George is a wonderful mechanic, he did a great job replacing the brakes on my Ford Excursion…read more Highly recommend.

We spend a LOT of time in our cars out here on the East End…read more Having a mechanic you can rely on is like having a good doctor... IT'S CRITICAL ! At North Fork the doctor is in!

Very nice, hard working men who watch after their customers They go out of their way to help.read more

Brought my car in for my gas recirculation solenoids to be diagnosed and the incorrect polarity was…read moreused to test the solenoids and resulted in my vehicle computer being fryed. The vehicle computer expense will cost me $2000

Overpriced and can't diagnose what I was able to and repair myself without his bullshit $250 per hr…read morefees

Great service. Good communication. Found the problem and repaired the same day. What more could you…read moreask for? I have a BMW X5

This place was a father and son business up until the past year. They could fix anything and had…read moreextremely reasonable rates, Now it's owned By people who have raised their rates for a oil change to almost double it was before . If you pay using your credit card. Expect a surcharge???? I used Allstar many times before. And these are not the same owners. I'm taking my business elsewhere.

Steve, the owner, is honest and upfront. He will let you know if something needs to be fixed…read moreimmediately or if it can wait. Doesn't make up things that need to be fixed just to increase the bill. Great work by an honest business.

I have been taking my car here for the past few months since bringing it to NY from CA. I had great…read moremechanics in CA and was nervous to try somewhere new. The staff here are so nice, really helpful, and do a great job. Prices are reasonable and I've been able to make appointments on Saturdays which is great since I work M-F in the city. Will absolutely continue to come here!

One of the best mechanics on the island!! I took my car for an oil change and inspection . my car…read morewas making a noise and they quickly figured out what it was !! I've told other mechanics about the noise and they never find out what it is . There was no waiting time for a Saturday so they took me in right away, all of them were really friendly. 10/10 !!

Very professional great service car was ready on time highly recommended best to call for an…read moreappointment

very professional and extremely honest. they service my 2017…read moreMB and are very capable.

We have had only very good experiences with Willow Hill in Southold and continue to use them.read more

I do most of the work on my own cars. However, I spend several months a year on the North Fork,…read morewhere I don't have access to my tools or a lift. So I had to find a local mechanic. Willow Hill was recommended to me by several friends in the area. I've taken my 2000 Range Rover there for both routine maintenance (oil changes etc) and more major repairs when needed. Every time the work was done right the first time, for a very fair price, and with none of the BS that so many shops pull these days trying to upsell or "fix" things that don't need to be fixed. They are excellent mechanics, and the owner is 100% honest in my experience. This is a hard thing to find these days. I can't recommend a shop more highly. If you need auto repairs on the North Fork, go to Willow Hill. The only downside is that everyone in town knows what I'm saying, so they can get very busy in the Summer. Call ahead to schedule as they are often booked up a week or more out in high season. As for the previous review here from Maya, no disrespect, but there must be a mistake or it's a troll review. I've had work done at Willow Hill 5 times in the past few years and I can't believe those comments. No one I know in our community has anything but positive things to say about this shop.

They know their stuff! Got me on the road in an emergency and I am eternally grateful. Thank you…read morefrom this out of towner.

DO NOT TAKE YOUR CAR HERE. Mechanic is unscrupulous and predatory! My wife brought our 2020…read moreSubaru Ascent in last week for a brake job. She left the car with him to get the job done. When she returned hours later she was told "you need a brake job and an oil change -- that'll be $165!" He claimed the charge was for "diagnostics." He had not done any of the work she requested on the vehicle and told her he did not have time to do the work on it that day. She says he got very aggressive with her when she questioned the charge. Agree with other reviewers here who say this fellow "fleeces you depending on your level of car knowledge and whether or not you live in the area. Ridiculously overpriced... greedy, unhelpful." That was certainly our experience.