The pizza here is really only a three, but because they have a great staff and a fun facility for birthdays, I give it a four overall. I know my son was really grateful to have celebrated his birthday there. There is a small arcade right across from the birthday room, so that was a big bonus. The staff was very accommodating and made great recommendations. The pizza itself could have a firmer crust to hold up all the toppings as it was pretty floppy. But really, I went back for a second slice of this really large pizza, which was fun. They do have a good selection of beer. I'm not huge on hops, so wheat or light is best for my wife and I. They had a great one. Some places that's hard to find. We've been here a few times and I'm sure we'll be back again! read more

New York Pizza Dept - The pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Post Falls, Idaho

See all

We called to order a pizza for delivery and the staff said they could not deliver because they were short staffed. So we started an order to pick up. They could not accommodate all the toppings because they were "out" of bell peppers. After a $60 dollar order, without any effort for compensation on the lack of delivery or toppings, we ended up with a half cooked pizza similar to a chucky cheese style pizza. So disappointing. read more

Love, love, love this place. We drive in all the way from Colville to get pizza here. Pizzas are huge and soooo good. Perfect amount of cheese, topping, sauce to dough ratio. Place is always clean and staff are friendly. If you are planning to get to go on a Sat make sure you call your order in with plenty of advance notice as they can get pretty busy. Best pizza around for miles. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places. The single slices are so big, I usually can't finish one. Last night we got our first full pizza and it was amazing! The Central Park. Highly recommend! read more

Omg! This is a true family run business and the food is incredible good! If you like mushrooms, you will love the batter on the mushrooms, good flavors and crisp. We had the chance to join family as they went to a police K9 fundraiser. When we come back we will stop for another great meal. I highly recommend a trip here. read more

My new favorite pizza place!! Was super impressed by the quality of the pizza and the size for the cost is pretty amazing! Service was very accommodating and nice staff overall! Loved the feel of the place too I took my order to go but would have loved to stay and enjoy my pizza there felt very nice! read more

New York Pizza Dept - Pizza Near Me - Post Falls, Idaho

Food was great, Would do again What could I say,great food, food was prepared in a timely manner read more

Good pizza with crust that reminds us of east coast, like the name says, New York. Not fancy at all but clean and service is friendly and fast. So 4-stars? Yes. It is a pizza joint and does it well. read more

I cater lunch for my work weekly Tuesday-Thursday for approximately 80 people each day. I called to get information on the sizes of the pizzas so I would know how many pizza's I would need to accommodate that amount of people. The male I spoke with was extremely rude and condescending. I will be taking our business elsewhere to a restaurant that appreciates their customers and understands the importance of good customer service and treating people with respect. Major loss for NYPD! read more

Pizza and food were really good. Service was awful. Ordered pizza at 7. They took 45 mins for our pizza which would have been fine but then they rushed us to leave. Not a very good company to treat people like that. They literally brought our pizza out and told us we had to go. Sounds like your problem it took you 45 mins to cook our pizza not mine. If you don't want to be there that's not my problem. Hope you enjoy our $200 plus $50 tip to be treated like garbage and they are stingy. read more

I mean, the food is good but a veryyyyy long wait time and a veryyyy high price but great staff

Huge slices, and great prices. I got the giant slice and soda for $7+tax and it was awesome. They put 2 toppings of your choice on it, too. And they didn't skimp. Pleanty of toppings to choose from. And it was fast. Best Pizza in Post Falls or CDA for my money. 100% will be returning! read more

Cool owners and huge slices at a decent price! I try to grab a slice whenever I'm in the area. I live an hour away. I do prefer sausage chunks instead of crumbles tho. Not a deal breaker. read more

It would be nice if they posted their hours and the days that they are closed! I stopped in here. Last time I was in town, and it was good enough that I was going to try again to offer an honest review. But when I drove out of the way to go here, the place was closed on Sunday and Monday. read more

Solid New York style pizza that will surprise you based on the location in a strip mall. Great $7 dollar lunch special.

