So we are from out of town.. First thing that struck me is the naming and sign is very confusing- we were looking for Nicky's Gyros based on the Yelp- but from the road it's called Lure- so not sure what that's really about. The place in whole is clean from the looks of everything- it seems like this is more of a carry out place as the dinning room was empty. We carried out as well- I ordered a Gyro- meat was very tender and yummy. My husband got a bacon cheeseburger and loved it- he says better than most fast food places- we also both got fries... They were okay, nothing special. read more

See all

Chicago dos were tasty, food came out fast and hot. Recommended for a quick bite to eat, price was $9 for two and fries. read more

Nicky's Gyros - Chicago style hot dog - Greek Near Me - Portage, Indiana

Had a gyro plate. It was good and they put a lot of meat in there! I ordered delivery. The guy who took my order seemed nice and the delivery guy was on time and nice. read more

We got some Chicago dogs, chili dogs and a couple polish. The Chicago dogs were real good but the peppers were hidden. They slid into the relish. My wife did not like biting into the pepper after looking g for it to remove. They were delicious though. The chili dogs were good. The polish were the best though. They cut the polish down the middle and fried them until burnt a little. Then when they put the polish into the bun, they filled the cut area with mustard and topped it with caramelized onions. It was very tasty!!! We also used them to deliver to our home. It was only $3 compared to Uber eats or other food delivery services. We got our order quick too. The driver was very nice and courteous. read more

Stopped eating here. The food used to be great, then they changed quality of the burger and the chicken they use. On to something else.

Food was garbage, asked to talk to manager has exact words were I don't have time for you, but he took my $17 for garbage onion rings and a cheeseburger read more

Nicky's Gyros - Greek Near Me - Portage, Indiana

More like three stars but I can't do in between. Probably your best option in this local vicinity. Lots and lots of options and the girls working. There were super nice and hospitable to me. Lots of open space. I prefer to shop local then go to McDonald's so here we are. read more

Went today. Service was crap. Been going over 10 years. New guy at cashier. Order gyros with feta. For 10 years I get served gyro dinner. Here is a clue, gyros, multiple, a dinner! Punk gave me and friend a sandwich. We did NOT order sandwiches. Did not fix order. Did not give a Sxxx! SCREW THEM! read more

My husband and I have tried the cheeseburgers, fries, chicken gyro, cheese sticks, tacos, tortas; it is all so fresh and delicious!!! This is one of the best fast food places around! If you haven't tried this place yet, you must try it asap! You won't be disappointed! The staff is super friendly too! The dining area is clean. Don't pass this place up! Oh and they have the best crinkle cut fries!! read more

Update it is expensive now l, not worth it anymore 2 cheese burgers 1 fry chicken gyro pizza puff 40$

me N my husband just got dinner gyros plate and rib tips aand we absolutely loved it everything was hot and fresh definitely our favorite place to order out read more

I decided to try a cheese burger. The beef was hot, good size. Unfortunately the taste was plain and without much flavor. I would like to see them add a little seasoning. It was clear by the taste the patty was cooked from frozen. The bun was about the right size for the burger. The cheese also seemed not to have enough cheese flavor. 1 - 10... I would give this a middle of the road score of 5.2 read more

Nothing special, got the broken fry debris @ the bottom of the bag served as part of my combo with stale, hard buns. Buns stay fresher in the bag, or steam. read more

Would have been higher but the front counter workers need to learnt to read orders back. Missed my onion rings that I ordered. Food is ok but places is really dirty and in disarray. Women's bathroom has 2 out of 8 lights working. Please fix the place up. read more

Love the atmosphere I come here all the time for the gyros and torta. Fries are my weakness and they have great fries here ! read more

Nicky's Gyros - Steak torta! - Greek Near Me - Portage, Indiana

Like many we stayed at Holiday Inn within walking Sign says burgers but they have a lot to choose from. Very good Gyros as others reported. Atmosphere was clean inside and good yet it's a shame owner isn't caring for the outside. Use some Round Up on all the vegetation growing in the cracks, clean up and now the lawn and they would likely get more business. We would normally not stop at such a plane yet food really is good and close. We are going to let them deliver tonight Clean the outside up is my advise read more

