Cancel

Open app

Search

Old Route 51 South BBQ

4.9 (17 reviews)

Old Route 51 South BBQ Photos

You might also consider

More like Old Route 51 South BBQ

Recommended Reviews - Old Route 51 South BBQ

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Old Rote 51 Southern BBQ
Julie K.

Great BBQ in a small town!! It's take-out only, but there are picnic tables outside. If you want to have the best selection of what they offer, make sure to get there early as they sell out of almost everything by later afternoon!! That's how good they are!! I had the pulled pork on a baked potato - it was awesome! The smokers are right outside the building, and they're happy to show them to you. What a great place!!

Fantastic Southern style barbecue! Great food and super friendly staff. We'll definitely be back!

See all

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Aaron D.
0
34
211

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Regina R.
114
25
22

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Their food is so good it's a must try! A bit pricey but totally worth it! The people working there are always sweet to us.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Old Route 51 South BBQ

You might also consider

Porch Chair BBQ PCB - 3 meats, coleslaw, reg fries and various sauces ( pickle, habanero mango, Dijon, spicy bbq)

Porch Chair BBQ PCB

4.8(34 reviews)
46.8 mi

Great little place thats big on flavor. We ordered the 3 meat plate, brisket, pulled pork, and my…read morewife's favorite turkey. Everything was tender and juicy. Service was good and food came fast considering there were a few in front of us. They have a number of sauces that were pretty decent. Definitely worth another stop when in the area.

Road snack! Pit stop for BBQ right off the highway. Wish I could be more enthused…read more We pulled in around lunch time, there were a couple of people seated. To the left of the door was a window opening to the back with a woman standing there with a baby on her hip, we were looking around to see where to go and she let us know to head to the second window to the back. Upon arriving at the second window, there was a young man standing there. He didn't greet us, didn't smile, just stood there. I indicated it was our first time in and asked a question about the menu, he responded with the answer and then just continued to stand there. I was very uncomfortable so just ordered a sampler with nothing else. For the three options, i chose pulled pork, brisket, and 2 ribs. The food came out right away but no comments or anything. We saw the BBQ sauce area and I took a couple of options in condiment cups with no lids available. grabbed some napkins as we would continue our road trip and eat in the car. I am never a big fan of pulled pork; I have my favorite and compare all to it. This had more flavor than most I have had but it was really dry for being ordered early in the day. The brisket was tender and the fat attached gave flavor. The ribs were fine, also dry. This was a pit stop on our road trip because we love BBQ, this just wasn't for us.

Photos
Porch Chair BBQ PCB - Merch area

Merch area

Porch Chair BBQ PCB - My dish!

My dish!

Porch Chair BBQ PCB - Snapped at entrance. Order at the FAR left corner.

See all

Snapped at entrance. Order at the FAR left corner.

17th Street Barbecue - Cold dry brisket, cold dry pork, luke warm ribs and great beans.

17th Street Barbecue

3.9(265 reviews)
16.6 mi
•$$

Great food and service! Always try to get something different each time we go and their "magic dust…read more" is amazing on everything that they have! And fresh pork rinds are incredible!

Terrible experience!…read more I expected better. After all, this place has won the BBQ World Championship three times. But I was totally disappointed by my experience there. The waitress took my drink order, poured me a glass of iced tea, and then went off to handle another table, leaving my tea on the counter on an 83 degree day. By the time she returned to pick it up and bring it to me the ice was semi melted and the tea was warm. Just what you want to drink on a warm day. I ordered the 2 meat combo of pulled pork and sliced brisket. When I took a bite from both, it tasted like yesterday's leftovers. It was dry, flavorless and simply blah. I couldn't even finish it. The sides were nothing to brag about either. But what really disturbed me was the attitude and behavior of the restaurant staff. When I told the waitress that I was really disappointed with the meal, she became angry, defensive, and accusative. At my request she took the food away (there was still 2/3 of it left), took it to the back, and dumped it in the trash. No apology, no attempt to resolve the problem. Then she brings me the check like she expects me to pay for food I sent back. Not a chance! I told her bluntly I was not paying for it. Another staff person came by and told me that I had told the waitress that "it was good." If I thought it was good, why did I send it back? If it was just a case of I was full or lost my appetite, I would have asked for a box to go. No, it was bad enough that I didn't want to eat it, period. Again, no apology, no attempt to resolve the problem. I got up and walked out. I then attempted to express my concerns at the office next door, but then another person (whom I suspect was the owner of the restaurant and the daughter of the original pit master, Mike Mills) came up to me and angrily told me that she was aware of my complaint and asked me to "get in my car and leave." I complied. Needless to say, I will not be back. If poor quality food and poor quality customer service is what one ends up with, then I cannot in good conscience recommend this restaurant to anyone. Shame on you, 17th Street BBQ! I am willing to bet Mike is rolling in his grave!

Photos
17th Street Barbecue - Interior

Interior

17th Street Barbecue - Fried pickles and sauces

Fried pickles and sauces

17th Street Barbecue - Outside sign

See all

Outside sign

Bo's Breakfast and Bar-B-Q - Breakfast Skillet

Bo's Breakfast and Bar-B-Q

4.4(39 reviews)
48.0 mi
•$$

Road tripping from St. Louis to Memphis and Sikeston is about the halfway point so we stopped for…read morelunch here. Figured a place close to both BBQ cities would have good BBQ and we were definitely right with Bo's! You order at the counter. They have a overhead board menu with half breakfast menu and half BBQ and both sides are served all day. My sister-in-law ordered the chicken breast plate with green beans and potato salad. Chicken was decent, potato salad quite good, but the green beans were bland. My husband ordered the pork steak initially but they were sold out so he switched to the ribeye steak. The steak was fantastic and actually prepared to medium rare. The side of mashed potatoes and gravy were basic and out of the box, but the quality of the steak more than made up for that. I ordered the smoked chicken drummy plate with german fries and baked beans. The smoked chicken was hands down the best smoked chicken I have had in my life! Smoked all the way through with great seasoning rub. I could have eaten it all day long. The baked beans also on point, a good sweet with a touch of heat flavor. The german fries were essentially home made potato chips, I would skip those next time.

