Bagels were good! The cinnamon sugar bagel was an unexpected hit! The bagels had a great consistency and were really good. The everything bagel was also nicely seasoned. Customer service was on point and helpful in addressing a mix-up with our order, even with a steady stream of customers coming in. Give them a shot! read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Service was meh. Bagels were meh. As somebody that grew up in NY I can confirm these are not NY bagels.

I have never have written a review before but felt the need to after my horrible experience. We typically go to barrier island bagels- which i highly recommend. Their bagels are the best and the costumer service is beyond excellent. We decided to try NY bagels. Never again- I have never experienced such rude costumer service. I see that it is often stated in these reviews that the employees at this shop are "busy" and therefore they are perceived as rude. They were not busy and were still super rude. Go to Barrier island! read more

AMAZING BAGELS AND SANDWICHES I'm from out of town and stopped here for a breakfast bagel and they did not disappoint! I had cheese everything bagel sandwich with sausage egg and cheese and garlic herb cream cheese and was very happy. Price is very reasonable as well!!! Very kind lady working the counter aso threw in my coffee for free and was very sweet! If you are in the area stop here for a fast and delicious breakfast! Was also very happy with the Texas Pete hot sauce on my table! Self service syrups for cold brew was also nice touch. read more

New York Bagels - Breakfast bagel and cold brew - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Great service & folks here. Best bagels around & the spreads weren't too overpowering of allll that good bagel-ness! Bought a bunch home to freeze. read more

Bagels are a very light color, dense as they should be, but a little on the small side. I was happy to see a NJ favorite on the menu; a pork roll, egg & cheese (Taylor ham) but it wasn't anything special. Minimal meat. Cheese wasn't melted. It wasn't made as the hot, hardy, gooey sandwhich it should be. Coffee was fine but they didn't have any creamer. Powdered creamer was the only option. That's fine for free coffee at the mechanic, but when I'm paying for it put out some cream! (Woman behind the counter was very friendly and offered to pour some milk in, which I appreciated). In short, it wasn't a bad place but I would not go out of my way to go back. Did not remind my of a NY bagel, despite the name. read more

New York Bagels - Kind of a weak take on a pork roll breakfast sandwich, but I appreciate the effort and the service was very friendly. - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Visited in the morning to purchase a dozen bagels & cream cheese. The female attendant was not cheerful or very welcoming. Display case had a few of the various types and they were placed in a plastic bag. I had to ask for knives & napkins since they weren't placed in the bag. I still left a tip on-screen for which no 'thank you' was offered. I was gifting them to tax preparers who volunteer their time. Prior to delivering them I squeezed each through the bag & got the impression they were leftover from the previous day as I'm ell-aware what a fresh bagel should feel like. I don't know of reactions by the recipients to be fair to the store. I won't be returning. read more

I really enjoyed my visit to N.Y. Bagels. The ambiance is nice and welcoming, making it a comfortable place to hang out. Their coffee is actually good, and the cheese everything bagel I ordered was solid, the scallion cream cheese is very good, definitely hit the spot. It's a great local find for a quick breakfast or a relaxed morning. read more

So how does a bagel shop run out of bagels at 9 am? How do you survive? 2nd time coming here and second time out of bagels....won't be a 3rd......and they didn't even care. read more

The customer service ordering the food was friendly and helpful. Bagels were fresh and there was plenty of variety to choose from. Will go back again when we're there again. Plenty of parking. read more

Smells SO good when you walk in. Like fresh bread and savory toppings. Ordered the Norwegian, and it was so warm and toasted when she handed it to me. Lots of drink selections! They were quick. Ordering, preparing and walking out the door in no time. We will be back! read more

See all

Is this a N.Y. bagel? No. But it was a good bagel. Nothing special, but good. Bagels are a good size (not the size of your head NY bagels) and taste good. Not many shops in the area so I'll take what I can get! read more

Ordered a plain bagel with cream cheese. After over 20 minutes of waiting and watching other people get their orders first, I asked the cashier who rudely told me my order was in line to be made. Food came out about 30 mins after ordering. This is a complete mess of a business. I highly recommend not going if there is any line. They don't have any ability to handle even a small crowd. Dreadful experience. The bagel was fine but the experience waiting sort of ruined it for me. If you are going here I would go during off times; non weekend or call ahead. Don't expect good service. read more

Quick efficient service from a nice lady. The bagels were delicious, hot and very good! We really enjoyed our breakfast. My husband got an everything bagel with egg and bacon, and I got an everything with cheese and cream cheese. We were super happy with the flavors and texture of the bagels. They also have coffee and you can add whatever flavors/sauces as you like and sugar and half and half. Couldn't ask for a better breakfast! Plus they are open on Monday morning in April...which a lot of other places are not, so that is great! read more

