PetSmart is a bit different from what I'm used to. (My experience has been more with PetCo.)…read more PetSmart has a little more warehouse-ish vibe to it, not that the "vibe" is really relevant to this review.
So, the main positive to PetSmart was the variety of different dog foods that they had. They had a lot of Blue Buffalo (including at least one variety that I hadn't seen before). They also had a ton of Nutro (which my dog doesn't seem to like for some reason, but which has a good reputation as far as I know). They also had a fair selection of Wellness, and a small selection of Castor & Pollux. I didn't look to hard at them, but it seemed like they also had a good variety of foods like Pedigree, Alpo, Iams, Hill's Science Diet, etc. The staff was also very friendly, which is nice.
There were two major negatives in my opinion. The first was that I couldn't seem to find Merrick anywhere. To be fair, I didn't ask for help finding it, but if they did have it, they couldn't have had much. I looked through all of the dog food aisles. This wasn't a huge deal for me, as this PetSmart is a little further than I would typically go for my every day pet store. Otherwise, it would be a big issue. As far as I know, there is no other dog food with a reputation for being healthy that offers such a wide array of creative dog foods. Since my dog is spoiled, and will not eat the same food over and over again, having odd varieties like Hawaiian Luau, Turducken, Brauts & Tots, etc. is very helpful. The other major detractor for this store, in my opinion, was that they really seemed to showcase unhealthy options for foods, treats, and even tooth / breath care. It's not a huge deal, since they had most of the healthy alternatives, too. You just weren't going to find them in the front of the store or on end caps.