TL:DR - Great old building that really transports you back. Lots of great stories about old prisoners, but just reading stories over and over again gets repetitive and boring after a while. The watch house tour is a must, however.
Man, this place is cool. Great way to kill 3 hours. The prison itself has an old timey haunted prison look to it. Lots of bare concrete and stone with lots of drab dark cells. It really transports you back into time with lots of great stories about the inmates held their, former beliefs about prison reform, and about Ned Kelly. Honestly, all the focus on Ned Kelly didn't make a ton of sense to me as an American, so it was a weird focus for me.
But the star of the visit was the watch house experience. You get to tour a separate part of the prison that served as an intake center until 1994, but the tour is given from the prisoner perspective, where you're "arrested" by a guard/tour guide. The guide was phenomenal and took his role seriously, which was great.
The only reason this place didn't get 5*s is because after a while the prison itself got a bit old. The stories were great the first 15 cells, but then got old. It turned into a great freaky location with 50 Wikipedia articles for people to read. Would have been great if it was a bit more interactive. read more