Extremely high prices for what it is. We paid $50 for a medium pizza and cheese bread and a drink. And the dough was RAW! And it isn't even that good. Not to mention the cheese bread was pre made and they just heated it up in the microwave.. It was a very long wait and not worth the price. And the staff definitely don't give very good customer service either. $50 for bad service and and raw pizza. Will not be going again. read more

Great pie! And nothing like the 1-star princesses (who never post pics) have stated. All the gals in there were friendly while busy as heck, getting creamed on a Saturday afternoon. Their crust is a tweener, meaning, not too thick or too thin, and had a nice chewy finish. Red sauce is excellent, nice amount of cheese, and toppings were just right. A slight knock on one of the combos we ordered was the toppings were all a little too much to the center, but I showed my gals a perfect--and unconventional--way to eat the slices. Shoulda got a pic of that mess, haha. Enjoyed their rib tip app, as well. It's great to see these guys are part of the renaissance of the old outlet mall in PF... read more

See all

I came here for lunch and ordered the combo sandwich (half). It was delicious and good size portion. Very friendly service and nice open space if you have a larger party. I will be back! read more

Much better this time. I came at lunchtime and had a perfectly reheated slice. It was delicious. Really a 3.5 but I rounded up.

Pizza by the slice! Love it! And the slice is a large portion. Great lunch special. Slice of pie with 2 toppings and a drink for $7. Well worth it read more

Amazing pizza! Awesome staff! Glen has a gem in the New York pizza department. Stop by for a cigar next door at Stogies!

Place has been fairly hit or miss. There's a woman who is almost always there I think she is the owner and whenever she's there by herself it's perfect. Sometimes when there's a bunch of people it's not as good. Like I got it last night and it was VERY greasy almost inedible. A few times the slices have tasted like they either weren't cooked or reheated right. Not sure what goes on here at night but if you go in right as the store opens you can get a giant fresh slice and drink for $7. read more

New York Pizza Dept - Giant slice of pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Post Falls, Idaho

Lunch special is amazing. MASSIVE slice of pizza and soda for a few bucks. Pizza is amazing. It's simple, no crazy garlic crust nonsense. I love going here with my wife for a quick lunch break. Good music and always friendly staff. read more

Woah, so rude and short tempered. Felt like ordering my food was a burden to the staff member in the kitchen. I understand the employee is stressed, I understand you might be short staffed but I Do Not understand why you have to be rude to me and my family. Also waiting 30 min for two slices of pizza? I don't care how good your food is if you have poor attitude and you don't ridicule your customer for cancelling part of the order to hopefully expedite two slices of pizza. You know we are less than 30 feet apart... we can listen to you being unprofessional. Maybe if the lady prepping didn't spend so much time complaining about how she can't catch up and instead focused on catching up she might be able to put out some orders in a timely fashion. I think I caught em on a bad night but bottle selection is great if you like stouts and barrel aged but almost all bottles aren't kept cold. read more

This is a great New York slice! We had the lunch special with a slice bigger than my head. It was delicious. They had a nice beer selection too. I had a Cold Smoke for $2.50, very cheap for a pint. We also took some BBQ wings home, they put this 'luv' spice sprinkle on them and that was a great surprise. We're coming back for the fried mushrooms next. read more

New York Pizza Dept - Lunch special slice with 2 toppings and a Cold Smoke draft. Yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Post Falls, Idaho

See all

Approved by a New Jersey pizza snob! Pizzas are enormous and tasty! Friendly staff, outdoor seating for those traveling with little yappy dogs . Definitely will come back! read more

New York Pizza Dept - Pizza Near Me - Post Falls, Idaho

See all

Went and had a slice and a drink for lunch. The slice was huge for sure and the crust was very good. I got sausage and jalapeño and enjoyed it. I have to go back a try a whole pie to see the difference then maybe even higher rating. See them again soon. read more

We walked in at 7:33 on a Friday night and we were turned away. The food here is good, but this experience will keep me away for a while. We drove from across town this evening and were turned away at the counter. If we'd walked in the door just three minutes earlier, we would've been welcome to sit and enjoy dinner with the other people already sitting with their dinners. Even when the lady at the cash register pleaded with her manager to let us stay, the manager wouldn't allow it. Just to be clear, the restaurant was still open. They would've happily taken our money and let us sit inside until the pizza was ready. Then they would've pushed our family outside into the 36° cold to actually eat it. I'm sure they've got very important reasons why they cared more about those three minutes than serving us and our kids. But that doesn't change the fact that tonight their priority was to watch us walk out into the cold rather than let us enjoy a family dinner in their dining room. read more

Who knew it was even in Riverbend. Stopped on impulse, and was pleasantly surprised. Nice, clean, well built pizza.