The owner of this place is the nastiest human being I've had the unpleasant experience of meeting. Picture a tall, mean, woman that looks like she could kick your butt... with compression socks. I was legit scared of her. So here's the deal. Two days ago, I stood in line & paid for 4 bagels. Paid about $8 & change, left a tip... then was told to wait. After waiting a stupid long time, I said nicely, I'll just come back tomorrow to pick them up. I'm on vacation with family. Due to unforeseen circumstances, could not pick up the next day... so I went the following morning. I explained the situation to the owner... and very rudely, she insisted that I re-pay for the bagels, bc she made them "special for me", (no, they were your average, sellable, garlic bagels)... rolled her eyes, saying she'll give me a discount. Fine. I waited in line, patiently, I get up to the front and explain the situation to the worker. She wanted to just give them to me, but I was honest & explained I was told to pay again. My discount? About $.50. Basically, I just paid again. The woman working was apologizing all over herself bc none of this made sense. So I'm now sitting in my car, confused & contemplating why the heck did I just have to pay double for bagels that first weren't ready for me, bc I wasn't ready for them?! ‍ I feel like I should have said something, fought a little harder... but I'm white. I didn't want people pointing & calling me a Karen. Plus, like I said, I was scared she would beat me up:( read more

New York Bagels - The bagel that stole my dignity. - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

A perfectly ok breakfast sandwich. The blueberry bagel wasn't super blueberry flavor, and it needed to be toasted a little more. Great service, though. And the lines are shorter than any other nearby breakfast care type places. read more

New York Bagels - Bacon, egg, and cheese on a blueberry bagel - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Placed a large to go order. Bagels were made fresh and still warm. Also ordered 3 types of cream cheese. Everything was delicious, staff was friendly, would definitely go back. read more

got a to go bagel it was big and delicious Service was fast and friendly Smallish store, but ok to sit and eat alone but not great for a conversation Sit outside for that read more

We needed quick breakfast food and stopped by NY Bagels. I was nervous that they were close to closing & they would not have any bagels or they would be old but we were able to get fresh ones! Staff was very friendly! The bathroom was really nice and super clean which is always a good thing! read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Bagel is good, but egg is gross. Not the pleasantest place to eat. Good service. Would come again, but just creamed cheese.

we ordered 3 bagels total and the lady rang it up for us. The nice girl making the bagels handed us two, we let her know that there was supposed to be 3 total. She said oh I'm sorry I'll make that for you right now. Then the original lady that rang us up comes back out with an attitude telling us the price of the third bagel. No apology. Just straight attitude. We were already waiting and assumed she was already making it. By this point we just let her know we didn't want the 3rd bagel because her attitude was awful. Learn some customer service lady and the business will go a long way. read more

A+++ Service and delicious bagels. I'm currently on vacation with my family and this morning stopped by to get 12 bagels and cream cheese and were freahly-made and delicious. Also, I accidentally left my debit card at the store and two hours later I called them and they were super nice to have put it away and protected me from getting it stolen and returned it. Super class, I will definitely comeback for bagels anytime and would recommend to anyone not only for their bagels but also for an outstanding business read more

New York Bagels - N.Y. Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Breakfast bagels are really really good! I got the bacon egg and cheese bagel on vacation and would go again!

Love the delicious sandwiches, fair prices, and the ability to get a turkey club for breakfast-- for our non egg loving people.

A toasted bagel it was not. Heated perhaps? Small selection of bagels but we were not impressed. Would not go back.

If you've never been to New York or had a bagel, perhaps you can believe these are "New York Bagels". The bagels do not seem to be boiled, so they are more like rolls/bread. Boiling bagels give them that quintessential chew. Also, the bagels are weirdly small and light. Again, not characteristics of New York bagels. Are the bagels fine? Yeah. They lack flavor. Especially the cheese bagels. The service was good. No complaints there. Just wildly disappointed in the bagels themselves. read more

Very nice people and bagels were fresh. Bagels were 1.70 a piece which isn't cheap by my thought, but resort towns dictate a higher price which is understood. Bagels were ok. Closer to bread than the chewy ones I get in NY, NJ, and PA...but you're in NC and I really think it has something to do with the water used which makes a bagel have a certain taste/ texture in whatever area. A+ for effort and service. 3 stars IMO on the actual bagel. I WOULD try again. read more

Im new to the area and i was craving a breakfast bagel, but i don't eat pork so i asked if i could get turkey on my bagel instead and they were very accommodating. I don't think I'm a fan of everything bagels, but it was worth a try! This place is inexpensive and fulfilling, I will definitely be back read more

