Excellent dinner! Even at peak times they hustled for our service! Very good overall! read more

We ordered to go about 9:30 after long car trip. Suggested to us by hotel clerk at Quality Inn right across the street. Looking for a place still open and not fast food. Ready in 20. They are open until midnight. Personal pizza and salad. Very good pizza and basic salad. Walk across the street for pick up. Get your dinner here! Fresh and good. We were pleased. read more

I love Old Chicago. The only reason this isn't a 5 star review is because sometimes the service is hit or miss. The Thai chicken and noodle salad is insanely delicious! And the breakfast is pretty unbeatable. If you happen to stop in on a night when the Bills are playing, expect the place to be a little bit rowdy but a whole lot of fun. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - THAI CHICKEN & NOODLE SALAD - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

I love it when the restaurant is connected to the Holiday Inn. You don't have to drive anywhere. We were seated in the bar. They were very busy. She got our beverage right away so I got the black tooth - black eagle Baltic Porter. I really enjoyed it then for dinner. I got the Strawberry Ricotta Basil salad with ricotta cheese, spinach, and arugula, strawberries,sliced mango,walnuts, sunflower seeds , and a honey poppyseed dressing. I ate every bite of that salad. It was so good.Dave got the Chicago 7 hoagie-pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, olives, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, and Parmesan cheese. He said he would get that again. they have a really nice outdoor seating area with a fire pit. read more

See all

For being in Rock Springs this place gets insanely busy Great ambiance and service Our waitress was such a lovely person Pizza is okay..... it wont blow your socks iff but their salads are pretty fantastic Great beer and wine list and solid cocktail's read more

See all

The ambiance is fantastic and the food was amazing. Our waitress was kind and attentive.

Our family stopped here during a road trip from California thru Wyoming. We were craving pizza and stopped at Old Chicago even though the rating and commentary was mixed. We were pleasantly surprised at the beauty of the restaurant, the liveliness in the dining room, the food selection and quality, and the amazing service. We ordered fettuccine alfredo, pasta pie, the Hangover burger, and a Chicago style pizza - everyone was so excited about their food we all shared a taste with each other. The food was high quality and tasted great. Our server was attentive and professional. Can't wait to come back here on our next road trip. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Chicago style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

See all

Great seating at the bar! Darby is simply the best bartender, great personality and always making sure your beer is full. Plenty of options on the menu and yummy tavern style pizza. Get here ASAP! read more

Amazing experience! Ordered takeout, and I swear, some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. Food came out quick, and the people were so friendly. Wasn't that busy or loud when we arrived, so we didn't have to worry about long waits. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Awesome pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

Tasty beers & friendly service. I was just passing through, but found this tap room & was glad that I did.

Not a very clean environment and overall just super mediocre. Server seemed kinda miserable too

This place is good but I got fucking food poisoning and I went to the bathroom 10 to 15 fucking flies in the toilet dead I would rather stand on the free way to get hit by a car. read more

Food was not good. Burrito came out with unmelted cold cheese on it. I was asked choice of meat and went with sausage. They took sausage links and cut them up. That's what they put in this burrito. Worst of all, the hash browns were freezer burn flavor. Worst breakfast ever. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - the entrance to the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

See all

Real fun place to watch college football and enjoy Chicago-style pizza because that's exactly what we did. Food: The pizza was great, with the crust well-done. Their nachose are just ok. Service: our waitress handled our party of approximately 30 people like a champ! Well done! read more

Great place to catch the game and with some good food options among many great draft beer selections too. Pizza is always good and I had the fried pickles during my last visit during Happy Hour. They have many TVs to watch your favorite sports team and restaurant is connected to the Holiday Inn so you can stay at a great hotel and dine here. Come give them a try and enjoy. Cheers! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Farm pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

See all

Last night I ordered inside the restaurant. The girls that work up front were very nice and helpful. I ordered the wings , the fish and chips and the cheesecake. The wings were really good. The fish was cook just right. The coleslaw I honestly didn't like. I prefer a sweeter sauce. To me it was too plain. I wasn't a fan of the cheesecake. Something was missing. The presentation was great. The take out service was quick read more

