Up and coming area to visit. read more

Great food and fast service. I've been looking for pasta Genovese since I've tried in Italy several years ago. This is the first place that's had it and it definitely didn't disappoint. Meatballs were ok. read more

See all

Love love love love! And I'm not even a pasta person! My kids love pasta, which is why I wanted to take them to see what the hype is all about and for them to have the option to choose their own pasta shapes and sauces. We chose the Paccheri pasta (out of spaghetti, gnocchi, fettuccine, fusilli, and penne) since that was the most distinctive one and we've never had that before. The sauces we chose were bolognese and genovese. The employees there were very informative and friendly. The food came to our table pretty quick. My son took a bite immediately while standing and said "MmmMMMmmm!!" From there, I knew it'd be good and I went in for my bite. The pasta texture was perfectly al dente. Perfection. Perfect bite, perfect resistance, perfect tenderness. The sauce and meat were a little salty, but I like salty foods and it paired with the plain pasta very well. We all loved it and finished it quickly. The bolognese was saucy and tender. The veal meat and onions from the genovese sauce was delicious and satisfying as well. We will definitely come back. My boys want to try other pastas and sauces next. read more

See all

Popped in for lunch. And the girl at the register was like above and beyond helpful. She explained every single pasta, every single side and every single sauce the combinations would be endless. Cacio e Pepe gnocchi was the combination that I chose for my pasta and it was definitely delicious, every single bite... we also did the red sauce rigatoni because you need to be basic and the meatballs, grilled chicken, and buratta. Every bite was delicious. Burrata was on the small side though. We ordered at the counter, and the food was delivered to our table. It was a great experience and fresh pasta just hits different. read more

I wish I can give this place 5000 stars! That's how good it is. Where do I even begin... my parents and I stumbled upon this GEM after a rough day at the DMV. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by friendly staff and fell in LOVE with the fresh pasta concept! (You can literally see someone making the pasta) We were so overwhelmed by the different tasty options on how to get your perfect plate of pasta. You are given the option to choose your pasta and then a sauce. I got the Gnocchi Cacio E Pepe, momma had Fettuccine pomodoro and dad had fettuccine Carbonara. ALL 3 were spectacular! The freshness of the pasta was unbelievable and the sauces were so delicious. The attention from the staff was great. Very attentive and friendly. The place itself is a bit on the smaller side but comfy and cozy. Overall a great find and new addition to my favorite dining places. I'm so glad we found this place and we will absolutely be coming back! read more

See all

Tried 2 types of pasta dishes recently for take out. First a basic spaghetti and meatballs. Issues: the pasta was very thick (not what I expected to be called spaghetti). It was chewy and undercooked (I know what al dente is and this was less than that). I also know traditional Italian isn't very saucy but there was barely any sauce. As a result, the take out pasta stuck together like a nest. The meatball side was good but small for the cost. My wife had a truffle and mushroom pasta that was somewhat better although again the pasta felt a bit too thick and chewy. I was excited about this place but given these disappointments I likely will not return. read more

I have heard so much about Pastaru Pastifico and have been wanting to try it out for sometime. Finally managed a Sunday night dinner. We were greeted by a very kind lady, she explained us the whole process of ordering, since this was our first visit. Definitely took sometime deciding what to eat. We got a Fromaggio stuffed Ravioli in pesto sauce. Their pasta is definitely fresh, it tasted fresh and was cooked to perfection. Pesto sauce was nice and flavorful. Soup of the day was good and served hot. Overall we had a good experience. It's a nice cozy small place and would definitely recommend if you want to have good pasta. I will be going for round two, to try some more classics. Would definitely rate them 5 for service. read more

See all

Amazing little place that is more quick serve than fancy, although the food is top notch it's not exactly a fancy Resturant which is good and bad. Good is top notch food at reasonable prices and great for any meal , bad is it does get noisy and hard to carry a conversation Would go back again read more

Pastaru Pastificio is a rare gem. I was blown away by the quality of the dishes they made, at the price point they make them at this unsuspecting casual eatery. We stepped in and marveled at the simple menu: pick a fresh pasta, pick a sauce, pick a topping (if you wish). For the uninitiated, you can even see a plate of the raw pastas in the window that's below the menu on the wall. And then we paid, we sat down at an empty table and got some glasses of water, fully expecting a lowkey self service type of experience. But as our pasta dishes were prepared, in came the staff, offering cheese (some good cheese, btw), and bread. When our entrees arrived, we were offered freshly cracked pepper, pepper flakes, and they checked on us constantly. I haven't been this attended to at some full service restaurants. They're so friendly here! And the food... the pastas are perfectly made, perfectly cooked and perfectly sauced. These are not stuff-you-till-you-roll-outta-there portions, no. These are quality portions of carefully crafted pasta dishes. We are a family of 4 so we got to try 4 different pastas and sauces. I can tell you that the genovese, carbonara, bolognese and funghi sauces were outstanding. These entrees at the lunch price of $15 (pasta+sauce) are an absolute steal. We took some of it home because we had to try the desserts. The tiramisu and the gelatos were the perfect end to a perfect meal. We left satisfied and amazed and immediately wondering when we can plan another trip back to have some more. It is clear to me how much they care about the food they make for their customers here. You can see it on your plate. You can feel it in the way the staff warmly attend to you. Don't hesitate to try Pastaru. You won't regret it. read more

I really wanted to like this place, but unfortunately, it fell flat in just about every way. We ordered pasta dishes - the Amatriciana and the Spaghetti Carbonara - and both were underwhelming. The flavor was nothing special, and the portion sizes were shockingly small for the price. We also tried the artichokes, which were completely over-salted and drowning in oil - almost inedible. It's hard to ignore the fact that this restaurant seems more focused on social media appearances than actual quality. The vibe screams "free meal for influencers," and you can tell that's where their priorities lie. Bottom line: The food is mediocre at best, overpriced, and simply not worth it. There are far better Italian options elsewhere that won't leave you feeling ripped off. Also, the bathroom was gross and there was food all over the floor in the main dining area. read more

I've been here twice for takeout. Excellent food, very friendly staff! Tremendous addition to the neighborhood read more

Not sure what the hype is all about, this place was extremely disappointing, the pasta portions are very small and not worth $19. We ordered the amatriciana and bolognese and the bolognese was dry (no sauce to be found) and the meat was very finely ground so the consistency was not good at all, it was mushy. The amatriciana is absolutely nothing like you get in Italy, I've been to many regions in Italy and this is my go to dish and it was nothing like I've ever had, and not in a good way. The only reason this review is getting 2 stars and not 1 star was because the arancini (rice ball) was good, not the best but it was good. Sadly, we had such high hopes for this place but we will not be going back. read more