My go to place for Italian. Love, love the service. Never have been disappointed with the meal. HOWEVER, seating is very limited. We decided to wait in the car for approx 20 min before it opened seating began. While we waited, approximately 8-10 couples started lining up outside the front door. It felt like waiting in line for tickets to an event. When doors opened, we were the last to walk in. We were told there would be an hour wait. I wasn't expecting this and blurted out, "An hour wait?" They saw our disappointment and made accomodations for my date and I. We had a wonder meal with terrific service. We tipped accordingly. Highly recommend. read more

When I showed up there was a line outside before they opened. Very popular place. I would recommend take out unless you have reservations. People standing in line were turned away. With that being said, food was amazing! We visit Pinetop once a year. This is a must visit. read more

I am not sure why this place is so busy. We had to wait for about 30 minutes to get a table since they don't take reservations. While the place is lovely, the servers are clueless and we had a few of them come up during our dinner. I asked if there is any pasta made in house and she said she did not know so I asked if she could check with the kitchen. Turned out they make cannelloni and ravioli in house. They were out of cannelloni so we ordered ravioli and veal Parmesan. Veal Parmesan was too breaded and spaghetti and marina were simply not tasty. Ravioli on the other hand were very good. The Caesar salad was not worth the upgrade since the lettuce were somewhat wilted. read more

See all

This place ROCKS! We've been dining here for almost 30 years. Always enjoy ourselves and whatever we order is so tasty. The service is always impeccable for us too! I highly recommend that you give it a try if you haven't already! read more

We have loved this place for a long time now. Whether it's a date night or a family night or a girls night, it's a must. My 11YO son is helping me with this review and he would like me to say: great service, good gluten free pasta, kids love it and we all agree on loving our server, Trace. He's the guy that will always remember you don't want ice in your water- year after year. Pro tip- Bolognese with the meat sauce and angel hair is a must order. You don't want to miss this family run place that makes you feel like family. read more

i have never written a review because i am simply not that person, however , this place was divine. our wait time was 30 minutes and we got seated in 5. The service was that of a fine dining restaurant with the FOH staff going above and beyond. You can tell they genuinely enjoy their position. The food was extremely delicious and portions were huge. if the price scares you away, then please reconsider as its 100000% worth it . The ingredients in both the pizza & pasta were incredibly fresh and you could taste the quality. BOH really knows how to cook!!!! My only dislike was I live 4 hours away from this place and cant go at least once a week! The restaurant was cute and ambiance was very chill and music wasn't too loud so you could hear your party. I will miss this place! Please come to phoenix!!!! read more

Pasta House - pomodoro pasta , the alfredo with chicken added & the little bronx pizza - Italian Near Me - Pinetop, Arizona

Lovely spot for dinner! We checked in when they opened at 5:00, and they called us at 6:00 for a table on a Sat night over Labor Day. It's nice that you can leave and return when they call you. Excellent staff and food! Homey feel read more

Another delicious dinner and great service at the Pasta House. They never fail when you need a dinner for a special occasion. Seated in the patio room provides the perfect ambience for a romantic dinner. Tonight I started with the extra dirty martini and blue cheese olives, we shared the calamari and the sauce is divine-perfect for dipping your bread in, followed by the Caesar salad, then the Veal Saltimbocca-that basil sauce and of course we had to finish with bananas foster and the chocolate torte. Thank you again for another wonderful meal. read more

See all

We absolutely LOVE this place, not just for the outstanding food, but for the incredible hardworking employees! They go all in to make your experience perfect. Every time I visit my hometown I stop in. Recently my partner and I came to celebrate my birthday and they nailed it! Made me a custom dessert and had us smiling the whole time. It's a beautiful and cozy place, you will love it, too! read more

See all

Food was great and the service also great! Best restaurant n Pinetop, we ave been going there for a long time! read more

