Chicken scarp was delicious - tender, with just the right amount of spicy vinegar peppers. Delicious ! read more

Old Stone Trattoria - Chicken Scarp - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

We made a promise never to get food from this place ever again. However, in the last 6 months people have said try it again. Unfortunately, it was a big mistake. The food took 1.20 minutes to be delivered after we were told it would take 45 minutes. The appetizer and 2 dinners were shit. The owner has always been a nasty bastard who does not care about his customers. This experience reinforced for me not to ever give them a dime and make sure we tell every person who discusses places for Italian food, never to even consider this place. Stay far away!!!!! read more

Finally got my boy his first NY pizza. We got the chicken alla vodka slice and the margherita slice. Both were fantastic and the staff was super friendly read more

See all

@oldstonetrattoria 425 King Street Chappaqua, New York 10514 Atmosphere was beautifully decorated, perfect place for a weekly family dinner or a birthday party. Small cozy yet perfect size for any gathering. Staff ‍ was super friendly with a warm greeting as soon as you walked in. Once seated we were checked on multiple times to ensure we had everything we needed and wanted. Food was WOW! Their brick oven pizza delicious, perfectly crispy and soft at the same time! When you walk in they give you their in-house freshly made bread with their tomato sauce for dippping and wow how delicious! We also ordered these amazing vodka Mac and cheese fritters, holy cannoli ! They were massive and so delicious! We would go back just for those 10/10 recommend you guys give this place a try read more

See all

2 hours to get a pizza. Called to check on the order and was told it would be "out the door" in 5 min. Called back 30 min later and was told it was leaving in 2 min. Honesty is easy. Average pizza is everywhere. read more

We were in the area for a show and decided to stop in. We were seated quickly. Service was friendly. They were busy, so it was a little slow. We ordered the rice balls for an appetizer. They were good. Not great, but good. I had the pappardelle for my entree and it was amazing. My mom had the mussels and she really enjoyed them as well. They brought bread over when we got our entrees. It was fresh and good. We would definitely go back if in the area. Unfortunately I didn't get many pics. read more

Old Stone Trattoria - a painting of a bird on display - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

This little restaurant offer great food selection with specials on pizzas. We ordered two pasta dishes and they were both amazing. The seafood portion is much larger than average Italian food in south west Chester county. read more

Old Stone Trattoria - a plate of musselling and sauce - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

See all

Why any Italian restaurant would wrap a hot parmigiana wedge in foil is beyond me. The cheese sticks to the foil and lifts right off the sandwich. Such a waste of cheese that should be enjoyed on the sandwich, not being peeled off foil. read more

Old Stone Trattoria - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

Slow service Good sauce. Long wait.CURRENT HEALTH SCORE 86 out of 100 September 16, 2022 VIOLATIONS Insects, rodents present Food not protected during storage, preparation, display, transportation and service, from potential sources of contamination (e.g., food uncovered, mislabeled, stored on floor, missing or inadequate ... Read more Lighting and ventilation inadequate, fixtures not shielded, dirty ventilation hoods, ductwork, filters, exhaust fans Show More ALL INSPECTIONS 86 out of 100 September 16, 2022 96 out of 100 November 5, 2020 ABOUT HEALTH SCORES Yelp obtains this data from Hazel Analytics, which collects public data from local government agencies. Health department practices vary widely across the country, and some do not publish a score along with their inspection findings. For these jurisdictions, Hazel Analytics collects underlying local health department data to provide an estimated score that shows how this business's latest inspection compares to others in the local health department's jurisdiction. Depending on how frequently a health department publishes inspection results online and how long it takes to process and send that information to us, there may be a delay before the most recent inspection is shown here. This is usually a temporary situation that will be resolved when we receive updated information. If you have any questions or comments about the data on this page, please visit Hazel Analytics' FAQ page. Powered by Hazel Analytics read more

Really great atmosphere - It's our go to on the way back from the airport! Don't ask me why! But we like to do it like this! Fly in, stop for Italian, die happy! read more

Always longer than anticipated pick up times. Nasty attitudes. Screwed up order and when called to complain that order was wrong and cold, no apologies given and they asked if we had a microwave. Used to go 3x a month and spent $150 each time...never again. read more

Our go to family neighborhood red sauce joint, great staff and service, huge take out business (our usual approach) prices reasonable. Love Old stone! read more

The food is very good, I've never been disappointed in that respect. But, be prepared to wait. My pickup orders have never been ready when they said it would and then you're forced to wait int Shri tiny entryway for minutes on end for your food. read more

Amazing food! Kind workers! Fast service! So recommend! You can go to eat like you would at a restaurant and/or take out!

