Mike is a kind man you can absolutely trust! I highly recommend him to everyone who is ready to…read moreturn old jewelry into cash. He patiently explained his calculations and explained how/why pieces had different resell values. The entire transaction was pleasant. I left knowing I had been blessed to get the referral to see Mike. A week earlier a jeweler had offered me $1,000 less for an 18 karat item. My spidey sense said no. So thank you Mike for ruing your business with respect for your clients. I so appreciTe you!

I had a few different estimates to sell certain jewelry that I stopped wearing. This was the best…read moreone. Excellent experience.

My 11 yo son loves rocks, minerals and had been watching silver go up for a while. When it sold off…read more30% on 1/30/26, and closed at $86. He wanted to use his snow shoveling money to buy an America eagle silver coin for his collection. We got there and the owner (I believe) ended up selling him a coin for $103 / a 20% premium. Plus the coin he received had dark spots around the edges. It will be a learning experience for him; and we will never go back.

My wife and I could not have been treated any better! We…read morebrought in some gold jewelry to sell. Brian was genuinely honest and extremely knowledgeable!!!!! we will be back to sell my coins,

I want to thank this business, especially Christine, for resolving the issue with my…read moregold bangle by replacing it with another lovely 14k one. I am very satisfied & wish you many more years of success! (Pic of my replacenent bracelet attached)

In my experience....they give serious salesmen patter..."oh I ,shouldnt give you this price…read morebut...." Then....all said and done, they still give pretty decent prices for metal by weight compared to others downtown and in Glenview, IL.

Some places sell jewelry. Fuenfer Jewelers handles the things you can't replace…read more I brought in my father's ring to be resized. I thought it would be straightforward. When I picked it up, I cried. The team didn't just do the work, they treated it like it mattered, because they understood that it did. That's not something you can fake, and it's not something every jeweler knows how to do. They also helped me pick out a wedding band, which somehow felt less like shopping and more like sitting with people who genuinely wanted me to find the right one. No pressure, no pushing, just honest expertise. And when I needed a watch appraised, Brett Fuenfer took the time to walk me through everything. His knowledge is the kind you only get from someone who deeply loves the craft, and the care he brings shows in every interaction. To Brett and the entire Fuenfer team, thank you. You turned three separate visits into moments I won't forget.

Went in for a cleaning and an appraisal for updating my insurance info. They did a good job…read morecleaning it but I do not recommend them for appraisal. They appraised two platinum and and Dimond rings for 1/2 the value they were appraised for 10yrs ago. I thought that was suspicious so I got 2 more separate appraisals elsewhere those two were both pretty close to each other but both were close to 70% higher than Fuenfer so across three appraisals Fuenfer was such a large outlier it was highly likely to have been incorrect.

The service is outstanding! Very pleasant to deal with and top dollar!!! Staff accommodating.read more

Very friendly staff, a huge selection of items for the amount of space. Ana the best part is that…read moreprices are better than many other shops. Think I might have found my go to place.

I was recommended by a friend while looking for a custom wedding ring and my wedding band. John…read moreknocked it out of the park! He walked me through the design process for her ring and was even so kind to drop off the ring at my office. When it came time for my wedding band, my initial idea was to resize my grandfathers ring but due to the unique pattern, John was concerned the resizing would ruin it. I really appreciated that. So we did the next best thing, he had my grandfathers ring duplicated out of white gold and I could not be happier with how it turned out. Now I have John looking for my next time piece. 10/10 would recommend!

Excellent customer service. I brought in assorted charms to be fashioned into a bracelet, and was…read morelooking for a suitable new chain and design. Thankful that I found Jonathan. His shop is an excellent addition to the neighborhood.

I was referred to Morton Grove Coins to sell a coin collection as I was told they have the best…read morepricing. The employees/owners are extremely honest particularly Mark and Dave. I've been back a few times and I always feel that I'm in great hands and getting the best pricing for everything I've sold. I would never go anywhere else to sell gold or coins!

Excellent, friendly service! Ron was very helpful and knowledgeable. I appreciated his…read moreprofessionalism and expertise. David, business owner, was very kind and helpful too. I had old pieces to sell and they were extremely helpful along the way. I would highly recommend!

Having grown up in Arlington Heights, I've known of this place for many years and used to go in…read morewhen they also dealt in baseball cards and sports memorabilia during the "heyday" of the 1980's. The store is a bit of a time warp, but you kinda have to love that. I'm not a coin expert, but I needed to sell some silver coins my dad had for MANY decades and after doing a good amount of research I called Arlington Coin who said over the phone they were buying then offered what I'm confident was a very fair price after reviewing the coins. Downtown Arlington Heights has changed a lot over the decades, but this place is still the same and a great option for supporting a local business and get great prices if you're in the market to buy or sell coins.

I was at Arlington Coin today with some silver coins. They looked through my coins and gave me a…read morefree assessment of the value. The ambiance does not feel very professional--very messy, but they are friendly. I would probably go back.