New York Bagels - Egg, Cheese, and Turkey on Cheese Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Went mid week to pick up bagels around 9 am. Quite a line and the buckets of bagels were semi empty apart from the "weird" ones (onion, everything etc). Was panicking a bit as was supposed to bring back food for 7. However when I got to the front the last told me they were making more, and even tailored the toppings on the batch to match what I needed, and a few minutes later I left with a bag full of hot bagels. I live in NY so am used to good bagels and these were pretty good. Being fresh out of the oven no doubt helped. They also sell cream cheese and coffee etc, plus bagel sandwiches. read more

This is the second time I walked out Black Friday - no selection No Plain Bagels Buisiness 101 - you can not make a profit if you csn not sell your product I am done ......other options for breakfast available read more

Worst service I have ever experienced on phone for a terrible bagel. So rude on phone and bacon was barely half cooked.

Good baegl.store in the outerbanks. They have a menu board when you walk in with funny named bagel sandwiches. I got the hangover cure which was double egg, double bacon and double cheese. Really good and filling. Small parking lot in from. Nice employees inside. read more

I was in the area and decided to look for a bagel shop since I love bagels. I found NY Bagels and decided to give them a try. I walked in and it was busy which I don't mind kept my distance(Covid times). It is a small shop with a few tables inside and a couple outside. They had several selections of bagels. I looked at their menu and was ecstatic that they had a BEC (bacon, egg and cheese). As I kept making my way up to counter I kept hearing a microwave. When it was my turn to order I asked them if they made their food with real egg and the cashier said no. I was DISAPPOINTED. I ordered a plain bagel with cream cheese and coffee. I waited for a few minutes before I got my order. When I got to my car I tried the coffee. It wasn't great. As far as my bagel it was ok. I've definitely had better. The staff was nice. But, I won't be going by there again. read more

New York Bagels - Menu (front) - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Good bagels. Delicious cream cheese. Good place to get a quick breakfast, although I am nut sure if eggs are cooked to order, seems they might have been prepared earlier. Still good place to get breakfast. read more

Let me start by saying that if you go by reviews you won't end up here. BUT if you look and see that most of the bad reviews or at least the credible ones are from 2014-2013. So we took the chance after I actually researched the reviews and realized YELP needs to have a time limit on them as in 2 years at most. SO... we went in and there was a line even at 9:30 which was a good sign. We ordered 3 bagels, 1 blueberry with cream cheese and 2 cheese, 1 with ham and egg and 1 with sausage and egg. The service was SUPER fast and SUPER friendly. The bagels themselves are fresh made in house and toppings are DELICIOUS and well put together (who wants a sloppy mess ). So next time before you just look at the stars on a place , make sure you first investigate how long ago they were from. Places change just like people change. read more

Delicious Bagels! Friendly and easy ordering process. Very clean and nice place. Recommend

OBSESSED! Idc what type of picky people reviews are on this place. My bf and I thought it was delightful. Absolutely delicious. These are bagels done right. Never had a NY bagel before but I don't even care because my taste buds were singing to me. We had a cheese bagel with garlic and herbs cream cheese, and then a plain bagel with strawberry cream cheese. First off, they don't skimp you on the cream cheese. They lay it on there! In a good way of course! Secondly, the texture of the bagels are on point. Chewy and thick in the inside and the top is a bit crispy. You hear a little snap when you bite into it. Exactly the way it should be! The only thing I was disappointed in, was the fact that I couldn't savor the last bite of my bagel because I ate it too fast. So damn good! So good, we went back the next day on the way back home to get some more. Please, do me a favor and stop in! read more

New York Bagels - Plain bagel w/ strawberry cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

The bagels were delicious! The service was excellent and super friendly! Definitely coming back!

Perhaps my review cannot be fair. Originally from NYC, I'm very skeptical of bagels. Came here based on reviews and we were not disappointed. These come very close to NY style bagels. Big and fluffy on the inside. Nice and firm on the outside. I like them a bit harder in the crust but overall excellent, excellent bagels. I was torn between a 4 and 5 starts. So as far as OBX goes, they are best bagels on the island. They had plenty of flavors to chose from and some were still warm at 11:30am. We got a lox cream cheese that was made to order, however was a bit shy of lox. read more

We went around 9 AM on a Saturday, and it wasn't extremely busy. The bagels were very good. We had blueberry, everything, and salt bagels with cream cheese. We also had a "health food" bagel which had all kinds of seeds on it in a egg and cheese sandwich which was very tasty. Overall, if you are visiting in the Outer Banks and want to get bagels, I recommended swing by and grab some. read more