Got old stone trattoria salad with blackened chicken. Delicious and weight watcher point friendly.

We came here with our 21-month-old and his behavior, as predicted, was a nightmare. The staff was INCREDIBLE. Catering to our misery and supporting us for the 20 minutes he was able to behave and then literally packing up everything for us and helping us to our car. Cannot wait to go back without him read more

Food preparation very uneven, 4 percent upcharge for credit cards (never mentioned), Owner/Manager attitude stinks. Menu prices not reliable. It is a shame-- this place used to be great. But success has been its downfall. Ordered some wings a few nights ago....got upcharged 4 bucks because of "market prices". The roasted vegetable salad featuring read more

By far my favorite pizza place. Staff are very nice and always positive! Definetly would go again. read more

Had Old Stone Trattoria last night for dinner and it was great! I ordered the baked gnocchi which is gnocchi with tomato sauce and mozzarella on top and it was delicious. I also had garlic knots which were good, but I was surprised by how small they were. I ordered takeout with my family and another so it was a pretty big order. We got it delivered and they said it should be delivered within an hour or an hour and a half but unfortunately it was a little longer than that. It was, however, a Friday night, so I am sure they were busy at the restaurant and in the kitchen so I can not blame them too much for the delay. The food was great but I do think it might be better to eat at the restaurant as the food will be warmer and the service will likely be better. I have not eaten at the restaurant for a long time and I am looking forward to when I do! read more

Lousy and cold food. Extremely nasty customer service. Took over 2 hrs to deliver one town over. Don't risk it - there are plenty of better pizza parlors in mid-Westchester. read more

I absolutely love this restaurant, as do my kids. We frequent about once or twice a week. Every meal from pizza to pasta are delicious. The owner and staff are simply the best. Courteous, professional and willing to do whatever it takes to make it an amazing experience each and every time. Yum! Thank you. Lisa N. read more

Amazing assortment of pizzas and we'll be back to savor some others we couldn't try. We ordered the white truffle pizza - the taste and the crust were terrific. Our 5yr old had just the cheese pizza - he loved it (to us, the taste was not necessarily anything to write home about but the crust, again, was terrific). Also ordered the roasted butternut squash salad which was a nice addition to the pizza. Service was friendly and the ambiance was laid back / relaxed - great for dining with young kids. Overall, a winner in our books and we'll be back. read more

Love this place. Food is delicious and the staff friendly. Only wish it was a little bigger

This place is trash. Ordered delivery, took over 2 hours and the pizza was cold. The woman on the phone was not at all helpful. What a disaster! read more

