Not sure what you all are rating so poorly. I was driving by and stopped for a quick slice. This…read moreplace rocks. One of the better slices I've had in a long time. Made my drive to toronto a bit more tolerable. Maybe they missed the mark on full pizzas. But they hit the mark on slices. Ask for it warmed for extra crunch!

Stopped in here on a drive from Markdale to Toronto over the holidays. Way better option than a…read moreboring ol' stop at Tim Horton's. Its super basic signage and interior might make you pass it by entirely, but its worth the stop if you're having a cheese and carb craving (which is almost always, am I right?) My driving companion and I each got a slice (a "garlic finger" for me and a "super" for him) and a couple o' dips (your standard Heinz roasted garlic and cheddar chipotle). They are BIG slices cut in two so you're basically getting two slices. Came to something like $14 total. Friendly staff and quick service. Would stop here again next time I'm coming through town.

In Shelburne for the weekend and kids wanted pizza. Decided to stop by and pick up some for the…read morekids. The location is very clean and well maintained, perhaps because it was fairly new built. The cashier was prompt and took our orders. Provided a time for the pizza to be ready but was ready a few minutes earlier than that. The pizzas were baked perfectly and topped sufficiently. Wish they had non-dairy crust and cheese available

Our family regularly orders from the Shelburne location and we are always happy with our delivery…read moreservice as well as our food. We got delivery today March 4, 2022 and it was FANTASTIC we changed up our regular order and got a feast veggie pizza and some wings, bites and a double pineapple pizza, the veggie pizza was so fresh and loaded with toppings, we're all stuffed. I called the store to compliment them and they were so gracious, I spoke directly with the person that made our order. Top notch all around

Its a takeout place, but food is make with love, and you can taste it!…read moreGet: Pep, bacon, pineapple, hot peppers and garlic sauce!

It was very greasy. Can't say anything else…read more People were nice and they seemed to know everyone that walked. Maybe it's just not to my taste.

Our Hawaiian and Pepperoni hit the spot! Minus not having the correct pizza sizes and had to split…read moreour order intro 2 different boxes

From the owner: Get 50% off some of your favourite regular priced medium pizzas: Hawaiian, Pepperoni Lover's,…read moreCanadian, and Margherita pizzas. Online Only. Limited Time.

Pizza was decent. Better than the budget pizza restaurant chains. Although I found the crust to be…read moreslightly burnt and they charge 2.4% extra to cover the cost of accepting credit cards. It wasn't mentioned at the time of purchase, and I didn't realize it until I got home. We are the pizza about 30 minutes after pickup, and found the crust to be hard and chewy. For the reasons of the pizza being burnt, the surcharge, the tough crust, and that there are many pizzarias to consider in Toronto instead, so I will not be returning.

Not sure why listed as closed. Clearly open today 9 July 2024. Going to give it a try…read more Update. Ordered the square pizza, requested thin crust, well done. It was cooked perfectly. Found the sauce a bit sweet but otherwise a decent pizza. Maybe ownership has changed but place is definitely open and a good option for a non-chain pizza if you live nearby.

Changed their pizza dough. Ordered two mediums, dough was very flat and not very good at all…read more Disappointing!

I have driven by this pizza place so many times... Always said to myself that I need to go in and…read moretry the pizza,.... well, today was the day! I went in, I grabbed four slices which are quite large and I walked out of there for under $25 including three pops a garlic dipping sauce and tip... Great customer service and a delicious cracker crust with an abundance of toppings put this pizza place a step above the rest! Well done!! Thank you! Zeke

This is my number one go-to pizza place in the Alliston area. Whether you arelooking for a quick…read moreslice or something to take home? Johnny's Pizza will not let you down.

The pizza was Cheesy, fresh & delicious. I am very glad we stopped in! The picnic tables outside…read morewere a Convenient place to stop and eat.

Honestly this is some of the best pizza iv ever had in my life perfect amount of cheese and other…read moretoppings. The staff are always great there's a manager there his name is Matt he's the nicest guy around and always makes you feel very welcome I'm happy to support a business with such great staff. Iv eaten inside the place as well great assortment of music great theme all in all I highly recommend the place.

Their claim is to be wood fired pizza restaurant, yet they're using gas ? don't get me wrong their…read morepizza is better than any of the so called pizza places and or chains, but they are doing a disservice to themselves, their customers and pizza by not relying on wood as its fuel source solely. The crust lacks the wood fired taste that only wood as the fuel source can achieve, you can't blend it and expect the same result, their dough did not have that malted taste you get from the traditional double 00 flour and 3 day formational process and leads me to believe it not proofed properly. If you claim to be something then be just that, don't misrepresent the process, thats just marketing not traditional pizza