Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Naptown Thrift

    5.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 7:00 PM

    Naptown Thrift Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Naptown Thrift

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 months ago

    Helpful 19
    Thanks 7
    Love this 23
    Oh no 0

    30 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Good prices! Rare finds. Very nice owners. Like a museum vibe. I take the time to go in here anytime I'm on this side of town.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Great staff and selection!!! So fun to look around d and great finds! Can't wait to go back!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Thrift Stores 3,135 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Second Treasures - Kid's clothes

    Second Treasures

    4.5(2 reviews)
    3.5 mi

    Thanks to fellow Yelper, Richard P., I found this little thrift store, which is in the basement of…read moreSt. Paul's Episcopal Church. The thrift store is opened to the public and sells mostly clothes (women's, men's and children's ) and shoes, with also a bit of vintage jewelry and women's accessories. I like rummaging through thrift stores and looking for unique vintage items. The volunteer staff is super friendly and helpful. Changing rooms are available to try on clothing. The small shop is well organized. Prices are very reasonable and proceeds benefit the food pantry. Jewelry was marked half price during my visit. I found a stunning artisan necklace, which I regret not buying. The shop is located behind the church and there is plenty of parking. The shop maintains the same hours as the adjacent food pantry, so the hours vary.

    I was fortunate to be able to catch the soft opening of Second Treasures, a thrift store opening up…read moreon a part-time schedule as part of Second Presbyterian Church's missions program. Second Treasures will be open about 10 hours a week with a particularly focus on supporting the needs of its Washington Township neighbors. It's patterned after the church's popular Bazaar and Clothing Sale and will support the work of the church's Women's Ministry. A good majority of the items are donated by church members and will be staffed by volunteers from the church. It's located at the North end of Second's Mission Suite (outside the Northside Food Pantry). The thrift store is opening to the public on Tuesday, April 23rd, and will be open on Tuesdays (12-3pm), Wednesdays (3:30-6:30pm), and Saturdays (9:30am-12:30pm). I was pleased with the items available and the prices at which they were marked. Clothing, of course, is quite popular here and there are items for men, women, children, etc. While you won't mistake this non-profit, church-based thrift store for one of the behemoths in terms of selection, this is a really cool idea for a great cause. Today's soft opening/open house was a great chance to get a feel for everything to be offered and how it all will work. Cash and credit cards are accepted. In terms of accessibility, there's plenty of accessible parking and doorways are pretty decent. This is on the first floor and accessibility should not be an issue. 5-stars might be a tad generous given the simplicity of the project, however, I'm always a fan of true non-profit, mission-based efforts and I'm anxious to see this one grow and truly support the Washington Township area.

    Photos
    Second Treasures - Second Treasures opening reception

    Second Treasures opening reception

    Second Treasures - Jewelry

    Jewelry

    Second Treasures - Entrance

    See all

    Entrance

    Good News Ministries - Exterior of our Men's Shelter.

    Good News Ministries

    4.7(6 reviews)
    5.8 mi
    $

    They provide excellent customer service and their items are reasonably priced. I have purchased…read moreeverything from clothing to dishes. The 2 broad rim hats were only $1 and they look brand new.

    Good News Ministries Thrift Shop is a small but mighty thrift shop that has existed quietly on the…read morecorner of East Washington Street and Rural since 2006 in what appears to have been a former Village Pantry. Falling under the umbrella of Good News Mission, a near-eastside ministry that started off as what one some would call a "homeless shelter" but has grown to include a youth center, supports for families, and even a neighborhood health clinic with a focus on the near-eastside. Good News Ministries Thrift Shop offers used or new clothing, furniture, appliances, household items, and much more. The thrift shop is run by residents from the men's shelter and offers them work experience and direct customer interaction. I drive by the thrift shop just about every single day on the way to work and had long been curious, however, I never stopped in until recently to finally check it out. Those who were working in the story were friendly and helpful. Rest assured that this is not a Goodwill store - it's smaller, less organized, and definitely more crowded and a bit run down. However, I found it to be clean and actually was surprised how much they actually had. 100% of the proceeds from the thrift shop help to support the various efforts of Good News Ministries. It's worth noting that this very much a ministry as is everything with Good News. There's a strong foundation of faith here, specifically Christian, and it radiates throughout their offerings. In terms of accessibility, I'd say the thrift shop offers casual accessibility. Yes, you can get in it and the actual environment typically will depend on what they have at the time. I generally had not much difficulty, but it's a bit hit-and-miss. Because it's an old Village Pantry, the building itself was generally designed with accessibility in mind. I've never seen an actual crowd here. The small parking lot has informal options for accessibility like aisle ends, etc. The thrift shop is catty-corner to the Good News 10-unit family shelter and right by the East Washington Branch Library. Would I return? Definitely. Prices are good, options are plentiful, customer service is casual but helpful, and Good News has been around since the 1950s and has a long history of helping those with housing instability. Since this is only their 2nd review, I think it's safe to say this highly visible but often unnoticed thrift shop is definitely an under-appreciated gem here in Indy and a terrific way of supporting Good News Mission. Oh, and yes, they do accept donations. You can visit their website to find out more.

