Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Olde City

    4.4 (10 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Olde City Takeout or Delivery

    Olde City Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Olde City

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Cheesesteak with added pickle
    Tia K.

    We loved the cheesesteak! It was delicious with tons of meat. Their bread is great as well. Would definitely recommend. We ordered online and our order was ready on time. They're a small shop with most people picking up to go. They have a standing bar to eat at. We stayed to eat, and the man working was super nice and gave us extra napkins and hand wipes. I highly recommend them for a cheesesteak!

    Onion rings $13
    Vanessa A.

    I was excited to see them opening in the neighborhood since I'd been wanting to try their cheesesteaks. This location is a small take out spot. I ordered online and was quoted 20 minutes. My order was ready in about 10. I ordered a cheesesteak and onion rings (about $30 total). You get 8 onion rings for $13. These were my favorite. The onions were tender so they were easy to bite into. The breading was fairly thin but maybe too thin because a lot of it fell off. I got a cheesesteak with fried onions. I wish it was cheesier (and without having to pay for extra cheese). This might be a personal preference though. I can't say I loved it enough to go back soon. If I go back I'd want to try something else.

    JP P.

    Ordered the Italian hoagie, cheesesteak with whiz and sauteed mushrooms along with a side of fries. The hoagie ingredients were all fresh...they provide oil and vinegar on the side. Additionally, the cheesesteak hit the spot...the bread was soft and chewy and all the ingredients blended well together. Lastly, their fries are outstanding...crispy on the outside with a smooth texture inside. Bottom line, the service is fast and the food is tasty. Definitely a great addition to the UWS!

    Garlic Aioli Black Cherry Authentic Cheesesteak

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    22 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 11
    Thanks 6
    Love this 8
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Joanne N.
    0
    231
    16

    9 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Olde City

    Review Highlights - Olde City

    First, give us a "for here" option when ordering, so that we can get our sandwiches on paper plates instead of wrapped -- they get soggy even after a couple of minutes.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Cheesesteaks 9,713 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Three Monkeys

    The Three Monkeys

    4.2
    (1.5k reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$

    Step into the new 3 Monkeys, a tri-level playground of grit and glamour -- exposed brick that looks…read morelike it survived Prohibition, tin and copper ceiling tiles that wink under amber mood lighting, and a wooden bar polished by a thousand high-fives. Surrounding TVs keep every play, fight and miracle replayed in glorious surround-sass while wooden tables beg for pitchers, pretzels and conspiracy theories about the ref. Whether you're upstairs for the 3rd floor vibe, mid-level for the perfect sightline, or down in the cozy den with the best acoustics, this is New York sports bar energy: loud, a little brazen, impossibly welcoming. One particular bartender, Delaney not only brings an awesome level of energy to the bar, she saunters in like a halftime show -- a grin that's equal parts mischief and welcome. She's all quick elbows and quicker comebacks, the kind of bartender who remembers your name, your drink, and that one ridiculous story you told months ago. Her laugh is loud, her wink is devious, and she has a way of making first-timers feel like regulars by the second round. Behind the wooden bar she's choreography: expert pours, theatrical muddles, and a flourish that makes every order feel curated. Delaney's drinks are personality-packed, with her behind the bar, the place doesn't just serve drinks -- it gets its personality back. It's a place off 8th ave where fitness meets fun, and every corner feels like home--complete with friendly staff who know your name (or at least your size) and are always ready to offer a witty comeback or a perfect recommendation. Cheers!

    Came here for a Knicks game and really enjoyed the nachos and wings they had! The nachos had a lot…read moreof toppings on them, which is much appreciated as lots of sports bars will skimp on toppings. Taking off a star because I had a weird experience with the people at the front. I'm currently recovering from an injury and I'm in a pretty obvious neck brace. I was visiting with two people who were on their way and would be arriving in about 10-15 minutes and the people at the front told me I couldn't be seated until they arrived. I understand that this is normal protocol, but I pointed out my neck brace and asked if an exception could be made because it's significantly more comfortable for me to sit down (and there was no room at the bar). They said that their manager wouldn't let them do that, and that they couldn't seat me until the rest of my party was there. There were tons of table tables available the entire time and when my friend arrived about 12 minutes later, they seated us, I totally could've sat the whole time and it wouldn't have been a problem. Not the end of the world and I probably could've pushed it harder, but it definitely was a little awkward!

