This store is so unique! Now slow down once you cross over Olentangy it is in the cut on the left…read more They have everything. Came in for a last minute mask and the were a lot of choices.

They were a huge help with a Santa costume I needed to get on short order. Lots of options at many…read moredifferent prices!

Just wanted to add a picture of the outfits we got! We got so many compliments and since they are…read morereal clothes they were comfortable and sturdy.

LEAVE PEOPLE ALONE UNLESS THEY ASK FOR YOUR HELP…read more The worst customer service I've experienced in awhile. To save yourself the headache just shop online. You'll get new and better quality items for CHEAPER and without the headache of the staff. You could go to the Renaissance Faire and get better prices and customer service. Just because you have a "unique" store for the area doesn't mean it'll be successful. Listen to your customer base and fix your pricing and STFU and leave us alone so we can shop. You literally drove numerous customers away to include my Wife. This could be a great store but I foresee it closing in the future. The way it's being ran, they seem desperate not to go out of business already.

It seems I end up here every other year to pick up some Halloween costume thing I need. It's been…read morecostumes, nail polish, and accessories. They have costumes for men, women, children, and dogs. Inventory includes wigs, jewelry, accessories and decorations. Each visit brings improvements. For example, they now have dressing rooms so you can make sure the costume fits okay. The employees are usually in costume so you can tell them apart from the clientele. They have been very helpful in pointing out where items can be found.

If there were such a thing as 'extra full price' that would be what this place charges. 39.99 for…read morethe same costume that I can get for 19.99 at target. It's very much a warehouse experience and not in a clean and tidy way. We were in and out in just a few minutes.

Above and beyond!! I was so impressed with how wonderful Belle (Elly) was with the kids - so sweet…read moreand patient. We had 22 kids - ages 15 months to 8 years, so definitely not easy to manage, but she did...and made sure to keep the attention on the birthday girl while not totally ignoring the others. She sang a song, painted faces, read a book and helped us sing happy birthday all in an hour, but none of it felt rushed at all. They were so easy to work with during the planning process - responsive, detail oriented and simply very nice. We will definitely be recommending PPP to all of our friends!

Our princess was wonderful. She was poised and handled the group of girls ages 3-8 remarkably well…read more She ran the entire party! I didn't have to do a thing! She had an amazing voice and sang several songs. She was intentional to include the birthday girl throughout her time. Everyone was in awe. Thanks to our Cinderella (Grayson) for making it a truly special 5th birthday for our little girl.

Mike was great! He has a huge selection of all types of uniforms, and is well versed in the sizing…read morefor each. He was able to quickly determine what size would fit me best for scrubs. He is very enthusiastic and is great to talk with. 10/10.

Mike is always so helpful . I have been coming here for six years for my scrubs and embroidery…read more They always have a huge selection and are very accommodating!

They have a great assortment of clothing for all sizes, for both males and females. Melissa who…read moreworks there is a sweetheart and very helpful. The ambiance is delightful.

The Alternative Shop on Fifth Avenue shows promise. It has a dense selection of used threads at…read moregood prices...including a large selection of rad-looking men's suit jackets (and men's clothing in general). Sadly, the thrift store is in the midst of a constant identity crisis. Is it a shoe repair shop? Is it a place to buy used wedding dresses? Is it a thrift store? It's all a little confusing. Also, there is so much stuff crammed into the tiny shop, it is tough to make sense of it all. All that being said, this is still an essential stop on the Fifth Avenue thrift shop hop.