​How was the food? We'll never know​! We were a party of six and called ahead for a reservation, but our call was never returned. Deciding to give it a try anyway, we arrived at 4:30 p.m. and were third in line, waiting in the hot sun for the 5:00 p.m. opening. When the doors opened, we were told that of their 11 tables, the only one available was a table for four. The remaining tables had been reserved for parties of five or more. No alternative was offered--not even a later seating, assuming one existed. We left and went to El Charro Beer instead, where we were promptly seated despite having no reservation. We enjoyed excellent service, drinks, appetizers, entrees, desserts, and coffee--all for roughly one-third to one-half the cost per person of a single entree at The Pasta House. Based on customer service and reservation management alone, we won't be returning to The Pasta House. read more

Fire Trish!!!! Let's starts with the restaurant. Absolutely amazing. Food....delicious. Trish is the mother of the manager....this may be their restaurant. Trisha was the worst server I've had in a very long time. She took our order and never returned. The rest of the staff was amazing. If this place is run by family then Trish can apparently do whatever she wants. I'm not spending my money here again as long as Trish is there. read more

Pasta House is a charming little restaurant in Pinetop! Service was friendly and attentive. Entrees come with light, flavorful garlic bread. Everyone in my party of 7 enjoyed their meals. I had the scallop special with garlic linguini. Scallops were buttery and perfectly cooked. Noodles had a nice spoonful of sliced roasted garlic on them. Very yummy! My boyfriend got chicken parmesan which was juicy and flavorful. Ended the meal with a FANTASTIC homemade tiramisu. Overall very happy with my meal here read more

Pasta House - Garlic Bread - Italian Near Me - Pinetop, Arizona

See all

Family owned and they take pride in their service and food. Which Is excellent! Loved the lobster ravoli and the pasta is fresh. Great bread, nice wine selection, good service. read more

Nice ambience and staff were pleasant. Food left much to be desired. The pesto pizza was a bobli crust from the supermarket with a pile of melted cheese. Pesto sauce was nonexistent. Prices were outrageous for that quality. Gnocchi and fettuccine were adequate but don't be fooled by the upscale look to the place. read more

Pasta House is a Pinetop favorite! Owners and staff are great. Food has never disappointed and we've probably tried half the menu! They offer a filet most nights that is spot on! read more

Let me say Wow! If you love pasta, steak and seafood then you have to try this place. Not only all their sauces are made in- house but so are all their pasta. The pasta was so good, definitely can tell it's homemade. Just has a different texture and beautiful taste. They have a great selection of wines and cocktails. They start you out with some warm savory garlic bread. It's a small cute place in a home setup. Feels like a homey family feel and the staff are so friendly and service was spectacular. I will definitely come back. For dessert we got the Banana Foster (to die for) and the crème Brûlée. I have not one negative or improvement to add. read more

See all

The pasta was phenomenal, and that is what truly carries this review. I got the chicken fettuccine Alfredo, and my fiancée got the aglio. It was delish. The Alfredo sauce is real authentic -- don't expect the garlic of an Olive Garden sauce. The aglio had a large amount of fresh garlic, which we were very pleased with. They serve free garlic bread at the table that was warm, soft and flavorful. We requested olive oil and balsamic, and that wish was granted. We tried the tiramisu for dessert, and my partner, who's Italian was a little underwhelmed, but it was tasty. My partner had a strong lemon drop martini that she gave 3/5 stars bc she likes hers sugary. But if you like strong alcohol taste she'd say 5/5. We waited an hour and 45 minutes for a table but it was New Year's Eve. It is a smaller place -- a cute house -- so call and make a reservation. The staff, with one exception, was very kind and warm and accommodating. We were happy with their service! The older woman on staff made a rude comment while we were waiting for a table, that the other staff members were quick to correct. Kudos to them for their hospitality. When seated, the older woman had warm conversation with every table but ours -- could just be that we're "out of towners". We have a cabin here, and will be back, so maybe next time the vibe will switch up and we'll earn her warmth. read more

See all

Staff is efficient, friendly and work as a team! The service was top notch. Seating is limited and they don't take reservations, unless there are five or more in your party. Be there by 4:45 if you want to be seated at 5:00 when they open, or your name will go on a wait list. The restaurant is not real big so it might get loud as the tables are pretty close together. The food is delicious, loved the Pomodora, great sauce. The steak special was perfectly prepared. Cocktails were fun. read more