    Photos
    The atmosphere..10/10
    The atmosphere..10/10
    The Three Monkeys
    Buffalo Wings

    See all

    Buffalo Wings
    Haswell Green's

    Haswell Green's

    4.5
    (752 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Discounts available

    Haswell Green has one of the best brunches in the city, and it definitely has one of the best…read moreservices as well. I was genuinely surprised by how large the space was. Its location near the Theater District also makes it a great stop before or after catching a Broadway show. The vibe is dark and intimate. However, it is still lively with live music and Christmas lights setting the mood. Their cocktail menu is another highlight, offering plenty of creative options. During brunch, they have an artist playing live music. I just stopped by for a quick bite and ordered the chicken tenders. What a great and crispy comfort food. Most of their menu consists of fantastic comfort food. Whether you are heading to a Broadway show, craving some comfort food, or just wanting to listen to live music, Haswell Green is worth the visit.

    We visited this bar which was near our hotel while we were in town. Initially we weren't gonna go…read morein because we saw they had a cover charge but they were on their last set so the bouncer didn't charge us. Upon entering we immediately felt at ease and relaxed. It wasn't as crowded any more which was good because we just wanted to get one drink. We sat in the bar and just enjoyed the ambiance and checked out the band that was playing. After a couple of minutes we were given the drink menu. I got the lychee margarita and my cousin ordered the pink paloma and by far one of the best drinks I've had in awhile. I also enjoyed the company of our female bartender. She's very cool and very chill. This was honestly a perfect end to our night. Amazing drinks, amazing music and all in all amazing vibe.

    Photos
    Arancini
    Arancini
    Broccolini Pizza
    Broccolini Pizza
    Steak Frites

    See all

    Steak Frites
    Tanner Smiths

    Tanner Smiths

    4.3
    (2.4k reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    We had scored an awesome street parking spot and there was no way we were giving that up, so hubs…read moremade sure wherever we ate was within this area. We reserved for a quick bite at Redeye Grill before catching Dog Day Afternoon on Broadway, but as soon as we walked up, some bouncer told us they were closed for a private wedding reception. We were dazed and confused because how was I able to reserve online? But the real plot twist was that it ended up being the best thing that happened. We actually stumbled into Tanner Smith's thinking it'd be the typical, boring bar-food spot. Nope. They first sat us at a hi-top by the door, but that wasn't our vibe, so we grabbed seats at the bar instead. Best decision. Our bartender, Josiah, was absolutely killing it. My cocktail had passion fruit, so of course I asked my usual question: "But is it real passion fruit?" He just nodded in agreement and that told me everything I needed to know. That drink was legit and had nice strength. The food was great too. My fish tacos were packed with fresh fish, the guacamole and salsa were chunky and full of flavor and hubs enjoyed his pastrami sandwich. I have no clue when we'll be back in Midtown, but one thing's for sure- we're sitting with Josiah again.

    Ordered food to go because the bar was very loud. The music the DJ was playing was good though…read more Ordered buttermilk chicken tenders, shepherd's pie, hot chicken sandwiches, Asian-sesame dry rubbed wings, fries, and tater tots. The shepherd's pie is insanely salty and it's very off-putting. It was inedible. I was looking forward to having it but I would not in good faith recommend this to anyone. The buttermilk tenders is supposed to come with pickled shallots and marinated green beans. We didn't get the pickled shallots or the marinated green beans, which was a shame. The chicken tenders by themselves didn't have much flavor. It also is unfortunate paying $17 for what was considered a small plate and just getting the chicken tenders. The Asian-sesame wings were okay. Also, didn't have much flavor and weren't that impressive. There was also still hair on some of the pieces of chicken, so the chicken could have been cleaned better. They have fries and hand cut fries. The regular fries were soggy. Should have went with the hand cut fries. The tater tots were okay. I was told that the chicken sandwich was good. It came with a little side of rustic chips. I would not come back for the food but I would possibly go back to try a drink if I was in the area. The drink menu looked pretty good.