I came here expecting more from the food. From the looks of the place inside and out and the number of people there on a weekday at lunchtime, I thought it would be off the hook great. Just getting someone to come by and get our drinks took unacceptably long. It was one of those times when I was looking around the dining room and assessing who was a server and what tables had come in before me. Finally, someone who could only do drinks came by and got us going there. It still took unacceptably long for the real server to come by. Granted, they were understaffed and she was working hard. Not the server's fault at all. The Caesar salad was nice. It came pre-tossed with the dressing which is the way it should be. The Mediterranean salad was also good but there was an inordinate amount of water in the bottom of the bowl. Not sure why/how that was but one couldn't simply tilt the bowl and slide a portion onto one's plate. We had to tong it, just without tongs. Weird, but really tasty once on the plate and minus the water. The soft pretzel appetizer was OK. My kids ate and were happy, but it was pretty clear that the pretzels were frozen beforehand and not really cooked as well as they should have been. They were kinda wrinkly and needed a few minutes in a proper oven. The cheese sauce though was outstanding and we kept that for pizza crust dipping. The pizza. Oh, I had such high hopes. The namesake item of the restaurant was underwhelming. We ordered the pan/deep pizza which we love from other Chicago-style pizza restaurants. When it arrived at the table, it really wasn't a deep dish (despite being in a deep pan). It could have been Papa John's pizza put into a pan for service, honestly. The crust looked and tasted as though it was frozen before cooking. On the plus side, the toppings were plentiful and in general, the pizza was tasty...just not what I expected for "Chicago style". read more

See all

Service was great, my food was okay, wife was dried out and over cooked she said it wasn't good at all

In a town limited in terms of dining options Old Chicago is by far the best option. I would always come here when I visited the area after the local steakhouse Coyote Creek shutdown for good during the pandemic. Everything here is delicious -- beers are great, pizza is excellent, portions are appropriate -- I really enjoy the booths and vibe here. Service is always excellent -- nice waitresses. This is definitely my go-to restaurant in Rock Springs, WY. No complaints! read more

See all

We finally had a chance to grab a pizza pie in Chi town. Our bartender was very friendly and food was great. The bar was very chill.

Go Golden Knights! ~ Stanley Cup finals away from home made better here. This is the place to be for happy hour, late night specials, sports tv, music channels and friendly chatter with cross-country motorbikers. Never heard of Old Chicago chain before until now and glad we found somewhere local open past 9pm. Of all things to order at a pizza joint, I had the rib eye in memory of my stepdad's birthday in Heaven. I don't usually order rib eye just anywhere but this entree was great quality portion, cooked perfectly medium rare, broccoli roasted just right and hearty potato--plentiful for breakfast steak and egg leftovers. The wings were a repeat hit for us as well. We came back a few times and our bartenders Michelle and Ally were awesome in remembering and treating us like regulars, as well as changing the sports channel for NHL. read more

See all

Decided to give this place a try. It looked a bit busy but there was seating. The menu was good. The options are fine. We had a part of 8, so we all got different things. Nothing was overly impressive and not very big plates. I asked about the turkey club. Waitress wasn't too familiar with. It was bland. Fries came out like warm. Added salt and then discovered the parm blend on the table. I added that to my fries. Saving grace for the fries. Everything was just mediocre. I wouldnt recommend it and likely wouldn't go back. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

3.5 stars The restaurant was modern and comfortable. The service was average, and the food was pretty good. The beer selection was impressive. This is going to sound strange, but the salads were the most impressive part of our lunch. We got the Mediterranean and the Caesar side salads for 4 of us to share. They were very large for a side salad. All ingredients were fresh and plentiful. The Bavarian pretzel sticks were OK. They tasted like they were frozen American pretzel sticks rather than traditional German pretzels. We also ordered a large Chicago style pizza with black olives and pepperoncini. It was fine. The amount of food for the money was shocking. I wouldn't say it was the best meal we had in Rock Springs but it was pretty good. read more

If you order anything but pizza from this restaurant... prepare to get robbed. 9 dollars for store bought Texas Toast. 15 dollars for a sad chicken sandwich with NO FRIES. God forbid you would like a side of meatballs because you will be dropping 4 dollars a pop! 45+ minute wait time for food. If you come here, only order pizza!!! read more

After my review a couple days ago I want to add a couple stars because of the general manager Keelen reaching out to me and wanting to "make it right". I understand mistakes happen and he was definitely sincere in his apology so I'm willing to bring my family in to give them another chance in making it right. I will update my review once more next month when I come back in. Stay turned read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

See all

Is there a zero stars? Obviously it is connected to a hotel they gave coupon for $5 off or 2/2/2 special for free minus free soda. So when you order ( we are moving and so some had to stay behind with the animals in various rooms) we told them we have to go orders and sit down orders BUT NEED THE CHECK when we got our food. Got it to the room. Waited for the sit down food . Asked 4 times after we got our food for our bill. Finally went inside the kitchen and asked for our check. Saying sorry does not cut it when we asked 4 TIMES. So if you think because you are staying at the hotel with free breakfast coupon at the old Chicago hotel establishment in Rock Springs, Wyoming think again, especially when you have to ask. BTW only 2 tables had people in them. read more

We were staying at a nearby hotel and were looking for pizza and we found this on Yelp. The service was excellent. The food was typical of what you might find at a casual dining restaurant, as were the drinks. read more

