Cancel

Open app

Search

On Second Thought

5.0 (1 review)

On Second Thought Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - On Second Thought

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Molly's Cobbler Shop - Cool little store - packed with stuff!

Molly's Cobbler Shop

(4 reviews)

The heel of an old boot came off because I am lazy, and used my other shoe to pry it off... instead…read moreof unlacing it and taking it off the right way. (My mother would have been pissed). I was mad because even though the boats were old, they were in great shape and most likely hard to replace. Instead of throwing them out, I took them to Molly's. It think I was charge $12 and he fixed both boots like brand new! So worth it. The shop is really cool. Smells like leather and shoe polish (in a good way) and even though the place was tiny... it was packed with a lot of neat stuff. I would say, stop in and walk around... but you literally only have to spin around to see the whole showroom! Owner was really friendly and he did a great job. Nice to support small, local businesses. Especially when they do a great service.

I told my wife I didn't have to wear pants. The sign says "please wear a mask, pants are…read moreoptional". Molly's is an old school business. Yes, the place smells of leather and oil. The place is small; but packed full of good stuff. Where else can you find mustache wax and beard oil? Need a hat or a Sheboygan t-shirt, here's where you can find you heart's desire. But the main attraction here is the owner. Kevin is a character right out of the 19th century. I call that a compliment as I am straight out of the same century. A century of individualism, hard work and honesty. My wife needed two pairs of boot repaired. Kevin did a fine job on both. Mind you Kevin is on island time. Be prepared to wait a week or more to get your job done. The job will be done perfectly; but if you're impatient or have entitlement issues you might want to go else where. In a consumption, throw away society this place makes a stand against wasting leather. I used to have a favorite leather conditioner called Lexol. Unfortunately it is no longer made. I asked Kevin what he had. He showed us several products and we picked the one he recommended. His expertise about treating and preserving leather was good enough for me. Kevin is a really nice guy who is genuinely glad to have you in his store. If you need any leather repair, leather products or some free advice, it would behoove you to stop in this unique little place. Get your favorite old boots repaired. Heck, you never know when you might need some mustache wax.

American Antiques & Jewelry

American Antiques & Jewelry

(32 reviews)

$$

I had the most wonderful experience picking up my jewelry today. From start to finish, the entire…read moreprocess felt thoughtful, professional, and genuinely welcoming. The staff made me feel valued and never rushed, and they took the time to walk me through each piece carefully. The craftsmanship is stunning -- every detail is exactly what I hoped for (if not better). You can truly tell they take pride in the quality of their work and the stones they select. Purchasing fine jewelry should feel special, and they absolutely delivered. I left feeling excited, confident, and already planning my next visit. Highly recommend!

We are currently talking to Katherine on hold, listening to her tell another employee that my wife…read moremade her so mad she wants to punch her. What did she do to deserve that customer service? My wife asked for an itemized receipt to explain additional newly added costs, they refused, then she asked for a refund, they refused. Katherine got aggravated and demeaning when asked to see my wife's point of view, and they went back and forth. No one yelled and nothing personal or rude was said. Katherine then agreed to a refund, put us on hold and went around the office telling people my wife was mean and screaming (she wasn't). I don't know if Katherine knew she was on speaker phone but we started recording because she was misrepresenting what happened. But then Katherine vented to a co-worker and threatened to punch my wife. We have it on recording in case of legal needs, but you might want to know the employees at this business are this unstable when asked for itemized invoices. I'm sure she made a mistake and was just defensive, but the way she emotionally escalated this was really inappropriate and then threatening. Not sure if they know they still have us on hold but now Katherine is talking to Bob in the background.

The Vintage Garden - From home and garden décor to chic, fashionable jewelry and accessories... we have a little mix of everything!

The Vintage Garden

(6 reviews)

$$

The store was really nice. Too bad the service there wasn't the best. The elderly man was SO rude…read more Didn't say hi. Didn't say anything as I complemented the store, didn't say anything while I made my purchase. I went back the next day to exchange a shirt and I asked the lady for an extra bag and told her I'd pay for it if it wasn't free and she made a big deal about it. Then she threw the bag at me after I purchased the other shirt. I will never spend my hard earned money there EVER again.

Make sure you understand the return policy thoroughly before making a purchase. I bought a Sherpa…read morepullover for my daughter here on Small Business Saturday, intending to give it as a Christmas gift. As a first time shopper, I asked about the return policy and was told it could be returned for in-store credit. The sleeves proved too short, so I tried to return the purchase today. Initially the cashier said there was a 10 day return policy on clothing and refused the return. I explained the information I had been given, but since it was seasonal, she would only make an exception to exchange it for the same clothing item. She referred me to the back of the price tag, which does explain the policy; but what I was verbally told was different. Well, a larger size doesn't have longer sleeves, but since I had no alternative, I made an exchange. I said that as a first time shopper, it didn't give me a good impression of the store. Nothing more was said. (BTW, the item is now on sale for 20% off vs my 10% discount. Bottom line, I thought this might become a store I would shop frequently, but now I will not return. I try to shop local, but with policies like this, it's no wonder larger stores are winning the retail race.

St Vincent Depaul Store

St Vincent Depaul Store

(8 reviews)

$$

St. Vincent DePaul Plymouth Wi store is amazing! The workers are very helpful! You never know what…read moreyou will find.

Today, I got my son a mattress and box spring at furniture store in Plymouth, Wisconsin…read more They were out of metal frames. Our sales person suggested we try the thrift store in the same strip mall. I found a twin/full metal frame that I wanted to buy. They were on the sales floor in a 55 gallon barrel with the top cut off. Before I could reach for it, I was told that I can't just free roam the furniture area. I saw other people (woman) looking, so I asked the woman why. She told me that fear people will switch tags. I informed her that I want to buy a twin/full metal bed frame. All the metal bed frames of that style were marked $25.00. In an effort to nice about it, I asked if she could call up the register. Then inform they it was $25. She wouldn't do that. I had to wait for a male employee to show up. He showed up 20 mins later. She watched me the entire top we waited. When he arrived, I told him I wanted to buy a twin/full bed frame. He looked at me funny. I was questioned as why I pick up it up, and take it to the register. My son pointed at the woman, and she unleashed hell on my 9 year old son. She used curse words and called us "tag switchers". In an effort to defend my son, I informed her all the ones of that style were $25. I suggested that cashiers knew they were all $25, and the woman unleashed hell on me. In an effort to avoid any further issue, I asked the male to walk us to the door of the store. I didn't want to give the woman the opportunity to say we stole something. As we walked to the door, the woman screamed at us at top of her lungs. When I saw the frames were $25, I was happy. The furniture store wanted $79.99. I would have gladly paid $25 for one. This woman thought I guilty of trying to switch tags, so I was automatically guilty. Not all white men are bad. Please, stop judging us!

On Second Thought - vintage - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...