Pasta House - Gorgonzola filet mignon house special, not on the menu - Italian Near Me - Pinetop, Arizona

See all

OMG!!! If I could give 10* I would! Absolutely amazing...ambiance, service, food, drinks & desserts, ALL OF IT!! We're only in town for 2 nights but I have a feeling we'll be back tomorrow night! There weren't many restaurants open on a Tuesday night and boy am I glad because that led us here! My husband got the sausage/spaghetti combo & I got the Ziti, both were sooo good! Large portions to have leftovers for lunch tomorrow. The house salad & the large portion of garlic bread was excellent! The martinis and Mexican Coffee were the best! I was so overwhelmed with the food quality that I couldn't decide between my three favorite desserts so we ordered the creme brûlée to eat now, OMG, the best we've ever had! We ordered a Tiramisu & Canolli for tomorrow I kid you not, as I'm an Elite Yelper, if you want Italian while you're in town, this is definitely a 10* fine dining place to come! Our server was Trace, he may be young but he presents himself with a lot of professionalism & yet very friendly! read more

See all

Pasta house is a little gem. Menu has many options.. we tried the squash ravioli for an app, Yum. Their house salads were fresh, and one step above your average HS. Everyone's pasta and chicken dishes were tasty and prepared perfectly. The comp garlic bread soft and tasty. And their version of Alfredo sauce was the Best I've ever had, (they put fresh herbs in it, and I don't order that sauce, there was some on the app. I travel A LOT, love finding good places to eat, and I will return to Pasta House when I have the chance. (It's a little spendy, but so worth it!) read more

This is a must try when in Pinetop. Delicious food and drinks with wonderful service. The veal parmigiana was excellent! Check this place out. read more

The Pasta House is the Best food in Pinetop- Lakeside! The owners are the second generation of locals. Brina is the best and her husband sure knows how to cook! It's our home a ay grom read more

Pasta house is amazing and the service is unlike anything I have ever experienced I highly recommend this place too anyone

Pasta House is HANDS down the best restaurant in Pinetop! The fact I've been here idk how many times with my husband for our anniversary dinner and I have zero pictures and have never reviewed it. I've had so many amazing dishes here, from shrimp to a basic Alfredo. The pink sauce here is so good I could drink it. Lol! The garlic bread, WOW. The best damn garlic bread that exists. I love that it's an old house and the dim lighting and table are always so cute. The service is hit or miss sometimes and my husband and I always think the cause is our age. We look fairly young comapred to the clientele that you see in there a mass majority of the time. We always see everyone chit chatting and so attentive to the older couples, but we kinda get left around for the most part. Nothing horrid of course, but something we've noticed in the past! We can't wait to come back next year! read more

This past weekend three couples went to the Pasta House and we could not have had a better meal or better service on the mountain! All three of the men in the group got the special of the scallops...my goodness...that was perfection. I got the pasta combo..Manacotti, stuffed shells and lasagna and the other women got chicken marsala and eggplant parmesan. We all got the ceasar salad, which was a slight upcharge but so worth it! Our wait staff included the following..Trish, Bella, Kyri,Trace, and Brynna. You may ask...why so many staff coming to our table. Well, they all just work so well together and they keep their eyes on EVERY TABLE in the restaraunt so no one is really waiting for anything. What a tremendous team! We highly recommend The Pasta House. Again, the BEST restaurant on the mountain and certainly the most pleasant wait staff you could ever ask for! read more

What an amazing find. My only complaint about this place was our server. She was an older gal but the rest of the staff was amazing. Now youbknow that if you plan on eating here there will be a wait. Its got a small, homey, cozy vibe, So the wait is worth it. Started with the stuffed eggplant. My goodness if your a ricotta lover, this is your dish. The tomato sauce is so incredibly well balanced and paired with creamy ricotta and topped with melted mozzarella cheese you cant go wrong. chicken piccata was so zesty and full of flavors. I'm so impressed by this little place that had amazing good read more

The Pasta House is an intimate place to have delicious Italian food. My husband likes veal and his favorite at The Pasta House is the veal saltimbocca. Service is excellent and we look forward to being greeted by the staff. read more

Open at 5pm. Some of the best Italian food I have ever had. Friendly, smiling service with nice decor. Couldn't ask for better.

