Toppings 5/5 Dough 3/5…read more I found the dough to be a little chewy. The toppings were fresh and I enjoyed the tomato sauce. They put their pepperoni under the cheese. And as you can see they maximize the space on the pizza leaving a small amount of crust. I am new to the area not much options and the few options are extremely expensive I'm glad pizza express is able to keep their prices reasonable.

Absolutely the best pizza place in Caledon East. Ordered pizza there many times and am never…read moredisappointed by the taste and quality of the ingredients. Family run business who pride themselves in giving the best to their customers. It does get busy around the weekends, so suggest ordering well enough in advanced to get you order.

You know that smell you get when you open a cardboard box? Well..that smell but in your mouth when…read moreyou eat this pizza, it's tasteless and not even hot when it's served. I ordered a slice of pepperoni and cheese and it was like I asked Mussolini for his nona to lend me her wooden spoon to beat myself with, the service was so bad as they had nobody working the front counter, someone eventually came out of the washroom to take my order. Only Zeus knows if he washed his hands... I wouldn't return to this place if Regis Philbin showed up on my lawn with while riding a green donkey and holding a giant cheque. Save your money or just eat tree bark.

First visit last night. We went in 15 minutes to closing. Had the family with me. I have to say…read moretheir pizza is very good. The bottom of the dough was just had a very light crunch and from the first bite to the last bite of the dough was just perfect. Very friendly service. She was right I will be going back.

We were starving on our trip to Wiarton to go camping for the weekend. Maybe it was me thinking…read moreI'd have to cook on an open flame all weekend so I better get some substantial calories before I burnt everything that made me so hungry:p I told my fiancee to pull into any restaurant that didn't look deserted. We drove by A LOT and I finally yelled just go anywhere and Good Fellas popped up. Hesitant at first, I'm use to seeing tons of cars parked outside a restaurant or a lot of people inside (hey i'm from the city and this was my first camping trip) but the second I walked inside I knew that I may have spoke too soon. The size of the pizza reminds me of Big Slice down in toronto... still not sure which is bigger, but the girl at the counter was super friendly warmed up our pizzas for us and grab us a drink. I couldn't finish this SLICE pizza that is how big it was and I was STARVING. Listen I make all-you-can eat buffets regret their business motto so i'm telling you this slice was HUGE and delicious! I was really happy with the food. The place could use a bit of sprucing up, no one wants to see the foam under the cover of their chairs but hey the food still great! Great price I think two slices came up to $13 with a root beer, it was under $20 I just cant remember how much it was. Great work! Oh and for the people who live up in that area, they deliver!

On our drive home to Toronto and we were starving and didn't feel like the usual Tim Horton's or…read moreburgers/fries. Chose this place because of the decent reviews. Uhhhh.....this pizza gave us instant heartburn and was way too overcooked or overheated up. Sorry, not so much Goodfellas.

Great place just opened up!!…read more Really good pizza and wings. They have burgers, veal Param etc which we haven't tried yet. Location is in the Tim Hortons plaza in the corner. They do have a gluten free pizza crust! They have just been open for two weeks! I will have to add more when I try more items!

Had a dairy-free meat lovers panzerotti delivered tonight, and it was so good! The dairy-free…read morecheese is definitely different it's kind of sticky, so it's not the best on pizza, but in a panzerotti it was absolutely perfect. Wait time was about an hour, and the lady on the phone was super sweet

This is my number one go-to pizza place in the Alliston area. Whether you arelooking for a quick…read moreslice or something to take home? Johnny's Pizza will not let you down.

The pizza was Cheesy, fresh & delicious. I am very glad we stopped in! The picnic tables outside…read morewere a Convenient place to stop and eat.

The pizza here is awesome! Garlic bread is delicious! The wings didn't look like the ones we…read moreusually have at other places, but I was wrong to judge so early because they tasted amazing! This will be my go to pizza place in Tottenham from here on out!

Dough is raw , employees are rude and not a very friendly atmosphere. I don't recommend them at allread more

BEST PIZZA AND PASTA WEVE HAD IN YEARSSSS…read more omg, this place is INCREDIBLE! It's small and fills up quickly, so make a reso. I am TELLING you, though, it's incredible food. We have the vodka sauce pizza with fresh Mozz and pepperoni along with the homemade pasta with creamy pesto sauce (I added shrimp) and we were losing our minds. My husband and i agreed we've never had better pizza or pasta in Ontario. It's a cute little place, very romantic. Highly recommend for date night (maybe without little kids, that's the vibe i got).

Great service, fresh tasty food and refreshing drinks on a great patio. This is a great place for a…read moresummer meal on the outdoor patio. I would recommend this place to family and friends. The menu has a lot of variety. We finished the meal with an Espresso Almond syrup over ice. We are looking forward to coming back.

So-so pizza place with crust that's a bit too doughy, but still passable and pretty cheap.read more

Excellent food great customer service, Love there crust. Definitely different then the other…read morepizza joints. If your looking for something really special in a pizza......this is it!