Passalinqua's Pizzeria GOOD: cheese and toppings are flavorful, fair prices if you avoid premium pies BAD: wet noodle crust and store logistics - line back ups, no paper receipts offered I wanted to like PP as most of the reviews were glowing. The toppings and cheese were flavorful (can't go wrong with a greasy meat meat combo). The price is reasonable on a per size and per topping basis. Unfortunately, a good stiff crust is nearly half of quality pizza. The middle-bottom portion sags immediately and you need two steady hands to catch the toppings. Aside from the crust, there is one register and operator, so on a busy take out night, one chatty customer phone call handcuffs the entire takeout operation. They need two registers to alleviate the take out pressure in case of a phone order (or write the phone order and allow someone else to process take out orders). Finally, I was forced to take a email or text receipt. Basic business operation should consist of offering a paper receipt. Older folks, buying for someone else, expensing meals all work better with paper receipts. I only hope their printer was broken. If your local, give them a try, but it's probably not worth a long drive East. read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - 12" with bacon and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

We were staying in Erie with family after a fun day at Splash Lagoon and needed something quick and satisfying--Passalinqua's Pizza came through big time. We ordered two large pizzas and it was more than enough to feed the whole crew. The service was top notch--friendly, fast, and they made us feel welcome even though we were out-of-towners. The pizza was delicious, with a perfect crust and generous toppings. Definitely a clutch find when you need a reliable, tasty bite in Erie! read more

See all

Pizza is absolutely delicious! I order on a regular basis. My favorite in town! Great flavor with fresh ingredients and they don't skimp on the toppings! Very friendly staff! read more

I have never had anything subpar at this place. Everything I've gotten has been absolutely delicious. I'm very picky when it comes to white pizzas. I even had a couple pieces left over and use the air fryer two days later to warm it up and it was like I had just ordered it. I've never had a bad experience with their service. The smells and flavor remind me of an Italian kitchen. My second favorite item is the chicken Parm and then the pasta meatballs. read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - White Pizza with Extra Cheese, Mushrooms, Bacon, and Banana Peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Got a supreme pizza. Nice crust with a good char on the bottom but still a bit soft and flexible. The toppings were good. Sauce was decent but a bit on the bland side. maybe a little salt needed. They say it's homemade so that's a plus. Others have mentioned the cheese and I'd say I agree. The cheese gets a bit nasty once the pizza cools off a bit. Not sure what kind they use. I'll go back and give them another shot. They seem eager to do a good job so I'll try again and update the review. read more

Definitely top 5 in Erie... Never had a bad meal. Variety of dishes will please your palate. read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - Garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Food is ok. I think slightly overrated honestly. Pizza was super greasy and cheese seemed really salty. Breadsticks were huge and delicious. Pasta was cooked well, sauce wasn't too bad. Meatballs reminded me of bigger versions of store bought freezer meatballs. Staff was polite when I asked for a change to a dish when ordering. I'd try them again in hopes that maybe it was an off day. read more

We ordered a pizza and when it was delivered it was a big sloppy undercooked mess of mush! Who sends out a pizza that bad honestly they should be ashamed ! Floppy mess of disgust !! read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

I love food. I have a few ultimate favorite foods like Max and Erma's tortilla soup, my mom's noodles and stuffing, Keytone Pub's buffalo chicken salad, Chic-Fil-A chicken nugs, and some more. The best pizza I have ever had is at the Marina Pizzeria in Atlantis Bahamas. Today.changed.everything. Not only is it the best pizza I've ever had, it's the best food I've ever had. I've never tasted anything better in my entire life. Y'all ever just want to lock yourself in a room and eat something alone in silence to be as disgusting and vulgar as you want and close your eyes and experience nothing but that food??? I need a hotel room with this pizza. We're going to have to come here once a week to get 10 pizzas to bring home. This is Passalinquas Pizzeria and their Spitz-I-Ano is nothing I've ever tasted. Ricotta cheese, spices, hot honey and their own ranch drizzle (which is more like a delicious ranch paste) We also got plain cheese and my husband ate the crust!!! He never eats the crust. I will never get over this pizza. read more

iIordered 2 supreme 10" gluten free pizzas and add banana peppers. They charged me for each vegetable @ $3 per topping on both pizzas for a total of $40 for 2 10" pizzas that I had to re-cook because they were very soggy! I nor my company will ever order there again!! Ridiculous! read more