Food was awesome!! The side salad was excellent, and the pizza was just right. Staff was friendly and attentive. They did an excellent job with the ambiance as well. 5 stars, without a doubt!! read more

Pasta House - The Little Bronx Pizza (7 inch) - Italian Near Me - Pinetop, Arizona

It was very disheartening that our family of five was not able to be served when another group of five walked out right in front of our eyes. Not sure what the issue was but it didn't feel right. read more

Service was great Food was great Great place for a date and nicer dining. Table cloth and cloth napkins. Still good for casual dress I would go back and i would order the same again. Eggplant rollatini - house salad Chicken Marsala -Caesar salad read more

I came here while visiting showlow, and this was probably my least favorite meal. Walking in, I love the cozy house vibe... but a lot seemed to fall short from there. The bread seemed to lack flavor and was cold (maybe supposed to be that way?). I ordered Alfredo as a side to maybe having something hit opposing the cold bread and felt the same, it was thin with a lot of flavor to be desired. For a meal, my friend and I split the bolognese. I'd say we ate under half of it. I'm not sure what it was but definitely wouldn't call it a traditional bolognese which I should have come to that conclusion when you could choose with or without meat. It wasn't bad but just definitely wasn't what I was wanting or expecting. Overall, this isn't a place I would want to return to. read more

We have eaten there in the past and really enjoyed our meal. But the last time we were there the pasta sauce was very spicey. It tasted like red pepper flakes were dumped in it. I mentioned it to our server and all she did was offer us to make another selection. I would not order pasta with red sauce again. read more

Amazing food and service We've been going here for years! It's a must when you're in the mountains! They desperately need to change their reservation policy The "five or more" need to be there at 5 o'clock and all parties present or they lose their table. We sat down last time and two different parties sat down at two different tables set for six. Only four members of their party were present. The restaurant had to turn away two other parties of two. After a half hour, and the folks of both the tables of four have their cocktails, they tell the staff that unfortunately their fifth person was not going to be able to join them. It was a scam by both of the parties. I hope Brenna is onto this!!! read more

First time eating here. Food was excellent. I had the chicken piccata and my husband had the special, Filet with Gorgonzola cream sauce. The meat was like butter it was so tender. My chicken piccata, well, let's just say I ate it all! Good wine menu. The cheese cake with raspberry mango sauce was excellent as well. We loved the background music as it added to the ambience. We will be back next time we visit anywhere in the area. read more

This is the wife and I's favorite restaurant in the mountains. We get the lobster ravioli to start every time and they have the BEST Alfredo sauce anywhere. Wife's go-to is the Pasta House Combo and I have had numerous things here I love. Try the torte or the crème brûlée for dessert. Cannot beat the atmosphere or the waitstaff here. We absolutely adore it read more

Went there with my sons for dinner. The place has great service. We had one primary server but we had three people in total when it comes to counting everyone that kept refilling our drinks and bread. Seriously great little gem in pinetop-lakeside. I forgot to mention, the food was outstanding. The parking is a bit odd but don't let that turn you away, it is worth it read more

The best thing about our visit was the service. There were many different people helping and they were all 100% professional. The place is too tight to move around easily and tables were wayyyyyyy too close. We could hear everyone's conversations, and the large groups didn't care how loud they talked. We sat in a very small area and should have requested to move. The food was good. Average. Red Devil is your place for Italian food in the area. Probably will not return. read more

We thought it was ok. The servers and service were amazing. There wasn't anything wrong with the food, but it was super hot (like scalding). Their bread is amazing! I ordered a wine and I thought it was really good. $8 a glass, and when I went to find it at the store, it was $10/bottle . Guess it wasn't as fancy as I thought. Parking is nuts, like everywhere up here. There aren't many tables, so be prepared to wait if you go after 6! read more