    Photos
    Good News Ministries - Our Youth Center's amazing 3-story playground!

    Our Youth Center's amazing 3-story playground!

    Good News Ministries - Our Free Health Clinic, includes pediatric, women's health, dermatology, and optometry!

    Our Free Health Clinic, includes pediatric, women's health, dermatology, and optometry!

    Good News Ministries - Providing hope to Indianapolis since 1950!

    See all

    Providing hope to Indianapolis since 1950!

    The Toggery Resale Boutique - Amazing amount of designer labels at bargain prices at the Tog. And because I had consignment credit it cost me $10 for 6 pieces

    The Toggery Resale Boutique

    3.9(74 reviews)
    1.2 miBroad Ripple
    $$
    Established in 1986
    Free estimates

    Oh the places you'll go! I'm sitting here on vacation drinking my coffee early morning in my tank…read moretop I got for $3 from the Toggery. This place is the best! We came here on a sleepy Saturday afternoon and hit the jackpot because they were having a sidewalk sale with very nice prices. I walked away with Talbots, Athleta, Rock and Republic, Free People on clearance and splurged on a Lululemon sweatshirt for full price (still under $40 so no complaints there). Not only are the prices great but this store will make any organized persons heart sing! Amazing organization and flow of the store, kudos Toggery! I will be making another trip here next time in the Broadripple area.

    I found some designer jeans here for $50 that usually sell for about $200, and they are my favorite…read morego-to jeans, so that's cool. At first, I was a little disappointed in The Toggery because it seemed like the clothes were just a half step up from a regular Goodwill, but then I found the jeans, and now I'm not so sure. I think it all depends on when you shop, and what you're looking for. If you're looking for unusual vintage gems, you probably won't find that here. If you're looking for regional-trendy clothing ... you will probably find that here. I visited on a Saturday afternoon, and the racks seemed a little picked-through, but I think that's because this place is popular and so the racks probably were indeed picked through. They buy clothing during the weekdays, so if you want to find the good stuff, you should probably visit during the week, I'm thinking. The clothing is arranged very nicely, and everything is super organized and clean. They have dressing rooms available that you can just walk into (you don't have to flag down someone!), and they also have sale items that are pretty good. Like most consignment shops, they don't accept returns or exchanges, so make sure you're happy with your items before you purchase!

    Photos
    The Toggery Resale Boutique - I did some research and if I purchased these Toggery finds at full retail price it would have cost $745. I paid only $45.

    I did some research and if I purchased these Toggery finds at full retail price it would have cost $745. I paid only $45.

    The Toggery Resale Boutique - 1 sweater, 3 (1 new with tags) shirts, 1 dress, 1 new with tags VS bra, and 1 Yves Saint Laurent bag $20.33! I love The Toggery!

    1 sweater, 3 (1 new with tags) shirts, 1 dress, 1 new with tags VS bra, and 1 Yves Saint Laurent bag $20.33! I love The Toggery!

    The Toggery Resale Boutique - Designer clothes for days

    See all

    Designer clothes for days

    Vintage 54 Collective

    Vintage 54 Collective

    4.6(14 reviews)
    0.9 miSoBro
    $$

    We went to see about a 1960s German China set that was purchased by my mom when stationed in…read moreGermany. Bone white with a simple platinum ring, complete settings and all the extras for setting a great looking special table. This was the perfect spot to display and sell our tableware. . The variety and quality of the other items (collectible posters, art, home decor, even pet clothes) are superb. We enjoyed visiting with nice lady working there very much. We will go back next trip to the next door eating location. Thanks

    Last year on a cold winter day we stumbled on this place while eating at Liter House. It is a…read morelittle kept secret... a true gem! We now check it out on a regular basis and always find some unique items. Prices are excellent, especially when compared to other vintage shops. The true treasure of the sho are the people that run it. They are so delightful and always make you feel welcome. Many times they have helped add to a collection by offering suggestions and remembering us when we came in. Though we don't always buy something we always learn something. Their knowledge and helpfulness is fantastic. I appreciate all the unique serving pieces and kitchen things available. My husband loves the record collection. Give this place a try... Parking can be utilized on either side of the building. You will have to look for it the first time but it is easy if you look for the grey building next to Liter House.

    Photos
    Vintage 54 Collective
    Vintage 54 Collective
    Vintage 54 Collective - A nice little selection of cookbooks and cookware.

    See all

    A nice little selection of cookbooks and cookware.

    Naptown Thrift - thrift_stores - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...