Friendly staff. Delicious pizzas!! Perfect amount of toppings - the meat sweats was fully loaded! This was our first time trying and we will definitely be back!! read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - Spitz-I-Ano - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

We love the pizza - tried an Italian sub for a change. We like pizza sauce on a sub which is a New England thing. The bread was stellar. A dark crispy crust and just enough bread to compliment the high quality meat and provolone. The lettuce and tomatoes were fresh. We also tried meatballs in sauce. It's an A+ Plenty of seasoning and parm, maybe Romano cheese. I believe the marinara is long cooked as it is more of a Sunday gravy, reminiscent of Serafinis, but better. I may never make sauce again. Job well done. read more

Pizza was super middle of the road. I thought the crust was actually pretty delicious, but couldn't get past just how greasy it all was. They also use a different cheese blend than what you may be expecting, so I was really off put by it. Shame to say, but it's just premium Dominos. After not even finishing half the pizza, I became quite nauseous and you know the rest. Erie just isn't a great place to get pizza. read more

Tried this place for the first time yesterday. Let me just say it starts with their people. They genuinely seemed happy to have us. The food is outstanding. But be warned, if you prefer the average "cookie-cutter" pie, this place is not for you. Authentic pizza has a little char to it, you want that crisp crunch. We seat in their new dining room and is exactly how it should be. TV's, cloth table settings, just a nice fresh look. If you're on the west side get to the old Hills plaza on38th St. and discover your new favorite place to get pizza. read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - 16 inch Cheese & Pep - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Easily the best pizza in Erie. Very much New York style if that's what you're looking for.

Ordered a cheese & pepperoni. Great pizza, great chewy crust, good tasting cheese, but didn't care for the spicy curled pepperoni. Good service tho, and really enjoyed the ranch. I assume it was homemade due to the extra dill flavor! I'd say the best pizza in Millcreek area read more

Passalinqua's Pizzeria - Cheese add pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Outstanding pizza is an understatement! Fresh dough, fresh pepperoni, fresh ingredients, not Papa John's, lol I would definitely recommend this business to all of my friends and family. If you haven't tried it you're missing out. Also, I love when I bite into the cheese and pepperoni pizza. I can taste the ingredients. You can taste basil. You can taste the tomato sauce and it's so so good. Definitely have to make it a priority to try this pizza! Nice guys too. See you next time, gentlemen! They will make your pepperoni curl!!!! read more

On business here in Erie from out of town and I saw the great reviews for this place. Definitely lived up to the hype!! Italian hoagie sandwich --the bomb! Supreme pizza--amazing! Appetizer meatball--delicious! Give it a try....! read more

Excellent service. Got pizza and side salad. First time there. No complaints. Pizza was delicious. Salad had more dark green lettuce than I expected. read more

Solid food nice little area in the back to eat and pretty good staff. Vibe of the place felt awesome. Pretty good prices and size of food. Recommend read more

First of all, the bread was delicious. As fresh as fresh bread can be. Secondly, the staff was so friendly. And finally, the food, the food, the food. Delicious!!! Really good Italian food. The red sauce is the best. The portions are gigantic. You will not be disappointed by going here to eat. Dining room is a bit small, but some would call it intimate. The Sinatra playing in the background was a nice touch. Make it a point to try this place out. We will be back. read more

I decided to try this newer pizza place and was happy with the experience. The staff was welcoming! The pizza was outstanding. The garlic dough was delicious. I also got a piece of ricotta cheesecake with chocolate ganache and candied orange peel. Such a great treat! If you are looking for a new pizza experience give Passalinqua'a a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

I personally didn't like the pizza, the sauce was to spicy for me. So I probably wouldn't order again, plus ur only open a few hours. But was very friendly when I was there, just didn't prefer the pizza. read more

Being from Boston and all, I'm very very picky about my pizza. I was passing through Erie PA and I came across this place that I have to say got a 9 1/2 out of 10 from me. Great Pizza great atmosphere great everything about it A+ in my book keep it up guys. I'll be back. read more