I visit Big Olaf's strictly for the nostalgia - it's where I lost a tooth as a kid eating ice…read morecream, after all! But after returning years later, it's unfortunately lacking. Though advertised as homemade ice cream, their product seems to come from a company called Yoders. Disappointing, but the ice cream was still tasty. The Kahlua ice cream had great flavor and I'm a sucker for unique flavors. The price point isn't all that bad either, which Ben & Jerry's walking distance away charging 3x more, it makes this treat a steal. The ice cream itself could be a bit fresher, as it tasted freezer burnt. The staff here could also be a bit friendlier. Overall, Big Olaf's isn't what I remember it being, but if you're looking for a cheap scoop when walking around St Armands it is worth a visit.

We were excited to try Big Olaf's, but we walked in to find a store that could definitely do with…read moresome updates. The man behind the counter was responsive but not terribly friendly. Of course the ice cream was still good--it's ice cream!!--but some of it seemed a little stale/crystallized, like it hadn't turned over in a while. The tables were small and chairs could have been cute, but their metal seemed rusty and the tables were obviously in need of replacing. As we ate our ice cream (mint chip, pistachio, my daughter had cheesecake and my husband had white chocolate raspberry, his favorite), I looked at the billboard behind them... There were old cartoons probably cut out 15+ years ago, and an ancient map of St. Armand's circle. The cartoons and map had drips of ice cream on them and were faded and torn. There was a fun fact about ice cream...from 1999. We might have caught them on an off day, but I was not impressed. They're also "cash only" and had a faded picture of George Bush and a Charlie Kirk hat on display... Overall, they need to do a deep clean, refresh their decor and perhaps implement some payment technology to join us in 2026.

Best 'key lime' cream ice cream experience EVER! You've GOT to try it. AND the sea salt caramel!…read more Just WOW!

We dropped in a few nights ago for something sweet after going to dinner nearby. It was a miss for…read moreus. The waffle cone wasn't great, wasn't fresh, was soft and was soggy. Ice cream is just your average ice cream from a tub.

Amazing place . Highly recommended . Great atmosphere and…read moredelicious sweets. Glad to stop by when I am in the area

Crepetopia is one of those hidden gems in the Meadows that you could easily miss if you're not…read morelooking for it--it's not the easiest spot to see from the road, but it's absolutely worth finding. The shop is run by the owner and his family, and that personal touch really comes through in the service. They're warm, welcoming, and genuinely care about making sure you have a great experience. The dessert selection is outstanding. From gourmet crepes to cakes, macarons, brownies, and plenty of other sweet treats, there's something for every craving--and everything I've tried has been delicious. It's the kind of place where you want to sample a little bit of everything. I've made it a habit to stop by whenever I'm in the area after dinner. It's the perfect way to cap off a night out, and it never disappoints.

We LOVE Sweet Melissa's! Awesome ice cream. Friendly staff. I wish they stayed open 30 minutes…read morelonger.

My niece said we must try Sweet Melissa when we visited. So glad we did. It was so amazing…read more Everyone loved the ice cream we had and the owners were so nice and appreciative. I had The most delicious peanut butter ice cream. Triple peanut was the best. My brother in law loved his snickers. The kids loved the vanilla. My mom loved her chocolate brownie ice cream. My sister in law loved her sorbet. Everyone loved it. Soooooo good! Definitely try it.

After a filling Turkish meal in the Gulfgate area, South Sarasota,we wanted something for dessert…read more We focused on gelato and walked in. The owner could not have been nicer and gave samples to try his offerings. The gelato is rich, creamy and delicious with some alcohol mixed in. I had a combo and loved every spoonful.(wish I could remember my combo) Flavors change periodically.

I stopped by for the first time after seeing this place on Yelp. The gelato itself wasn't bad and…read morereminded me of the style I saw in Florence, especially the way the gelato was displayed in the covered containers. The experience, however, could have been better. The employee did greet me when I walked in and let me sample a flavor before I made my choice, which I appreciated. However, he seemed to be in a rush, which made the experience feel less welcoming. I came hoping to try the tiramisu flavor because I had seen it on Yelp, but I was told it was only last week's flavor. I understand that flavors change and that they had just received a shipment, so not everything was available yet. I just wish there had been a little more guidance, such as letting first-time customers know where the current flavors are posted (I had to ask if they update them on Instagram). As a first-time customer, it would have been nice if he had asked whether I had visited before or explained how the rotating flavors work, instead of making me feel like I needed to quickly pick a flavor and move on. One other thing I noticed is that there isn't any seating inside. A few tables or chairs would make it a more enjoyable place to sit and enjoy the gelato. Overall, the gelato was good, and I appreciated being greeted and being able to sample a flavor before ordering. With a friendlier, more engaging customer experience and a few small improvements, I'd be more likely to return. *Thank you for your response. I believe there has been a misunderstanding, as the visit you described was not mine. I visited as a first-time customer and purchased two gelatos to go--one for myself and one for my husband. I sampled two flavor before ordering, which I appreciated. I also want to clarify that I never had a father with me, nor was I part of a group sampling every flavor. Because of that, I was surprised to read those comments in response to my review. My review was simply an honest account of my personal experience. I acknowledged the things I appreciated, including the greeting and being able to sample a flavor, while also sharing constructive feedback about feeling rushed and wishing there had been a little more guidance for first-time customers regarding the rotating flavors. I respect that every business receives feedback differently, and I wish you and your business continued success.

We LOVE Pomegranate. Everything is always fresh. Large variety of toppings. Great rotating flavors…read moreof yogurt, but the staples are our favorite. This is the place my kids always choose when we are celebrating big or small. The owners and staff are always kind. The store is always clean even when they are busy. We also, love that they support our local schools and youth sports. If I could give them 10 stars I would!

This frozen yogurt shop is a true community gem, boasting an impressive rotation of unique flavors…read morewhile keeping beloved classics available. The owner and staff's passion for excellence shines through in the store's spotless condition, reflecting their commitment to quality and community. It is well decorated and I love the fact that they have a sofa in the back for relaxing, especially if you're with a little group of people. There are also several tables and chair, chairs inside and a few outside for those nicer days. The owner's warm and engaging personality makes everyone feel welcome, and their dedication to hosting fundraising events is inspiring.

This is a very cute little gelato place with authentic handmade fresh flavors…read more They have fruit gelato, chocolate gelato, and a bunch of other different flavor flavors that are classic and a little bit more un unique. It's all fresh and can come in either a cup or a cone. They also serve cappuccinos, lattes, and espresso if you'd like. There's little seating, but it is offered indoor and outdoor.

Best gelato in town! Dark chocolate dairy free is amazing, Oreo is also SO GOOD!! Highly recommend…read moreyou checking it out!

Super yummy they allowed us to build our own rolled ice cream! They are also very nice and we are…read moreglad they were open until 9!

Neat stop for your ice cream fix. Spacious and bright, pleasant serving staff. A varied selection…read moreof ice specialties, Bobo teas, and many flavors of ice cream. Limited seating and take out service. Our ice cream was delicious and of high quality. Try them out.