Used to get great service. Sadly that time has passed. Food has always been average but the price was good. Won't be back after the lady on the phone yelled at my wife for wanted to pay ahead for a pickup order. (Which we have done almost weekly for years) Then she yelled at me when I stopped in to pick it up. Not a big loss in my book. read more

Nickys gyros was down the street at a smaller location years ago. Like any start up restaurant they start out like gangbusters, put out really good food, care about quality, service, and usually leave a good impression that makes you come back. Unfortunately that's the past for Nicky's Gyros. I've eaten here a few times and I haven't necessarily been really impressed but it was good. It's a typical, gyro, French fries, hot dog spot-they don't specialize in anything they just serve everything. I normally wouldn't review a place like this for that very reason, there's no need to tell people about hot dogs, French fries, and gyros. One thing they can impress in is service, and quality! If they ever do get service and quality back I will never know-because I've moved on. read more

This place has awesome gyros and chicken strips. Fries were delicious, overall amazing experience. Customer service was great too!

Very good. Stopped here on the way to the airport. We had gyros, cheeseburgers and chicken strips.

This is probably my favorite taco joint in town. It may have a bit of a bad location on route 20, but it has amazing food. I personally love the tacos here, and would rate them a 10/10. One thing that I don't always like though is that the television is always on, so it's more difficult to have conversations with the people that you are there with. As well as having great tacos, Nicky's has ice cream bars. There are many different flavors, but when I eat there I always like to get the cookies and cream bar. If you are looking for something new, and don't mind the noise, the. I would say you should go check it out! read more

Good food for a fair price. Have a large variety on the menu, only been 3 times, but didn't find anything I didn't like. People working were pleasant. read more

I had a chicken gyro- which is grilled chicken strips with tzatziki sauce, onions and tomatoes on a pita. It was good- portion size is huge! My son had a burger- he liked it. The place is what you'd expect for a burger- fast food joint. The woman working was really friendly- good customer service. read more

Nicky's Gyros - Chicken gyro - Greek Near Me - Portage, Indiana

Stopped here when traveling from Chicago to Michigan. We were in a hurry and were not in the mood for cold subs. Not much to look at from the outside but has a certain bit of personality. Several small tables and a counter with bar stools inside. Just one girl behind the counter taking orders. She was very kind and accommodating. While we were eating two more people came in to order food to go. They were very obviously regulars. My husband and I both ordered the gyro with fries ($4.75 each). The servings were very generous. My gyro was very good; the pita was fresh and the fries were great. Our little boy was very happy with his cheese burger. I would give it five stars except the fountain pop had a funny metallic taste. They do have bottled pop and I would recommend that. We will not hesitate to go back next time we pass through. read more

We were in Portage and wanted a meal that wasn't McDonalds, and I'm so glad we found this place. This hole in the wall isn't much to look at, but oh is the food good. And it is SO much food. I ate barely half of my gyro meal. The meat was flavorful, the fries were better than I expected, the tomato and onion were fresh, the feta was tasty...love it. My kids got the hotdogs, they said the hotdogs were also good. The portion of fries that came with the hotdogs was also huge. read more

The best fast food joint in the area, solely because their Gyros are soooo good. Additionally the young woman taking orders was extremely pleasant (unlike the majority of establishments around). If tasty fast food + quality service is your thing, stop by nickys for sure. read more

Wonderful food and the ladies working here are nice. Really small on the inside, so it's better just to pickup your food. Not much on the outside, just a few tables to sit at. read more

Nicky's Gyros - Pablo loves tacos and gyros. - Greek Near Me - Portage, Indiana

See all

Steak & chicken tacos ($2 each) are both great. Gyros are also good. It looks like an old ice cream stand. A few 2 top tables and a counter with stools inside and some metal 4 top tables outside. Kind of a small dive but great food! read more

