First, I gotta air some grievances.
We almost gave up on trying to find this place. In daylight I am sure it is easier, but this was pitch dark with no moon, and it's not in town where there are street lamps. There are more ruralish residences nearby, so it's just plain weird to find it in the dark. We had to stop at the Aldi grocery store nearby to get help in Spanish from the checker. Mind you, I am doing this in Spanish, so her explanation about driving through a cemetery to get there made me question my fluency. Sure enough, you turn into a cemetery, and just as you go up the drive for it, there is a dirt road veering off to the left, that looks like a service road for the groundskeeper. Anyway, follow that (it gets REALLY bumpy) and Las Tinajas eventually shows up with neon lights. I had read reviews explaining it's tricky to find, but seriously, in the pitch dark... glad I knew Spanish or we'd have had to eat at Mac-Do (as the French say).
Also, I had read that in most Portuguese restaurants they charge for the bread / oil / olives / butter on the table, but this was never my experience in Spain, and nowhere else in Spain did we encounter it on our bill... except at Parrilla Venta Las Tinajas. So beware. It was not explained to us, despite my communication in Spanish. Not a huge fee, but definitely unexpected. The bread was ripped apart by hand too, so if you're gonna charge for it, at least make it look nice.
I am not generally a fan of Iberian steaks. Spanish steak is not the same as American beef. It is cut more thin, typically it's cooked pretty well done (and they don't ask temp), and it has a lighter flavor, IMO, than American steak. BUT, this was touted in reviews for ox, and other dishes, which all were authentic to Andalucia, so I wanted to experience it.
So, as mentioned by others, the patatas with garlic sauce were complimentary, and tasted great as a starter. There were 90-some options for entrees on the menu (not a tapas place). My husband got the ox tenderloin with black pepper sauce, and thought it was 5 stars. I got lamb chops and they were not for me at all, overdone and really gamey tasting. My husband ate most of them. The Yelp photos of protein and TWO starches, with no veg, on every plate reminded me of my hs trip through Andalucia, and as far as my experience, this IS typical Spanish roadhouse cooking. While tapas are the star of this region's cuisine, the rustic meat-n-potatoes dish is equally authentic. I definitely would have appreciated some veggies, though, but note that just isn't the style of this place, and it is what it is.
I will say the flan was great, and they added complimentary digestivos, which was a nice end to the meal.
As others have mentioned, there is indoor / outdoor seating. We were there in the off-season so we ate inside. I would definitely have preferred being outside, as the interior was definitely authentic for contemporary Spanish roadhouses, but not super cheerful.
This place seems to cater somewhat to Americans. They fly an American flag outside, alongside the Spanish, Cadiz, and EU flags. You can see all the American reviews, and there was a party of about 6 Americans adults there (the only other customers for our late dinner). I am guessing they were naval service members, because they were completely casual there, as though they'd been a million times. So, it appears this is kind of an American spot in Rota, among others.
* * * TIP * * *
Closed on Mondays.
* * * TIP * * *
Tipping in Spain is optional but much appreciated. We gave them 20% and had to ask them to add it to our c-card on the bill. Since it was our first night, I asked (in Spanish) if the tip was okay, and they shrugged, ho-hum, saying "it's normal" (in Spanish). Hmmm. Maybe the American population has them used to it? Afterwards, we had a lot of feedback at all other restaurants, and they were overjoyed to get 20%, so IDK what the deal was, here. I say, do what you feel is deserved. Remember that the economy in Spain is not the best right now, and unemployment is really high, so in general, it's probably very appreciated. read more