Excellent pizza! Reminded me of my childhood really. Fresh ingredients, amazing flavors, and the fastest delivery you could wish for! This is our go to from now on. Thank you thank you thank you! Highly recommend!!!! read more

I don't know why anyone would give this establishment less than five stars. By far my favorite pizza, 2nd only to Golden Boy in North Beach SF. I love their crust and the toppings are always fresh. The staff is super friendly and my pizza is always ready in a timely manner. For the quality of the pizza, I think the price for the pizza is very fair. read more

My family was really impressed with the cheese pizzas we bought here. Hot, cheesey and the crust was perfect. My mom loved it and I rarely ever hear her talk so glowingly about pizza. I will definitely be ordering from here more often. I really recommend NY (style) pizza! read more

Recently visited this pizza spot and overall had a really positive experience. The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with quality ingredients. The pizzas had a great balance of toppings and sauce. Crust is not too thick or too thin. Prices were reasonable for the quality, and the portion sizes felt worth it. Only thing is parking might be challenging. Updated menu pics posted. read more

See all

My bf and I were staying in South City for his bday weekend and we were looking for a pizza spot near the area. We came across this place and it seemed to have good reviews. We came by on a rainy night so we decided to dine in. They have quite a few menu items. We ended up getting a large pepperoni pizza and cheese bread. Worker was very nice and recommended getting the cheese bread over the garlic bread, and it was a great decision. Food came out in a timely manner. Lots of people were coming in and out for pick ups too. Pizza was really good. Nice crust, good amount of pepperonis. Overall, great spot. Would come back if im ever in the area. read more

New York Pizza - Pepperoni pizza large - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

See all

I order pizza from this place once or twice a month because it's close by the house and it's delivered HOT!! It's not the best pizza I've eaten, but it's consistent. Yesterday I decided to try something different, so I ordered a chicken parm sandwich and a meatball sandwich to share with my husband. When I opened the door to grab the bag, I could smell something burnt. I took the bag to the kitchen and unraveled it, both sandwiches were beyond toasted, THEY WERE BURNT, Including the meatballs! I got on the phone and called them immediately. I explained my situation and the man on the other line told me that he was sorry but next time I should ask for the sandwich to be lightly toasted! WTF??????? I was dumbfounded at his response and told him again the sandwich was burnt and not edible. He apologized again and hung up! i'm done! I try to support local business but will not support this business again, terrible customer service. read more

New York Pizza - Chicken Parmesan Sandwich and Meatball Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

See all

We got an extra large NY special pizza. The toppings were well balanced but I was kind of hoping the crust would be a bit more toasty on the bottom. The pizza was a bit more on the salty side but overall still a decent pie! We're always trying out different pie spots around the area. read more

New York Pizza - New York Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

Had a New York Special the other day. $42.00 with tax. Wow! Pizza getting expensive these days. It was delicious. Should have gotten the King Kong though. Will do that next time. Called it in. Was ready when I got there in less than 30 mins. Great they have a parking lot on the side. read more

Hot spot for buffalo wings!!! Very friendly staff, easy to assist I asked for extra crispy wings and they were perfect. A little hole in the wall of San bruno perfect for lunch. Stop by you won't regret. read more

New York Pizza - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

Excellent pizza. Loved the King Kong size. Fed a lot of people. Fast free delivery. Well deserving of a generous tip for both cooks and delivery driver. read more

If I ever crave pizza in the area I always come here, cooked delicious and crispy every time. Front counter workers always greet me with a great attitude. Thanks for having me once again !! Try them out you won't regret it! read more

New York Pizza - Pepperoni & Italian Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

Their sauce really stood out throughout all the topping.Really got my attention How they were able to delivered as noted,got thru all the construction.Delivery guy was very friendly read more

Slices are massive! Hit the spot but what sets this place apart is the service - whoever helped us tonight was the man!

The pizza i ordered it was great and the drop off it was cool. One thing is that the location for walk ins is quite inconvenient but its good to have a pizza pot there, besides everyone enjoy their product. Thanks yall read more

Great service from the owner, very fresh garden salad and pizza iis great-being from Chicago asked for extra crispy and it was perfect read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

This is hands down the best pizza I have ever had, they make the pizza fresh and the sizes and pricing are perfect. The workers are friendly and also the inside of the restaurant is so cool, with all the murals. Will definitely come back soonnn!! read more

Been ordering for years, they have good pizza. The King Kong pizza is huge , I usually get the pineapple pepperoni

Last time, my husband got sick after we had pizza from this location. We recently tried the same pizza at San Mateo location, and the difference was significant -- the quality there was much better. I'd encourage you to focus on consistency across all locations to ensure the same high-quality experience everywhere. read more

Good food god service excellent location close to the airport and 101 they have multiple options to chose from and they always very polite and accommodating read more

Pizza is always solid and delivered hot. Never have had a problem and recommend highly

This is the second time I pay for a large and they deliver a medium. Check it before you pay and tip the driver. I won't be ordering again. Fool me one shame on you fool me twice... thats it read more

The tag line is, "Doesn't get any better than this"..... my reply: uh yes it does! The sauce is so sugary, the cheese is subpar and the toppings are no better than arcade pizza. The dough is really a shame. It is no way anything like a true New York pizza. Out of respect they should change their name to: San Bruno pizza. The size of a large is more like a medium and it is so over priced for what it is, but I understand that inflation plays a part. In my opinion 1 large cheese and 1 large pepperoni here are worth $10 at max. Service is not great, but not bad either... it's just whatever. The place itself did look clean and orderly. In a word: joyless read more

See all

Pretty decent pizza but they certainly didn't have to many toppings on the pie. Perhaps I caught them on the end of a cycle. It was like 2 slices of pepperoni on each piece. read more

Bury me with the sweet chili wings. If you're going to get something, please get that. Pizza is good, but the wings are amazing.