    Photos
    The setting from the entrance
    The setting from the entrance
    Gluten free bun
    Gluten free bun
    Double Smoked Cheeseburger

    See all

    Double Smoked Cheeseburger
    Jasper's Taphouse + Kitchen

    Jasper's Taphouse + Kitchen

    4.2
    (493 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    Food is good, service was great. Management is horrible…read more I have been frequenting this restaurant for a long time. I noticed recently that there was a $2 transaction fee added to my bill. This was not a credit card fee (that I can understand). It is a "transaction fee" that is applied to all invoices. Are you kidding me! I have no trouble paying a an extra dollar for a burger. But if you try to rip me off by sneaking in extra charges, I will never come back. You just lost a regular customer over a $2 charge.

    Came here on a Sunday afternoon in late March, when the sun is just starting to come out again, but…read morethere's still a crispness to the air. They had outdoor seating along 9th ave and 51st street. We sat inside at a hightop , along their big open windows of 9th; great in between of inside and outside. Plenty of options for a big or small group, or solo! Our server was McKenna, who was incredibly attentive, we never felt like we were waiting or had to wave anyone down. The food came quickly, and was great. Nothing that changed our lives, but hot, quick, and delicious. I can see this becoming a regular spot for when we can't decide on where to go and just want somewhere dependable and consistent. Inside is like a typical Irish pub: long bar, wood everywhere, comfy high tops and booth seating along the wall. Keep in mind that it is a sports bar with TVs everywhere, so they will be playing the major sport of the season. The volume isn't too loud though, enough to hear, but don't need to cover your ears. The bottomless option on the weekend is great, 2-3 drinks and you get your money's worth. The bloody's are good quality, with a good bite of Tabasco and horseradish (I prefer that!) and the mimosas are bubbly forward (they're not skimping you with mostly OJ). The food prices for brunch aren't crazy either. Selection is a bit limited, but seeing as this is a pub/tavern, I think they have a pretty good mix. Overall, would absolutely recommend. If you have a big group, have some common sense and book a reservation, but likely able to do walk-ins for small groups, couples, or singles easily. This is a great option for laid back vibes in HK.

    Photos
    Jasper's Taphouse + Kitchen
    Chicken Caesar Wrap
    Chicken Caesar Wrap
    Jasper's Taphouse + Kitchen

    See all

    Barking Dog

    Barking Dog

    3.7
    (155 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$

    Great dinner with family tonight, a Friday night in the city. We were a party of 5 and we made a…read morereservation. The place was located on a cute circle in Hell's Kitchen with indoor and outdoor seating and offered a "Yappy Hour": (any day) bring your dog to receive 50% off cocktails. Sweet deal, & have a menu for your dog, as well! (In hindsight, there was no wonder there were so many dogs there! ) I ordered the spicy gin margarita which had a kick but was so delicious. My cousin ordered it too and enjoyed the spice. To eat, we enjoyed wings, some lemon chicken soup and guac with pita to start. I lovveed the soup. Wish it came in a larger bowl - would absolutely ordered that again. Time for our entrees. My husband and I shared the parpadelle short rib ragu because my husband was pretty full from all the apps. (So good!) it really was a 10/10. It was perfectly seasoned and did not disappoint. My aunt ordered the fish and chips and my cousin the spaghetti Pomodoro. Everyone enjoyed their meals and the hospitality of the staff. Thank you for an awesome dinner!

    As with it's other location in Yorkville on the UES this Barking Dog offers a comfort food menu in…read morea cozy relaxed setting. Of course, if you're a dog lover you'll enjoy the related decor, coffee cups, and the place itself is dog friendly. Not too long ago I met up with a friend here for a quick meal after some morning run training. Happy to see they offer the Barking Dog Breakfast Special at this location - 3 eggs, home fries, biscuits, fruit, with ham, bacon, or sausage. Good deal to fill up along with some hot coffee. This location is in a spot close to where I used to work near Hells Kitchen, and offers nice outside seating on the patio area around it. Friendly service and a decent spot for brunch, lunch, a burger, or salad.

    Photos
    Barking Dog
    SALMON AVOCADO TOAST
    SALMON AVOCADO TOAST
    Sidewalk

    See all

    Sidewalk

    Olde City - cheesesteaks - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...