Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mystery Thrift Store

    4.2 (6 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 4:00 pm

    Mystery Thrift Store Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mystery Thrift Store

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    A great little thrift store. A good variety of inventory at very fair prices. I make sure to stop in whenever I pass by.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Kyle W.

    Kyle W.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Kyle W.

    Kyle W.

    Robert, We appreciate your business and honest feedback! Thank you!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mystery Thrift Store

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Thrift Stores 1,119 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Trash to Treasures

    Trash to Treasures

    4.3
    (10 reviews)
    5.6 mi

    I always find treasure at this local female owned business. They have a great selection of…read morehousehold items, furniture, art supplies, books and more. Clothes & shoes are more hit & miss. Vintage earrings for $3. Handmade art for $5. A vintage wooden leg ironing board for $15! Really kind people, and truly old school thrift shop prices that all of us long time thrifters appreciate. The location has plenty of parking, and the shop is quiet and cozy.

    Horrible experience. Absolute waste of time. The store is a…read moretotal mess with items piled up everywhere, but that's her problem. What shocked me was her attitude: the moment I tried to pick up an item to look at it, she immediately snapped "NO!" at me. She literally forbids customers from touching anything, rejecting every single inquiry with a rude "No." It creates an incredibly uncomfortable and unwelcoming atmosphere. To top it all off, the prices in this disorganized hoard are completely detached from reality. Paying premium prices to be treated with absolute hostility in a messy, empty store is ridiculous. Do not waste your time or money here. Avoid this place at all costs! UPDATE The response from the owner, Chelsea, is an absolute fabrication. Her claim that I was "going through her personal belongings behind the counter" is completely ridiculous and utterly false. The items in question were sitting directly ON TOP of the main sales counter, thrown into a disorganized pile in plain view of anyone entering the shop. If these were truly your "personal, not-for-sale belongings," why on earth were they left piled up on a public retail counter? This is a desperate, made-up excuse to cover up your hostile and completely unprofessional behavior. Furthermore, you did not "politely explain" anything. You repeatedly snapped a single word at me: "NO!" - treating me like a dog that had wandered into your yard rather than a human being and a customer. It is pathetic that instead of taking accountability for your terrible customer service, you choose to invent outright lies to gaslight people. This owner is not just incredibly rude; she is completely dishonest. Avoid this place her behavior is absolutely unhinged.

    Photos
    Patterns
    Patterns
    Seasonal collections
    Seasonal collections
    Very nice store...

    See all

    Very nice store...
    Value Village

    Value Village

    2.5
    (66 reviews)
    6.1 mi
    $$$

    I shop at Value Village somewhat frequently and I would just like to comment that the return policy…read morethey have in place for not offering dressing rooms and listing their second hand items at the rate they do, seems very unreasonable to me. The only "return" option is actually a strict exchange (no credit issued) that needs to either meet or exceed the amount of original purchase within 14 days. Lets say I buy 4 pairs of pants that I cannot try on in store, at $12.99 a piece and none of them fit, thats $52 worth of thrift store merchandise that I need to purchase, in order to return the used pants that i had no option to try on before buying. This policy also leads to people trying on clothes in the aisle because of course they would.. and ultimately this creates an unprofessional environment and personally I feel disrespected as a customer. I hope Value Village considers restoring the dignity of their customers by either offering a dressing room or changing their return policy in the future. Thanks.

    The prices keep going up and the customer service keeps going down way down the people are really…read moredisrespectful to young girls looked at me roll their eyes and told me to ask it cashier they were just standing there talking in the clothing aisle I asked the elderly woman in her 50s 60s with white hair very nice very pleasant a question she answered right away two little Latino girls answered me right away but the disrespect from those other two girls I wanted the back hand them because not even my children would talk to me the way those kids did my grandkids have more respect than that and they're seven and 12 good God I'm not going back here and I'd never tell anybody else to shop here I got a lot of friends and we go there quite often to buy different things but not anymore

    Photos
    Value Village
    I went shopping for my lil boy. I bought him an all new wardrobe.
    I went shopping for my lil boy. I bought him an all new wardrobe.
    Value Village

    See all

    Labels Women's Consignment

    Labels Women's Consignment

    3.4
    (60 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $

    Love labels! With a HUGE selection of clothes, accessories,housewares, books, stemware and cute…read moredishes for entertaining. What's not to love about Labels? Just a few things in my experience... Sage, the owner is an absolute professional and I have been consigning with her for years at different locations. The James street and NW store seem to be inconsistent with each other as far as what they will accept. If one location does not take something, I go to the other store and they accept it. So, it may depend whose working or the particular needs of the store at a given time. This is my biggest issue with them is the consistency. Their acceptance seems to, at times depend on who is working and I rarely see the same gals behind the counter. They are always pleasant and don't make me feel rushed though. I like that they donate clothes, so you know if Labels does not accept them they will end up in a good home :-) I have purchased a few books here (bran new) but rarely anything else. I searched for jeans several times and can't find my size. Also, it's hard to get to clothes because most of them are jam- packed on the racks with little room to freely move about the store. They accept and move an insane amount of merchandise, which is great for consignors but doesn't lend to to a very pleasant shopping experience. Payments are always prompt and hassle free. Some places require you to have a minimum amount in your account. Not the case here, just present your ID and you're good to go!

    Seller Review - You are much better off selling via Poshmark and having control over pricing. After…read moresubmitting several items for sale recently, I am shocked at the proceeds I've received (and didn't realize that if you want a cash payout, that amount gets cut in half - read the fine print!). Armani dress (polyester shift), new with tags, original price $187 - earnings $12.60. LOL!! Club Monaco quilted jacket (like new condition) - earnings $9.20. La Vie En Rose satin romper, new with tags, original price $54 - earnings $4.40. *The above amounts are only if I use the earnings in store as credit; they get reduced by about 50% if I request a cash payout. The staff was friendly and the store is tidy and well merchandised, I am just providing an honest review for sellers who want to get higher earnings on quality clothing resales.

    Photos
    Labels Women's Consignment
    Labels Women's Consignment
    Labels Women's Consignment

    See all

    Mystery Thrift Store - thrift_stores - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...