Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Nickolini's Pizza

    4.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 3:00 PM

    Nickolini's Pizza Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Nickolini's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Great food! Take out only, but, given the location, it's a great find. Perfect for tourists/visitors to the East coast of Vancouver Island.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 321 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Salt Pizzeria - CAPRICCIOSA- Tuscan Ham, marinated artichokes, kalamata olives, mushrooms

    Salt Pizzeria

    4.7(34 reviews)
    23.9 km

    Great pizza place just outside of Parksville. They do a Neapolitan style pizza when thin base…read morewithout it being soggy. Lots of customers while we were there on a weekday afternoon. They do half baked pizzas to go as well so you can finish up when you get home. We got 2 large pizzas. Can't remember the cost but total came to over $50. Their "regular" pizzas are pricey for what they are. Pepperoni and cheese are priced the same or v similar to something more exotic w truffle oil. There are a few tables inside, pretty no frills and 2 tables outside. I'd go back again for some quality pizza when you are in or around Parksville.

    4.5 rounded up Full…read moredisclosure, I had very low expectations. I was filling up with gas when this place caught my eye. The first thing I thought was "gas station pizza". Similar to gas station sushi. Something anyone with a brain interacting with taste buds wouldn't do. I also didn't have internet. The connection was spotty so I couldn't check the reviews. Throwing caution into the wind, I went for it. What a surprise! The pizza was incredible. Apparently their pizzas sometime sell out according to some local reviews. I can certainly see why! So good, I got one to go. A hole in the wall location in the middle of nowhere along the Island Highway, Small spot seating maybe 10 inside along with a picnic table outside for some additional seating. Friendly service. More take away than dine in. This may be one of the best pizzas I've had. See my pics. They don't skimp on the toppings. Bonus: they have a liquor license. Recommended

    Photos
    Salt Pizzeria - Margherita

    Margherita

    Salt Pizzeria - This is a half salami (they were out pepperoni) and half four cheese pizza.   You do pay a bit more for half and half.

    This is a half salami (they were out pepperoni) and half four cheese pizza. You do pay a bit more for half and half.

    Salt Pizzeria - This is the prosciutto fresco. You can't do half baked for this one.

    See all

    This is the prosciutto fresco. You can't do half baked for this one.

    Craig Street Pizza

    Craig Street Pizza

    4.8(11 reviews)
    27.2 km

    Great pizza choice in Parksville. Walking in I was greeted…read moreimmediately by the staff with great attitude and enthusiasm. I realized right away they have a lot of choices and interesting toppings. You can get a whole pizza or order by the slice. I couldn't choose a single pizza so I ordered two different slices. They gave a couple tables outside to enjoy the elements but also a table and counter seating area inside if you want to be inside. You can watch them making pizza; from stretching the dough, saucing, topping to cooking. So much fun to watch. Taste is AWESOME!! I truly loved the pizza. The toppings, perfect amount of sauce and great crust. The crust is the secret to me. Great tasting, nice crunch and just a slight sweet taste. I suggest trying this place out if looking for a pizza night.

    This place is awesome! It's small and BUSY! There's good reason for the latter. The pizzas are…read moreunique with fresh, high-quality ingredients and house-made dough. They sell both by the slice and whole pie. From what I observed, you can create your own whole pizza in person by selecting various slices available, which is a great option because they all look delicious. We ordered a whole Italian Bomb and were not disappointed. It was one of the best pizzas we've ever eaten, and the price was very reasonable. If you're in the area, check this place out. As I mentioned, it's very busy, so your best option for getting a whole pizza before they run out of dough for the day is to order a few hours early and schedule a time for pickup.

    Photos
    Craig Street Pizza - Right on the corner of Craig and Hirst.

    Right on the corner of Craig and Hirst.

    Craig Street Pizza - Sweet & Spicy sausage

    Sweet & Spicy sausage

    Craig Street Pizza - Roasted garlic, artichokes, and arugula. My favorite!

    See all

    Roasted garlic, artichokes, and arugula. My favorite!

    Cuckoo Italian Trattoria & Pizzeria - Carbonara

    Cuckoo Italian Trattoria & Pizzeria

    3.7(146 reviews)
    21.2 km
    $$

    We've had lunch at Cuckoo's once before so we knew pretty much what we were getting ourselves into…read more It's decorated in quite a traditional manner, and currently set up for Christmas. The floors look to be original hardwood, and there are lots of beams and logs to see. I personally love the old style look, but it might not be to everyone taste. The service is quite good, our server especially, although it did seem like one individual was more interested in polishing glasses and not running food or bussing tables. He was a little passive aggressive with another staff member when he did run a couple of plates, came back and said "see that wasn't that hard." Not a good look. The food was quite good, although we felt, this time like the last, it was a little on the expensive side. It is quite a tourist mecca just outside of Parksville so that's likely part of the reason. It's also quite busy so clearly people are willing to pony up. We had the soup of the days Chantrelle mushroom soup. Evidently those mushroom are very plentiful in the area this time of year. It was quite good, creamy for sure, but we would have liked some more noticeable bits of mushroom. We also shared a Caprese salad which needed more balsamic and a little salt. The capers were a nice add. We finished with Margherita pizza which was nicely cooked and finished with fresh basil. Can't believe I am saying this, but there was too much cheese on it and maybe a little shy on the tomato sauce. Peroni beer on tap is a total winner for me. Have been twice, might go again, but likely not.

    Food was great, service was attentive. The restaurant is beautiful and calm inside. I highly…read morerecommend saving room for dessert!

    Photos
    Cuckoo Italian Trattoria & Pizzeria - The wood fired oven

    The wood fired oven

    Cuckoo Italian Trattoria & Pizzeria
    Cuckoo Italian Trattoria & Pizzeria - Bread provided was very nice

    See all

    Bread provided was very nice

    Nickolini's Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...