Nicky's Gyros - Greek Near Me - Portage, Indiana

Normally I would've given 4 stars...maybe even 5 but recently their service has drastically declined. I order from here for delivery almost weekly. Rarely had any issues then about 2 months ago I wasn't receiving what I ordered even tho I was very specific and the girl taking my phone order (who clearly is either distracted easily or just refuses to care and be professional) repeated my order back to me. Then when I call to discuss my improper order, she wants to deny taking said order when I clearly remember speaking to her then offering zero apologies. The food has been subpar at best as well. I just ordered yet again, hoping it's all been a fluke but the same girl answered again and struggled AGAIN with taking my order so I'm leery about what I'll be getting tonight. Fingers crossed! read more

Hit or miss at best this is a last resort place. Ordered a gyro plate and the portion was unbelievably small. Also make sure your burger is fully cooked because I received one with lots of pink. The cashier's are very friendly, however the cooks not so much. Last resort option at best. read more

Greek Chiken Pita was amazing! The pink lemonade was also good. I'm not really sure what else to say :)

Very good gyros. I ordered 4 gyros thinking we could eat two each, but we could barely eat one because it was loaded with tons of meat. Food was great and you definitely get your monies worth. Has a drive-thur to make it convenient to order your food and take with you. read more

Low quality "Greek " eatery run by Hispanics. Lol. Not bad but just know it is what it is. It's all heat and eat food from a package, box or can. Good price points, cheeseburger isn't bad and Gyros are good. I've had good luck with fast delivery as well. read more

Patronize this business a lot from my place of employment for lunch. A lot of employees do. The food is already not that great. I tip the drivers every time they deliver my food. I've paid many ways including with big bills as high as a $50 bill. Today I stood in the cold in front of my job arguing with the driver telling me my $50 was fake but never once did she check it. & we all know there is various ways to check the authenticity of bills. VERY UNPROFESSIONAL! I called Nicky's only to be told "what do you want me to do? We don't have anything to do with our drivers!" We all know that is a lie! These people are driving cars with this business logo on the top of the vehicle but yet you're telling me you don't have control over who is delivering YOUR businesses food and driving YOUR business vehicles & also collecting YOUR businesses money. Will not patronize this business again. Don't waste your time or money because it is not appreciated. The least Nicky's could of done was insure they would speak to the driver about how to verify bills so that this doesn't happen again. read more

Excellent gyros with lots of meat, delicious seasonings, and fresh toppings. This is everything a gyros should be.

Food is above average for this type of place. Service was exceptional. Nice place with plenty of room to dine inside, or opt for outside seating. Wide variety of food types. Gyro is stuffed with a generous amount of meat. Rib tips were excellent, and plentiful. read more

I had a very bad experience, I ordered 3 beef tacos and received 3 steak tacos. Once I got to work I looked at my food and noticed the steak tacos and I called and spoke to the girl that took my order and she confirmed the cooks made a mistake once she asked them , so o asked for a manager to credit me for my tacos , he was very rude and told me we all are human and make mistakes. I replied yes we are but you being a manager and not sympathizing with the customer is not right and he told me well you can bring the food back tomorrow. I was like hell no I'm done doing business here. read more

Excellent gyros, excellent service definitely will be returning. Though I was a little worried when we pulled in because the parking lot was such a disaster. read more

What a hole! This place use to be good. Went on a rainy night and water was dripping from the ceiling everywhere. Of all the tables in the place 2 were clean. Ice was empty at the machine and the girl behind the counter was acting like she didn't notice! Took 5 mins just to get some ice. But little did I know I didn't even need ice. I could have dipped my cold gyro meat in my drink to cool it off. I'm pissed at myself for trying to eat my food., I did throw half away. Should of just got up and left. read more

This place has great tasting fast food. Their cheeseburgers are pretty darn good for the price. Their chicken sand and steak burrito is pretty good too :) read more