What a perfect little spot! Traveling through town we stopped in for breakfast by doing a quick…read moresearch in the area. What a little hidden gem! The staff was very friendly and helpful, food was served perfectly and the dining area had plenty of seating. You order at the counter, pour your own coffee from the coffee station and seat yourself. Food is brought promptly and served warm! Eggs were cooked perfectly, bacon had an amazing crisp to it and the biscuits were soft! A lovely gentleman walked around refilling coffee at the perfect time as well.

Photos
Bo's Breakfast and Bar-B-Q - Cooking area directly behind order counter - the savory aromas are mouthwatering!

Cooking area directly behind order counter - the savory aromas are mouthwatering!

Bo's Breakfast and Bar-B-Q - Two meat plate ribs and pulled pork

Two meat plate ribs and pulled pork

Bo's Breakfast and Bar-B-Q

See all

Pat's BBQ & Catering - The Sampler combo plate

Pat's BBQ & Catering

4.8(34 reviews)
18.0 mi
•$

Popped in for Thurs lunch favoring Pat's with fewer but better ratings and less expensive option in…read moreMurphysboro. First time...so went withh the sampler at $18 and most of their meats are included except the pork steak (makes sense to me since that's usually a separate feature in these parts along with Kentucky). It was three of us and we were given the heads up that the sampler can feed two. Figured we could start with that and order more. The order was a very generous helping of two large rib tips, two pork rib bones, two wing pieces, and pulled chicken, pork, and chopped brisket. Our choice of two sides were slaw and mac & cheese. Three buns were thrown in given the three of us in the party (thanks for the flex). Local bottled Big Muddy root beer is the same $1.50 as the can sodas in the case and it is made with honey and cane sugar. Of the things I tried, I thought the rib tips were excellent - smoked pink and moist - got a meaty piece with only a small piece of cartilage. The chopped brisket isn't my thing - I prefer sliced. My daughter said the ribs were great (figured would be as good as the tips). The wings I believe were smoked too rather than grilled and the taste from the rub/marinade wasn't something I was familiar with. Tender and not dry. Pulled pork and chicken were solid. We still had leftovers - so I'll get my chance to try the ribs and focus on the flavor of the wing. Will have to get the pork steak next time and order plates next time focusing on our faves. Roomy dining area with some tables near the windows. It was getting warm out there so having plenty of indoor seating on a quieter Thursday lunch was welcome over overflow seating outside at the covered picnic tables.

I live in the Midwest, in a small city. Our BBQ places are easy to find: look for a big, shouty…read moresign; the owner's $120,000 extended F250 taking up a space right in front of the door; and an ambiance that includes corrugated steel walls, self-consciously Texas-y lamps over closely huddled booths, and servers all wearing the same hat and shirt. Oh - and the food is usually fine, except no fried okra. Pat's is not in a city. It's outside a small southern Illinois town. Pretty far outside, in fact, which is where true BBQ is supposed to be located. The parking lot is gravel. The only pickups there belong to customers, and their worth is more in the range of $12,000, except to their owners, who use them as trucks. And the sign is a sign. It tells you where you are. Oh, wait - there are BBQ competition trophies in the entryway. Stand and marvel. There are more inside. Marvel more. Because other than these and some pics of family and locals and celebrities I didn't recognize on the walls, that's about it for decoration. Stare at the menu, menu board and signs. Pay attention to the happy person behind the counter when she tells you what they're out of, because the best BBQ places are out of something you want. Note the teasing banter between local customers and the kitchen staff, because everyone knows someone back there. And order. We got the pulled pork plate. My sister got potato salad and green beans. I got the fries. I got the local(?) root beer. They don't do fried okra, but this IS the Midwest. It all came to our table in a reasonable amount of time. The BBQ sauce came in a cup on the side. Ketchup was brought to us. So why only four stars? Everything was perfect, right? And prizewinning? Yeah, but BBQ is personal. Everyone has an opinion. I lived in northern Alabama, which styles itself as BBQ Country. As does Texas and Kansas City and Memphis and everywhere. Pat's, much beloved by regulars for its mild smokiness, juicy juicy soft texture and other features, seemed a bit too mild and even soggy to me. I know - I have no taste. And it was good. Just not five stars great. And not enough sauce in the container, though I could have gotten up to ask for more. And the potato salad was fine and the fries a little too starchy, but only a little. That said, the beans were the wonderful dark green juicy soft salty ones that are too ... wonderful. Get those. The root beer, brewed with honey, y'all, was the best ever. Get that, too. The dessert was what they were out of, dang it! Overall the experience was just great. Someplace to go back to. And you should go there.

Photos
Pat's BBQ & Catering - Winner, winner!

Winner, winner!

Pat's BBQ & Catering - Large Barbecue smoked pork nachos and a Big Muddy Rootbeer Mmmmm

Large Barbecue smoked pork nachos and a Big Muddy Rootbeer Mmmmm

Pat's BBQ & Catering - Seriously delicious root beer. With honey!

See all

Seriously delicious root beer. With honey!

Old Route 51 South BBQ - bbq - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...