After sitting down and then reading some of the harsh reviews of this place, I was admittedly a little concerned. But none of the negatives came to pass during our family meal here this fourth of July. Instead, we had a great meal that we will never, ever forget. As much I'd like to say the memory was made thanks to the food we ate here, the truth is our experience was memorialized the moment Bill Clinton stopped by the window and peeked his big ole head in. This being my first trip to Chappaqua, I had joked with my in-laws on the ride over as to whether we would run into Bubba dining here, and of course no one expected that would happen. But then lo and behold, I am staring the man in the eye as he looks through the window. Understand now that I am the *last* person to go gaga over celebrity sightings. And even if deep-down I am somewhat excited by seeing someone famous, I have a rule to never bother them. But my mother-in-law would have none of it, and thought this was the opportunity of a lifetime for the grandchildren. And to her credit, Mr. President seemed to be fishing for attention by peering in the window. Long story short, we followed him outside and asked for a photo, which he happily obliged. (Several photos, actually.) He even hung out for a bit, let us play with his two dogs, and was essentially the same charming man that you have always seen on TV. Pretty amazing. He really is larger than life. As for the food, well, turns out Clinton is a frequent visitor to the Old Stone Trattoria. And let's face it, Bubba knows a good meal when he sees it. (Although it was clear from the photo, Hillary's keeping him very trim.) Well, I must say I had one of the more delicious plates of pasta that I have had in a long time. It was a simple dish that I ordered: Whole wheat penne baked with eggplant and marinara sauce, and topped with a layer of fresh mozzarella. Dishes like this all come down to the gravy. My friend Marc N's family makes the best gravy I've ever had, and this was pretty damn close. You cannot get this much flavor without making it from scratch, and cooking it for hours and hours on end. It was absolutely delicious. My mother-in-law and wife shared an eggplant wedge. (Normally, being from NJ and all, I refuse to call subs "wedges," but I'll be nice in this case given that I was dining in the Wedge Belt.) MIL and wifey said it was very good. My manorexic father-in-law had a small Chappaqua Salad, but wasn't able to finish it. (smh) And my son, the healthy eater he is, had a giant slice of chocolate layer cake and only ate the icing off the top and back. A classic family dinner. Old Stone Trattoria, truth be told, is technically just a glorified pizza joint. But they've decorated it such that it feels like you are dining in someone's house. And the BYOB policy is nice given that they have a liquor store literally right next door. I did not try the pizza unfortunately, as that would be the true measure of this place's greatness. But I did spy an artichoke and spinach pizza on whole wheat crust on the menu, which I most certainly will come back for. And who knows, maybe next time Bubba will come in and join me for a slice. (No deduction of stars for all the Chappaqua locals who gave us the stinkeye for bothering their local celebrity. Tough titty for you.) read more

Old Stone Trattoria - One of the perks of eating here is that your family might get to run into Bubba. Like mine did tonight. - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

The salads are not very good and they rip you off when you order pizza. I prefer not to get pizza from them. Sorry for the bad review but I'm fed up to be ripped off and bad attitude to customers. read more

Food is good but avoid it at all costs. It takes forever to get your food. Get ready to wait with a bunch of other people in a crowded front area read more

We figured on a quick birthday dinner on a Monday night. Must have been the B-team tonight because it took FOREVER! My Mom ordered sole with lemon sauce. When our meals all arrived, we were told there was a mix-up with Mom's dish. OK, we started eating while they went back to work wth Mom's dish. When it arrived 15 minutes later, it was the wrong dish again. Another 15 minutes later, third time was the charm and they got it right. We had brought a birthday cake to celebrate. To make up for the snafu with Mom's dish, we were all offered coffee or cappucinos, so we took them up on it. Unfortunately, they brought us the cappucinos but didn't get around to serving the birthday cake until another 15 minutes after we finished our cappucinos! We had to ask for the check and finally got it. Total elapsed time: 2-1/2 hours (no kidding)! This experience would have knocked them all the way down to one star, but the staff was gracious, so they get one star back. read more

So beyond thankful for Old Stone's takeout service during the COVID-19 situation. They always have such pleasant customer service, and the food never disappoints. My personal favorite is the chicken Siciliana (basically chicken parm with a layer of eggplant in between the chicken and cheese). The shrimp oreganata is also incredible (shrimp with lemon butter sauce and breadcrumbs over sautéed spinach). Not to mention, the bread that comes with the food is fabulous!! read more

Shiver me timbers that was a feeeeeeeed! My personal choice of the penne chicken vodka roll had value for money written all over it. And that's not to say it didn't taste good either tehe winky face this thing was ridiculously satisfying on the taste buds read more

Old Stone Trattoria - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

Great food! Best pizza and pasta in town. We used to be long-time Mario's customers, but when they shut down, we needed to find a new place for our pizza fix! Pizza Station is OK but not great - same goes for Pizza 238 in Millwood. But then came along Old Stone, and they had nothing on this place! Great place, great service. Word of advice - when ordering pizza, go for the Chicken Parm Pie. A must-have! read more

