Ordered a pizza and a gyros sandwich for delivery they said 730 it will arrive called at 755 and…read moreasked where are order is Finley got here cold pizza forgot the sauce for gyros and cold pizza complained told me 2 dollars off next order sandwich you can't eat and cold pizza never again

This place was great! We were visiting Brookings. Stopped in here and immediately it smelled like…read morean old fashion pizza restaurant! It's a little old, but really cute and comfortable! Clean as well. The staff was great! We ordered a thin crust, large deluxe, and the crust was just right! Not cracker-thin! And the toppings were dispersed, beautifully, and just plain delicious! Good cold, beer too!

Traveling on business, decided to give this place a try and was pleasantly surprised, this is great…read morepizza. Reasonably priced, fresh ingredients, great flavor. If I was local I would be a regular. Place is cash only so be prepared.

It's been the best pizza since the 1970's. Whenever I return to Brookings it's a date almost every…read morenight. Just delicious!

I was so happy to see a brewery downtown in Brookings. The bartender was really nice and helped me…read morepick a light beer to drink. I ended up staying for a couple of hours which was really nice they allowed that. Would highly recommend and definitely go back!

We went there after a soccer event Food and service was…read morevery good Nice and clean and everyone in our group, like it

I ordered a Chicken Alfredo Pizza with mushrooms- Spinach- onions- Olives- Garlic and it was…read moreExcellent and Stuffed Crust. I would Definitely order another Pizza again and my wife had macaroni with Chicken Both Orders were Great.

A lot of the reviews are from years ago, this past year I've eaten from here more then I would like…read moreto admit do to its locational convince. Generally I have not had an issue with my order except once with a very complicated one that was compensated for. The pizza is always hot, and decent. The service ranges from friendly to slightly indifferent. I have had 2 or 3 orders with near hour+ waits that some of the reviews have warned about, but it is not a regular thing by any means.

New in town and trying a variety of places, learning what the area has to offer and DVD's pizza is…read morelegit!! Artisan pizza, local brews, and great service!! Staff was informative and patient with a newbie. Had the Georgia Aloha on this visit and it was GREAT! For those who don't believe pineapple belongs on pizza, try this and revisit your thought process. This pizza was sweet, brought the heat, deep flavors and a great crust!! Will be adding this to my regular rotation. Paired with a pint of Banshee made this meal complete. Seating is limited, large party's wouldn't work but great for a family of 4, date night or going solo.

I am still trying to get over the disappointment I went through from hearing Brookings was getting…read morea Dempsey's to finding out it was a only a Dempsey's junior with a very limited menu. This is not the Watertown version of Dempsey's, which is utterly amazing. This is the college town pizza-only version where they make pretty good pizza at higher prices then their competition, and there is a lot of competition in Brookings. We placed our one order and were overall satisfied but not enough to give up our regular pizza place (George's). Maybe someday they will expand the menu and we will give it another chance, or we'll just drive to Watertown.

I ordered chicken wings and they were good and so were the fries. The waiter was okay. You could…read moresmell the pool water from the hotel by it.

Bartender was fine. She did all she could do. We were the first to order from a big post concert…read morerush. Here's my thought, we waited 1.25 hours on "one cook" but never smelled any food cooking. I don't think there was anyone there cooking. 1.5 hours in we finally got our pizzas after others got their wings and cheesy bread after "the second cook came in". Either way, would not recommend. We like Boss's in SF, and it's great for late night but eating our supper at this location at 1:06am is pretty ridiculous.

Sorry to say that the deep fried appetizers, onion rings and mini corn dogs, looked burnt and…read moredidn't taste good. I sent them back and they came out just as bad. One cost $7 and the other one $8. After that I changed my mind and did not order an entree. I had to go back on my word that I was taking my grandson out for lunch. The place could have been a whole lot cleaner. I wouldn't say it was filthy but I wouldn't say it was clean. The menus were actually sticky and had food and gunk stuck to them. The waitress was perky and friendly and running around doing her best to keep everyone attended to. When I told her that the food she brought out was subpar and I wasn't happy with it, she said that it was fine but she would get me replacements. It was moments later she came back with food that looked exactly the same. I told her that I wasn't convinced it wasn't the same food... I swear it was just a burnt as burnt looking as before but it turned out she was right. This time the mini corn dogs were burnt on the outside and still frozen in the middle. My son-in-law, the chef, tells me that it was because the oil was old and rancid. Apparently this gives all food the appearance of being burnt with a bad taste. What I didn't appreciate was that I was asked to pay for food that anybody would have raised an eyebrow at and treated like I was the problem. The cook even came out of the kitchen and tried to nonchalantly check out who I was. When I met her I she gave me a dirty look and marched back off into the kitchen. Not recommended. I won't ever go back. If they don't know enough to know that they're serving people bad food or have the professionalism to own up to it when they have, then I have no time for them.

Poor acoustics make the place very loud even if it's only 1/3 full. Food is fine they have a few…read morespecialty burgers. Typical bar food. Outside seating is small but cozy, you can watch folks go by on the bike trail.

Great service! Friendly staff! Burgers are simply delicious no bells and whistles needed this place…read morethe food stands alone and stands out.

Great customer service great hamburgers recommend to anybody that lives in Brookings or Sioux Falls…read moreor anywhere in South Dakota

I've never had a bad experience with Papa John's here in Brookings. The food is always of perfect…read morequality, and that's too be expected, due to the high prices of their items. Their delivery drivers are very pleasant to do business with as well and I appreciate that very much! We placed an order for $227.19 through web order. We got a call from the manager stating that they were not prepared for such a large order at this time of day (mid afternoon) and told us it would be closer to 45 minutes to an hour. We were just fine with that, as we understood that our enormous order would be a lot of work. However, to our surprise, our food came in less time than estimated and everything was absolutely perfect! I'm only giving them 4 stars, because I believe that the online web ordering should provide customers the option to add extra sauces. I like to have my own sauce, rather than having a bunch of people share the very few sauces that come with the items. That brings the risk of sharing germs. Yuck lol! Everything else is excellent!

Tried to order via the website on my wife's iPhone using the Brave (Chrome variant) browser. When I…read morewent to place the order, I got a cartoon of a man throwing water on a brick pizza oven with the message "OH NO! Looks like we left this page in the oven too long." I thought maybe i needed to be a reward member so I joined and tried the order again. Same message. Next I thought that maybe Brave wasn't accepting a tracking cookie so I tried Safari. Still same message. Finally I placed the order on my Samsung. It went through with no problems. This took 25 minutes from when I started until finally placing the order and required stopping our trip to complete. $30 for a large single topping pizza and a Philly Sub is outrageous. PLUS, the Philly hardly had any meat OR cheese on it. I guess it's a Philly Cheese Steak lite. I can get the sandwich at Jimmy Johns with twice as much meat for $8 and a large Pepperoni pizza at Pizza Ranch for $15. As far as Ambiance, there is none as this is carry out.