The perfect place for comfort food! Friendly staff! Followed COVID precautions. The classic pizza was delicious, although I couldn't eat more than one piece because it was so thick and heavy! If you are HUNGRY and are craving carbs, this is the place for you! read more

See all

Very okay food, wings were hard and undercooked. Horrible managers, the one that's cross eyed would NOT leave us alone. Very annoying and my girlfriend found hair in her food, would not recommend, go to Denny's if it's late, this place is not worth it. read more

Another review that is long overdue! The first time I tried Old Chicago was in Wichita, KS and the place was like a club, with a dj, and packed until almost midnight. This was definitely not the situation in Wyoming but was happy as to see that there was one in Rock Springs. I have to travel down to Rock Springs for work about twice a month and everytime after I have completed my work, I have to stop by Old Chicago for some pizza, wings, and a beer. This time, my job ended at 3:20 P.M. and it was time to stop in for Happy Hour! I arrived there and the parking lot was packed as usual. I am really starting to think that this must be the go-to spot for the locals because the restaurant is always packed. After being seated by the hostess, my waiter had to hurt my soul and tell me that Happy Hour didnt start until 4 P.M and I had to wait. Well lets just say, that didn't stop me from ordering a 9 piece wing before Happy Hour started and another 9 piece wing to GO for happy hour! The 9 piece I ordered to go did turn into a 5 piece because lets just say the wings were that Good and I had to eat a couple more. I ordered were the BONE-IN Original Buffalo and Sweet Thai Chili Wings with celery sticks and house-made ranch. We also ordered the THE Pepperroni which was covered in brick cheese, pizza sauce, and cup & char pepperoni. This was a unique but delicious pizza. The sauce was poured on top of the cheese and the char pepperoni made the pepperoni crunchy and extra tasty. The wings were so good, crispy but tender, easy to eat, and the sauces made the wings stand out. Hands down this place is a good place to eat if you looking for good pizza and wings. Service is usually on point for the most point but done definitely had some bad waiters and waitresss. That definitely wont stop my for coming back in the future. I will be making a return visit by here and enjoy some delicious OLD Chicago! read more

See all

I ordered online and was told it was a 25 minute wait. I arrived after 30 min and was told they didn't even have my order. They asked for the name and order 3 times. Finally, they wrote it down after I showed them the confirmation and had the chefs make it. I waited an hour and a half before receiving this. When I was there, I made a second order, completely separate, in person to go, was told it would be 25 minutes. It was 1 hour later I received my order. When the order was ready, the order was wrong and they remade it. When I opened the order, it was still made wrong!! Three times in a row. I had no customizations to my order whatsoever so confused where the errors came from. The girl at the front who took my order seemed confused as to where my order was although she took it and provided them the tab. In the end, all they offered me was a free drink, I said I didn't need one and would like an item from my order on the house, they said they could not do that and only provided a discount on one of my items. They did not accept my form of payment which was even more frustrating. Overall, first and only time coming here. Will not be coming back. read more

Ok, so we stop just about every time we come to town. Have a had wonderful keto burgers. This is pathetic. The new menu sucks. You have shot yourself in the bullseye of failure. Oh, well it was a good run. And the burger was Not cooked as requested. The waiters was awesome. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pathetic example of keto - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

Our hotel suggested Old Chicago for dinner. It was very busy, but we were able to find an open table in the bar. Our server was very cheerful, helpful, and she made excellent suggestions. Had the rib-eye steak for dinner. Nothing short of outstanding!!! Highly recommend Old Chicago when passing through Rock Springs!! read more

Ordered the spinach artichoke dip and the kids pizza for pick up. So disappointed. The chips were all crumbles not real chips like it came from the bottom of a bag. The dough on the pizza was not cooked all the way through and was doughy and wet. Really gross. read more

See all

Busy place, decent prices, multiple TV's with sports on. Food was okay, ordered an appetizer, personal pizza and salad for the two of us to share. EVERYTHING came out at the same time (waitress acted surprised that and appetizer would come out ahead of the main courses) $50 for the two of us isn't unreasonable, waitress ignoring us, because her two friends came in and sat in her section seemed rude. Overall 3 stars, taste and quantity of the food was the only saving grace. read more

Good place to go if you want to watch College Football. Some of the food can be on the heavy side, but there are good options overall.

Tried this restuarant first time. Once and done. Well done hamburger does not mean burnt to a crisp along with the jerky sweet potatoe fries. So far below our expectations. lesson learned for this restuarant read more

Excellent food and service. Thins crust pizza was crispy and delicious. Wings and beer were also great. Deserves better than the 3.5 star current rating read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Rock Springs, Wyoming

The food is very very good and prices are pretty reasonable and their strawberry lemonade is sooo good!

I had the fish and chips..OMG delicious! Highly recommend. Service was great, establishment was clean and very friendly staff. Will be going back! read more