I haven't had the pleasure of dining in this restaurant, but certainly will once the Covid issue is settled. But I have gotten take-out from here many times in the past few weeks and the food is excellent! Pizza is perfect with nice thin crust and the pastas, even when ordered al dente-are prepared correctly and with subtle basil, garlic and tomato flavors in the most basic of sauces. It is difficult to find a great Italian--but in Chappaqua, this is it! read more

This restaurant is awesome the food is delicious and the staff is very accommodating! They don't rush you out they always come around to check if you u need anything .. will definitely be going back .. read more

I don't know what alternate universe some of the other reviewers have been visiting but we've never had a bad experience with takeout or dining in. The pizza is some of the best around and the eggplant rolletini is excellent. The staff is always warm and friendly. We've never had an issue so can't attest to how they handle complaints but based upon how busy it is, i can't imagine they're as rude as some of the reviews suggest. read more

Food ok. Owner did not respond nicely when I informed him of burnt pizza. Nasty. Also overcharges for salad substitution

I'm giving this place 4 stars if for no other reason than consistency. I lived near here for years. The pizza is great but it was their chicken soup that keeps me coming back. read more

Lost me as a customer today after being a customer since the restaurant opened. I ordered the sausage, peppers and Onions pizza and asked the person to "substitute" peppers for mushrooms. They charged me price by topping. Once I told them that they charged extra - the person who just charged my card, just shrugged and said "that's not it it works". Well the person taking my order on the phone did not mention that substitutions are not allowed. It's less about $4 extra - more about treating customers well when they have an issue. I have many more choices in Chappaqua - which I will use from now on. read more

Ordered for take out the first time tonight. I'm house sitting in the area and decided to try it out, despite so many bad reviews. I have to say, I should have listened to the reviews. I ordered a cold antipasto, the specialty clam pizza with no bacon and baked manicotti. All were pretty averagely priced for Westchester. Let's start with the cold antipasto. I never got it, it was a chef's salad. I do have to say the greens looked fresh in this salad but it wasn't what I ordered. Remember the clam pizza with no bacon? Well it came with bacon. Two strikes. The woman on the phone even repeated my order back to me so I'm confused as to where the miscommunication would be? Ate it anyway, was fairly tasty but I'm not a huge fan of the taste of salt (hence no bacon) so I'm not very happy. The baked manicotti was quite literally plain ricotta cheese wrapped in a pasta topped with what tasted like grocery store brand shredded mozzarella and a watery out-of-the-can tasting marinara sauce. The one really good thing I can say about Old Stone Trattoria is that the garlicky bread that came with the pasta was very soft and tasty. Overall very unhappy with my experience and I highly doubt I will be ordering from here ever again. read more

I live nearby this place and have been a fairly longtime customer. So when my friends and I wanted a place to grab a bite to eat as a group, I recommended we try this place out. The food was fairly good, nothing too amazing but definitely pretty solid for Westchester pizza. The service was also pretty good as the waitress was friendly and the food didn't take too long to get out. However, the reason for the low review is that they were extremely rude about us splitting the bill. The very first thing we were asked when we arrived was if we wanted to split the bill. We said yes and then enjoyed our meal. When the time came to pay, we all got up to pay and split the bill so that each entree was one bill, which is a very simple and common way of splitting the bill. Yet we were scolded by several people in the restaurant there. This is in spite of being asked earlier. It was unnecessarily rude for a very simple and common request that we were clearly told is ok there. Would not recommend for a group. read more

I have been here a few times and in those few time I have never been disappointed always been welcomed by the owner and I have always received the greatest service. Recently I came in to pick up a few slices but today in particular I picked up a scarp slice and they beat every other pizzeria in town i have tried that slice in other pizzerias as well as the dish and will never go anywhere else but here.I would recommend this place to everyone I know keep up the good work guys read more

Old Stone Trattoria - Scarp slice - Italian Near Me - Chappaqua, New York

See all