First time in. High prices long wait for pizza, wrong pizza made and lack luster layout. Pizza mediocre at best.

Yummy pizza and beer. They are big supporters of people in uniform which I love. The pizza slices at lunch are the size of my huge head

Good pizza Anna nice service. Would try it again when I visit. Prices compatible with other local areas Pizza places

Moving here from New York City a little more than a year ago, I was craving some good thin crust pizza, and thought I'd give this place a try. Their website ordering could use some improvements as I always have trouble when trying to order from my iPhone. When I finally made my order I was super happy with the pizza. It tasted fresh and was loaded with my favorite toppings. Could have ate the whole thing to myself, but had to share with the kids. read more

They changed the name it's the same owners. Pizza is still average and too high price for the quality. Pay $30 for a pizza and they still charge you for some ranch. I know the last name had some bad reviews on the owners attitude. I didn't see any bad attitudes. Just very average pizza. Kids had a hard time eating because the entire top of pizza all comes off in one slide. read more

Consistently delicious pizza, beers & wine selection. All staff is always friendly and always ensures your pizza was made to order before you leave. read more

This spot is serving a limited dine-in or to-go menu and it is spot on! Oversized serving size (MASSIVE PUZZAS) and quality ingredients. The sandwiches are HUGE! And did I mention how tasty? There's a great bar and they even have Fleur de Cana rum - killer vodka, wine and more. We look forward to visiting again. Put this place on time list! read more

New York Pizza Dept - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Post Falls, Idaho

See all

Gave it two visits before reviewing, but 2nd visit no better than the first. 1st visit we spent $50 on two 18-inch cheese pies, but when we got home (just the other side of the freeway), couldn't believe how undercooked and over-cheesed. 2nd visit, got an order of garlic bread sticks and two slices and the only thing edible was the cheese slice. Sticks were almost raw and literally drenched in butter. Sausage slice was unrecognizable. read more

Good pizza, great lunch deal. The slice of pizza was huge and flavorful. They also have a good selection of craft beer.

This is one of the few spots myself, my wife, and all four kids agree on for dinner. Enormous pizza and definitely worth every penny. Plus it has Irish death on tap. They have a great reward program and amazing food. I absolutely love supporting this place. read more

First let me say the pizza was really good but the rest of our experience will insure we never go back. We walked in excited that this business was finally back up and open again. We stepped up to the counter to order our pizza and were met by an older teenager with a scowl on her face who acted like we were interrupting her and this was the last place on earth she wanted to be. She barely spoke to us and the scowl never left her face. The décor in the new place is dark gray, drab, cold and uninviting. It's very "industrial". The floor looks like it's in the middle of a construction project. Another teen delivered our pizza after a fairly long wait considering we were the only customers in the place and presented two flimsy paper plates, no forks for us to eat our pizza with. We find eating off paper plates unappealing at best but since we knew from past experience they claimed they had no place to wash dishes we brought our own plates and forks. Never once did any of the what I counted to be 2 owners and 4 or 5 teen/young adult workers come over to our table to inquire if our pizza was OK. Three of the young workers resembled the owners and one girl even called one owner mom. We assumed at least 3 of the 4 young workers were being forced to work in their parents pizza shop against their will. That was the vibe in the place. We put our pizza in a to-go box and waved a goodbye as several workers stood behind the counter in complete silence. Like I said, the pizza was good but nothing about the rest of our experience rates more than a -1 on a scale of 1 - 5. Oh, and did I mention there are several not so subtle political statement signs on the walls for decorations? Obviously this is a Republican leaning family which is none of my business but we don't expect it to be shoved in our face when we dine out either. The business isn't open on Sunday, a prime day to sell pizza especially during football season. I mentioned that when ordering and the girl all but hissed at me saying "we have to go to church". You could see her disgust at me for even suggesting Sunday being a day one might sell pizza. We came to support a once struggling and relocated business but this was our last experience with New York Pizza Department. Get your pizza to go if you like the pizza and forget about a pleasant dining experience. You won't get it here. We won't be back. read more