This place is pretty good. It's not bad for a pizza place. They have a TV for you to watch sports while eating pizza. Their pizza is pretty good. It's kind of hard to mess up a pizza. I usually get cheese or combo pizza. The pizza is nice and hot. Its thin base is nice and its New York styled pizza. The staff is nice and always greeting you at the door. The tables though are a little bit old, but it's whatever. That doesn't matter. As long as the pizza is good and tastes good, that all that matters. read more

Fast, Hot and good Pizza. A little pricey, but what isn't these days! I would order again!

Good food and A ton of different options to chose from Amazing service definitely will be coming here more often

Our favorite pizza spot! If you like thin, crispy delicious NY pizza this is the place! Great place to watch the game and have a drink and enjoy good pizza. Great serive too. read more

New York Pizza - Pesto Augustus Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

Door dashed. Well packaged(microwaveable). Good portion(spaghetti). Tasty, low sodium Well priced.

Meh. This isn't even remotely like New York style pizza. It's passable at best. One of our pizzas seemed overcooked. Overall, it's not bad, but kind of a level above dominos. Someone recommended this place to us. Never trusting their taste again. read more

Great pizza. Get the BBQ chicken one. The sweetness of the BBQ sauce goes really well with the chicken and all the ingredients. The crust is perfectly thin and the toppings are generous. We also got a cheese pizza. This is just standard and I don't know if I'd recommend. The wings are $8.99 which was a bit steep because they were so tiny and it was maybe 7-8 of them haha. I wouldn't get these again but I would definitely get the pizza again. It was speedy and ready for pickup! read more

New York Pizza - BBQ chicken pizza. X large - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

All meat pizza is always perfect, and the salads are crisp and delicious, with excellent homemade ranch. Crust is crispy with a good chew, and perfectly cooked. The guys working are always so nice! read more

New York Pizza - All Meat - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

I had a great delivery experience with a fairly short wait time. The pizza arrived hot and fresh still.

Naw bro. This is not the place for quality pizza. Pizza was all dried out like it was sitting under a heat lamp for hours. Everything was all hard and crispy like it was old. Even almost crack my tooth on something I think might have been bacon. read more

New York Pizza - Naw bro - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

I have been ordering from New York Pizza the past six months and I have to give them 5 stars. We usually order the King Kong sized combination for big parties. The quality of food far exceeds my expectations. Their menu provides many choices. Go ahead and give these folks a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Pasta was good. It came with garlic bread for free. Pizza was okay. Spicy all around so i couldnt remove the jalapeño for my son to eat. But thats a good thing for us adults read more

New York Pizza - Chicken and jalepeno - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

See all

Pizza is just like in New York! Super thin, super crispy and a giant slice cut in half. Service is always amazing and the restaurant is always super clean! Best pizza in the area, our go to spot to watch the game, have a beer and good bite. read more

New York Pizza - La Super Combo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

I swung by because I had to stay four hours past my shift and the spot is fairly close. I wasn't expecting too much and I got exactly that. I honestly believe that the pizza dough they use is frozen. There was no way, that it was fresh. I also looked at the rest of the menu and it's a bunch of frozen items cooked to order. I was satisfied with the Caesar salad though. I think I've been spoiled by Totos Pizza. read more

New York Pizza - Pretty Fat For A Slice! - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

Good pizza for a party! Ordered takeout here today for our office and we were pleasantly surprised by the size and quality! It wasn't the best pizza I have ever had but it certainly wasn't the worst. I really liked the more basic pizza that we ordered. The "meat lovers" really didn't have enough toppings to make it deserving of its title. The pepperoni and cheese pizzas however were great! The pizza was way more greasy than I am used to which was a negative. Where this pizza really wins is size! If you are buying for a large group you really can't go wrong. And they can have your order ready fast! So in short if you want a good solid pizza and have a large group to feed. This is your spot! read more

New York Pizza - Great cheese pizza! - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

See all

Okay, for the large KING KONG sized pizza we've gotten twice already, it's pretty delicious! Who'd thought? But really, the pepperoni was crisp and the cheese was cheesy stretchy! For the value that we got, we were able to have it for 2 days, not too bad! Not bad for also finding this place on Yelp! Also didn't expect the King Kong sized pizza to be as big as it was when I first went there! read more

New York Pizza - GIANT pizza, this is their 2 topping, king Kong Pizza! HUGE! - Pizza Near Me - San Bruno, California

See all